A survey on geometrical reconstruction as a core technology to sketch-based modeling

! ! (@5#+32#' 9.!4@/3!_<2c]!4@1!d5?cB2<7.D3!5.D!10<A74/<.!<=!4@211FD/81.3/<.5A!21?<.3427?4/<.!<=! A/.1! D25_/.B3! D72/.B! 4@1! A534! 4@/24C! C1523! /3! D/3?7331D:! )! .1_! B1.125A! 45a<.<8C! /3! ;2<;<31D! 4<! 85c1! 5;;521.4! 5.D! D/3?733! 4@1! @/34<2/?5A! 10<A74/<.! <=! B1<8142/?5A! 21?<.3427?4/<.! 5.D! 4@1/2! [email protected]:! >@1! 10<A74/<.! <=!B1<8142/?5A! 21?<.3427?4/<.! =2<8! 21?<012/.B! c.<_F@<_! 34<21D! /.! 1.B/.112/.B! D25_/.B3! 4<! 3c14?@Fd531D! 8<D1A/.B! =<2! @1A;/.B!/.!4@1!=/234!341;3!<=!?<.?1;475A!D13/B.!;72;<313]!5.D!4@[email protected]!<=! B1<8142/?5A!21?<.3427?4/<.!521!D/3?7331D!4<<:! ! ! AB!C/#+.<*2#"./' $13?2/;4/<.! <=! 4@211FD/81.3/<.5A!<dZ1?43! B1<8142C! /.! 5! 4_<FD/81.3/<.5A! 372=5?1! @53!d11.!5.!5?5D18/?!D/3?/;A/.1!=<2!8<21!4@5.!4_<!4@<735.D!C1523:!>@1!2101231!;2<dA18! /3!?<.?12.1D!<.!@<_!4<!e21?<012f!4@1!B1<8142/?5A!5.D!4<;<A<B/?5A!3427?4721!<=!5!4@211F D/81.3/<.5A!<dZ1?4!dC!/.412;214/.B!4_<FD/81.3/<.5A!21;2131.454/<.3:!&=!?<7231]!"#$%"&"'! 21?<012C!5?4/<.3!521!?522/1D!<[email protected]!4<!e215Df!D25_/.B3]!3/.?1!1012:!+14]!()$%"&"'! =<285A/g54/<.!<=!4@/3!;2<dA18!d1B5.!4<!54425?4!3<81!5441.4/<.!<.AC!/.!4@1!GWRIh3]!_@1.! ?<8;74123h! D101A<;81.4! 85D1! ;<33/dA1! 3<81! c/.D! <=! 574<854/?! 5;;2<5?@13:! >@/3! ;2<dA18]!.581D!*(+#(',"&-%!,(&+./',0&'"+.![<2!%".(!1,-2".*!,(&+./',0&'"+.]!<2!3/8;AC! ,(&+./',0&'"+.\!/8;A/13!4@1!D14128/.54/<.!<=!B1<8142/?5A!5.D!4<;<A<B/?5A!21A54/<.3!<=!5AA! 54<8/?!;5243!<=!<.1!<dZ1?4!D1;/?41D!/.!5!D25_/.B:!94!8734!.<4!d1!8/345c1!=<2!,(/'"'0'"+.! 5.D!,(&+*."'"+.i!4_<!_1AAFD1=/.1D!=/1AD3!?<.?12.1D!_/4@!3<81!c/.D!<=!/D1.4/=/?54/<.!<=! <dZ1?43]!5.D!.<4!_/4@!5!D145/A1D!D13?2/;4/<.!<=!/43!B1<8142C:! (<34! <=! 4@1! c.<_.! 5;;2<5?@13! 521! .<_! /.! 1a;12/81.45A! 345B13]! 5.D! 521! 5dA1! 4<! /.412;214![_/4@<74!85.C!122<23\]!5A8<34!5AA!c/.D!<=!;<AC4<;13:!9.412;21454/<.!<=!4@1!8<34! 7375A!372=5?1!1A181.43![A/c1!?CA/.D123]!3;@1213]!14?:\!/3!5A3<!?<.3/D121D!dC!3<81!<=!4@1! 5;;2<5?@13:!).C_5C]!_@1.!?<8;A1a/4C!<=!<dZ1?43!/.?215313]!574<854/?!;2<?13313!7375AAC! B/01!;533!4<!D/==121.4!318/574<854/?!5;;2<5?@13:! 9.!4@/3!524/?A1!4@1!2137A4!<=!5.!/.41.3/01!d/dA/<B25;@/?5A!3152?@!<.!4@1!B1<8142/?5A! 21?<.3427?4/<.! /3! 378852/g1D:! j13/D13! 05A/D54/.B! 4@1! ?2/412/5! 5A215DC! 1345dA/3@1D! dC! <4@12! 574@<23]! 5! .1_! B1.125A! ?A533/=/?54/<.! ?2/412/<.! /3! ;2<;<31D]! 4<! 85c1! 0/3/dA1! 4@1! @/34<2/?5A!10<A74/<.!<=!B1<8142/?5A!21?<.3427?4/<.!5.D!4@1/[email protected]:! &.1!<=!4@1!=/234!54418;43!/.!B1<8142/?5A!21?<.3427?4/<.!_53!4<!1a425?4!/.=<2854/<.! =2<8!1.B/.112/.B!;A5.3!<2!dA71;2/.43:!>@/3!_53!5.!/8;<245.4!B<5A!3/.?1!5A215DC!1a/34/.B! D13/B.3! 37;;<31! 5.! /8;<245.4! ec.<_F@<_f]! _@/?@! /3! 34<21D! /.! 1.B/.112/.B! D25_/.B3:! >@/3! 815.3! 4@54! 574<854/?! 3<A/DF8<D1A! B1.1254/<.! =2<8! 345.D52D/g1D! D25_/.B3! ?<7AD! @501! d11.! 4@1! ed2/DB1f! 4<! 21?<012! 4@1! /.=<2854/<.! d7/A4F/.! /.! 4@1! 4@<735.D3! <=! <AD! ! ! D13/B.3! =/A1D! /.! D25=4/.B! 2<<83:! ><! D<! 4@54]! 5AA! /.=<2854/<.! /.?A7D1D! /.! 41?@./?5A! D25_/.B3! 3@<7AD! @501! d11.! e215Df:! j74! 4@1! 453c! ;2<01D! 4<! d1! D/==/?7A4]! d1?5731! 1.B/.112/.B!D25_/.B3!?<.01C!V$!/.=<2854/<.!21;2131.41D!4@2<7B@!&+#$%()!0/1_3![85/.! <24@<B25;@/?!0/1_3]!;524/?7A52!0/1_3]!?743]!14?\!5.D!5..<454/<.3![D/81.3/<.3]!4<A125.?13]! 14?\:!9.!=5?4]!87A4/;A1!0/1_3!d531D!?7221.4!5;;2<5?@13!521!7375AAC!A/8/41D!Z734!4<!?<.3/D12! 85/.! <24@<B25;@/?! 0/1_3! _/4@<74! 5..<454/<.3:! >@1C! D<! .<4! 101.! 5??1;4! 345.D52D/g1D! ?<.01.4/<.3!A/c1!;524/?7A52!0/1_3!5.D!31?4/<.3:! k<_1012]! 4@1! 85/.! B<5A! <=! 21?<.3427?4/<.! ?<887./4C! D/D! [email protected]! /.! 4@1! GWWIh3:! *<_5D5C3]! 8<34! <=! 4@1! 3C34183! 521! <2/1.41D! 4<_52D3! ?<.?1;475A! D13/B.]! 0/5! 3c14?@F d531D!8<D1A/.B]!5.D!731!<.AC!5!3c14?@!B1.12541D!dC!4@1!7312!53!/.;74!D545:!-;!4<!D541]! 4@1C!50</D!4@1!8<34!3;1?/5A/g1D!?<.01.4/<.3!<.!B1.125A!;2/.?/;A13!<=!21;2131.454/<.!5.D! 521! A/8/41D! 4<! B1.12541! <.AC! ;2<;<24/<.5A! 8<D1A3]! _@/A1! 4@1C! A14! =<2! 5! A54412! ;@531! 4@1! 1a5?4!D/81.3/<./.B:! $72/.B!D/3?733/<.]!_1!3@5AA!52B71!4@54]!4@1!B<5A!<=!B1<8142/?5A!21?<.3427?4/<.!/3!=52! =2<8! d1/.B! 5??<8;A/3@1D]! 3/.?1! ')$! 3C34183! @501! .<.F31^71.4/5A! [B25;@/?\! <74;743]! d74!5??1;4!<.AC!31^71.4/5A![012d5A\!/.;743:!>@/3!/3!5!D/21?4!?<.31^71.?1!<=!4@1!31^71.4/5A! .54721! <=! 5AB<2/4@8/?! A5.B75B13! 731D! =<2! ;2<B2588/.B! 453c3:! &.! 4@1! ?<.4252C]!D13/B.! ;2<?133]! 5.D! /.! ;524/?7A52! /D154/<.! ;2<?133]! .11D! .<.F31^71.4/5A! 4@<7B@4:! +14! /4! /3! /8;<245.4!4<!.<4/?1!4@54!_1!D<!.<4!?A5/8!=<2!4@1!;@C3/?5A!/8;A181.454/<.!4<!d1?<81!.<.F 31^71.4/5Ai!/4!/3!Z734!4@1!?<.?1;475A!8<D1A![5.D!4@1!/.4125?4/<.!=2<.4!1.D\!4@54!8734!d1! eB25;@/?5Af]! /.! 4@1! 31.31! <=! .<.F31^71.4/5A:! '<.31^71.4AC]! <.1! B25;@/?5A! A5.B75B1! /3! 21^7/21D!4<!/8;2<01!4@1!;2131.4!?<887./?54/<.!d14_11.!D13/B.123!5.D!')$!3C34183:! )8<.B!4@[email protected]]!_1!3@5AA!@/B@A/B@4!4@54!;2<Z1?4/01!B1<8142C!A5_3!521!7.5dA1! 4<!213<A01!4@1!;2<dA18]!d1?5731!/4!/3!_1AA!c.<_.!4@54!d/7./0<?5A!?