Full text
A&A, 690, A216 (2024)
h ps://doi.o g/10.1051/0004-6361/202348572
c
The Au ho s 2024
As onomy
&
As ophysics
Va ying linea pola isa ion in he dus - ee gamma- ay
bu s 210610B
J. F. Agüí Fe nández1,?, A. de Uga e Pos igo2,3 , C. C. Thöne4, S. Kobayashi5, A. Rossi6, K. Toma7,8 ,
M. Jelínek4, D. A. Kann1,9, S. Co ino10 , K. Wie sema11, D. Ha mann12 , P. Jakobsson13, A. Ma in-Ca illo14,
A. Meland i15,10, M. De Pasquale16, G. Pugliese17, S. Sa aglio6,18,19 , R. L. C. S a ling20, J. Š obl4,
M. Della Valle21, S. de We 22, and T. Za a 23,24
(A ilia ions can be ound a e he e e ences)
Recei ed 12 No embe 2023 /Accep ed 23 Feb ua y 2024
ABSTRACT
Con ex . Long gamma- ay bu s s (GRBs) a e p oduced by he collapse o some e y massi e s a s, ha emi ul a- ela i is ic je s. When he je s
collide wi h he in e s ella medium hey decele a e and gene a e he so-called a e glow emission, which has been obse ed o be pola ised.
Aims. We s udy he pola ime ic e olu ion o he GRB210610B a e glow, a z=1.1341. This allows us o e alua e he ole o geome ic and/o
magne ic mechanisms in he GRB a e glow pola isa ion.
Me hods. We obse ed GRB210610B using imaging pola ime y wi h CAFOS on he 2.2 m Cala Al o Telescope and FORS2 on he 4 ×8.1m
Ve y La ge Telescope. Complemen a y op ical spec oscopy was ob ained wi h OSIRIS on he 10.4m G an Telescopio Cana ias. We s udied he
GRB ligh -cu e om X- ays o he op ical bands and he Spec al Ene gy Dis ibu ion (SED). This allowed us o s ongly cons ain he line-o -
sigh ex inc ion. Finally, we s udied he GRB hos galaxy using op ical o NIR da a o i he SED and de i e i s in eg a ed p ope ies.
Resul s. GRB210610B had a b igh a e glow wi h a negligible line-o -sigh ex inc ion. Pola ime y was ob ained a h ee epochs: du ing an ea ly
pla eau phase, a he ime when he ligh cu e b eaks, and a e he ligh cu e s eepened. We obse e an ini ial pola isa ion o ∼4% ha goes o
ze o a he ime o he b eak, and i hen again inc eases o ∼2%, wi h a change in he posi ion angle o 54 ±9deg. The spec um shows ea u es
wi h e y low equi alen wid hs. This indica e a small amoun o ma e ial in he line o sigh wi hin he hos .
Conclusions. The lack o dus and he low amoun o ma e ial in he line o sigh o GRB210610B allowed us o s udy he in insic pola isa ion
o he GRB op ical a e glow. The GRB pola isa ion signals a e consis en wi h o de ed magne ic ields in e eshed shock o /and hyd odynamics-
scale u bulen ields in he o wa d shock.
Key wo ds. pola iza ion – echniques: pola ime ic – gamma- ay bu s : indi idual: GRB210610B
1. In oduc ion
Gamma- ay bu s s (GRBs) a e among he mos ene ge ic elec-
omagne ic explosions ha ha e been obse ed in he Uni e se.
These e en s ha e wo main emission episodes: he p omp -
emission and he a e glow-emission phases. The p omp emis-
sion ep esen s he i s obse able elec omagne ic emission and
is domina ed by gamma- ay pho ons las ing seconds o minu es
a e he onse o he bu s . The a e glow has a synch o on spec-
um anging om adio o gamma- ays and e ol es in ime du -
ing much longe ime spans.
GRBs a e ypically classi ied as sho o long acco ding o
hei measu ed T901du a ion in gamma- ays (Kou elio ou e al.
1993). Sho GRBs (sGRB) a e associa ed wi h he coales-
cence o wo compac objec s, hei T90 du a ion is ypically
sho e han 2seconds, and hei X- ay spec um is ha d. The
disco e y o a sGRB associa ed wi h he g a i a ional wa e
(GW) de ec ion GW170817 de ini i ely linked a sGRB wi h he
me ge o wo neu on s a s (Abbo e al. 2017). On he o he
hand, long GRBs (lGRB) ha show T90 longe han 2seconds
and ha e a so e spec a in he p omp emission phase. These
a e ca aclysmic e en s associa ed wi h he collapse o massi e
s a s. They a e also associa ed wi h he de ec ion o b oad-line
?Co esponding au ho ; [email p o ec ed]
1The T90 is he ime span wi hin which a GRB eleases be ween 5%
and 95% o he o al ene gy du ing he p omp phase.
(BL) ype Ic supe no ae (SNe) (see e.g. Galama e al. 1998;
Hjo h e al. 2003). La ely, se e al e en s de ec ing a kilono a
(KN) emission in a bu s wi h a du a ion o dozen seconds
ha e cas doub s on he 2-seconds di ision as he unique c i e-
ion o dis inguish be ween sGRBs and lGRBs (Ras inejad e al.
2022;T oja e al. 2022;Yang e al. 2022;Gompe z e al. 2023;
Le an e al. 2023,2024).
The p omp emission in a GRB is powe ed by a newly
o med compac objec ha is ed by he su ounding ma e ial.
Acc e ion on o his compac objec launches ul a- ela i is ic
je s, in which he p omp emission is gene a ed h ough in e -
nal dissipa ion p ocesses including in e nal shocks (see e.g.
Rees & Mesza os 1994;Sa i & Pi an 1997;Kobayashi e al.
1997). This p omp high-ene gy emission eleases iso opic-
equi alen ene gies ha can each up o 1055 e g (see e.g.
Bu ns e al. 2023), al hough he eal eleased ene gy can be se -
e al o de s o magni ude lowe due o he je collima ion.
Pola ime y is an essen ial ool o explaining GRB physics.
Using his echnique, we can es models ha include magne ic
ields and he geome ical cha ac e is ics ha a e a play, and we
can de e mine how hey e ol e h oughou he di e en phases
o he GRB. The s udy o he p omp emission pola isa ion and
i s empo al e olu ion can help us o unde s and how he je is
powe ed by he cen al engine. The long and ex emely b igh
GRB221009A was obse ed du ing he p omp - and a e glow-
emission phase by he Imaging X- ay Pola ime y Explo e
Open Access a icle, published by EDP Sciences, unde he e ms o he C ea i e Commons A ibu ion License (h ps://c ea i ecommons.o g/licenses/by/4.0),
which pe mi s un es ic ed use, dis ibu ion, and ep oduc ion in any medium, p o ided he o iginal wo k is p ope ly ci ed.
This a icle is published in open access unde he Subsc ibe o Open model.Subsc ibe o A&A o suppo open access publica ion.
A216, page 1 o 17
Agüí Fe nández, J. F., e al.: A&A, 690, A216 (2024)
(IXPE) and only uppe limi s we e ob ained (Neg o e al. 2023).
S udies o he p omp -emission pola isa ion wi h ins umen cal-
ib a ed o pe o m pola ime y a e a e so a . The As osa mis-
sion wi h he on-boa d Cadmium-Zinc-Tellu ide Image (CZTI)
ins umen shows he p omp emission as highly pola ised, while
o POLAR, GRBs a e lowly pola ised o no pola ised a all (see
e.g. Gill e al. 2021).
The ma e ial ejec ed h ough he je s e en ually collides wi h
he ci cumbu s ma e ial, decele a ing as in e ac s wi h i . These
o wa d shocks gene a e a b oadband synch o on emission ha
is known as he a e glow. This b igh shock can be obse ed
du ing days o e en mon hs in he case o adio equencies.
In ce ain cases, a e e se shock ha p opaga es backwa ds
wi hin he ela i is ic je can be obse ed a ea ly imes (see e.g.
Mészá os & Rees 1997;Pi an 1999). Di e en models p edic
his emission o be pola ised. G uzino & Waxman (1999) p o-
posed a model in which he a e glow would show pa ches wi h
locally o de ed magne ic ields andomly o ien ed bu wi h many
o hem sha ing a common di ec ion leading o a global low le el
o pola isa ion in he GRB a e glow.
The numbe o s udies using op ical linea imaging pola ime-
y and spec opola ime y echniques is s ill e y small (see e.g.
Co ino & Go z 2016). The i s GRB wi h a pola isa ion de ec-
ion in he a e glow was GRB990510. I s pola isa ion deg ee
(PD) was 1.7%, 0.7days a e de ec ion (Co ino e al. 1999;
Wije s e al. 1999). Many e o s ha e been made o inc ease
he sample o pola ime ic measu emen s, bu he ain ness o
hese objec s, hei as e olu ion, and he long obse ing imes
equi ed o a good signal- o-noise a io (S/N) lea e us wi h
less han 20 GRBs wi h a measu emen abo e 3σ. Fas eac-
ion is c ucial o obse ing he i s GRB phases in which
a highe PD migh be expec ed. The highes measu ed alue
was o GRB120308A wi h a PD o 28% 5 minu es a e he
bu s , which apidly dec eased o 16% as he a e glow e ol ed
(Mundell e al. 2013). A high PD o ∼10% was also measu ed
o GRB020405, GRB090102 and GRB091208B (Be sie e al.
