scieee AI-readable full text Open interactive document viewer

Virginia Woolf's 'Monday or Tuesday': An Approach

Lojo Rodríguez, Laura María

Abstract

In 1921, Virginia Woolf publishes a collection of short stories entitled Monday or Tuesday which comprised different impressions of the everyday life, or the life of Monday or Tuesday. "Monday or Tuesday", the story which gives title to the collection seems to mark a borderline as far as technical experimentation is concerned as well as a point of inflection in Woolfs literary career. The story is the literary reflection ofWoolfs concems with literature, explicitly posed in her essay "Modern Fiction" (1919): at this point, Woolf started to experiment with the fragmentation of the subject by means of achieving different perspectives offered from a multiplicity of angles and filtered through voice and vision, through language and imagery, through words, elements which convey beauty in themselves

Full text

Laura Lojo Rodríguez Virginia Woolf's "Monday or Tuesday": An Approach Virginia Woolfs "Monday or Tuesday": An Approach Laura Lojo Rodríguez Universidade de Santiago de Compostela In 1921, Virginia Woolf publishes a collection of short stories enti tled Monday or Tuesday which comprised different impressions of the everyday life, or the life of Monday or Tuesday. "Monday or Tuesday", the story which gives title to the collection seems to mark a borderline as far as technical experimentation is concerned as well as a point of inflection in Woolfs literary career. The story is the literary reflection of Woolfs concems with literature, explici tly posed in her essay "Modern Fiction" (1919): at this point, Woolf started to experiment with the fragmentation of the subject by means of achieving different perspectives offered from a multipli city of angles and filtered through voice and vision, through lan guage and imagery, through words, elements which convey beauty in themselves. 107 Virginia Woolf (1880-1942) has been considered to be one of the major British writers of the twentieth century in the western literary canon. Her novels are widely known and read in most countries in the world, and they constitute a significant part of university and high school curricula for students of English literature. Critics have also focused on her life and work as one of the main exponents of British Modernism to such an extent that it proves a hard task to study any aspect which has not been touched on yet by scholars. Her works have been translated into most of the European Jan guages as her reputation as a writer has increased. However, her short fiction has often been neglected both by the critics, reading public and by translators: on the one hand, short fiction, in spite of the growing interest it is now arousing in scholars, continues to be an underrated art and is still seen as a "minor genre" when it comes to be compared to the novel, espe cially if the writer in question is the author of masterpieces such as Mrs. Dalloway, The Waves or To the Lighthouse. On the other hand, most of Virginia Woolfs short fiction has a highly experimental quality: she often 108 BABEL-AFIAL, 6/0toño de 1997 rehearsed in her short pieces man y of the innovative techniques she would distil for further development in longer works, such as the interior mono logue and similar experiments as far as the narrative voice is concerned, the treatment of time and space, the possibility of dialogue as a defining device and the development of what later carne to be known as "moments of be ing", this being one of the intrinsic and defining features of each one of her short stories. The above mentioned experimental quality of this kind of fiction obviously represents an extra difficulty for the critic to the already compli cated prose of this writer. Woolf herself was aware of the newness and innovation of this kind of writing, which may have aroused opposition. In this respect, she returns a letter to Ethel Smith acknowledging the com plexity and strangeness of "Monday or Tuesday" and "Blue and Green", the latter being a story which reached the border of complexity and repre sented the limits to which W oolf could go as far as experimentation was concerned: You are perfectly right about Green and blue and the heron one [i.e. "Mon day or Tuesday"]: thats mainly why I won't reprint. They are mere tangles of words; balls of string that the kitten or Pan [Ethel' s dog] has played with ... Green and blue and the heron were the wild outbursts of freedom, inar ticulate, ridiculous, unprintable mere outcries1• Any reader should bear in mind those words which probably allude to the reception of her short stories, and which on the other hand, point to the fact of their being not on the whole comprehensible or readable -as other pieces of writing -but the expression of a writer seeking freedom from literary convention, experimenting and subverting traditional genre, form and content. Its experimental character is the very essence of "Monday or Tues day" and therefore, the first thing to be apprehended, should be the aware ness of its being different to what had been done befare. Woolf herself points out that "they don't see that I'm after something interesting ... And there was Roger [Fry] who thinks I'm on the track of real discoveries"2• She might be implying that her narrative works on, at least, two levels: the lineal structure, undoubtedly confusing and unusual and, on the other hand, what is under surface, the workings of a new form, especially latent in the specific disposition of words and the references to what is left unsaid, im- Laura Lojo Rodríguez "Virginia Woolf's "Monday or Tuesday ": An Approach" 109 plied beyond writing. The fact that it was Roger Fry -one of the most tal ented, open-minded members of the Bloomsbury group -who perceived "something