<2213;<.D1.?1!58<.B! H$! /85B13! 5.D! V$! 8<D1A3! D<13! .<4! 1a/34:! k1.?1]! 0/375A! ;12?1;4/<.! ?<.42/d74/<.3! 521! 21^7/21D:!k<_1012]!4@1!0/375A!;12?1;4/<.!/3!34/AA!.<4!;2<.1!4<!5AB<2/4@8/?!=<287A54/<.3! d1?5731!/4!@53!d11.!A/44A1!347D/1D:!(<21<012]!5AA!<=!4@1!?7221.4!5;;2<5?@13!?<.45/.!5!8<21! ! ! <2!A133!d5A5.?1D!8/a!<=!B1<8142/?!5.D!;12?1;475A!;2/.?/;A13]!d74!4@1!?<7;A/.B!/3!34/AA!.<4! _1AA!3<A01D:! DB!4%$3#%<'?.+9' S/234]!5!d2/1=!378852C!5d<74!3c14?@F8<D1A/.B!d5?cB2<7.D!/3!/.?A7D1D!4<!1345dA/3@! /43! A/.c! _/4@! B1<8142/?5A! 21?<.3427?4/<.:! )=412! 4@54]! 5! 21D7?1D! 314! <=! 21=121.?13! /3! /.?A7D1D!/.!4@1!.1a4!31?4/<.:!).!1a41.3/01!A/34!<=!_<2c3!<.!B1<8142/?5A!21?<.3427?4/<.!/3! 505/A5dA1! 54! @44;TPP___:41?:7Z/:13PDP21B1<P:! j74]! <.AC! 4@1! 21=121.?13! .1?13352C! 4<! 18;@53/g1!4@1!85/.!@/.43!_1!=/.D!/.!/43!10<A74/<.!521!/.?A7D1D!/.!4@1!;5;12:! %1A54/01!4<!21=121.?13!<.!B1<8142/?5A!21?<.3427?4/<.!210/1_3]!4@1!d<<c!dC!E7B/@525! `JXb! /3! 4@1! 8<34! ?<8;[email protected]/01! 21=121.?1! 4<! 4@1! 152AC! @/34<2C! <=! A/.1! D25_/.B3! /.412;21454/<.:!*5B1.D5!5.D!O7Z52!`lQb!;7dA/3@1D!5!?<881.4!<.!1A101.!;5;123!;7dA/3@1D! d14_11.! GWJV! 5.D! GWXQ! <.! 4@/3! 4<;/?]! /.?A7D/.B! 5! ?541B<2/g54/<.! 4211:! m5.B! 5.D! O2/.341/.! `WJb! 7;D541D! 4@1! ?541B<2/g54/<.]!5.D!<d45/.1D!5!45a<.<8C!<=!V$!<dZ1?43! 21?<.3427?4/<.! =2<8! A/.1! D25_/.B3! /.! 4_<FD/81.3/<.5A! ;2<Z1?4/<.:! >@1! ?A533/=/?54/<.! 21A/1D!<.!D/==121.4!d74!D1;1.D1.4!53;1?43:!! $/34/.?4/<.3! _121! 85D1! d531D! <.! 4@1! .54721!<=!!<dZ1?43!4<!d1!21?<.3427?41Di!4@1! /.412.5A! 21;2131.454/<.! <=! 4@1! B1.12541D! 8<D1Ai! 4@1! .78d12! <=! H$! 0/1_3! .11D1Di! 4@1! 21^7/21D!;218/313]!5.D!4@1!D1B211!<=!/.4125?4/<.!=2<8!4@1!;524!<=!4@1!7312:! DBA!)9%#27"/8'3/<'1.<%$"/8' Ec14?@13! @501! d11.! ;2131.4! /.! ?<8;7412! 5/D1D! D13/B.! 3C34183! 3/.?1! 4@1/2! d1B/../.B3! /.! 4@1! GWRIh3:! ! [email protected]! Ec14?@;5D! `XHb! _53! 4@1! =/234! ;2<B258! 4@54! 5AA<_1D!4@1!7312!4<!?21541!B25;@/?5A!/85B13!D/21?4AC!<.!4@1!?<8;7412!3?211.!dC!815.3!<=! 5! A/B@4! ;1.:! 6<@3<.h3! Ec14?@;5D! 999! `VRb! 5DD1D! 4@211FD/81.3/<.5A! 8<D1A/.B! 4<! [email protected]!3C3418:!>5BB524]!*1B2<;<.41!`lRb!5.D!k12<4!D101A<;1D!54!4@1!d1B/../.B!<=! 4@1!GWJIh3!4@1!k-*'k!3C3418]!?<8;<31D!dC!5!314!<=!S&%>%)*!;2<B2583!_@/?@!_121! D13/B.1D!4<!;2<[email protected]!3c14?@13!D25_.!_/4@!5!D545!45dA14!<2!A/B@4!;1.:!!>@/3!3C3418! ! ! _53! 5dA1! 4<! ;2<0/D1! 574<854/?! A54?@/.B! <=! A/.1! 1.D;</.43]! 5.D! D141?4/.B! ?<2.123! 5.5ACg/.B! [email protected]! /.! 342<c1! D/21?4/<.:! )A3<]! 5! =/234! 54418;4! 4<! /.412;214! 3c14?@13! 53! 21;2131.454/<.3!<=!4@211FD/81.3/<.5A!<dZ1?43!_53!D<.1]!53!.<41D!dC!k12<4!/.!`HWb:! k<_1012]!D13/B./.B!5!4271!/.4125?4/01!3c14?@!d531D!8<D1A/.B!3C3418!21^7/21D!4@1! D101A<;81.4! <=! 4@1! ?<2213;<.D/.B! <.FA/.1! 21?<B./4/<.! 41?@./^713! 5.D! 4@1! ;2<;12! @52D_521!D10/?13:!$72/.B!4@1!152AC!WIn3!(/?2<3<=4!/.41.D1D!4<!;2<8<41!om/.D<_3!=<2! "1.! '<8;74123o]! 5.! <;1254/01! 3C3418! d7/A4! <012! 345.D52D! m/.D<_3! _/4@! 5! 314! <=! 1a41.3/<.3!4<!37;;<24!5!7312!/.412=5?1!d531D!<.!4@1!/.4125?4/<.!_/4@!5!34CA73!5.D!5!L'$! 45dA14:!94!_53!5!?<8812?/5A!=5/A721!d1?5731!<=!4@1!385AA!;2<?133/.B!;<_12!<=!4@<31!o;1.! ?<8;74123o:!!*<_5D5C3]!4@1!A57.?@!<=!4@1!>5dA14F"'!54!4@1!1.D!<=!HIIH!@53!21.1_1D!4@1! /.412134!/.!3c14?@!d531D!5;;A/?54/<.3:!! >@1!.11D!=<2!3c14?@Fd531D!B1<8142/?!8<D1A123!/.!4@1!1.0/2<.81.4!<=!?<.?1;475A! D13/B.! ?5.! d1! 425?1D! d5?c! 4<! 4@1! A534! D1?5D1! `XJb`Glb`GXb`XRb:! )4! ;2131.4]! 4@211! 85/.! 5;;2<5?@13!4<!V$!8<D1A/.B!dC!3c14?@/.B!1a/34T!! x!3(/'0,-%! 3C34183! ;2<0/D1! ;21D1=/.1D! B134721! 5A;@5d143! 4@54! 1.?<D1! 3<81! B1<8142/?!8<D1A/.B!<;1254/<.3i!d53/?5AAC!4@131!3C34183!37d34/4741!4@1!31A1?4/<.! <=!/?<.3!5.D!81.73!dC!B25;@/?!B1347213:!! x!4(&+./',0&'"+.-%!3C34183!5;;AC!B1<8142/?!21?<.3427?4/<.!41?@./^713!4<!d7/AD!4@1! <dZ1?4h3!B1<8142C!=2<8!5!3c14?@:!! x!567,"1!3C34183!?<8d/.1!4@1!4_<!;210/<73!5;;2<5?@13:! '@2<.<A<B/?5AAC!21?<.3427?4/<.5A!3C34183!5;;1521D!d1=<21!B134725A!<.13:!!O134725A! 3C34183! 21^7/21! 8<21! 1A5d<2541! 21?<B./4/<.! 1.B/.13! =<2! D/34/.B7/3@/.B! B1<8142C! /.=<2854/<.!5.D!B134725A!?<D13]!5A4@<7B@!4@1!=/234!3C34183!50</D1D!4@/3!73/.B!/?<.3!5.D! 81.73!4<!1a;A/?/4AC!B/01!4@/3!/.=<2854/<.!4<!4@1!3C3418:!!%1?<.3427?4/<.5A!3C34183!4<<c! 5D05.45B1!<=!;210/<73!_<2c3!/.!4@1!<==A/.1!A/.1!D25_/.B!21?<B./4/<.!=/1AD:! (5.C! <=! 4@131! 3C34183! 5;;AC! 5! d54?@! `RIb!<2!/.4125?4/01!d1574/=/?54/<.!<=!4@1! [email protected]! 3c14?@! /.! 4@1! V$! B1<8142C! ?<.3427?4/<.! ;2<?133! `Vlb`VVb:! 9.4125?4/01! ! ! d1574/=/?54/<.!;2<0/D13!4@1!7312!_/4@!/881D/541!=11Dd5?c!d1?5731!/4!<;125413!53!4@1!7312! D25_3! 4@1! 3c14?@! 5.D! /4! <==123! d14412! /.41B254/<.! _/4@! 5! ?5AA/B25;@/?! /.412=5?1:! j54?@! d1574/=/?54/<.! 5AA<_3! 3<81! 5.5AC3/3! 4<! d1! /8;A181.41D]! =<2! 1a58;A1! 3C88142C! D141?4/<.]!_@/?@!521!d14412!?522/1D!<74!<012!4@1!_@<A1!3c14?@!`GHb:! DBD!E"5#.+"23$'%,.$*#"./'.F'59%#27:@35%<'5-5#%15' M/c/.B!`Rlb]!/.!GWWH!/3!<.1!<=!4@1!=/234!21=121.?13!/.!4@1!.1_!B1.1254/<.!<=!3c14?@! d531D! 8<D1A123! 4@54! /.41B25413! d<4@! 3c14?@/.B! /.;74! 