2003;S eele e al. 2009;Ueha a e al. 2012). All o hem we e
obse ed ea lie han 0.01 days a e he GRB de ec ion. Obse -
a ions a la e s ages shows his sou ces as lowly-pola ised wi h
some deg ee o a iabili y h oughou hei ligh -cu e e olu ion.
The mos de ailed example is GRB030329 (G eine e al. 2003)
whose PD e ol es somewha andomly om 0.91% a 0.5days
o 1.4% 37.5days a e he bu s .
A e glow pola isa ion mus be unde s ood oge he wi h he
su ounding en i onmen . Dus in he line o sigh can change
he obse ed PD and p e en he measu emen o he in insic
pola isa ion (Lazza i e al. 2003). This measu emen by i sel is
also incomple e when i is no ollowed by he s udy o he ligh -
cu e e olu ion. I is c ucial o dis inguishing be ween he mod-
els ha ha e been p oposed o explain he GRB je physics o
unde s and whe he he e is a b eak in he ligh cu e and how
he pola isa ion beha es be o e, du ing and a e his b eak (see
e.g. Co ino & Go z 2016).
We p esen a comp ehensi e s udy o GRB210610B, i s
a e glow emission and i s en i onmen using di e en ech-
niques. Pola ime ic, spec al and pho ome ic obse a ions we e
secu ed o his b igh long GRB. We also obse ed he pu a-
i e hos galaxy in o de o cha ac e ise i and place he GRB
in o con ex . This wo k is s uc u ed as ollows: In Sec ion 2we
p esen he obse a ions o bo h, he a e glow and he unde ly-
ing galaxy. In Sec ion 3we p esen he esul s o he analysis
o he linea pola ime y o he a e glow, he ligh cu e and
i s spec um, as well as he analysis o he galaxy. In Sec ion 4
we discuss he esul s by se ing he amewo k in o which
GRB210610B is embedded. We also place he esul s o he
GRB a e glow pola ime y measu emen s in o con ex . Finally,
in Sec ion 5we p esen he conclusions.
Th oughou his s udy, we desc ibe he spec al and empo al
e olu ion o he da a using he con en ion by which Fν∝ −αν−β.
We adop a cosmological model wi h H0=67.3 km s−1Mpc−1,
ΩM=0.315 and ΩΛ=0.685 (Planck Collabo a ion XVI 2014).
2. Obse a ions
2.1. High-ene gy da a
GRB210610B was i s de ec ed by he Gamma- ay Bu s Mon-
i o (GBM) on boa d he Fe mi obse a o y a 19:51:05.05UT
o 10 June 2021 wi h a T90 =55.04±0.72s and a luence o
(1104.2±0.5) ×10−5e gcm−2in he 10keV o 10MeV band
(Malaca ia e al. 2021; on Kienlin e al. 2020). A he edshi
o he GRB (see Sec . 3.3), he compu ed iso opic ene gy is
Eiso, es =4.17+0.02
−0.02 ×1053 e g in he 0.1keV o 10MeV band.
This alue is ully consis en wi h he so-called Ama i ela-
ion (Ama i e al. 2002;Ama i 2006) o long GRBs. The bu s
was de ec ed ∼22s la e by he Bu s Ale Telescope (BAT;
Ba helmy e al. 2005) on boa d he Neil Geh els Swi Obse a-
o y wi h coo dina es RA=16h15m45s, Dec= +14◦2302900 and
an unce ain y o 30. The X-Ray Telescope (XRT; Bu ows e al.
2005) s a ed obse ing he sou ce 89.9s a e BAT and
quasi-simul aneously, he Ul a iole /Op ical Telescope (UVOT;
Roming e al. 2005) obse ed he ield in he Whi e band. The
image showed a new b igh sou ce wi hin he XRT posi ion wi h
a magni ude in he Swi /UVOT na i e sys em o 13.70±0.14,
unco ec ed o galac ic ex inc ion (Page e al. 2021). The la e
analysis, p esen ed in Siegel e al. (2021), upda ed his alue
o 13.63±1.10 and he sou ce loca ion o RA=16h15m40.40s,
Dec= +14◦23056.900 wi h an unce ain y o 000
.42.
In he e ined analysis om he BAT da a, he bu s had a
T90 du a ion o T90 =69.38±2.53s in he 15 o 350keV band
wi h an Epeak =339.3 ±218.6 keV(K imm e al. 2021). The bu s
showed a ha dness a io (HR)2o 1.78±0.04. This alls in he
uppe pa o he bulk o he HR dis ibu ion o long GRBs
(see e.g. Lien e al. 2016). The bu s was also de ec ed by Konus-
Wind obse a o y wi h a du a ion ∼100s (F ede iks e al. 2021).
The HR o he bu s , i s T90, and i s iso opic ene gy elease clas-
si y GRB210610B as a long GRB.
2.2. Linea pola ime y imaging
We obse ed he GRB210610B ollowing he Swi /BAT ale
wi h wo di e en ins umen s in linea pola ime y mode. We
i s obse ed i wi h he Cala Al o Fain Objec Spec o-
g aph (CAFOS) moun ed on he 2.2me e elescope a Cala
Al o Obse a o y3. The obse a ions s a ed 0.08days a e
he Swi /BAT de ec ion wi h an exposu e pe hal -wa e pla e
(HWP) posi ion angle (see below) o 900s in Rband. A second
obse a ion was ob ained wi h he FOcal Reduce and low dis-
pe sion Spec og aph (FORS2) moun ed on he Uni Telescope 1
o he Ve y La ge Telescope (VLT) o he Eu opean Sou h-
e n Obse a o y (ESO)4. The VLT/FORS2 obse a ions s a ed
2The ha dness a io o spec al ha dness (Kou elio ou e al. 1993) o
a GRB is he a io be ween he luence emi ed du ing he p omp emis-
sion in he 50–100keV band o e he 25–50keV band.
3Obse a ions we e ob ained wi h p og amme F21-2.2-021 (PI: Agüí
Fe nández, J. F.).
4Obse a ions we e ob ained wi h p og amme 106.21T6.003 (PI: Tan-
i , N.).
A216, page 2 o 17
Agüí Fe nández, J. F., e al.: A&A, 690, A216 (2024)
0.24days a e he GRB ale in RSpecial,bHigh, and zSpecial bands
wi h 180s exposu e ime pe image and wi h wo cycles wi h he
same con igu a ion.
Fo bo h ins umen s, obse a ions we e ob ained using he
HWP in ou di e en o a ion angles o 0.0◦, 22.5◦, 45.0◦, and
67.5◦and wi h a Wollas on p ism o spli he ligh in o he o di-
na y (o) and ex ao dina y (e) beams. A mask was se o a oid
o e lapping o he ligh om he wo beams.
To calib a e he CAHA/CAFOS obse a ions, one high- and
one ze o-pola ised s anda d s a we e obse ed ollowing he
same p ocedu e as o he GRB. The la - ields in he co espond-
ing band we e ob ained wi h he ull op ical se up in he ligh
pa h. Fo he VLT/FORS2 da a, calib a ion and s anda d obse -
a ions we e pe o med as speci ied in he FORS2 Use Manual
(Ande son 2015).
We ob ained a second epoch wi h VLT/FORS2 in RSpecial ∼
1day. We inc eased he exposu e ime pe image up o 300s o
accoun o he ading o he sou ce by pe o ming wo cycle o
his obse a ions.
2.3. Pho ome y
Pho ome ic obse a ions we e pe o med using se e al ins u-
men s a di e en obse a o ies and in mul iple bands. In his
sec ion, we desc ibe he de ails o each o he obse a ions. The
measu ed pho ome y is compiled in Table A.1.
2.3.1. Small Binocula Telescope
The Small Binocula Telescope (SBT), loca ed a he Ondˇ
e-
jo Obse a o y, obse ed GRB210610B a dusk wi h he wo
20cm New onian as og aphs moun ed on a common moun .
The main de ec o s ha e 4096×4096pixel CCDs ha p o ide
a ield o iew o 3.5◦×3.5◦wi h a 3.1400 sampling. Ope a ions
a e designed such ha he eadou ime o one came a equals he
exposu e ime o he o he came a o a oid any blind ime du ing
he obse a ion.
The SBT obse a ions s a ed ∼860s a e he bu s . Du ing
he ea ly ollow-up phase, 12s exposu es we e aken wi hou a
il e . A e wa ds, he obse a ions consis ed o up o 34 expo-
su es o 120s each in SDSS- 0band (see Table A.1 o u he
de ails). Obse a ions we e in e up ed a 23:47UT, almos 4 h
a e he GRB de ec ion.
