Experimental Radial Profiles of Early Time (<4 μs) Neutral and Ion Spectroscopic Signatures in Lightning-Like Discharges
Abstract
This work has received funding from the European Union Horizon 2020 research and innovation program under the Marie Sklodowska-Curie grant agreement SAINT 722337. Additionally, this work was supported by the Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation, MINECO, under project PID2019-109269RB-C43 and FEDER program. M. Passas-Varo, F. J. Gordillo-Vázquez, J. Sánchez, and N. Kieu acknowledge financial support from the State Agency for Research of the Spanish MCIU through the Center of Excellence Severo Ochoa's award for the Instituto de Astrofísica de Andalucía (SEV-2017-0709).
Full text
1. Introduction Slitless spectroscopy is a well known technique to analyze the absortion and emission of light coming from a narrow source, that consists of an optical system including a diffraction element and a sensor. It is a very useful tool to analyze the spectrum of natural (Boggs etal.,2021; Orville,1968; Prueitt,1963; Uman,1963) and triggered lightning (Walker & Christian,2019; Weidman etal.,1989) since it provides a wide field of view which usually allows to capture the whole lightning stroke in the camera sensor, which not only permits to measure the electron density and temperature in the lightning core (Prueitt,1963; Uman,1963; Walker & Christian,2017,2019), but also vertical temperature profiles in natural lightning return strokes (Boggs etal.,2021). Unfortunately, slitless spectroscopy makes difficult to discern wavelengths among nearly coincident lightning flashes, besides the serious limitations it presents for wavelength and, especially, for flux calibrations that could negatively affect spectral data reduction. Moreover, to date, slitless spectroscopy studies do not provide a direct measurement of the radial features of the lightning stroke channel, due to the low spatial resolution of the instruments in the radial dimension. Despite this inconvenience, recent studies have theoretically estimated the radial profile of the lightning channel temperature from the direct quantification of the gas temperature in the core of the lightning channel through the solution of the heat transfer differential equation (An etal.,2019; Bocharov etal.,2021; Ripoll, Zinn, Colestock, & Jeffery,2014; Ripoll, Zinn, Jeffery, & Colestock,2014; Sousa-Martins etal.,2016,2019). On the other hand, slit spectroscopy includes a very narrow slit in the optical path so it is possible to analyze a narrow area from wider light sources, becoming an ideal tool for the optical diagnosis of distant plasmas Abstract This study presents experimental results for the radial and temporal variation of neutral and ion spectroscopic signatures emerging from the heated channel of lightning-like discharges diagnosed with a high speed (900,000 fps) imaging spectrograph. Light emissions emanate from three regions: an inner core (up to ∼2mm), an external sheath (up to ∼4mm) featuring a sudden temperature increase, and further optical emissions forming a dim glow from 4mm up to 16mm. The optical emissions are initially (<1.11μs) dominated by the N2 first positive system at 660.8nm and by the N II ion line at 661.05nm. Between 1.11 and 3.33μs the optical emissions are dominated by Hα (656.3nm) and O II ion (656.54nm) lines. The N II ion line at 648.20nm prevails in the outer dim glow region (9–12mm) before 2.22μs. Spectroscopic signals were used to experimentally derive the time dynamics of the electron density and electron/gas temperature radial profiles, which allowed the estimation of the early time overpressure pulse, electrical conductivity and concentrations of key molecular species (N2, NO, O2, OH, H2, N2O, NO2, HO2, O3, and H2O) along the radial axis of the heated air plasma channel. These populations were calculated from the overpressure pulse, assuming that they were produced from humid (50%) air under thermal equilibrium conditions. OH is found to be the second most abundant molecular species (after NO) directly generated by heated lightning-like channels. Plain Language Summary The present work explores the temporal evolution (with submicrosecond time resolution) of spectroscopic optical emissions along the radial dimension of lightning-like channels. Such study can contribute to quantify the radial variation of the gas temperature and electron density, and to explore their influence on the direct early production of important neutral (atoms and molecules) and ion species along the heated channel. Our study has found that the gas temperature peaks at the edge of the channel and that early (0.72μs) radial optical emissions are dominated by molecules followed by ions and atoms that also prevail at later times. The study also suggests that hydroxyl (OH) could be the second most abundant molecular species (after nitrogen oxide) directly generated by heated lightning-like channels. PASSAS-VARO ET AL. © 2022. The Authors. This is an open access article under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs License, which permits use and distribution