interesting" in her stories may also be significant3. Indeed, they were utterly different in forrn and content from the more traditional The Voyage Out (1915), and incomprehensible beyond ali question if compared with Night and Day (1919), the novel which she published in the same year as "Monday or Tuesday" in a collection which bore the same narne, and which represented, according to sorne critics, a step backwards as far as innovation was concerned. Leonard Woolf decided to compile, posthumously, eighteen of the stories written by his wife, sorne of which were never published during her lifetime. In the foreword to the collection, A Haunted House and Other Short Stories, he alludes to Virginia Woolfs need to free herself frorn the harness of convention, which she did in sorne of her short stories: Al! through her life, Virginia Woolf used at intervals to write short stories. It was her custom, whenever an idea for one occurred to her, to sketch it out in a very rough forrn and then to put it away in a drawer. Later, if an editor asked her for a short story, and she felt in the mood to write one (which was not frequent), she would take a sketch out of her drawer and rewrite it, sometimes a great many times. Or if she felt, as she often did, while writing a novel that she required to rest to rest her mind by working at something else for a time, she would either write a critica! essay or work upon one of the sketches for short stories4• The title of the short story, "Monday or Tuesday" is apparently un related to what comes afterwards in the narrative. There is nothing in the text which could be directly related to that expression. However, the phrase "Monday or Tuesday" does occur somewhere else in Virginia Woolfs writing, and in this respect the publication date of the story could be useful for overall perspective. According to a postcript in a letter that Virginia W oolf wrote to her sis ter Vanessa Bell on 31 '1 October, 19205, the writer seems to have planned the expression "Monday or Tuesday" as a title for the collection to be published in 1921 before she actually wrote the story of the same name: I'm getting doubtful whether I have time to write the story called Monday or Tuesday -if not, I don't know what to cal! the book. 110 BABEL-AFIAL, 6/0toño de 1997 Probably in the same period of time, Virginia Woolf was rewriting her essay "Modern Novels" for inclusion in The Common Reader (1925) as "Modern Fiction", which is one of her most emblematic essays. "Modern Fiction" deals basically with what Woolf thought to be the basis of the new Iiterature being produced, as opposed to more traditional literary tenden cies. Issues such as the task of the writer, and of the artist by extension, subject-matter and literary techniques are central elements to the essay: They [James Joyce and other young writers] attempt to come closer to life, and to preserve more sincerely and exactly what interests and moves them, even if to do so they must discard sorne of the conventions which are com monly observed by the novelist. [ ... ] Let us not take for granted that life exists more fully in what is commonly thought big than in what it is com monly thought small6 It seems clear that, in coming closer to Iife, anything would be suit able stuff for fiction, not just events in themselves, but mere impressions or perceptions, as is the case in "Monday or Tuesday" where "nothing hap pens": The mind receives a myriad of impressions -trivial, fantastic, evanescent, or engraved with the sharpness of steel. From ali sides they come, an inces sant shower of innumerable atoms; and as they fall, they shape themselves into the life of Monday or Tuesday, the accent falls different from old; the moment of importance carne not here but there.7 The expression "Monday or Tuesday" is unusual enough to occur in two texts, although different in their nature, written roughly in the same period and, therefore, the idea of a mere coincidence should be discarded. It seems obvious that, to Virginia Woolf, the subject of "modern fiction" should be ordinary Iife, things considered unimportant by traditional writ ers or, in her own words, "the Iife of Monday or Tuesday". That was ini tially intended to be the title of her collection of short stories, probably because they would <leal with everyday life, with those ordinary percep tions otherwise discarded by more traditional points of view. The short story "Monday or Tuesday" is constructed upon ordinary, everyday images, perceptions and thoughts coming from different angles, with no coherent shape or sequential order, because that is the way in which they occur: Laura Lojo Rodríguez "Virginia Woolj's "Monday or Tuesday": An Approach" 111 Life is not a series of gig-lamps symmetrically arranged; life is a luminous halo, a semi-transparent envelope surrounding us from the beginning of consciousness to the end. Is it not the task of the novelist to convey this varying, this unknown and circumscribed spirit, whatever aberration or complexity it may display with as little mixture of the alien and externa! as possible?8 This paragraph seems to justify the apparently chaotic arrangement -or disarrangement -of elements in sorne of Virginia W oolf' s writings, but it applies especially to "Monday or Tuesday". The translator has to bear in mind that the story is to differ a great deal from more conventional pieces belonging to the same genre. What is more, most of it is not go ing to have a linear meaning, is not going to "make sense" in the con ventional use of the phrase, and is even going to subvert the most tradi tional constrictions of earlier writing: [ ... ] if a writer were a free man, and not a slave, if he could write what he chose, not what he must, if he could base bis work upon his own feeling and not upon convention, there would be no plot, no comedy, no tragedy [ ... ]9. Woolf is, however, aware of the implications that freedom from convention would have. She is probably alluding to publishing houses and editors, a problem that W oolf herself did not share with other writers, since the Woolfs owned the Hogarth Press and were publishers themselves. In this way, "Monday or Tuesday" is as free from convention as possible, deals with ordinary experiences and perceptions, and subverts the traditional conception of fiction and even of literary genre, as will be seen later on. The short story puts into practice the literary issues idealistically posed in "Modern Fiction", but using a different narrative vehicle: this time the essay is to be substituted by the short story, the pamphlet is to become art itself. The genre, significantly chosen to develop for the first time those innovative conceptions as mentioned earlier, is going to differ from the traditional short story which had been written so far. As an obvious conse quence of the intention of directly representing the nature of experience itself, chaotic and heterogeneous in itself, the modernist short story, and Virginia W oolf s in particular, is to reject the traditional conception of plot, of the well-wrought tale, constructed to achieve eventually a "unity of 114 BABEL-AFIAL, 6/0toño de 1997 (l. 8), "for ever desiring -" (l. 11), "- for ever desiring truth" (l. 14), "- and truth?" (l. 16, 27), "-truth?" (l. 34). Ali of these expressions are introduced as a sort of coda, or even conclusion after the different perceptions described in the story. It is sig nificant that all of them are either preceded or followed by a dash, as a sort of afterthought which, paradoxically, is the underlying subject-matter that gives shape to "Monday or Tuesday": the narrator's anxious and agonic search for truth. The second paragraph starts by progressively developing this last element: "Desiring truth, awaiting it, laboriously distilling a few words, for ever desiring -" (11. 8, 9.). The -ing forms mark a process which seems to be endless, stressed by the adding of "for ever" (l. 9). On the other hand, they also leave the agent of the action unknown, although the narrative voice may correspond to the narrator's. "Laboriously distilling a few words" (11. 8, 9) introduces a key aspect to the narrative. On the one hand, and due to the sequential arder, "words" seems somehow to be coupled with "truth", as a factual reflection of the narrator's desire and search. It may not be adventurous to assert that the anxiety to find the right word, namely poetic truth would correspond to the task of one who somehow uses words as a daily instrument of work: a writer. Could the narrative voice, therefore, be characterised as such12? What comes in brackets is going to produce a disruption in the nar rative: the narrator interrupts his thoughts on the problems of aesthetic creation and introduces a different perspective, a different focaliser. This time it is not going to be the heron offering an aerial perspective, but an unknown focaliser introducing perceptions apprehended by the senses: "a cry srarts to the left, another to the right. Wheels strike divergently. Omni buses conglomerate in conflict" (11. 9 -11). These sensations are especially related to the semantic field of sound: "cry, strike, conglomerare in con flict", ali of them suggesting the idea of a rush, of the movement of a city, probably offered by the point of view of a passer-by. The language used differs a great <leal from what has been previ ously recorded. These impressions are arranged in syntactically simple utterances, lacking the elaboration of the previous part of the discourse, giving the impression of an anxiety to provide as much information as possible with few words. The sequence works, therefore, in the guise of stage directions, very similar to them both in language and in function. In Laura Lojo Rodríguez "Virginia Woolf's "Monday or Tuesday": An Approach" 115 spite of their brevity, they succeed in defining in a clear and rapid way space and time in the story, work:ing as a traditional description would. The setting seems to be a large city, for its number of cars and omnibuses, "conglomerating" in a traffic jam; the time therefore could correspond to the rush hour. Before actually continuing with the factual description provided by the "stage directions", the typography of the dashes marks again the narra tor's comments on the nature of truth. The brackets reopen again defining more clearly the space and time frame within the story: it is midday, the sun is shining and children are probably coming out of school. As was earlier mentioned, the information in brackets provide what a traditional description would do in terms of function, but in fact, because of their belonging to a different literary genre -drama -it works by introducing one genre within another one -the short story, or even poetry, as discussed abo ve. The tenses used in the stage directions belong also, as in the rest of the text, to the simple present. This points out to the idea of those actions taking place repeatedly every day, any day, ordinary events and ordinary habits which make up every day routine, every day existence. The closing of the second paragraph is of a slightly different nature. Typographically, the next lines are not presented in brackets, but they are also quick descriptive assertions separated by semi-colons, descriptive strokes which keep on sketching the spatial frame. Again, the focaliser provides a vision which is obviously apprehended by the senses, being on the one hand predominantly visual ("Red is the dome; coins hang on the trees; smoke trails from the chimneys", 11. 