The a e glow was no de ec ed in single exposu es,
and we he e o e s acked he images o ob ain an accep -
able (S/N). We used mon age o ob ain a weigh ed image
co-addi ion simila ly o Mo gan e al. (2008), which op i-
mises o he a iable backg ound caused by dusk and hick
ci us.
As o he images in 0band, pho ome ic calib a ion was
pe o med agains he A las ca alogue, which uses he Pan-
STARRS ca alogue o ain a ge s. Images in he clea band
we e calib a ed agains he 0band and a polynomial co ec ion
in ol ing pho ome ic colou s g0− 0, 0−i0, and i0−z0was pe -
o med. Pho ome ic measu emen s ob ained his way a e shi ed
compa ed o he o iginal s anda d 0band by a co ec ion ha
depends on he objec colou . This co ec ion can be compu ed
om he i ed ela ion when he pho ome ic colou s o he a e -
glow a e known. By i ing he comple e pho ome ic se wi h an
empi ical b oken powe law we, de e mined his co ec ion o
be kc− =−0.0045mag. The e o e, unde he assump ion ha
he a e glow shows no colou e olu ion, we a e able o con-
e he un il e ed alues om SBT in o 0by simply sub ac ing
kc− .
2.3.2. FRAM-ORM elescope
The 25cm elescope FRAM-ORM, is ope a ed as pa o CTA-N
a Roque de los Muchachos a La Palma, Spain. The elescope
is equipped wi h a 1024 ×1024 pixel CCD de ec o and a Bessel
il e se , which p o ides a ield o iew o 260×260wi h a pixel
scale o 1.500.
FRAM-ORM obse ed he GRB s a ing a 20:49 UT (1 h
a e igge ) and ob ained a o al o 83×60s images in Rband
using a o al o 1.5h o obse ing ime. Images we e educed
using s anda d p ocedu es and combined in o g oups in o de o
p o ide a good (S/N). Pho ome y was pe o med in a simila
way as o he SBT un il e ed images, using 0band and 0−i0
band ca alogue alues. The de i ed co ec ion ac o is kR− =
−0.036mag.
2.3.3. Telescope D50
The D50 Telescope is a 0.5m New onian obo ic elescope
loca ed a Ondˇ
ejo Obse a o y. I has a 1024 ×1024 EMCCD
came a wi h a ield o iew 200×200, scaled a 1.1800 pe pixel.
The elescope is equipped wi h an SDSS il e se .
D50 s a ed obse ing 0.06days a e he bu s de ec ion,
s a ing wi h SDSS- 0band and ollowed by a se o obse a ions
in SDSS-g0, 0,i0, and z0bands using di e en exposu e imes
(see Table A.1 o u he de ails). Du ing he i s nigh , he ele-
scope spen 3.2h on a ge and s opped a 01:05UT. The e we e
addi ional obse a ions in nigh 2, 4, 5, and 7, collec ing 16.75h
o u he ollow-up da a.
All images we e p ocessed in a s anda d manne pe o ming
da k sub ac ion, la - ield co ec ion, and inge emo al o i0
and z0, and he images we e co-added when necessa y. Pho ome-
y was pe o med using he SDSS ca alogue in he co espond-
ing band. The GRB a e glow emission is de ec ed e en a he
la es epoch.
2.3.4. CAHA/CAFOS
In addi ion o he pola ime ic obse a ion, we pe o med u he
imaging o he a e glow in he second nigh wi h CAFOS on he
2.2m elescope o he Cala Al o Obse a o y. The images we e
co ec ed using bias and la ields using s anda d p ocedu es in
IRAF. The obse a ions we e pe o med wi h he RC il e and
calib a ed wi h espec o PanSTARRS ield s a s, o which a
il e co ec ion was used o de i e AB magni udes in he RC
band. These magni udes we e hen ans o med in o he 0band
using he colou in o ma ion ha we ha e om he a e glow.
The inal alues a e shown in Table A.1.
2.3.5. GTC/HiPERCAM
The ield o GRB210610B was obse ed in ou epochs
using he HiPERCAM mul i-band image (Dhillon e al. 2021)
moun ed on he 10.4m G an Telescopio de Cana ias (GTC) a
Roque de los Muchachos Obse a o y (La Palma, Spain) using
p og amme GTCMULTIPLE2C-21A (PI: de Uga e Pos igo).
HiPERCAM simul aneously ob ains obse a ions in he i e
SDSS il e s (u0,g0, 0,i0,z0) using e icien dich oic beam-
spli e s and mul iple came as. The las o ou obse a ions was
ob ained almos wo mon hs a e he bu s when he emission
was domina ed by he hos galaxy (see Fig. 1).
The da a educ ion was pe o med using an au oma ic shell
sc ip ha inds and o ganises he iles, calls commands om he
HiPERCAM pipeline o pe o m bias and la co ec ions and
A216, page 3 o 17
Agüí Fe nández, J. F., e al.: A&A, 690, A216 (2024)
Fig. 1. Colou images o he ield using he g0, 0and i0bands o HiPER-
CAM a 1day and 58 days a e he bu s , espec i ely. In he i s image
he a e glow is s ongly de ec ed, in he second image, i has aded and
he hos galaxy domina es he emission. 2.7a csec no h-wes o he
hos galaxy lies a companion galaxy a he same pho ome ic edshi o
he hos (see Sec . 3.4).
con e s he HiPERCAM one-dimension i s iles in o classical
wo-dimension i s images. Fu he IRAF p ocedu es allow us o
ob ain an e en backg ound om he di e en quad an s o each
de ec o . Finally, he images a e egis e ed and combined using
SWARP (Be in 2010). Pho ome y was pe o med wi h ape u e
pho ome y using e e ence ield s a s om he PanSTARRS ca -
alogue. Fo he las epoch, we used he same ape u e o compa e
he esul s o he es o he da a. Addi ionally, we pe o med
pho ome y o he comple e hos galaxy adap ing he ape u e
o i s ligh , and in a simila way, we ob ained pho ome y o a
nea by objec no h-wes o he hos , which we iden i ied as a
companion galaxy a he same edshi (see Sec . 3.4).
2.3.6. Pe ek 2 m elescope
The Pe ek 2.0m elescope a he Ondˇ
ejo Obse a o y obse ed
GRB210610B a e glow 6days a e he bu s in SDSS-g0band.
The pho ome ic came a o his elescope has a 1092×736pixel
CCD wi h a ield o iew o 50×70scaled a 0.400/pixel. A e
s anda d imaging da a educ ion and a e imaging co-addi ion,
pho ome y was pe o med as o he D50 elescope. The GRB
a e glow is well de ec ed.
2.3.7. GTC/EMIR
La e- ime nea -in a ed (NIR) obse a ions we e pe o med on
19 Feb ua y 2022 in sea ch o he hos galaxy o GRB210610B
wi h he EMIR ins umen (Ga zón e al. 2022) moun ed on
he 10.4m GTC elescope wi h p og amme GTCMULTIPLE2H-
21B (PI: de Uga e Pos igo). The obse a ion consis ed o a o al
exposu e o 349 ×3s in Hband. The da a educ ion was pe -
o med using a sel -made pipeline ha co ec s la ields, does
backg ound sub ac ion, bad-pixel masking, alignmen and com-
bina ion o he ames. The hos galaxy was no de ec ed in he
inal ame down o a 3-σlimi ing magni ude o 22.9mag.
2.4. Spec oscopy
We obse ed GRB210610B using he long-sli mode o he
Op ical Sys em o Imaging and low Resolu ion In eg a ed Spec-
oscopy (OSIRIS) (Cepa e al. 2000) moun ed on he 10.4m
GTC. The obse a ion consis ed o 3×900s exposu es wi h
g ism R1000B and a sli wid h o 100 o ien ed a he pa allac ic
angle5. The mean epoch o he obse a ion was 11 June 2021 a
01:59:14UT (6.12972h a e he Swi igge ) a a mean ai mass
o 1.13.
Flux calib a ion was pe o med ela i e o an obse a ion o
he Ross 640 (Oke 1974) spec opho ome ic s anda d, obse ed
a he beginning o he same nigh and using he same g ism.
The a e glow spec um shows a e y s ong con inuum, wi h a
median (S/N) o ∼100 pe dispe sion elemen and weak abso p-
ion ea u es.
3. Resul s
3.1. Linea pola ime ic analysis
Fo all linea pola ime y da a, we pe o med egula imaging-
educ ion p ocesses. Images we e bias sub ac ed and la - ield
co ec ed using PyRAF asks (Science So wa e B anch a STScI
2012). The la ield co ec ion o VLT/FORS2 was pe -
o med as speci ied in González-Gai án e al. (2020). Fo
CAHA/CAFOS, we combined he la ields using PyRAF, and
we used a cus omized Py hon sc ip o sepa a e he oand e
beams in o wo sepa a e images. We no malised each beam o
he co esponding median alue and c ea ed he oand ebeam
combined la . We ollowed he same p ocedu e o each image.