5.D! 21?<.3427?4/<.:! 94! 37;;<243! 5! A/.1FD25_/.B!<=!5!;<AC@1D25A!<dZ1?4!53!/.;74!_@121!73123!?5.!;A5?1!B1<8142/?!?<.3425/.43:! >@131!?<.3425/.43]!4<B14@12!_/4@!5!314!<=!?<.3425/.43!D12/01D!=2<8!4@1!A/.1FD25_/.B]!521! 731D! 4<! D1=/.1! 01241a! B1<8142C! /.! 37d31^71.4! /.412;21454/<.3:! m1! ?5.! ?<.3/D12! 4@/3! 3C3418! 53! 5! m9("! 5;;A/?54/<.! ?5;5dA1! <=! /.412;214/.B! 3c14?@13! 21;2131.4/.B! A/.1! D25_/.B3!<=! <dZ1?43:! (<D13!<=! <;1254/<.!521!31A1?41D! dC! 4@1! 7312! ?A/?c/.B! <.!5!314!<=! d744<.3:!"12=<285.?1!_53!012C!A/8/41D!D71!4<!4@1!505/A5dA1!@52D_521:! 9.!GWWQ]!9$1E!_53!;2131.41D!dC!j25.?<!14!5A:!`Rb:!>@/3!3C3418!5A3<!731D!m9("! /.4125?4/<.!?<8d/.1D!_/4@!3c14?@!/.;74!37;;<24/.B!;123;1?4/01!<2!5a<.<8142/?!D25_/.B3! D25_.! _/4@<74! @/DD1.! A/.13:! ><! d7/AD! 5! 8<D1A]! 4@1! 7312! D25_3! /4! dC! @5.D]! 5.D! <.?1! =/./3@1D]!@1!/.=<283!4@1!3C3418!4@54!/4!/3!V$!8<D1A!21;2131.454/<.:!!)A412.54/01AC]!73123! @501!3<81!8<D1A/.B!<;1254/<.3!505/A5dA1!53!1a4273/<.!4<!?21541!3<A/D!=2<8!1A181.452C! 3@5;13]!73/.B!/?<.3!21;2131.4/.B!4@1!8<D1A/.B!<;1254/<.:!>@/3!3C3418!?5.!d1!?A533/=/1D! /.! 4@1! 21?<.3427?4/<.! ?541B<2C]! _<2c/.B! <.AC! _/4@! A/.1! D25_/.B3! 4@54! 21;2131.4! 3<A/D3! _/4@!;A5.52!=5?13!5.D!42/05A1.4!0124/?13:! 9.! GWWl]! D72/.B! 4@1! V2D! EC8;<3/78! <.! E<A/D! (<D1A/.B! 5.D! );;A/?54/<.3! 4_<! 3c14?@!d531D!8<D1A/.B!5;;A/?54/<.!_121!;2131.41D:!!K7/?cF3c14?@!D101A<;1D!dC!#BBA/!14! 5A:!`GWb!_53!5!3<A/D!8<D1A12!_@/?@!/.?<2;<2541D!5!3c14?@/.B!4<<A!4@54! 37;;<241D!A/.13]! ?/2?A13]!52?3]!<2! jF3;A/.1! ?72013! 4@54! _121!574<854/?5AAC! 21?<B./g1D! =2<8!25_! 342<c13:! K7/?cF3c14?@! 574<854/?5AAC! D14128/.1D! 21A54/<.3]! 37?@! 53! 2/B@4! 5.BA13]! 45.B1.?/13]! 3C88142C]!5.D!;525AA1A/38]!=2<8!4@1!3c14?@!/.;74:!!>@1.]!4@131!21A54/<.3@/;3!_121!731D! ! ! 4<! ?A15.! 7;! 4@1! D25_/.B:! )! ?<.3425/.4! 85/.41.5.?1! 3C3418]! d531D! <.! B134725A! 85./;7A54/<.!5.D!3<=4!?<.3425/.43]!_53!18;A<C1D!/.!4@/3!3C3418:!E10125A!41?@./^713!=<2! B134721Fd531D! D1=/./4/<.3! <=! 3<A/D! <dZ1?43! _121! ;2<0/D1D! 53! 1a4273/<.]! 372=5?1! <=! 210<A74/<.]!27A1D!372=5?13!5.D!3_11;:!!>@1!<4@12!3C3418!_53!;2131.41D!dC!O2/83415D!5.D! (524/.!`HVb!5.D!/4!_53!5dA1!4<!B1.12541!5!jF21;!3<A/D!8<D1A!=2<8!5!3/.BA1!@/DD1.FA/.1! 218<01D! 3c14?@! 0/1_! <=! 5! V$! <dZ1?4:! 94! _<2c1D! <.! ;<AC@1D25A! <dZ1?43! _/4@! 42/@1D25A! 0124/?13!5.D!;12=<281D!5!H$!d1574/=/?54/<.!345B1!53!5!;210/<73!341;!4<!V$!21?<.3427?4/<.! 73/.B!5!A/.1!A5d1A/.B!5AB<2/4@8:!! 9.! E9OO%)"k! hWR]! <.1! <=! 8<34! ?/41D! 3c14?@! d531D! 8<D1A/.B! 3C34183! _53! ;2131.41D:!Ep#>'k!`GIVb!/3!5!?A533/?5A!21=121.?1!D71!4<!/43!B134721Fd531D!/.412=5?1!4<! 5;;2<a/8541!V$!;<AC@1D25A!8<D1A3:!!Ep#>'k!731D!5!B134725A!8<D1!<=!/.;74!/.!_@/?@! 5AA!<;1254/<.3!_121!505/A5dA1!D/21?4AC!/.!5!V$!3?1.1!4@2<7B@!5!4@211Fd744<.!8<731:!>@1! 7312!3c14?@1D!4@1!35A/1.4!=1547213!<=! 5.C! <=!5!052/14C!<=!V$!;2/8/4/013!5.D]!=<AA<_/.B! 3<81!3/8;A1!;A5?181.4!27A13]!4@1!?<2213;<.D/.B!V$!;2/8/4/01!_53!/.3454/541D!/.!4@1!V$! 3?1.1:! 943! 85/.! ?<.42/d74/<.! _53! 4<! ;2<0/D1! 5! B134725A! /.412=5?1! =<2! 85.C! <=! 4@1! <;1254/<.3!<=!4@1!3C3418:! $/B/45A! 'A5C! ;2131.41D! /.! GWWX! `JGb! 37;;<241D!;<AC@1D25A! <dZ1?43:![email protected]! /3<8142/?! 5.D!;123;1?4/01!3c14?@13!_121!5DZ7341D!5.D!425.3=1221D!4<!5!21?<.3427?4/<.!d2<_312!4@54! 731D!k7==85.F'A<_13!`GGb`VGb!5AB<2/4@83!4<!21?<.3427?4!4@1!<dZ1?4n3!B1<8142Ci!=/.5AAC! 4@1!D545!_53!1a;<241D!/.! M%(L!=<2854:!>@/3!3C3418!?<8d/[email protected]!3c14?@! /.;74! _/4@! m9("! /.4125?4/<.! 5.D! 37;;<241D! D/21?4! 1D/4/.B! <=! 4@1! 21?<.3427?41D! V$! 8<D1A]!! d1/.B!5!21;2131.45.4!<=!4@1!21?<.3427?4/<.5A!5;;2<5?@:!! 9.!E9OO%)"k!qWW!>1DDC!dC!9B5253@/!14!5A:!_53!;2131.41D!`VQb:!94!/3!<.1!<=!4@1!8<34! ?/41D!3c14?@Fd531D!3C34183:!94!37;;<243!=211=<28!342<c13!4<!D1=/.1!4@1!H$!3/A@<71441!<=!5.! <dZ1?4]!4@54!/3!42/5.B7A541D!73/.B!5!?<.3425/.1D!$1A57.5C!42/5.B7A54/<.:!)!?@<2D5A!5a/3]! _@/?@!?<..1?43!4@1!8/DDA13!<=!4@1!/.412.5A!1DB13!<=!4@1!42/5.B7A54/<.!/3!4@1.!d7/A4!5.D! 731D!53!5!3c1A14<.!4<!1A10541!4@1!372=5?1:!>@/3!3C3418!@53!/.3;/21D!85.C!<4@12!3C34183! D10<41D!4<!=211=<28!372=5?1!D1=/./4/<.!dC!3c14?@/.B:!S<2!1a58;A1]!m5.B!14!5A:!`Wlb!@501! ! ! D101A<;1D!5!3c14?@Fd531D!813@!1a4273/<.!814@<D!4@54!<012?<813!4@1!>1DDCF3!3;@12/?5A! 4<;<A<BC!A/8/454/<.:! p52;1.c<!14!5A:!;2131.41D!/.!HIIH!5!3C3418!`VWb!_/4@!5!012C!3/8;A1!7312!/.412=5?1]!/.!4@1! A/.1! <=! 9B5253@/h3! >1DDC]! 73/.B! 052/54/<.5A! /8;A/?/4! 372=5?13! =<2! <dZ1?4! 8<D1A/.B:! 94! 37;;<241D! <0123c14?@/.B! =<2! 21D1=/./.B! 4@1! d<7.D52C! <=! 5! dA<d! 5.D! ;2<0/D1D! 3/8;A1! .50/B54/<.!=5?/A/4/13!4<!5AA<_!73123!4<!2<4541!5.D!425.3A541!<dZ1?43:!>1DDC!D/D!.<4!37;;<24! 4@131!=1547213!3/.?1!4@1!_@<A1!3?1.1!?<.45/.3!5!3/.BA1!<dZ1?4:!jA<d85c12!dC!$1!)257Z<! 5.D! 6<2B1! `GJb! ;2131.43! 3<81! /8;2<0181.43! <012! p52;1.c<h3! 3C3418:! ! >@1! 8<D1AA12! 5AA<_3!4@1!7312!4<!8<D/=C!3@5;13!73/.B!4@1!812B/.B!5.D!<0123c14?@/.B!<;1254<23:!9.!4@1/2! 5;;2<5?@! 4@1! 3c1A14<.! /.=<2854/<.! B1.12541D! D72/.B! 4@1! /.=A54/<.! ;2<?133! <=! 5! dA<d! /3! 731D!4<!5AA<_!85./;7A54/<.!<=!dA<d3]!50</D/.B!4@1!731!