in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited, the use is non-commercial and no modifications or adaptations are made. Experimental Radial Profiles of Early Time (<4μs) Neutral and Ion Spectroscopic Signatures in Lightning-Like Discharges M. Passas-Varo1 , F. J. Gordillo-Vázquez1, J. Sánchez1, and N. Kieu2 1Instituto de Astrofísica de Andalucía (IAA), CSIC, Glorieta de la Astronomia s/n, Granada, Spain, 2Physics Department, Loyola University, Chicago, IL, USA Key Points: • Dynamics of radial spectroscopic structure (up to 16mm) of heated lightning-like channels is explored. Gas temperature peaks at the edge • Early (0.72 μs) radial optical emissions are due to molecules. Ions and atom emissions dominate at later times (≥1.83 μs) • OH is found to be the second most abundant molecular species (after nitrogen oxide) directly generated by heated lightning-like channels Correspondence to: M. Passas-Varo, [email protected] Citation: Passas-Varo, M., Gordillo-Vázquez, F. J., Sánchez, J., & Kieu, N. (2022). Experimental radial profiles of early time (<4μs) neutral and ion spectroscopic signatures in lightning-like discharges. Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres, 127, e2022JD036553. https://doi.org/10.1029/2022JD036553 Received 24 JAN 2022 Accepted 13 JUN 2022 Author Contributions: Conceptualization: M. Passas-Varo, F. J. Gordillo-Vázquez, J. Sánchez Data curation: M. Passas-Varo Formal analysis: M. Passas-Varo, F. J. Gordillo-Vázquez Funding acquisition: F. J. Gordillo-Vázquez Investigation: M. Passas-Varo, F. J. Gordillo-Vázquez, J. Sánchez Methodology: M. Passas-Varo, F. J. Gordillo-Vázquez, J. Sánchez Project Administration: F. J. Gordillo-Vázquez Resources: F. J. Gordillo-Vázquez, J. Sánchez Software: M. Passas-Varo 10.1029/2022JD036553 RESEARCH ARTICLE 1 of 18
Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres PASSAS-VARO ET AL. 10.1029/2022JD036553 2 of 18 such as transient luminous events (Gordillo-Vázquez et al., 2018), emissions from meteor luminous trails (Passas, Madiedo, etal.,2016; Passas, Sánchez, etal.,2016), natural lightning (Dufay,1926; Slipher,1917) or lightning-like plasma channels (Kieu etal.,2020,2021). This technique results especially useful to analyze laboratory plasmas, since we can predict the plasma channel location and, therefore, we can aim the system so the plasma channel can be easily imaged on the slit. It provides a higher radial and spectral resolution compared with slitless spectroscopy, and allows a direct measurement of the radial profiles of electron density and temperature in the plasma channel. Moreover, the wavelength and flux calibration of slit spectrographs are trustful and easy to develop and reproduce (Fantz,2006; Parra-Rojas etal.,2013; Passas, Madiedo, etal.,2016; Passas, Sánchez, etal.,2016; Passas-Varo etal.,2019). The analysis of the spectrum of distant plasmas allows to infer physical properties as the gas temperature or the electron density. So far, the method to obtain a spectral curve from 2D spatial-spectral images, consists of integrating the entire image in the spatial dimension, so the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) is enhanced in the spectral dimension (Kieu etal.,2020,2021). However, this method usually ignores the spatial information that could reveal the radial distribution of electron density and/or temperature from the core of the lightning-like plasmas to its surface. In this paper we focus on the radially resolved slit spectroscopy of 20 laboratory-produced lightning-like discharges in air of ∼30mm length using the GrAnada Lightning Ultrafast Spectrograph (GALIUS) (Passas-Varo etal.,2019) in the visible (645.0–663.0nm) region operated at 900 kfps with 0.79μs exposure time and spectral resolution better than 0.38nm. This allows us to experimentally quantify the profiles of electron density and temperature along the radial dimension of the lightning-like plasma channels and their temporal dynamics. From these measurements we also estimate the evolution of the radial profiles of the electrical conductivity and overpressure. Furthermore, by using the overpressure peak profile, we estimate the populations of important molecular species (N2, NO, O2, OH, H2, N2O, NO2, HO2, O3, and H2O) produced along the radius of the plasma channel, assuming that they were produced from humid (50%) air under thermal equilibrium conditions. 