We pe o med his co ec ion since la ields we e ob ained wi h
he ull op ics on he ligh pa hway. This led o a a he di e -
en coun a e in each beam wha would ha e led o an inac-
cu a e no malisa ion. Finally, we spli all he educed images
in o an oand eimage and applied he L.A. Cosmic algo i hm
( an Dokkum 2001) o emo e cosmic ays.
We used PyRAF o measu e he on- ame ull wid h a hal
maximum (FWHM) in each image including he high- and ze o-
pola ised s anda d s a s. The FWHM was measu ed indepen-
den ly o he oand ebeam since he shape o he poin sp ead
unc ion (PSF) can a y, especially o sou ces wi h a high
deg ee o pola isa ion.
To ob ain e e ence ield s a s we used a sou ce de ec ion
algo i hm based on DAOS a Finde in Pho u ils and applied
i o he backg ound-sub ac ed oand eimages sepa a ely. The
selec ed sou ces we e hose wi h a h eshold abo e he median
plus h ee imes he s anda d de ia ion o he backg ound. The
s a is ics we e calcula ed pe beam and pe angle posi ion o he
HWP using a sigma clipping o he masked image. F om hese
sou ces, we disca ded hose ha we e clea ly ex ended and hose
ha lay oo close o pa ially wi hin he ins umen al mask edges.
We also checked whe he he sou ce was sa u a ed in any o he
beams. We ended up wi h i e sou ces, including GRB210610B,
in he FORS2 images and i e sou ces in he CAFOS images.
The sou ces om FORS2 and CAFOS images a e di e en due
o sa u a ion o because sou ces all a he mask edges.
We pe o med ape u e pho ome y using ci cula ape u es
wi h a adius equal o he FWHM and applied in ini e-ape u e
co ec ions using a cus om Py hon sc ip o he FORS2 da a.
In o de o a oid con amina ion by a nea by spu ious sou ce,
we measu ed he lux o he CAHA/CAFOS da a using a ixed
ape u e o h ee imes he FWHM pe image and pe beam
and sub ac ed he sky o an annulus a ound he sou ce wi h an
inne and ou e adius o ou and i e imes he FWHM, espec-
i ely. In he FORS2 images, his spu ious sou ce was ou side he
5The obse a ions we e ob ained unde he p og am
GTCMULTIPLE2C-21A (PI: de Uga e Pos igo).
A216, page 4 o 17
Agüí Fe nández, J. F., e al.: A&A, 690, A216 (2024)
measu ed egion. The e o s o he ape u e pho ome y we e
ob ained conside ing each beam as an unique image, ha is, we
sepa a ed he o dina y s ipes om he ex ao dina y s ipes.
Wi h he measu ed lux alues pe sou ce and pe beam, o
and e, we ob ained he S okes pa ame e s Qand Udesc ib-
ing he linea pola isa ion (see e.g. Pa a & Romaniello 2006;
Bagnulo e al. 2009) o each o ou images. We used he no -
malised S okes pa ame e o he linea pola isa ion.
Q
I=q=2
N
N−1
X
i=0
Ficos iπ
2(1)
U
I=u=2
N
N−1
X
i=0
Fisin iπ
2(2)
whe e Nis he numbe o posi ions o he hal -wa e pla e, Iis
he in ensi y, and Fiis he no malised lux di e ence pe HWP
posi ion angle,
Fi= o,i− e,i
o,i+ e,i·(3)
Following he equa ions abo e, we can ob ain he pola isa-
ion deg ee Plin,
Plin =qq2+u2.(4)
Fo he posi ion angle, we ollowed he o malism as used in
Bagnulo e al. (2009).
We hen co ec ed o he e ec s o op ics and de ec o in
he pola isa ion images. To do his, ze o-pola ised s anda d s a s
we e obse ed in he co esponding bands wi h VLT/FORS2
ollowing he p ocedu es de ailed in Ande son (2015). Fo
CAHA/CAFOS, obse a ions o s anda d s a s we e ca ied ou
in he same nigh . In he case o VLT/FORS2, b- and z-band
s anda ds we e comple ely sa u a ed, and no subsequen s an-
da ds we e ound in he ESO a chi e a ound he ime o he
obse a ion. Fo he Rband, he s anda ds we e also sa u-
a ed. We hen used WD1620−391 o he ze o-pola ised s an-
da d s a , obse ed 18days a e he GRB, o VLT/FORS2,
and BD+332642 (Tu nshek e al. 1990) o CAHA/CAFOS
obse ed in he same nigh as GRB210610B.
We inally emo ed he e ec on he pola isa ion induced by
he dus in he Milky Way (MW). To do his, we measu ed he
qand upa ame e s o he ield s a s in ou images. Howe e ,
FORS2 is known o ha e a adial p o ile in which he pola isa ion
a ies ac oss he ield om he op ical axis owa ds he edges o
he de ec o s (see e.g. González-Gai án e al. 2020). To accoun
o his e ec , we applied he co esponding co ec ion by using
he q,ubackg ound co ec ion and he ins umen al pola isa-
ion maps p esen ed in González-Gai án e al. (2020). We hen
measu ed he Galac ic in e s ella pola isa ion (Galac ic ISP, o
GISP) using h ee me hods, ollowing Wie sema e al. (2012):
Fi s , we measu ed he mean alues o he q,upa ame e s om
he ield s a s. Then we pe o med a one-dimensional Gaussian
i o he q,u alues o he ield s a s by gene a ing a no mal dis-
ibu ion o alues o he q,uwi hin hei co esponding e o s,
and we hen i ed a Gaussian o each S okes pa ame e . Finally,
we pe o med a wo-dimensional Gaussian i o he q,u, adap -
ing he p ocedu e om he one-dimensional Gaussian i (see
Fig. 2 o an example o he wo-dimensional Gaussian i ). All
he q,u i ed pa ame e s a e consis en wi hin he e o s, and
we he e o e ec o ially sub ac ed he mean alue om he q,u
alues o he GRB. The mean sky alues a e lis ed in Table 1,
Fig. 2. Two-dimensional Gaussian i o he ield s a s q,upa ame-
e s. Le : No mal dis ibu ion o andomly gene a ed da a a ound he
q,u alues. The ampli ude o gene a e he da a is he S okes pa ame e
e o s. Cen al panel: wo-dimensional Gaussian model i ed o he da a
poin s. Righ : Residuals.
which a e all consis en wi h o close o ze o. Bo h qand ushow
some a ia ion om one epoch o he nex , which we assumed is
due o di e en sky backg ound ligh be ween he epochs6.
Fo he CAFOS images, he same analysis was pe o med,
al hough we we e unable o co ec o backg ound pola isa ion
and ins umen al pola isa ion ac oss he images because we lack
a cha ac e isa ion as we ha e o FORS2. Howe e , luna illumi-
na ion was close o 0%, and we do no expec a high ins umen al
pola isa ion (Pa a & Taubenbe ge 2011) o CAFOS. Indeed,
he wo-dimensional Gaussian i o he ield s a s (see Fig. 2)
shows i o be consis en wi h no pola isa ion om he ISM and
implici ly, no pola isa ion om he CAFOS ins umen .
A e he pola isa ion induced by he MW dus was emo ed
we calcula ed he inal pola isa ion om bo h ins umen s in all
he il e s. Nex , we needed o conside he con ibu ion o he
pola isa ion om he dus in he hos galaxy i sel . Since he
in o ma ion is mo e limi ed han o he dus in he MW we
assumed a Se kowski law (Se kowski e al. 1975) o he hos
galaxy. F om he spec al ene gy dis ibu ion (SED) i o he
GRB ligh cu e, we ob ained he colou excess on he line o
sigh (see Sec . 3.2). Assuming his alue as he ex inc ion o he
a e glow a he hos galaxy, using PISP(%) ≤9.0×E(B−V),
we ind ha he con ibu ion om he hos galaxy could be as
high as PHos ISP ≤0.09%. We no e ha in ex agalac ic sigh
lines, his may no be applicable because he dus p ope ies may
di e om hose o he MW (Nagao e al. 2022). This alue is
well below he PD measu ed o he a e glow, and we he e-
o e conside ed he hos con ibu ion o be negligible. Finally,
we co ec ed o he pola isa ion de ini ion bias wi h he modi-
ied asymp o ic es ima o (MAS) Plaszczynski e al. (2014). The
co ec ed alues o he pola isa ion deg ee a e shown in Table 1
be o e and a e he bias co ec ion.
We also de e mined he pola isa ion posi ion angle (PA) o
he GRB a e glow. The FORS2-measu ed aw PA was co -
ec ed o ch oma ici y using he abula ed alues pe bandpass
p esen ed in Ande son (2015). We hen co ec ed o i using
he s anda d s a Hil ne 652, obse ed on he 19, July 2021,
al hough he PA co ec ion is e y small wi h ∆θ=0.5±0.9.