<=!4@1!813@!21;2131.454/<.!=<2!4@1! /8;A181.454/<.!<=!4@1!<;1254<23:! 9.!HIIQ]!)A1a1!14!5A:!`Qb!;2131.41D!5.<4@12!=211=<28!372=5?1!8<D1A12!4@54!731D!9B5253@/h3! 3c1A14<.!1a425?4/<.!;2<?1D721!`VQb:!>@1C!18;A<C!4@1!3c1A14<.!4<!;A5?1!/8;A/?/4!3;@1213]! _@/?@!521!574<854/?5AAC!dA1.D1D!/.!<2D12!4<!21?<.3427?4!5!38<<4@!372=5?1:!>@/3!3C3418! 7313! 5! D<7dA1! 21;2131.454/<.T! 4@1! V$! 3@5;1! 5.D! 4@1! 3c1A14<.]! ;2<0/D/.B! 3/8/A52! =7.?4/<.5A/4/13! 4@54! ;210/<73! 3C34183]! /.?A7D/.B! .1_! 1D/4/.B! 4<<A3! 37?@! 53! 4@/?c.133! ?<.42<A! <=! 4@1! V$! 3@5;1]! [?<;CP?74\F;5341! 5.D]! <;1254/<.! <.! 4@1! 3c1A14<.:! 943! 85/.! D25_d5?c!/3!4@1!D/==/?7A4C!/.!21;2131.4/.B!3@52;!1DB13:!! >5/! 14! 5A:! `XVb! ;2131.41D! /.! HIIQ! 5! 3C3418! d531D! <.! ?<.0<A74/<.! 372=5?13! =<2! 4@1! D1=/./4/<.!<=!=211=<28!8<D1A3!34524/.B!=2<8!5!3/A@<71441!?7201:!>@1!B1.12541D!3@5;1!@53! ?/2?7A52! ?2<33F31?4/<.]! d74! /4! ?5.! d1! 8<D/=/1D! 73/.B! 5! 3c14?@1D! ;2<=/A1! <2! 3@5;1! ;525814123:!k<_1012]!/43!7312!/.412=5?1!=<AA<_3!4@1!m9("!;525D/B8:!!'7.<!14!5A:!`GRb! @501! ;2131.41D! /.! HIIl! 5! 3/8/A52! 3C3418]! d74! /4! /8;A181.43! 5! B134725A! /.412=5?1! 4@54! 3<A013!58d/B7/4C!3/4754/<.3!dC!815.3!<=!5!37BB134/01!/.412=5?1:! E4/A4<.! `Xlb! ! /3! 5! 3c14?@/.B! 3C3418! <2/1.41D! 4<! 52?@/41?4725A! D13/B.:! 94! 37;;<243! 3c14?@! /.;74! /.! 5! M%(L! 1.0/2<.81.4! 5.D! 7313! 5! 21?<.3427?4/<.! ;2<?133! 4@54! 7313! 4@1! <;4/8/g54/<.!5;;2<5?@!d531D!<.!B1.14/?!5AB<2/4@83:! ! ! O9$1E! `RGb! 5AA<_3! D545! /.;74! =2<8! 5! 3/.BA1F0/1_! ;2<Z1?4/<.! <2! =2<8! 310125A! D/1D25A! 0/1_3:!9.!4@1!?531!<=!<dZ1?4!21?<.3427?4/<.!=2<8!5!3/.BA1F0/1_!;123;1?4/01]!4@1!3C34183! ?<.45/.3!5!B134721!5A;@5d14!4<!/D1.4/=C!5!d53/?!314!<=!8<D1A/.B!;2/8/4/013!37?@!53T!;2/38]! ;C258/D]!1a4273/<.!5.D!210<A74/<.]!58<.B!<4@123:!9.!5DD/4/<.!4@1!DC.58/?!21?<B./4/<.!<=! 4@131!8<D1A/.B!B1347213!;2<0/D13!4@1!7312!5!.78d12!<=!?<.41a475A!/?<.3!_@/?@!5AA<_!@/8! 4<! ?<.=/28! @/3! D13/B.! 53378;4/<.3:! K/.! 14! 5A:! `RRb! 5A3<! ;2131.41D! /.! HIII! 5.! <.FA/.1! 3c14?@/.B!3C3418!d531D!<.!=7ggC!c.<_A1DB1!4@54!=<AA<_1D!4@1!=154721!d531D!8<D1A/.B! ;525D/B8!dC!5;;AC/.B!21?<B./4/<.!41?@./^713!4<!D/3?<012!V$!=1547213!3c14?@[email protected]! <.!5.!/3<8142/?!D25_/.B:!! '9O%&!`GQb!/8;A181.43!5.!/.4125?4/01!d1574/=/12!4@54!5DZ7343!4@1!/.;74!3c14?@!/.! 215A!4/81!5.D!=11D3!5!21?<.3427?4/<.!1.B/.1!<;1254/.B!<.!5.!5a<.<8142/?!;2<Z1?4/<.:!>@1! 3C3418! 37;;<243! 21?45.B7A52!;<AC@1D25A! <dZ1?43! 5.D! ;2<0/D13! DC.58/?! 0/1_;</.43! 4@54! 85c1!/4!153C!4<!/8;A181.4!5.!/.?2181.45A!8<D1A/.B!342541BC:!O#O%&EE!`llb!1a41.D3! '9O%&! ?5;5d/A/4/13]! 425.3=<28/.B! /4! /.4<! 5! @Cd2/D! 3C3418! [73/.B! d<4@! B134725A! 5.D! 21?<.3427?4/<.5A!5;;2<5?@13\!/.?<2;<254/.B!D/81.3/<.5A!?<.42<A!<012!3c14?@13!dC!815.3! <=! D/81.3/<.3! D25_.! dC! @5.D! 4@54! ?<.42<A! 5! ;5258142/?! B1<8142C! 1.B/.1:! ).<4@12! 1a58;A1! <=! @Cd2/D! 3C3418! /3! E()%>")"#%! `JHb]! 4@54!?<8d/.13! B134725A! ?<885.D3! _/4@!5!V$!21?<.3427?4/<.!5;;2<5?@!d531D!<.!L/;3<.h3!_<2c!`Qlb:! ><! 378! 7;]! 4@121! 521! 4_<! 85/.! 814@<D3! 4<! ?5;4721! D13/B.12! /.41.43T! 574<854/?! [21?<.3427?4/<.Fd531D\!5.D!/.4125?4/01![B134721Fd531D\:!$/==121.?13!/.!4@1!d1574/=/?54/<.! ;2<?133!5A3<!1a/34:!>@<31!D13/B.!/.41.43!4@54!@501!5!eA<?5Af!/8;5?4![/:1:!4@1C!5==1?4!4@1! B1<8142C! <.AC! /.! 4@1! .1/B@d<2@<<D! <=! 3<81! 1A181.4\! 521! 8<34AC! ?522/1D! <74! ?<.?7221.4AC! _/4@! 3c14?@/.B! [/.4125?4/01AC\:! j1574/=/?54/<.! 4@54! 5==1?43! 4@<31! D13/B.F /.41.43!4@54!21^7/21!BA<d5A!5A41254/<.3!<=!?7221.4!B1<8142C]!@<_1012]!521!d14412!D<.1!5=412! 3c14?@/.B! [/.! d54?@! 8<D1\:! '<2.123! 4@54! D<! .<4! 8114! 521! B<<D! 1a58;A13! <=! A<?5A! d1574/=/?54/<.3]!_@/A1!3C88142C!21^7/213!5!8<21!BA<d5A!?<.3/D1254/<.!`RHb:! ! ! 5??725?C:!+14]!7;!4<!D541]!?<8;7412Fd531D!3c14?@/.B!?5;5d/A/4/13!?<.4/.71!4<!d1!A/8/41D! 5.D!e7.;A7BB1Df!4<!')$!3C34183:! (<21<012]! D13/B.! /.41.43! 8734! d1! ?<.01241D! /.4<! 3c14?@1D! B1<8142C! d1=<21! 4@1C! ?5.!d1!e215Df!dC!4@<31!1a;12/81.45A!3c14?@Fd531D!8<D1A123:!9.!<4@12!_<2D3]!4@1!3C3418! ?215413! 5! D/B/45A! ;2<4<4C;1]! d74! 4@1! ?2154/<.! 453c! /3! .<4! eA/.c1Df! 4<! 5.C! ;210/<73! ?<.?1;475A!3C.4@13/3!453c:! 9.!<72!<;/./<.]!=<2!4@/3!;72;<31]!3<81!%-.*0-*(!<2/1.41D!4<!?2154/0/4C!1.@5.?181.4! 8734!d1!D1=/.1D!4<!/8;2<01!4@1!D13/B.12!4<!')$!3C3418!?<887./?54/<.:! >@1!5/8!/3!.<4!153C]!d1?5731!?<887./?54/<.!d14_11.!D13/B.123!5.D!')$!3C34183! /3! 7.d5A5.?1D! /.! =50<2! <=! ;2<B2588/.B! .11D3:! 9.! 4<D5Ch3! 34541]! ')$! 3C34183! =<2?1! D13/B.12!4<!?<.42<A!5!31^71.4/5A!=A<_]!D/21?41D!=2<8!3;1?/=/?54/<.3!4<!D145/A1D!D13/B.:! E1^71.4/5A!.54721!<=!5AB<2/4@8/?!A5.B75B13!/3!4@1!2153<.]!d1?5731!4@<31!A5.B75B13! 521!/.!4@1!d5?c!1.D!<=!4<D5Ch3!?<8;7412!4<<A3![5.D!O25;@/?5A!-312!9.412=5?13!521!.<4!5.! 1a?1;4/<.!4<!4@/3!27A1\:!>@1!.11D!=<2!;2<B2588123!4<!D1=/.1!5.!/8;A181.454/<.!8<D1A!<=! 4@1! ;2<?133! 4<! d1! 1a1?741D! 21/.=<2?13!4@1!31^71.4/5A!41.D1.?C:!j1?5731]!=<2! ;2<B2588123]! D1=/./.B! 5! ;2<?133! e?<.?1;475Af! 8<D1A! [e_@54f! 4@1! 3C3418! ?5.! D<\! 53! ?A<31!53!;<33/dA1!4<!4@1!e/8;A181.454/<.f!8<D1A![e@<_f!/4!D<13!/4\!/3!5A_5C3!4@1!3/8;A134! 