14, 15) or they reproduce the different sounds heard in the street, introducing also the direct speech of an ironmonger: "Iron for sale" (l. 16). This description, however, and unlike the previous one, is interiorised by the particular vision of the focaliser by using metaphors: "Red is the dome" may refer to the sun reflecting on a cathedral's dome, "coins hang on the trees" might refer to the light filtering through the leaves of a tree, in the particular perception of the focaliser. Finally, the paragraph ends with the narrator's rhetorical question on truth, typographically preceded, as usual, by a dash. The next paragraph presents a change in the setting and situation. Two simultaneous perspectives are presented, filtered through the eyes of 116 BABEL-AFIAL, 6/0toño de 1997 the same focaliser; on the one hand, there is a description of a setting which is fixed, static. By contrast, the paragraph closes with a collection of im ages and perceptions taken from different angles and different settings, ali taking place at the same time. The expression "while outside" on line 21 provides the key for the spatial frame: "while" underlines the fact that what has been previously described and what comes rightly after are simultane ous in terms of time. "Outside" makes a clear distinction in terms of space location: the description of the preceding lines may correspond to sorne place "inside" a building where the focaliser is also situated: the "outside" may refer to the recollection of descriptive images of the street. The paragraph opens with a particular description offered by the fo caliser who, again, interiorises the images perceived through his eyes using codified language: "Radiating to a point men's feet and women's feet, black or gold-encrusted" (11. 17, 18), "the firelight darting and making the room red" (l. 20), and the use of -ing forms points to a process taking place in a particular moment or period of time. The focaliser directs his eyes to the floor of a room, where it is possible to see the shoes of the people there, either black for men or more colourful for women. The room seems to be illuminated by a fire, whose flame leaves red reflections on the objects seen there and which provides a contrast between light and darkness ("black figures and their bright eyes", l. 21). The focaliser's perception is interrupted by a sequence presented in brackets similar to those in previous paragraphs. It is endowed with the same nature as the preceding ones, namely to provide a substitute for a traditional description of place, time and situation. This time they are not going to be stage directions, but fragments of conversations in direct speech which may probably have been heard -or overheard -in the room: "- (This foggy weather -Sugar? No, thank you -The commonwealth of the future) -", (11. 18, 19). "This foggy weather" points directly to a precise location of the action in terms of space: it may be referring to London, widely regarded as "the" foggy city. "Sugar? No, thank you" is even more exact; the action may be taking place in a coffee-shop where people are having their morning tea. Finally, politics are a recurrent topic in everyday conversation, so "the commonwealth of the future" would be an assertion quite likely to be heard in a coffee-shop. "While outside" (l. 21) is the mark to present, as has been argued earlier, a group of images which are simultaneous to the scene described in Laura Lojo Rodríguez "Virginia Woolf's "Monday ar Tuesday": An Approach" 117 the coffee-shop. The focaliser offers an account of the sight which a win dow to the �reet presents: "while outside a van discharges, Miss Thin gummy drinks tea at her desk, and plate-glass preserves fur coats -" (ll. 21, 22, 23), the rush of the street, a break at an office and a shop. The sights are described in the simple present, again as the usual sight of every <lay, any <lay in London, with a generalising perspective reflected in the language by the lack of definite articles ("plate-glass preserves fur-coats", l. 23) or the allusion to "Miss Thingummy" (l. 22), an educated and slightly archaic variant for "Mrs.-what's-her-name". The next paragraph presents a conglomerate of adjectives and past participles functioning as predicative complements of a subject which is not explicit in the text and has to be supplied by association. The sequence is especially complicated, not only for the ambiguity which the elision of the subject provokes, but also because it works in terms of rhythm, stress pattern, interna! rhyme and oppositions. Sandra Kemp13 suggests for this paragraph the influence of the poet Gerard Manley Hopkins, whose poems were first published in 1918. Virginia Woolf wrote to Janet Case on 23 July, 1919: Have you read the poems of a man, who is dead, called Gerard Hopkins? 1 liked them better than any other poetry for ever so long; partly because they're so difficult, but also because instead of writing mere rhythms and sense as most poets do, he makes a very strange jumble; so that what is ap parently pure nonsense is at the time very beautiful, and not nonsense at aI114. The first line of the paragraph has an alliteration of the sounds /f/, JI! and /t! ("Flaunted, leaf-light, drifting at corners, l. 24), a device which is repeated in the next one with the sounds /!/, /si /di ("wheels, silver splashed, home or not home, gathered", l. 25), /si and /k/ ("scattered, squandered in separate scales, swept up" l. 26) and /ni ("down, torn, sunk, assembled", l. 27), together with a rhythmical stress pattern. The paragraph ends with the narrator questioning on truth, which opens the possibility of considering the whole sequence as a reference to the nature and state of it. However, it would be feasible to consider that the whole paragraph may be referring to the nature of the perceptions described in the preceding paragraphs, to the different sights and sensations which have been gathered and interiorised by the different angles that the various focalisers have