The high pola isa ion s anda d in RSpecial band closes in ime o
he GRB was also sa u a ed in a leas one beam. We co ec ed
he de i ed PA alue o he s anda d o he alue p esen ed in
Ciko a e al. (2017). As he measu ed b-band alue o he PA
in Hil ne 652 is e y close o he Bband alue in Ciko a e al.
(2017) we use Bband o co ec o he b-band alue. Fo he z
band, no obse a ions we e ound so a o his s anda d, and we
he e o e used he PA o he Iband in Ciko a e al. (2017). The
high pola isa ion s anda d obse ed o CAFOS, Hil ne 960,
6ESO wea he log.
A216, page 5 o 17
Agüí Fe nández, J. F., e al.: A&A, 690, A216 (2024)
Table 1. Measu ed alues o he linea pola isa ion and PA o GRB 210610B.
Epoch Bandpass Ins umen /Telescope qsky usky PLin PLin,Debiased θS/N
− 0(day) (%) (%) (◦)
0.1205 RCCAHA/CAFOS 0.2±2.4 –0.01±0.31 4.50±1.45 4.27±1.45 183±9>500
0.2418 RSpecial VLT/FORS2 –0.30 ±0.32 –0.29 ±0.20 0.28 ±0.20 – 267 ±19 >710
0.2593 RSpecial VLT/FORS2 –0.79 ±0.28 0.81 ±0.22 0.60 ±0.24 – 17±11 >690
0.2698 bHigh VLT/FORS2 – – 0.18±0.16 – 187±24 >395
0.2803 zSpecial VLT/FORS2 – – 0.23±0.28 – 199±35 >180
1.2674 RSpecial VLT/FORS2 –0.13 ±0.22 0.06 ±0.07 2.28 ±0.22 2.27 ±0.22 237 ±3>330
1.2766 RSpecial VLT/FORS2 –0.36 ±0.39 0.06 ±0.07 1.72 ±0.27 1.69 ±0.27 238 ±5>300
No es. When he s anda d co ec ed PA is nega i e, i was co ec ed o posi i e alues by sub ac ing i om 360◦. We measu ed he (S/N) in each
beam and a each HWP angle image. The alue we p esen he e is he lowes we measu ed in one beam in one image a a ce ain HWP angle.
was co ec ed o he “ heo e ical” alue ollowing Schmid e al.
(1992).
We de ec pola isa ion a &3σsigni icance o he i s and
las epochs, while he second epoch is consis en wi h ze o pola -
isa ion. We de ec 1σpola isa ion in he Rband on he second
epoch. We conside his measu emen , oge he wi h he Rband
obse a ion a ∼0.26days o he band zband as limi , howe e .
Since he MAS co ec ion is no comple ely applicable when
PD/σP<3.0, we did no apply his co ec ion o he men ioned
limi s. In his PD egime, he PA would beha e e a ically and,
we he e o e canno ea i as a limi .
3.2. Ligh -cu e analysis
We i s modelled he op ical and X- ay ligh cu es simul a-
neously wi h a smoo hly b oken powe law (Beue mann e al.
1999), F=(Fκ
1+Fκ
2)−1/κ, whe e FX= b eak( / b eak)−αX,
b eak being he lux densi y a he b eak ime b eak,κis he
b eak smoo hness pa ame e , and he subsc ip s 1,2 indica e p e-
and pos -b eak, espec i ely. We did no conside da a be o e
0.06days (∼5ks) because hey a e s ill domina ed by he ini-
ial apid decay. E en be o e any modelling was pe o med, i
is clea ha he op ical ligh cu e is ini ially la a leas un il
∼0.25days (∼20 ks; see Fig. 3), while a he same ime he X-
ay beha iou is di icul o disce n, hough he wo g oups o
obse a ions a 4ks and 7ks show possible ading, in con as o
he op ical. No knowing he p ecise e olu ion o he ea ly X- ay
da a, we allowed he ini ial X- ay decay o be di e en om he
op ical. No e ha a di e en decay implies a colou e olu ion
be ween X- ays and he op ical. We ind a shallow b eak wi h
b eak,op =0.326 ±0.011 d (27.7±1.2 ks), a la op ical decay
wi h α1,op =0.00 ±0.01, and an op ical o X- ay decay index
α2,b eak =1.85 ±0.04, wi h a b eak smoo hness κ=1.4±0.1,
wi h χ2/d.o. .=2.6.
A e he b eak, we analysed he ull op ical o X- ay SED
when we he co e age in bo h equency egimes was bes . To
build his SED, we i s c ea ed he XRT spec a using he ime-
slice ool in he XRT eposi o y (E ans e al. 2007,2009) in he
ange 30ks−50ks a a mid- ime o 1.2days. We hen shi ed he
op ical GTC/HIPERCAM ug iz da a a 1.097days close o hese
imes using he decay indices ound abo e.
We modelled he a e glow SED om op ical o X- ay e-
quencies using Xspec 12.13.0 (A naud 1996). The edshi
was ixed o z=1.1341, and we ixed he Galac ic hyd ogen col-
umn densi y o NH=3.94 ×1020 cm−2(Willingale e al. 2013).
The da a a e bes modelled by a single powe -law (χ2/d.o. .=
264.5/298) wi h β=0.869+0.003
−0.007, in insic abso p ion NH=
18.3+6.5
−5.9×1020 cm−2(using he Tübingen-Boulde ISM abso p-
Fig. 3. GRB op ical o X- ay ligh cu e i o a ailable pho ome y
(see Table A.1) and Swi X- ay da a. The g ey shaded egion is no
aken in o accoun o he i as i may be con amina ed by he p omp
emission. The clea cyan egions ma k he imes we chose o de i e he
SED o he ligh cu e. The da a a e shown wi h an o se in lux o
be e isibili y.
ion model; Wilms e al. 2000) and E(B−V)<0.01mag, using
he Small Magellanic Cloud (SMC) ex inc ion law (Pei 1992).
We also ob ained an op ical o X- ay SED a 0.079days
(6871s) aking he X- ay da a be ween 6000 and 8000s and
using he op ical ligh cu e abo e o shi he co esponding
g iz pho ome y. A e ixing he edshi , ex inc ion, and abso p-
ion as o he la e epoch and ollowing he same i ing p o-
cedu e, we ind ha he da a a e bes modelled by a b oken
powe law (χ2/d.o. .=143.3/197) wi h βop =0.43+0.046
−0.046, and
βX=βop +0.5, which indica es he p esence o a spec al b eak,
like he cooling b eak o synch o on emission. We no e ha he
spec al index o he high- equency b anch is consis en wi h
he alue ound a la e ime, sugges ing ha he b eak shi ed o
lowe equencies wi h ime, which is expec ed o an ISM en i-
onmen wi hin he i eball model and be o e he je -b eak occu s
(Sa i e al. 1998). Howe e , he shallow decay o he ea ly ligh
cu e canno be explained wi hin he s anda d i eball model,
unless we conside a mo e complex scena io such as an ene gy
injec ion (e.g., Zhang e al. 2006).
3.3. Op ical a e glow spec um
The a e glow spec um obse ed by OSIRIS ∼0.25days a e
he bu s shows se e al ansi ions o Fe ii, Mg ii, and Mg i(see
Table 2), all o hem a a common edshi o z=1.1341±0.0004
A216, page 6 o 17
Agüí Fe nández, J. F., e al.: A&A, 690, A216 (2024)
Table 2. Equi alen wid hs in he obse e ame measu ed in he a e -
glow spec um.
Obse ed λFea u e z0EW
(Å) (Å)
5001.69 Feii 2344.21 1.1336 0.49±0.07
5066.45 Feii 2374.46 1.1337 0.23±0.06
5084.79 Feii 2382.77 1.1340 0.61±0.07
5520.91 Feii 2586.65 1.1344 0.25±0.07
5549.64 Feii 2600.17 1.1343 0.53±0.07
5976.16 Mgii 2796.35 1.1341 3.29±0.10
Mgii 2803.53 1.1345
6090.41 Mgi2852.96 1.1348 0.64±0.07
4353.92 Mgii 2796.35 0.5570 0.39±0.10
4366.46 Mgii 2803.53 0.5575 0.23±0.08
(see Fig. 4and Table 2). This alue is a lowe limi o he bu s
edshi due o he non-de ec ion o ine-s uc u e lines exci ed
by he GRB i sel . The de ec ion o he a e glow in he blues
band om Swi /UVOT se s an uppe limi o z=1.7, using he
so-called Lyman d op-ou echnique, ollowing (Jakobsson e al.
2012). Conside ing his limi and he lack o abso p ion lines
common o GRBs (Ch is ensen e al. 2011) a highe edshi ,
we hence adop ed z=1.1341 as he edshi o GRB210610B.
We also de ec ed wo abso p ion ea u es ha co espond o he
Mgii double in an in e ening sys em a z=0.5572 ±0.0002.
The equi alen wid hs (EWs) o he de ec ed abso p-
ion lines we e measu ed using he GRBspec da abase ools
(de Uga e Pos igo e al. 2014;Blažek e al. 2020) (see Table 2).