3<A74/<.:! )3! 5! 2137A4]! D13/B.12! /3! ?<.4/.7<73AC! 53c1D! =<2! -&'"+./![_1AAFD1=/.1D!5.D! 31^71.4/5A!5?4/<.3\]!4<!d1!D<.1!dC!')$!3C3418:!).D!4@/3!/3!.<4!5!B<<D!342541BC!_@1.!4@1! D13/B.12!/3!42C/.B!4<!=/a!e0/3/<.3f]!4@54!/3]!/AA!D1=/.1D!5.D!.<.F31^71.4/5A!/D153:! >25.3;521.4!?<885.D3![/:1:!418;<252C!/.41227;4/<.!<=!5.!<2D12!4<!1a1?741!5.<4@12! e.1341Df! <2D12\! ?5.! B/01! 4@1! _2<.B! /8;2133/<.! 4@54! 7312! ?5.! D<! 5A8<34! 1012C4@/.B! /.! 5A8<34! 1012C! 8<81.4:! ).D]! /.! =5?4]! ')$$! 3C34183! [1,-2".*! 3C34183\! 521! @/B@AC! e/.4125?4/01f]! d1?5731! 4@1C! /8;<31! =1_! A/8/454/<.3! 4<! e_5.D1212f!73123:! j74! _1! 8734! 21818d12!4@54!4@1!2153<.!/3!4@54!4@1C!521!d531D!<.!D13?2/;4/01!B1<8142C!5.D!41?@./?5A! D25_/.B3T!D/3?/;A/.13!d531D!<.!.<.F31^71.4/5A!A5.B75B13:!-.=<247.541AC]!4@/3!/3!.<4!4@1! ?531!<=!215A!V$!')$!3C34183![1(/"*.!3C34183\:!')$!3C34183!?5.!?21541!0/2475A!4@211F ! ! D/81.3/<.5A! 8<D1A3! 4@54]! /.! 472.]! ?5.! d1! 3@<_.! /.! ;2144C! 21.D121D! [5.D]! <=! ?<7231]! B25;@/?\!/85B13:!j74!4@1!?<.3427?4/<.!<=!4@<31!8<D1A3!/3!342/?4AC!31^71.4/5A:!&.1!3/.BA1! 5?4/<.!=<AA<_3!1012C!?<885.D]!5.D!4@1!3C3418!472.3!d5?c!4<!4@1!e.17425Af!34541!_5/4/.B! =<2!4@1!.1a4!1a;A/?/4!?<885.D:! ><!378!7;]!5!A<4!<=!_<2c!@53!d11.!D<.1]!3/.?1!B134721!21?<B./4/<.!A/d252/13![A/c1! '5A/!`HGb\!5.D!3c14?@Fd531D!3C34183!!1a/34]!d74!<72!;2<dA18!/3!4@54!e.<.F012d5Af!4@<7B@4! ?5..<4! d1! 1a;21331D! /.! 5! e012d5Af! A5.B75B1:! M12d5A! /3! D1=/.1D! 53! 3C.<.C8<73! <=! 31^71.4/5A:!>@54!/3]!012d5A!A5.B75B13!521!d531D!<.!052/54/<.3!<=!5!314!<=!3/B.3!5A<.B!4@1! 4/81]! .1012! 8/.D! _@1.! 4@1! 3/B.3! ?5.! d1! 3<7.D3! <2! B25;@/?5A! =<283:! &.! 4@1! ?<.4252C]! .<.F012d5A![<2!eB25;@/?f\!A5.B75B13!521!4@<31!/.!_@/?@!425.38/33/<.!<=!/.=<2854/<.!/3! d531D!<.!4@1!815./.B!<=!5!;21D1=/.1D!314!<=!3/B.3]!d74!5A3<!/.!4@1!3;54/5A!21A54/<.3!58<.B! 5AA!3/B.3:!>@54!/3]!4@1!21318dA5.?1]!<2D12]!;2<;<24/<.!5.D!.1/B@d<2@<<D!21A54/<.3!;2131.4! /.!1012C!_2/441.!?<887./?54/<.![5.D!.1?13352C!5d31.4!/.!<25A!?<887./?54/<.3\:!94!8734! 5A3<! d1! .<4/?1D! 4@54! /.! .<.F31^71.4/5A! ?<887./?54/<.]! 4@1! 4/81! .11D1D! 5.D! <2D12! =<AA<_1D!4<!_2/41!5.D!215D!4@1!81335B1!D<13!.<4!5==1?4!4@1!/.=<2854/<.:! >@1!74<;/34!<dZ1?4/01!_<7AD!d1!5!D13/B.!3C3418!5dA1!4<!/.41B2541!5AA!/.=<2854/<.! ?<.45/.1D! /.! 5! 3c14?@! /.4125?4/01AC! D72/.B! 4@1! 3c14?@! ?2154/<.! 5.D! 21=/.181.4! ;@5313:! )dA1!4<!=<285A/g1!4@1!.<.F=<285A/g1D!/D153!?<.45/.1D!/.!4@1!3c14?@:!).D!5dA1!4<!5.5ACg1! 5.D! 105A7541! 4@1! ;2<0/3/<.5A! 8<D1A]! 5.D! B/01! 4@1! D13/B.12! 5! =11Dd5?c! <.! 4@1! ;12=<285.?1!<=!4@1!/.41.D1D!/D15:! m1!?5.!?<.3/D12!1.B/.112/.B!D25_/.B3!53!5!A5.B75B1!731D!=<2!?<887./?54/<.!5.D! /.!4@/3!31.31!/4!/3!21A541D!4<!345.D52D/g1D!?<.01.4/<.3:!k<_1012]!A5.B75B13!521!.<4!<.AC! 731=7A!=<2!?<887./?54/<.i!4@1C!;A5C!5.!/[email protected]!;524!/.!<72!4@/.c/.B!;2<?13313![/4!?5.!d1! 35/D! 4@54! _1! 731! A5.B75B13! 4<! eD/5A<Bf! _/4@! <7231A013\]! 5.D]! 4@121]! ;3C?@<A<BC! 5.D! ;12?1;4/<.!27A13!;A5C!4@1!8<34!/8;<245.4!2<A1:! ! ! IBD!4%2./5#+*2#"./'3/<'K%+2%K#"./' m@54!/3!e4271f!/.!5!D25_/.B!D1;1.D3!<.!4@1!;7237/4!<=!37?@!21;2131.454/<.:!9.!=5?4]! 1.B/.112/.B!B25;@/?3!D/==12!D1;1.D/.B!<.!4@1/2!;72;<31!<2!e57D/1.?1f:!>@1!D1;1.D1.?1! /3! <.! 4@1! 58<7.4! <=! /.=<2854/<.! [21^7/21D! ?A52/4C]! ;21?/3/<.! 5.D! A101A! <=! D145/A\! 4@1! 21?1/012!21^7/213!5.DP<2!?5.!;2<?133:!>@211!=<283!521!7375AAC!D/34/.B7/3@1DT! G:!85D1! =<2! ;123<.5A! 731]! 5.D! .<4! 815.4! 4<! d1! 7.D1234<<D! dC! 5.C<.1! d74! 4@1! /.D/0/D75A!_@<!;2<D7?1D!/4:! H:!/.41.D1D!4<!?<887./?541!4<!3<81<.1!_@<!7.D12345.D3!41?@./?5A!D25_/.B3:! V:!731D!4<!=724@12!?A52/=C! D13/B.!/D153!5.D! 4<! ?<887./?541!4@<31!/D153! 4<! .<.F 41?@./?5A!/.D/0/D75A3:! 9.! 4@1! 10<A74/<.! <=! B1<8142/?5A! 21?<.3427?4/<.! 4@1! 18;@53/3! @53! 8<01D! =2<8! B1<8142C! 4<! ;12?1;4/<.:! 9.! 4@1! d1B/../.B]! B1<8142C! _53! 4@1! ?1.412! <=! 5441.4/<.:! )3! Z734/=/1D!5d<01]!4@/3!_53!;524/5AAC!D71!4<!4@1!.11D!4<!/.412;214!_@54!_1!@501!?A533/=/1D!53! D25_/.B3!/.41.D1D!4<!?<887./?541!D13/B.3!5A215DC!=/./3@1D:!k<_1012]!8<21!5.D!8<21! 4@1! 18;@53/3! _53! 8<01D! 4<! ;12?1;4/<.]! /.! ;525AA1A! 4<! 4@1! B2<_/.B! /.412134! /.! 731! D25_/.B3!4<!=724@12!?A52/=C!D13/B.!/D153!5.D!4<!?<887./?541!4@<31!/D153!4<!.<.F41?@./?5A! /.D/0/D75A3:! '1245/.AC]!;12?1;4/<.!@53!d11.!A133!347D/1D!4@54!B1<8142C]!d74!1a?1AA1.4!21=121.?13! 1a/34! 4<! ?<012! 4@1! .11D3! <=! 5.! /.42<D7?4<2C! 347DC! =<2! 4@1! B1<8142/?5A! 21?<.3427?4/<.! ?<887./4C!`lXb!`VIb:!E<81!@/B@A/B@43!@501!4<!d1!D<.1!/.!<2D12!4<!45c1!4@1!85a/878! d1.1=/4!=2<8!;12?1;4/<.:! 9.!<72!<;/./<.]!;12?1;4/<.!/3!5!;2<?133!4<!1a425?4!/.=<2854/<.!=2<8!4@<31!34/87A/! 4@54!@501!05A71!53!3/B.5A3:!>@1C!521!?<.3/D121D!3/B.5A3!4@<31!34/87A/!4@54!;2<8<41!3<81! 3<24! <=! 5?4/<.:! ).D! 4@1C! 521! 5?4/<.3! d1?5731! ;12?1;4/<.! /3! 5.! 5?4/01! 5.D! ?<.3427?4/01! ;2<?133:! 9.! <4@12! _<2D3]! 53! 4@1! ;2<?133! /3! ?<.3427?4/01]! /4! /3! D<.1! 4@2<7B@! 345B13! [31^71.4/5A\!5.D!A101A3![@/1252?@/?5A\:!k1.?1]!/4!/3!5!7(9-:"+,:!S724@128<21]!4@/3!d1@50/<2! D1;5243!=2<8!5.!/..541!d531!5.D!/3!18;<_121D!dC!A152./.B:! ! ! j1?5731! <=! 