We ollowed de Uga e Pos igo e al. (2012) o compa e hese
alues wi h he common end o long GRB sigh -line en i-
onmen s. The line s eng h pa ame e (LSP) measu ed o
GRB210610B is ex emely low, LSP =−2.17 ±1.13, implying
ha his line o sigh has weake ea u es han 99.85% o he
GRBs in he a o emen ioned sample. The line-s eng h diag am
in Fig. 4shows ha he FeII lines a e pa icula ly weak and a e
only de ec ed h ough he e y high signal- o-noise a io o he
spec um. The magnesium ea u es a e s onge , bu s ill among
he weakes in he sample. The low EW alues imply a low col-
umn densi y and hence a low amoun o gas and possibly dus in
he line o sigh consis en wi h a negligible dus -induced pola -
isa ion.
3.4. Hos galaxy
We obse ed he loca ion o GRB210610B ∼58 days a e
he bu s using GTC/HiPERCAM and ∼253days a e wi h
GTC/EMIR. In he HiPERCAM images, we de ec an unde ly-
ing objec a he GRB posi ion and we conside his objec o
be he hos . We also ind a pu a i e companion galaxy owa ds
no h-wes o he hos candida e (see Fig. 1) a a dis ance o
∼200
.7, which would co espond o a dis ance o 22kpc a he ed-
shi o he sys em. The pho ome y o he hos galaxy is shown
in Table A.1, oge he wi h he alues o he companion.
We pe o med a SED analysis o he wo galaxies assum-
ing ha bo h o hem a e a he GRB edshi . Fo his analysis,
we used he SED i ing code CIGALE7(Bu ga ella e al. 2005;
Noll e al. 2009;Boquien e al. 2019) in i s la es e sion. To i
he s a o ma ion his o y (SFH), we chose a delayed s a o ma-
ion his o y wi h an age o he main s ella popula ion anging
7h ps://cigale.lam. /
Fig. 4. Abso p ion spec oscopy and line p ope ies o GRB210610B.
Top: Spec al ea u es de ec ed a he edshi o he GRB, plo ed in
ed, and he ea u es om he in e ening sys em a e shown in blue. The
dashed blue line shows he e o spec um. Bo om: Line-s eng h dia-
g am o he spec al ea u es in he hos galaxy. The diag am compa es
he ea u es measu ed in ou spec um ( ed) wi h he a e age alues o
a la ge sample (black) (see Sec . 3.3).
om 0.1 o 13Gy and a la e bu s wi h an age a ying om
20−500My . We allowed he code o a y he co esponding
mass ac ion om he o al galaxy mass o he la e bu s om
0, which implies a single decaying exponen ial o he SFH mod-
elling, up o 0.6, ha is, 60% o he o al galaxy mass. We use he
ini ial mass unc ion (IMF) as desc ibed in Chab ie (2003) wi h
aB uzual & Cha lo (2003) s ella popula ion model, assuming
a s ella sub-sola me allici y (Z∗) o he galaxy (see Sec s. 3.3
and 4) ha was se o a y om 0.004 o 0.008, acco ding o
he scheme used in B uzual & Cha lo (2003). The nebula emis-
sion was modelled conside ing he same me allici y alues o
he gas.
Fo he a enua ion law, we conside ed he modi ied
Calze i e al. (2000) law implemen ed in CIGALE, assuming a
Small Magellanic Cloud (SMC) ex inc ion law o he a en-
ua ion o he emission lines. We did no obse e a colou
e olu ion o he Galac ic-dus -co ec ed (Schla ly & Finkbeine
2011) magni udes, and we do no de ec he hos galaxy in he H
band down o 22.9 magni udes. This migh indica e a low le el
o dus emission due o low dus hea ing om UV massi e s a
pho ons, indica ing a low numbe o massi e s a s o an in insic
lack o dus in his sys em. Since he amoun o de ec ed Mg,
ypically o med in he explosion o massi e s a s, is la ge com-
pa ed o he amoun o Fe in he aced sys em, al hough s ill
low o common lGRBs sigh -lines (see Fig. 4), his a ou s he
scena io o low in insic ex inc ion a he han he absence o
massi e s a s (see Sec . 4 o an ex ended explana ion). The e-
o e, we chose he colou excess o he nebula lines o be
lowe han 0.1. The slope o he a enua ion cu e (Boquien e al.
2019) was allowed o a y be ween −0.6 and 0.6. Fo he
dus emission, we selec ed he Dale e al. (2014) models and
allowed he exponen ha con ols he adia ion ield dis ibu-
ion o he e-emi ed ene gy by dus hea ing o a y be ween 1.0
and 3.0.
We applied he same SED i o bo h galaxies. Howe e ,
he companion galaxy shows colou excess in he HiPERCAM
obse a ions, and we he e o e allowed he colou excess o
he nebula lines o ange up o 0.4. The esul s o he com-
A216, page 7 o 17
Agüí Fe nández, J. F., e al.: A&A, 690, A216 (2024)
Table 3. Fi ed physical p ope ies o he pu a i e hos galaxy o
GRB210610B and i s pu a i e companion.
Hos galaxy Hos companion
log10(M∗) (M) 9.10+0.40
−0.20 9.60+0.55
−0.24
log10(SFR) (M/y ) 1.06+0.12
−0.10 0.47+0.32
−0.10
sSFR(Gy −1) 9.26±6.02 0.76±0.68
AV(mag) 0.19±0.10 0.51±0.33
Z∗0.006±0.002 0.006±0.002
Reduced χ20.49 0.50
Fig. 5. GRB hos SED wi h he co esponding esiduals modelled
using he CIGALE i ing code (Bu ga ella e al. 2005;Noll e al. 2009;
Boquien e al. 2019) o he pu a i e hos galaxy o GRB210610B. The
e ical blue a ow indica es he Hband uppe limi .
pu ed physical p ope ies om he SED i can be ound in
Table 3and he bes i is shown in Fig. 5. The SED o he
companion galaxy allowed us o de e mine a pho ome ic ed-
shi ha is consis en wi h he edshi o GRB210610B. The
companion is a a dis ance o 2.67a csec, co esponding o
a physical dis ance o 22.6kpc a a edshi o z=1.1341.
We he e o e assumed ha hese wo galaxies a e pa o a
g oup.
4. Discussion
A b oad s udy o he GRB p omp and a e glow emission
oge he wi h i s hos galaxy is c ucial o be e cons ain s o
he cha ac e is ics o GRB210610B. The bu s p omp emission
p esen s he GRB as a ha d bu s , as obse ed by Swi , posi-
ioning i in he op pa o he long GRB egion o he ha d-
ness a io e sus T90 ela ion (see e.g. Lien e al. 2016). The
iso opic equi alen ene gy, oge he wi h he obse ed peak
ene gy, shows ha GRB210610B is ully consis en wi h he
Ama i ela ion (Ama i e al. 2002;Ama i 2006) o long GRBs.
The p omp , high-ene gy emission o GRB210610B has been
analysed wi h Fe mi da a by Chen e al. (2022). They epo ed
ha he p omp emission is bes i by a hyb id je model
(Gao & Zhang 2015) in which a ho i eball componen domi-
na es he emission in he beginning, while a Poyn ing lux com-
ponen supe sedes a la e imes. Chen e al. (2022) desc ibed
hese esul s as consis en wi h he magne a model as a plau-
sible cen al engine (Me zge e al. 2011).
4.1. Hos galaxy
The SED analysis o he GRB210610B hos e eals a galaxy
wi h a low s ella mass, consis en wi h a dwa galaxy ha is
ac i ely o ming s a s and has low ex inc ion. A he same ed-
shi , he companion is mo e massi e han he GRB hos , wi h a
highe s ella mass bu lowe SFR. The ex inc ion o his galaxy
is also highe han ha o he GRB hos assuming he same
ex inc ion law.
F om he a e glow spec um, we ind ha GRB210610B
is embedded in an en i onmen wi h low amoun s o Feii and
somewha highe alues o Mgii and Mg i. The low amoun o
Fe could be indica i e o a low numbe o SNIa in he hos , since
hese explosions a e he main sou ces o Fe (Pagel 2009). This
could mean ha ei he he e is an in insic lack o his ype o
s ella explosions nea he abso be si e o ha he sys em i sel
is oo young o ha e been Fe-en iched ia SNIa. Howe e , he
absence o ine-s uc u e lines in he spec um does no allow us
o de e mine he dis ance o he abso bing clouds o he explo-
sion si e and, he e o e, he a e glow spec um could be ac-
ing gas in he ex e nal pa s o he hos galaxy, whe e we would
expec i o be less en iched. Ne e heless, we ind a highe el-
a i e alue o he EWs o Mg, al hough i is s ill low compa ed
o he mean alue ound o GRB si es (de Uga e Pos igo e al.
2012). Mg is eleased in o he ISM h ough he explosion o mas-
si e s a s (Pagel 2009). Toge he wi h he low amoun o Fe, his
migh sugges ha he hos galaxy is a e y young sys em. This
is also suppo ed by he ex inc ion we measu e om he SED i .
The AV alue may indica e ha he hos galaxy has a low amoun
o dus , which is expec ed o a low me allici y and, he e o e, o
a young sys em.
4.2. A e glow
The GRB a e glow ollows a decay-pla eau-decay beha iou
wi h an ini ial decay ha is well i ed by a b oken powe law
wi h an op ical spec al slope a ∼0.08days o βop =0.43+0.05
−0.05
and a βXR ∼0.83. A e wa ds, he ligh cu e en e s a pla eau
phase ha las s ∼0.247days o inally change o he inal decay
a ∼0.326days a e bu s . This inal decay is be e i ed by a
powe law wi h β=0.869+0.003
−0.007, consis en wi hin e o s wi h
βXR a ∼0.08days a e GRB. The change in he spec al slope a
∼0.08days migh be indica ing a spec al b eak a he beginning
o he pla eau phase. The SED i shows negligible ex inc ion on
he line o sigh owa ds he GRB and a low X- ay hyd ogen col-
umn densi y, as compa ed o NH alues o ela i ely low edshi
GRBs (Campana e al. 2010). This low NH oge he wi h he low
E(B−V), con adic s wha would be expec ed o low- edshi
bu s s, whe e a highe dus - o-gas a io is expec ed o lowly NH
X- ay abso bed bu s s (Campana e al. 2010).
4.3. Pola isa ion
Ou pola isa ion obse a ions ma ch h ee e y impo an s ages
o he GRB210610B a e glow ligh -cu e. The i s pola ime-
y measu emen s we e pe o med 0.1205days a e bu s , igh
a e he ligh cu e en e ed he pla eau. The second epoch a
∼0.26days is close o he end o his pla eau phase, almos con-
sis en wi h he b eak o he op ical ligh cu e a 0.326days a e
he GRB. A e his, he ligh cu e unde goes i s inal decay,
whe e a inal pola ime y epoch was obse ed. The a e glow
is pola ised a he beginning and owa ds he end o he ligh -
cu e e olu ion, bu no a ound he op ical b eak a 0.326days
a e bu s , whe e he pola isa ion d ops o ze o wi h a small ise
o 0.61% in he nex obse a ion, which is sligh ly abo e he
A216, page 8 o 17
Agüí Fe nández, J. F., e al.: A&A, 690, A216 (2024)
PHos ISP limi , bu only a a 2.5-σle el. In he inal decay, he
pola isa ion inc eases o 2.27% and hen dec eases o 1.69% as
he a e glow ades away. We ind ha band zbands show pola -
isa ion alues consis en wi h ze o a a close epoch o he 2.5-σ
R-band measu emen . The e o e, he mul i-band obse a ions do
no allow us o asses ch oma ici y/ach oma ici y in he a e glow
pola isa ion. The PA a ies by ∼54◦be ween he 3σde ec ions.
The measu ed pola isa ion is well consis en wi h p io measu e-
men s o linea pola ime y o GRB a e glows, as shown in
Fig. 6.
One impo an aspec when de e mining he in insic pola i-
sa ion is o cons ain any con ibu ion om he dus in he hos
galaxy. A possible pola isa ion om he MW was emo ed du -
ing he analysis (see Sec . 3.1). The SED i o he GRB ligh
cu e esul s in a negligible alue o he a e glow ex inc ion
on he line o sigh and he in e ed uppe limi o he GRB
hos ISP is a he small compa ed o e o s o he measu ed 3-
σpola isa ion de ec ions (see Sec . 3.1). This means ha ei he
he pola isa ion con ibu ion o he hos galaxy along he line
o sigh is well below he PHos ISP limi o ha his con ibu ion
would cancel he a e glow pola isa ion ou . The ela i ely high
alues we measu ed o he 3σde ec ions and he e y low limi
o he hos galaxy pola isa ion led us o assume ha he hos
con ibu ion is negligible. This low ex inc ion also suppo s he
scena io in which he pola isa ion is in e p e ed as in insic o
he GRB a e glow. This is u he con i med by he pola isa ion
non-de ec ion in he second epoch, which is an indi ec measu e-
men o he hos ISP.
4.4. Theo e ical In e p e a ions o he pola isa ion signals
The i s pola ime y obse a ions show a a he high linea
pola isa ion deg ee o ∼4% a ∼0.1205day. Conside ing ha
he obse a ions we e ca ied ou du ing a shallow decay/pla eau
phase, a non-negligible ac ion o op ical pho ons migh o igi-
na e om e eshed shocks in he o iginal ejec a om he cen-
al engine. As p e ious pola ime y s udies o he ea ly a e -
glow indica e ha ejec a om he cen al engine con ain la ge-
scale o de ed magne ic ields, a leas o a subg oup o GRBs
i no o all (e.g. Mundell e al. 2013), he e eshed shock
emission can be pola ised due o he o de ed magne ic ields
in he ejec a. The combina ion o he pola ised e eshed shock
emission and unpola ised o wa d shock emission is likely o
gi e low-/in e media e-pola isa ion signals. Fo GRB191016A,
Sh es ha e al. (2022) epo ed he de ec ion o pola isa ion sig-
nals wi h P∼5−15% which a e coinciden wi h he s a o
he pla eau phase. An ene gy injec ion model was discussed o
explain he coincidence.
The op ical ligh cu e s a s o decline a ∼0.2days (see
he op panel o Fig. 7). This indica es ha he ene gy injec-
ion s ops a ound ha ime and ha he op ical band is dom-
ina ed by he o wa d-shock emission well be o e he second
pola isa ion epoch is conduc ed a ∼0.24day. The mag-
ne ic ields in he o wa d-shock egion ( he shocked ambien
medium) a e con en ionally assumed o be gene a ed locally by
mic oscopic ins abili ies in shocks (see e.g. Med ede & Loeb
1999), and hey a e expec ed o be highly angled. The PD o
he o wa d-shock emission is expec ed o be ze o when he line
o sigh does no un along he je edge. The low pola isa ion a
∼0.24−0.28days can be explained na u ally when he op ical
emission is domina ed by he o wa d-shock emission.
Due o he ela i is ic beaming e ec , he obse e can see
only a small isible egion (a small pa ch wi h an angula size o
1/Γ, loca ed a ound he poin a which he line o sigh in e -
sec s he je ) ins ead o he en i e su ace o a shock on .
The isible egion appea s as a ing due o a ela i is ic limb-
b igh ening e ec (G ano e al. 1999). Synch o on emission
om each small segmen o he ing can be pola ised when he
andom magne ic ields pa allel and pe pendicula o he shock
no mal ha e di e en a e aged s eng hs. Howe e , he ne PD
is ze o because o he symme y o he isible egion.
As he o wa d shock slows down, he angula size o he
isible egion g ows as 1/Γ∝ 3/8(ISM) o 1/4(wind medium).
E en ually, a pa o he ing is loca ed ou side he je edge
and he emission egion becomes asymme ic. This migh ha e
occu ed by he hi d pola isa ion epoch a ∼1.27day. Be ween
he second and hi d epochs, he angula size o he isible egion
can g ow by a ac o o ∼1.7 (ISM) o 1.4 (wind medium).
Op ical linea pola isa ion measu emen s ha e been ca ied ou
o many la e GRB a e glows ypically se e al hou s o a ew
days a e he p omp gamma- ay emission (e.g. Co ino & Go z
2016). In his pe iod, a je b eak is expec ed o occu . The de ec-
ion o uppe limi s o he linea PD a e gene ally low (less han
a ew pe cen ), which migh indica e ha he shock-gene a ed
andom magne ic ields pa allel and pe pendicula o he shock
no mal ha e simila a e aged s eng hs. The pola isa ion signals
P∼2% a ∼1.27days migh be explained in his geome -
ical model. I he la ge-scale magne ic ields in he ejec a a e
o oidal, he PA change be ween ∼0.24 days and ∼1.27 days
is expec ed o be 0 o 90◦. Howe e , he la ge-scale magne ic
ields in he ejec a can be la gely dis o ed be o e hey injec
ene gy in o he o wa d shock (o he o iginal magne ic s uc u e
can be e y di e en om he o oidal con igu a ion). The posi-
ion angle change can be any alue. Howe e , his model p e-
dic s a s eepe decline a la e imes. E en in he non-sp eading je
model, he expec ed decay index is α=3(p−1)/4+3/4∼2.05
(ISM) o (3p−1)/4+1/2∼2.30 (wind medium) o p=2.74,
which is s eepe han he obse ed alue α=1.85 ±0.04. I we
ely on he a he high alue o pob ained om he SED mod-
elling, we can ule his geome ical model ou .
The na u e o magne ic ields ha a e gene a ed in shock
ins abili ies is no ye ully unde s ood. The mic oscopic-scale
angled magne ic ields may decay so apidly in he downs eam
o he shock ha hey could no accoun o he obse ed syn-
ch o on lux (e.g. Si oni e al. 2015). Al e na i ely, he o wa d-
shock egion could ha e magne ic ield u bulence on la ge
scales, compa able o he wid h o shocked egion ∼R/16Γ(e.g.