4@1! ;12?1;4/<.! d1/.B! 5! d1@50/<2]! /4! 21^7/213! ".'(.'"+.!5.D!-''(.'"+.:! 9.41.4/<.! 3/.?1! /4! /3! 5! 31^71.4/5A! 5.D! 31A1?4/01! d1@50/<2:! m1! D<! <d31201! dC! _5C! <=! 37??133/01!1C1/.B]!5.D!<.AC!3<81!3;1?/=/?!53;1?43!521!?<.3/D121D!_@/A1!1C1/.B:!9.!=5?4]! 4@/3!d1@50/<2!Z734/=/13!_@C!?52/?547213!_<2cT!d1?5731!4@1C!3/8;A/=C!4@1!/85B13!d74!c11;! 5.D!1.A52B1!4@1!;124/.1.4!53;1?43:! j1?5731!<=!4@1!;12?1;4/<.!d1/.B!18;<_121D!dC!A152./.B]!425/./.B!/3!4<!d1!D2/01.! 4<_52D3!/.?21531!4@1!5441.4/<.:!94!/3!1(%"7(,-'(![_1!e;5C!5441.4/<.f\!5.D!1",(&'(1!4<!5.! <dZ1?4/01![_1!eA<<c!=<2!3<814@/.Bf\:!>@/3!/3!_@C!?58<7=A5B1!_<2c3T!d1?5731!_@1.!4@1! 53;1?4!_1!521!3152?@/.B!=<2!/3!@/DD1.]!4@1!1.4/21!<dZ1?4!D/35;;1523:! 9.! =5?4]! <;4/8/g54/<.! 5;;2<5?@! [A/c1! `lIb! /.! >5dA1! G\! /3! /41254/01! [<2! 31^71.4/5A\i! D1A/d12541]!d1?5731!_1!3152?@!=<2!21B7A52/4/13![/:1:!_1!;74!/.41.4/<.!5.D!5441.4/<.!4<_52D3! 4@<31!;2<;124/13!<=!4@1!/85B1!4@54!_1!d1A/101!4<!?<2213;<.D!4<!;2<;124/13!<=!4@1!8<D1A\]! 5.D]!<d0/<73AC]!/4!/3!D/21?41D!4<!5.!<dZ1?4/01![/:1:!_1!<;4/8/g1!5!=/B721!<=!812/4\:!94!/3!5A3<! @/1252?@/?5A]!3/.?1!21B7A52/4/13!521!_1/B@41D!/.!4@1!<dZ1?4/01!=7.?4/<.:!k<_1012]!21?1.4! ?<.42/d74/<.3! 4<! A/.152! ;2<B2588/.B! 5;;2<5?@! [A/c1! `HVb]! `XWb! 5.D! `XXb\! /.?A7D1! 3<;@/34/?541D! @/1252?@/38! 5AB<2/4@83! 4@54! <74;74! B<<D! 5AB<2/4@8/?! 3<A74/<.3! 4<! eD1A/d1254/<.f!<.!_@54!/3!;124/.1.4!/.!4@1!D25_/.B!4<!B14!4@1!d134!?@525?412/g54/<.!<=!4@1! 8<D1A:! 9.!378]!8<21!5.D!8<21]!4@1!21?<.3427?4/<.!5;;2<5?@13!45c1!/.4<!?<.3/D1254/<.!4@1! ;12?1;4/<.! ;2/.?/;A13! 5.D! A5_3]! 5.D]! ?<.31^71.4AC]! 4@1C! 521! /.! 4@1! _5C! 4<! -,'";"&"-%! $(,&($'"+.:! LB!6./2$*5"./5'3/<'F*#*+%'<%,%$.K1%/#5' >@1!=/234!e210<A74/<.f!<=!B25;@/?5A!?5;5d/A/4/13!<=!?<8;74123!/.!4@1!D13/B.!;2<?133! _53! 4<! 533/34! D25=4/.B]! 5.D! 5A8<34! 574<8541! /4:! >@1! 31?<.D! @53! d11.! /.42<D7?/.B! /.4125?4/01! ?2154/<.! 5.D! 85./;7A54/<.! <=! V$! 0/2475A! 8<D1A3! 4<! 21D7?1! [5.D! 5A8<34! 1A/8/.541\!4@1!.11D!=<2!D13?2/;4/01!B1<8142C:!9.!4@/3!_<2c]!_1!@501!52B71D!4@54!4@1!.1a4! e210<A74/<.f!_/AA! d1! 4<! 85c1!1.B/.112/.B! D25_/.B3! 4<! d1!5! 7./01235A!A5.B75B1! =<2!4@1! ! ! _@<A1!?<8;7412!5/D1D!D13/B.!;2<?133]!/.!<2D12!4<!21D7?1![5.D!0/2475AAC!1A/8/.541\!4@1! .11D!<=!D545!425.3=12!58<.B!D/==121.4!;@5313!/.!4@1!;2<?133:! O1<8142/?5A! 21?<.3427?4/<.! /3! B</.B! 4<! ;A5C! 5! =7.D581.45A! 2<A1! 53! 5! ?<21! 41?@.<A<BC! /.! 4@/3! ;2<?133]! 3/.?1! 574<854/?! 3<A/DF8<D1A! B1.1254/<.! =2<8! 345.D52D/g1D! D25_/.B3!/3!4@1!8<34!1==/?/1.4!_5C!4<!1345dA/3@!5!=A7/D!?<887./?54/<.!d14_11.!D13/B.123! 5.D!')$!3C34183:!>@/3!/3!4@1![email protected]!<=!V$!,(&+./',0&'"+.!<=!D13/B.!8<D1A3!=2<8! 1.B/.112/.B!D25_/.B3]!5.D!;12?1;4/<.!8734!;A5C!5!21A105.4!2<A1!/.!4@/3!;2<?133:! ! ! (29/.?$%<81%/#5' >@/3! _<2c! _53! ;524/5AAC! 37;;<241D! dC! >0.1-&"?! @-")-! @-/'(%%?AB-.&-")-!7.D12! 4@1!C.":(,/"'-'!D-0#(!E!;2<B258!=<2!%13152?@!"2<8<4/<.!["2<Z1?4!"GFGjHIIHFIX]!4/4A1D! eS2<8! 3c14?@! 4<! 8<D1AT! .1_! 7312! /.412=5?13! =<2! ')$! 3C34183f\! 5.D! 4@1! E;5./3@! (/./342C!<=!E?/1.?1!5.D!#D7?54/<.!5.D!4@1!#72<;15.!-./<.!["2<Z1?4!$"9HIIQFIGVJV\:! ! ! 4%F%+%/2%5' `Gb!)@FE<<.! ']! ><8d21! p:! )! 341;! 4<_52D3! 21?<.3427?4/<.! <=! VF$! ')$! 8<D1A3! =2<8! 1.B/.112/.B! D25_/.B3:! "2<?11D/.B3! <=! 4@1! V2D!9.4:!'<.=121.?1!<.! $<?781.4!).5AC3/3!5.D!%1?<B./4/<.]!(<.4215A]!'5.5D5!GQFGR!)7B734!GWWl:!;:! VVGFVVQ:! `Hb!)AD1=1AD!j]!%/?@412!k:!E18/574<854/?!4@211FD/81.3/<.5A!/.412;21454/<.!<=!A/.1! D25_/.B3:!'<8;74123!s!O25;@/?3!GWXQi!X[Q\T!VJGFVXI:! `Vb!)AD1=1AD! j:! &.! 574<854/?! 21?<B./4/<.! <=! V$! 3427?47213! =2<8! H$! 21;2131.454/<.3:!'<8;7412F)/D1D!$13/B.!GWXVi!Gl[H\T!lWFRQ:! `Qb!)A1a1! )]! O5/AD254! M]! j524@1! L:! 9.4125?4/01! 8<D1AA/.B! =2<8! 3c14?@13! 73/.B! 3;@12/?5A!/8;A/?/4!=7.?4/<.3:!"2<?11D/.B3!<=!4@1!V2D!9.412.54/<.5A!'<.=121.?1!<.! '<8;7412! O25;@/?3]! M/2475A! %15A/4C]! M/375A/354/<.! 5.D! 9.4125?4/<.! /.! )=2/?5]! )=2/B25;@!HIIQ]!*1_!+<2cT!)'(!"2133]!HIIQ]!;:!HlFVQ:! `lb!j<<c12!"6:!)!k/34<2C!<=!#.B/.112/.B!$25_/.B:!L<.D<.T!*<24@B541!"7dA/3@/.B! '<:!L4D]!GWJW![S/234!"2/.41D!/.!GWRV\:! `Rb!j25.?<!M]!!'<345!)]!!S1221/25!S*:!Ec14?@/.B!V$!8<D1A3!_/4@!H$!/.4125?4/<.! D10/?13:!'<8;7412!O25;@/?3!S<278!GWWQi!GV[V\T!QXWFlIH:! `Jb!j25.?<! M]! '<345! )]! *7.13! S:! Ec14?@/.B! V$! 8<D1A3! _/4@! H$! /.4125?4/<.! D10/?13:!'<8;7412!O25;@/?3!S<278!GWWQi!GV[V\T!QXWFlIH:! `Xb!j2<_.!#]!m5.B!"E:!>@211FD/81.3/<.5A!<dZ1?4!21?<012C!=2<8!4_<FD/81.3/<.5A! /85B13T!5!.1_!5;;2<5?@:!9.T!'53531.4!$"]!1D/4<2:!"2<?!E"9#!HWIQ]!9.41AA/B1.4! %<d<43!5.D!'<8;7412!M/3/<.!tMT!)AB<2/4@83]!>1?@./^713])?4/01!M/3/<.]!5.D! (5412/5A3!k5.DA/.B]!GWWR:!;:!GVXFGQJ:! `Wb!'@1.!u]!"12.B!$]!'@1.!']!m7!':!S534!21?<.3427?4/<.!<=!V$!81?@5./?5A!;5243! =2<8! H$! <24@<B25;@/?! 0/1_3! _/4@! 27A13:! '<8;7412! 9.41B2541D! (5.7=5?472/.B! GWWHi!l[G\T!HNW:! `GIb!'@1.! u]! "12.B! $:! )74<854/?! 21?<.3427?4/<.! <=! V$! 3<A/D! <dZ1?43! =2<8! H$! <24@<B25;@/?!0/1_3:!"54412.!%1?<B./4/<.!GWXXi!HG[l\T!QVWFQQW:! `GGb!'A<_13!(j:!&.!311/.B!4@/.B3:!)24/=/?/5A!9.41AA/B1.?1!GWJGi!H[G\T!JWFGGH:! `GHb!'