Si oni & Goodman 2007). In his case, he PD and PA empo-
ally change in a andom manne , and PD ∼70%/√N, whe e Nis
he numbe o pa ches wi h a cohe en magne ic ield wi hin he
angula scale 1/ΓG uzino & Waxman (1999). Kuwa a e al.
(2023) cons uc ed a semi-analy ic model wi h a a ying la ge-
scale u bulen ield in he o wa d-shock egion, o which hey
pe o med nume ical calcula ions in he case o iso opic u bu-
lence and ze o iewing angle. They ob ained a andomly a y-
ing PD on a imescale o hou s a a le el o ∼1−3% and PA
wi h changes ha we e no limi ed o 90◦. These p ope ies
appea o be consis en wi h ou da a o GRB210610B. When
hyd odynamic-scale u bulen magne ic ields a e assumed, we
ha e wo possible scena ios: (1) he ∼4%, ∼0.2%, and ∼2%
pola isa ion signals a e all due o u bulen magne ic ields, o (2)
he ∼4% pola isa ion signal is due o pola ised e eshed shock
emission, and he o he wo signals a e due o u bulen magne ic
ields.
Fo non-sp eading op-ha je s wi h mic oscopic-scale an-
gled ields, he PD ligh cu e would ha e wo maxima a ound
a je b eak, wi h he pola isa ion PA changing by 90◦be ween
he i s and second maximum (Ghisellini & Lazza i 1999;Sa i
A216, page 9 o 17
Agüí Fe nández, J. F., e al.: A&A, 690, A216 (2024)
Appendix B: Linea pola isa ion measu emen s on GRBs a e glow emission.
Table B.1. Measu ed alues o he linea pola isa ion and PA o GRB a e glows om he li e a u e.
GRB Redshi Tmid PLin θRe
(days) (%) (◦)
GRB990510 1.62 0.7708 1.7±0.2 101±3 [1]
0.8583 1.6±0.2 96±4 [2]
1.8083 2.2+1.1
−0.9112+15
−17 "
GRB990712 0.43 0.44 2.9±0.4 121.1±3.5 [3]
0.70 1.2±0.4 116.2±10.1 [3]
1.45 2.2±0.7 139.1±10.4 "
GRB020405 0.695 1.2292 1.50 ±0.40 172±8 [4]
1.3208 9.89±1.30 180±4 [5]
2.2682 1.96±0.33 154±5 [6]
3.8792 1.47±0.43 168±9 "
GRB020813 1.35 0.21528 2.22 ±0.07 157.6±1.0 [7]∗
0.26181 1.98±0.04 153.4±1.7 "
0.34167 1.96±0.07 152.0±1.2 "
0.89792 1.07±0.22 154.3±5.9 [8]
0.93750 1.42±0.25 137.0±4.4 "
0.97542 1.11±0.22 150.5±5.5 "
1.01625 1.05±0.23 146.4±6.2 "
1.11667 1.43±0.44 155.8±8.5 "
1.97958 1.26±0.34 164.7±7.4 "
GRB021004 2.33 0.37 1.72 ±0.56 187.7±8.3 [9]
0.38 2.09±0.60 173.0±7.9 "
GRB030329 0.17 0.5321 0.92±0.10 86.13±2.43 [10]∗∗
0.5492 0.86±0.09 86.74±2.40 "
0.5671 0.87±0.09 88.60±2.64 "
0.5850 0.80±0.09 91.12±2.88 "
0.6921 0.66±0.07 78.52±2.94 "
0.7129 0.66±0.07 76.69±2.89 "
0.7342 0.56±0.05 74.37±3.11 "
1.5204 1.97±0.48 83.20 "
1.5500 1.37±0.11 61.65±2.38 "
1.5800 1.50±0.12 62.29±2.44 "
1.6700 1.07±0.09 59.41±2.51 "
1.7000 1.09±0.08 66.07±2.45 "
1.7200 1.02±0.08 67.05±2.60 "
1.7400 1.13±0.08 70.56±2.51 "
2.6800 0.52±0.06 30.76±5.04 "
2.7000 0.52±0.12 12.55±4.63 "
2.7200 0.31±0.07 24.50±6.94 "
A216, page 16 o 17
Agüí Fe nández, J. F., e al.: A&A, 690, A216 (2024)
Table B.1. con inued.
GRB Redshi Tmid PLin θRe
(days) (%) (◦)
3.5400 0.57±0.09 53.85 ±4.08 "
3.5600 0.53±0.08 57.08 ±4.06 "
3.5800 0.42±0.10 62.21 ±6.10 "
5.6600 1.68±0.18 66.32 ±3.38 "
7.6400 2.22±0.28 75.16 ±3.32 "
9.5900 1.33±0.14 70.91 ±3.31 "
13.6000 2.04±0.57 1.16 ±7.64 "
22.5000 0.58±0.10 42.7 ±9.26 "
37.5000 1.48±0.48 25.42 ±9.41 "
XR080109 0.007 3.6416 0.95±0.20 114.9 ±5.9 [11]
5.5552 0.85±0.28 106.1 ±9.4 "
20.6279 1.05±0.06 135.3 ±1.7 "
20.6443 1.28±0.06 132.5 ±1.4 "
52.5578 1.42±0.46 139.0 ±9.1 "
GRB080928 1.6919 1.7 4.49+1.16
−0.96 41.3±6.3 [12]
GRB090102 1.55 0.0025 10.1±1.3 – [13]
GRB091208B 1.063 0.0042 10.4 ±2.5 92±6 [14]
GRB091018 0.971 0.2461 1.07±0.30 179.2 ±16.1 [15]
0.4548 1.44±0.32 2.2 ±12.6 "
1.1394 1.73±0.36 69.8 ±11.7 "
1.1552 3.25±0.35 57.6 ±6.1 "
1.1735 1.99±0.35 27.6 ±10.0 "
1.1893 1.42±0.36 114.6 ±14.0 "
1.3918 0.97±0.32 32.8 ±17.8 "
1.4493 1.08±0.35 88.7 ±17.9 "
2.3902 1.45±0.37 169.0 ±14.3 "
GRB120308 2.22 0.0033 28+4
−434±4 [16]
0.0042 23+4
−444±6 "
0.0052 17+5
−451±9 "
0.0062 16+7
−440±10 "
0.0081 16+5
−455±9 "
GRB121024A 2.298 0.2194 4.09 ±0.2 163.7±2.8 [17]
0.2302 4.83±0.2 160.3 ±2.3 "
0.2782 3.82±0.2 182.7 ±3.0 "
0.2928 3.12±0.19 175.3 ±3.5 "
0.3088 3.39±0.18 178.0 ±2.9 "
0.3252 3.49±0.18 180.3 ±3.0 "
0.3412 3.2±0.18 174.5 ±3.3 "
1.2995 2.66±0.6 83.0 ±12.6 "
GRB191221B 1.148 0.121 1.4±0.1 68 ±5 [18]
0.417 1.0±0.1 57 ±5 "
2.525 1.3±0.1 62 ±6 "
GRB210610B 1.1345 0.0973 4.27±1.45 183±9 This wo k
0.2407 0.22±0.20 267 ±19 "
0.2688 0.03±0.17 – "
0.2793 0.15±0.28 – "
1.2655 2.27±0.22 237 ±3 "
1.2829 1.69±0.27 238 ±5 "
GRB210619B 1.937 0.1057 2.2±0.7 22.0 ±10.0 [19]
0.1070 2.6±0.8 2.0 ±8.0 "
No es. We include only he alues om li e a u e o which we calcula e P/σP>3.0 wi h Tmid in obse e ame. (∗) F om he spec opola ime ic
measu emen s in (Ba h e al. 2003), since we do no conside ch oma ici y in he pola isa ion, we show he median alue o he measu ed pola isa-
ion on he di e en wa eleng h bins, o he h ee epochs hey p esen s. (∗∗) Fo GRB030329 we made use o he da a p esen ed in Co ino & Go z
(2016) and, speci ically, he esul s p esen ed in his e iew aken om G eine e al. (2003) and Magalhaes e al. (2003).
Re e ences o alues om li e a u e a e: [1] (Co ino e al. 1999), [2] (Wije s e al. 1999), [3] (Rol e al. 2000), [4] (Mase i e al. 2003), [5]
(Be sie e al. 2003), [6] (Co ino e al. 2003), [7] (Ba h e al. 2003), [8] (Go osabel e al. 2004), [9] (Rol e al. 2003), [10] (Co ino & Go z
2016), [11] (Go osabel e al. 2010), [12] (B i io e al. 2022), [13] (S eele e al. 2009), [14] (Ueha a e al. 2012), [15] (Wie sema e al. 2012),
[16] (Mundell e al. 2013), [17] (Wie sema e al. 2014), [18] (U a a e al. 2023), [19] (Manda akas e al. 2023)
A216, page 17 o 17