<8;5.C! "]! '<.412<! (]! '<.135! 6]! "/^712! ):! ).! <;4/8/354/<.Fd531D! 21?<.3427?4/<.! 1.B/.1! =<2! V$! 8<D1A/.B! dC! 3c14?@/.B:! '<8;74123! s! O25;@/?3! HIIQi!HX[R\T!WllFWJW:! `GVb!'<8;5.C! "]! O<8/3! 6(]! '<.412<! (T! O1<8142/?5A! 21?<.3427?4/<.! =2<8! 3/.BA1! A/.1!D25_/.B3!73/.B!<;4/8/g54/<.Fd531D!5;;2<5?@13:!"2<?11D/.B3!<=!mE'O!hWW]! "Ag1.]!'g1?@!%1;7dA/?!XFGH!S1d2752C!GWWW:!;:!VRGFVRX:! `GQb!'<.412<! (]! *5C5! S]! 6<2B1! 6]! '<.135! 6:! '9O%&T! 5! 8/./85A! /.3427?4/<.! 314! ?5AA/B25;@/?! /.412=5?1! =<2! 3c14?@Fd531D! 8<D1A/.B:! L1?4721! *<413! /.! '<8;7412! E?/1.?1!HIIVi!HRRWT!lQWFllX:! `Glb!'7B/./!-:!>@1!;2<dA18!<=!7312!/.412=5?1!/.!B1<8142/?!8<D1A/.B:!'<8;74123!/.! 9.D7342C!GWWGi!GJ[Q\T!VVlFVVW:! `GRb!'7.<!)]!#3;125.v5!']!'505A?5.4/!"%]!S52/53!%:!V$!S211FS<28!(<D1A/.B!_/4@! M52/54/<.5A!E72=5?13:!>@1!6<72.5A!<=!mE'O!HIIli!GV[GFV\T!WFGR:!!! `GJb!$1! )257Z<! j]! 6<2B1! 6:! jA<d(5c12T! S211F=<28! 8<D1AA/.B! _/4@! 052/54/<.5A! /8;A/?/4! 372=5?13:! "2<?11D/.B3! <=! GHw! #.?<.42<! "<247B7x3! D1! '<8;745vy<! O2z=/?5]!"<24<]!HIIV:!;:!GJFHR:! ! ! `GXb!$<2/! $]! ><8d21! p:! S2<8! 1.B/.112/.B! D25_/.B3! 4<! V$! ')$! 8<D1A3T! 521! _1! 215DC!.<_{:!'<8;7412F)/D1D!$13/B.!GWWli!HJ[Q\T!HQVFHlQ:! `GWb!#BBA/!L]!j2|D12A/.!j"]!#Ad12!O:!Ec14?@/.B!53!5!3<A/D!8<D1A12!4<<A:!"2<?11D/.B3! <=! 4@1! V2D! )'(! 3C8;<3/78! <.! 3<A/D! 8<D1A/.B! 5.D! 5;;A/?54/<.3:! E5A4! L5c1! '/4C]!-45@]!-./41D!E45413]!GWWl:!*1_!+<2cT!)'(!"2133]!GWWl]!;:!!VGVFVHH:!!!!! `HIb!S12B73<.! #E:! #.B/.112/.B! 5.D! 4@1! (/.Dn3! #C1:! '58d2/DB1]! ()T! >@1! (9>! "2133]!GWWQ:! `HGb!S<.31?5! (]! 6<2B1! 6:! #a;12/81.45A! #05A754/<.! <=! 5.! &.FL/.1! E?2/ddA1! %1?<B./g12:!"54412.!%1?<B./4/<.!L144123!HIIGi!HH[GH\T!GVGGFGVGW:! `HHb!O1.B!m]!m5.B!6][email protected]!+:!#8d1DD/.B!0/375A!?<B./4/<.!/.!V$!21?<.3427?4/<.! =2<8!87A4/F0/1_!1.B/.112/.B!D25_/.B3:!'<8;7142F)/D1D!$13/B.!HIIHi!VQT!VHGF VVR:! `HVb!O2/83415D! 96]! (524/.! %%:! '2154/.B! 3<A/D! 8<D1A3! =2<8! 3/.BA1! H$! 3c14?@13:! "2<?11D/.B3!<=!4@1!V2D!EC8;:!<.!E<A/D!(<D1A/.B!);;A/?54/<.3]!E5A4!L5c1!'/4C]! -45@!GJFGW!(5C!GWWl:!*1_!+<2cT!)'(!"2133]!;:!VHVFVVJ:! `HQb!O2/83415D!96]!(524/.! %%:!9.?2181.45A!A/.1! A5d1AA/.B! =<2!3c14?@! /.;74!<=! 3<A/D! 8<D1A3:!'<8;7412!O25;@/?3!S<278!GWWRi!Gl[H\T!GllFGRR:! `Hlb!O7! p]! >5.B! u]! E7.! 6:! %1?<.3427?4/<.! <=! V$! <dZ1?43! =2<8! <24@<B25;@/?! ;2<Z1?4/<.3:!'<8;7412!O25;@/?3!S<278!GWXRi!l[Q\T!VGJFVHQ:! `HRb!O7Z52!-O]!*5B1.D25!9M:!'<.3427?4/<.!<=!V$!3<A/D!<dZ1?43!=2<8!<24@<B25;@/?! 0/1_3:!'<8;74123!s!O25;@/?3!GWXWi!GV[Q\T!lIlFlHG:! `HJb!O7g8z.! ):! $1?<8;<3/4/<.! <=! 5! 0/375A! 3?1.1! /.4<! 4@211FD/81.3/<.5A! d<D/13:! "2<?11D/.B3!<=!)S9"E!S5AA!6</.4!'<8;7412!'<.=]!GWRX:!;:!HWGFVIQ:! `HXb!k525A/?c! %(]! K711.1C! $:! -.D12345.D/.B! 1.B/.112/.B! D25_/.B3:! '<8;7412! O25;@/?3!5.D!985B1!"2<?133/.B!GWXHi!HIT!HQQFHlX:! `HWb!k12<4! 'S:! O25;@/?5A! /.;74! 4@2<7B@! 85?@/.1! 21?<B./4/<.! <=! 3c14?@13:! )'(! E9OO%)"k!'<8;7412!O25;@/?3!GWJRi!GI[H\T!WJFGIH:!!!! `VIb!k<==85..!$:!M/375A!9.41AA/B1.?1:!k<_!_1!?21541!_@54!_1!311:!*1_!+<2cT!mm! *<24<.!s!'<8;5.C]!HIII:! `VGb!k7==85.! $):! 98;<33/dA1! <dZ1?43! 53! .<.31.31! 31.41.?13:! 9.! j12.52D! (1A4g12! 5.D!$<.5AD!(/?@/1]!1D/4<23]!(5?@/.1!9.41AA/B1.?1!GWJGi!RT!HWlFVHV:!#D/.d72B@! -./0123/4C!"2133:! `VHb!9D135_5! (:! )! 3C3418! 4<! B1.12541! 5! 3<A/D! =/B721! =2<8! 4@211! 0/1_3:! 6E(#! j7AA14/.!GWJVi!GRT!HGRFHHl:! `VVb!9B5253@/!>]!(5437<c5!E]!p5_5?@/C5!E]!>5.5c5!k:!9.4125?4/01!d1574/=/?54/<.T!5! 41?@./^71!=<2!25;/D!B1<8142/?!D13/B.:!"2<?11D/.B3!<=!4@1!)'(!EC8;<3/78!<.! -312! 9.412=5?1! E<=4_521! 5.D! >1?@.<A<BC! [-9E>hWJ\]! &?4<d12! GQNGJ]! GWWJ:! *1_!+<2cT!)'(!"2133]!GWWJ:!;:!GIlFGGQ:!! `VQb!9B5253@/! >]! (5437<c5! E]! >5.5c5! k:!>1DDCT!5!3c14?@/.B!/.412=5?1!=<2!V$! =211=<28! D13/B.:! "2<?11D/.B3! <=! )'(! E9OO%)"k! hWW]! L<3! ).B1A13]! '5A/=<2./5!XFGV!)7B734!GWWW:!;:!QIWFQGR:! `Vlb!61.c/.3! $L]! (524/.! %%:! );;AC/.B! ?<.3425/.43! 4<! 1.=<2?1! 73123h! /.41.4/<.3! /.! [email protected]!HF$!3c14?@13:!9.41AA/B1.4!EC34183!#.B/.112/.B!GWWHi!G[G\T!VGFQW:! `VRb!6<@.3<.!>#:!Ec14?@;5D!999]!4@211!D/81.3/<.5A!B25;@/?5A!?<887./?54/<.!_/4@!5! D/B/45A!?<8;7412:!"@$!>@13/3:!(:9:>:]!'58d2/DB1]!()!-E)]!GWRV:! ! ! `VJb!p5.5D1!>:!)!4@1<2C!<=!<2/B58/!_<2AD:!)24/=/?/5A!9.41AA/B1.?1!GWXIi!GV[V\T!HJWF VGG:! `VXb!p5.B!$!6]!(532C!(]!L/;3<.!k:!%1?<.3427?4/<.!<=!5!V$!&dZ1?4!S2<8!5!(5/.! )a/3! EC3418]! )))9! S5AA! EC8;<3/78! <.! (5c/.B! "1.Fj531D! 9.4125?4/<.! 9.41AA/B1.4!5.D!*54725A]!&?4<d12!HIIQ]!;:!RVFRW:! `VWb!p52;1.c<! &]! k7B@13! 6S]! %53c52! %:! S211F=<28! 3c14?@/.B! _/4@! 052/54/<.5A! /8;A/?/4!372=5?13:!'<8;7412!O25;@/?3!S<278!HIIHi!HG[V\T!lXlFlWQ:! `QIb!p7<!(kT!%1?<.3427?4/<.!<=!^75D2/?!372=5?1!3<A/D3!=2<8!4@211F0/1_!1.B/.112/.B! D25_/.B3:!'<8;7412F)/D1D!$13/B.!GWWXi!VI[J\T!lGJFlHJ:! `QGb!L5=71! O:! %1?<B./4/<.! <=! 4@211! D/81.3/<.5A! <dZ1?43! =2<8! <24@<B25;@/?! 0/1_3:! '<8;7412!O25;@/?3!GWJR![E9OO%)"khJR\i!;;:GIVFGIX:! `QHb!L58d! $]! j5.D<;5D@5C! ):! 9.412;214/.B! 5! V$! <dZ1?4! =2<8! 5! 2<7B@! H$! A/.1! D25_/.B:!"2<?11D/.B3!<=!M/375A/g54/<.!hWI]!E5.!S25.?/3?<]!'5A/=<2./5!GWWI:!;:! lWFRR:! `QVb!L1?A12?!+]!S/3?@A12!(:!).!<;4/8/g54/<.Fd531D!5;;2<5?@!4<!4@1!/.412;21454/<.!<=! 3/.BA1!A/.1!D25_/.B3!53!V$!_/21!=25813:!9.4:!6:!<=!'<8;7412!M/3/<.!GWWHi!W[H\T! GGVFGVR:! `QQb!L11!k]!k5.!E:!%1?<.3427?4/<.!<=!V$!/.4125?4/.B!3<A/D3!<=!210<A74/<.!=2<8!H$! <24@<B25;@/?!0/1_3:!'<8;7412F)/D1D!$13/B.!HIIl:!9.!;2133:! `Qlb!L/;3<.!k]!E@;/45A./!(:!&;4/8/g54/<.Fd531D!21?<.3427?4/<.!<=!5!V$!<dZ1?4!=2<8! 5!3/.BA1!=[email protected]!A/.1!D25_/.B:!'<8;7412F)/D1D!$13/B.!GWWRi!HX[X\T!RlGFRRV:! `QRb!L/7! Et]! k7! E(]! '@1.! +6]! E7.! 6O:! %1?<.3427?4/<.! <=! ?7201D! 3<A/D3! =2<8! 1.B/.112/.B!D25_/.B3:!'<8;7412F)/D1D!$13/B.!HIIGi!VVT!GIlWFGIJH:! `QJb!LC35c!$j]!$1057a!"(]!p53472/!%:!M/1_!A5d1A/.B!=<2!574<8541D!/.412;21454/<.! <=!1.B/.112/.B!D25_/.B3:!"54412.!%1?<B./4/<.!GWWli!HX[V\T!VWVFQIJ:! `QXb!(5?c_<24@! )p:! 9.412;214/.B! ;/?47213! <=! ;<AC@1D25A! 3?1.13:! )24/=/?/5A! 9.41AA/B1.?1!GWJVi!Q[H\T!GHGFGVJ:! `QWb!(5A/c! 6:! 9.412;214/.B! A/.1! D25_/.B3! <=! ?7201D! <dZ1?43:! 9.4:! 6:! <=! '<8;7412! M/3/<.!GWXJi!GT!JVFGIV:! `lIb!(52/AA! >:! #87A54/.B! 4@1! @785.! /.412;21454/<.! <=! A/.1FD25_/.B3! 53! 4@211F D/81.3/<.5A!<dZ1?43:!9.4:!6:!<=!'<8;7412!M/3/<.!GWWGi!R[H\T!GQJFGRG:! `lGb!(524}! #]! %1B/.?~3! 6]! L~;1gFp25@1! 6]! M/AA5.7105! 66:! k5.D! A/.1! D25_/.B! /.412;21454/<.! 53! 4@211FD/81.3/<.5A! <dZ1?43:! E/B.5A! "2<?133/.B! GWWVi! VH[GFH\T! WGFGGI:! `lHb!(537D5!k]!*785<!(:!)!?1AAFd531D!5;;2<5?@!=<2!B1.1254/.B!3<A/D!<dZ1?43!=2<8! <24@<B25;@/?!;2<Z1?4/<.3:!'<8;7412F)/D1D!$13/B.!GWWJi!HW[V\T!GJJFGXJ:! `lVb!(1125.! E]! "2544! (6:! )74<8541D! =154721! 21?<B./4/<.! =2<8! H$! D25_/.B:! '<8;7412F)/D1D!$13/B.!GWWVi!Hl[G\T!JFGJ:! `lQb!*5B1.D25!9M]!O7Z52!-O:!VF$!<dZ1?43!=2<8!HF$!<24@<B25;@/?!0/1_3!F!)!37201C:! '<8;74123!s!O25;@/?3!GWXXi!GH[G\T!GGGFGGQ:! `llb!*5C5!S]!'<.412<!(]!)A1/a<3!*]!6<2B1!6:!"5258142/?![email protected]!3c14?@13:!L1?4721! *<413!/.!'<8;7412!E?/1.?1!HIIQi!VIQQT!GGQFGHI:! `lRb!*1B2<;<.41!*]!>5BB524!>:!k-*'kF!5.!1a;12/81.4!/.!3c14?@!21?<B./4/<.]o!/.! '<8;7412!O25;@/?3]!1D/41D!dC!m:!O/A</]!j12A/.]!GWJG:! `lJb!&@!jE]!p/8!'k:!"2<B2133/01!21?<.3427?4/<.!<=!V$!<dZ1?43!=2<8!5!3/.BA1!=211F @5.D!A/.1!D25_/.B:!'<8;74123!s!O25;@/?3!HIIVi!HJT!lXGFlWH:! ! ! `lXb!"5A812!E#:!M/3/<.!E?/1.?1:!"@<4<.3!4<!"@1.<81.<A<BC:!'58d2/DB1]!()T!>@1! (9>!"2133]!GWWW:! `lWb!"52<D/!":!>@1!?<8;A1a/4C!<=!7.D12345.D/.B!A/.1!D25_/.B!<=!&2/B58/!3?1.13:!9.4:! 6:!<=!'<8;7412!M/3/<.!GWWRi!GX[H\T!GVWFGJI:! `RIb!"50A/D/3!>]!M5.!mCc!'6:!).!574<854/?!d1574/=/12!=<2!D25_/.B3!s!/AA734254/<.3:! '<8;7412!O25;@/?3!GWXli!GW[V\T!HHlFHVQ:!! `RGb!"121/25! 6]! 6<2B1! 6]! j25.?<! M]! *7.13! S:! ><_52D3! ?5AA/B25;@/?! /.412=5?13T! 3c14?@/.B! V$!3?1.13! _/4@! B1347213! 5.D! ?<.41a4! /?<.3:! "2<?11D/.B3! <=! mE'O! hHIII]!"Ag1.]!'g1?@!%1;7dA/?!JFGI!S1d2752C!HIII:! `RHb!"/^712! )]! (524/.! %%]! '<8;5.C! ':! Ec1_1D! (/22<2! EC88142C! =<2! $1;4@! #34/854/<.! /.! V$! L/.1! $25_/.B3:! L1?4721! *<413! /.! '<8;7412! E?/1.?1! HIIQ]! VIXXTGQHFGlV! `RVb!"/^712! ):! )24/=/?/5A! ;12?1;4/<.! <=! A/.1! D25_/.B3:! "@$:! >@13/3:! 65781! 9! -./0123/4C]!E;5/.]!HIIV![/.!E;5./3@\:!9Ej*T!XQFRXXFJIRGFJ! `RQb!"21/33! p:! '<.3427?4/.B! 4@1! 3<A/D! 21;2131.454/<.! =2<8! 1.B/.112/.B! ;2<Z1?4/<.3:! '<8;7412!s!O25;@/?3!GWXQi!X[Q\T!VXGFVXW:! `Rlb!"7B@! $:! $13/B./.B! 3<A/D! <dZ1?43! 73/.B! /.4125?4/01! 3c14?@! /.412;21454/<.:! "2<?11D/.B3!<=!4@1!GWWH!EC8;<3/78!<.!9.4125?4/01!V$!O25;@/?3]!'58d2/DB1]! (5335?@731443]!-E)]!GWWH:!*1_!+<2c]!*+]!-E)T!)'(!"2133]!GWWH:!;:!GGJF GHR:! `RRb!K/.! ES]! m2/B@4! $p]! 6<2D5.<0! 9*:! S2<8! <.FA/.1! 3c14?@/.B! 4<! H$! 5.D! V$! B1<8142CT!5!3C3418!d531D!<.!=7ggC!c.<_A1DB1:!'<8;7412F)/D1D!$13/B.!HIIIi! VH[GQ\T!XlGFXRR:! `RJb!%<d1243!LO:!(5?@/.1!;12?1;4/<.!<=!4@211FD/81.3/<.5A!3<A/D3:!"@:$:!4@13/3]!(9>! $1;:!<=!#A1?42/?5A!#.B/.112/.B]!GWRV:! `RXb!%<3!L]!>@<853!S:!&012?<8/.B!E7;12342/?4.133!/.!L/.1!$25_/.B!9.412;21454/<.:! 9###!>25.3:!<.!"54412.!).5AC3/3!5.D!(5?@/.1!9.41AA/B1.?1!HIIHi!HQ[Q\T!QlRF QRR:! `RWb!E5c725/!k:!E<A/D!8<D1A!/.;74!4@2<7B@!<24@<B25;@/?!0/1_3:!'<8;74123!O25;@/?3! GWXVi!GJ[V\T!HQVFHlH:! `JIb!E5342C!$E]!E5385A!*]!(7c12Z11!):!#==/?/1.4!?541B<2/g54/<.!<=!V$!1DB13!=2<8! H$! ;2<Z1?4/<.3:! "2<?11D/.B3! <=! 4@1! V2D!9)"%!9.4:!m<2c3@<;!<.!O25;@/?3! %1?<B./4/<.!O%#'!hWW]!65/;72]!9.D/5!HRFHJ!E1;418d12!GWWW:!;:!HXXFHWJ:! `JGb!E?@_1/c52D4!#]!O2<33!($:!$/B/45A!'A5CT!D12/0/.B!D/B/45A!8<D1A3!=2<8![email protected]! 3c14?@13:!)74<854/<.!/.!'<.3427?4/<.!HIIIiW[G\TGIJFGGl! `JHb!E@13@!)]!'@1.!j:!E()%>")"#%T!).!/.4125?4/01!5.D!7312!=2/1.DAC!3c14?@/.B! 3C3418:!'<8;7412!O25;@/?3!S<278!HIIQi!HV[V\T!VIGFVGI:! `JVb!E@/83@<./!9]!"<.?1! 6:!%1?<012/.B!4@1!3@5;1!<=!;<AC@1D25!73/.B!A/.1FD25_/.B! 5.5AC3/3! 5.D! ?<8;A1a! 21=A1?45.?1! 8<D1A3:! "2<?11D/.B3! <=! 9###! '<.=:! '<8;7412!M/3/<.!5.D!"54412.!%1?<B./4/<.!'M"%!hWQ]!E1544A1]!HGFHV!67.1!GWWQ:! ;:!lGQFlGW:! `JQb!E@/.! jE]! E@/.! +O:! S534! V$! 3<A/D! 8<D1A! 21?<.3427?4/<.! =2<8! <24@<B25;@/?! 0/1_3:!'<8;7412F)/D1D!$13/B.!GWWXi!VI[G\T!RVFJR:! `Jlb!E@78!E"]!L57!mE]!+71.!(S]!+7!p(:!E<A/D!21?<.3427?4/<.!=2<8!<24@<B25;@/?! <;5^71!0/1_3!73/.B!/.?2181.45A!1a4273/<.:!'<8;74123!s!O25;@/?3!GWWJi!HG[R\T! JXJFXII:!