2. Instrumentation and Experimental Setup Figure1 shows a schematic of the experimental setup we used. It consists of the above-mentioned GALIUS ultrafast imaging spectrograph, a photometer, a field camera and an electrostatic generator, both first being placed on an optical rail that allows a correct alignment. GALIUS is a portable, ground-based slit spectrograph able to record spectra of natural/triggered lightning or lightning-like plasmas with submicrosecond time resolution thanks to a very high sensitivity Photron SA-Z camera. GALIUS can be set up with a total of 22 configurations made of combinations of 10 collector lenses, 2 collimator lenses in the near UV and visible-NIR range and 4 high spectral resolution interchangeable volume-phase holographic (VPH) grisms (Arns etal.,1999; Hill etal.,2003). For the results presented here, GALIUS was set up in slit mode (50μm×3mm) with a collimator lens of 50mm (F#11) combined with a collector lens of 60mm (F#1.5) focal length, and a grism of 1,855 lines/mm with its central wavelength at≃654nm providing a spectral resolution better than 0.38nm. We set up a recording speed of 900 kfps combined with a exposure time of 0.79μs, that allowed a maximum sensor area of 56×128 pixels, providing a spectral bandwidth of 18nm due to the spectral dispersion of GALIUS under this setup.We chose the spectral range to be between 645 and 663nm to simultaneously measure the N II ion lines at 648.20 and 661.05nm, and the H I neutral line at 656.27nm, which allowed us to calculate the radial profile and its variation with time of the electron (gas) temperature and the electron density of the plasma channel, following the methods explained in next section. Full description of GALIUS can be found in Passas-Varo etal.(2019). Table1 summarizes GALIUS setting parameters. The distance between every spark and the collector lens was 680mm±5mm. The photometer synchronizes the GALIUS Photron SA-Z camera with the initial stage of a luminous event. This is done with a TTL trigger to avoid collapsing the internal buffer of GALIUS camera with empty images. It works with a typical delay of 220ns. Voltage and current from the spark are measured by a TESTEC TT HVP 15HF high voltage probe and a Chauvin Arnoux Miniflex MA200 insulated flexible AC current probe, respectively. Both probes are connected to a RS PRO IDS-1104B oscilloscope, that also measures the photometer response through a BNC connector. The delay Supervision: M. Passas-Varo, F. J. Gordillo-Vázquez Validation: M. Passas-Varo, F. J. Gordillo-Vázquez, J. Sánchez Visualization: M. Passas-Varo, J. Sánchez, N. Kieu Writing – original draft: M. Passas-Varo Writing – review & editing: F. J. Gordillo-Vázquez
Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres PASSAS-VARO ET AL. 10.1029/2022JD036553 3 of 18 of the camera trigger is calculated from the mean time between the instant at half rising up of the photometer response and the instant at half rising up of the current between electrodes. The electrostatic generator is an automated Wimshurst machine of dimensions 360 × 250 × 400 mm 3 and contra-rotating discs of 310 mm diameter, that generates lightning-like plasmas (sparks) of variable length, depending on the distance between electrodes. The path between electrodes is placed perpendicular to the optical rail so the spark plasma-channel is horizontal and also perpendicular to the optical rail. Figure2 shows the area of the plasma channel that projects on the slit. The field camera is provided with a sensor of 1,280×720 pixels and a frame rate of 30 fps that records a video of every discharge. A spatial pattern between electrodes is also recorded to estimate the spatial dimensions of every spark. 3. Methodology In this study we have analyzed the electric features, field images and 2D spatial-spectral images of 20 lightning-like plasmas and their evolution in time. We estimated the injected energy in the 30mm sparks from the oscilloscope electric signals of current and voltage; from the field images we characterized the dimensions of the lightning-like plasmas thanks to a calibrated pattern we placed between electrodes. Besides, the 2D spatial-spectral images allowed us to experimentally derive the radial profiles of electron/gas temperature, electron density, and from them to deduce the electrical conductivity and overpressure in the air plasma discharge. Moreover, the concentrations of key molecular species (N2, NO, O2, OH, H2, N2O, NO2, HO2, O3, and H2O) along the radial axis of the heated air plasma channel were calculated from the overpressure pulse, assuming that they were produced from humid (50%) air under thermal equilibrium conditions. The typical time scale of our lightning-like discharge is much shorter than that of a real and/or triggered lightning air plasma because, in real lightning, the injected current can last for tens to hundreds of microseconds. However, this does not invalid our results. We see a number of spectral (and derived magnitudes) similarities between our discharge (that we call lightning-like discharge) and a real and/or triggered lightning plasma: (a) ionic lines dominate over neutral lines (Hα at 656.2 nm) in the early (sub-microsecond) temporal stage (see also Figures 1e and 1f in Kieu etal.(2020), where the same lightning-like discharge was used), (b) at later times (beyond 1 μs), the intensities of atomic lines (Hα at 656.2nm) are much more intense than those of ionic lines, and (c) both temperature and electron density in our Figure 1. Experimental setup that consists of the GrAnada Lightning Ultrafast Spectrograph (GALIUS) ultrafast imaging spectrograph, a photometer and an electrostatic generator, both first being placed on an optical rail that allows a correct alignment. The RS PRO IDS-1104B oscilloscope measures the photometer response, the voltage and the current from the spark. 3+27521 6$= *$/,86 &2//(&725 /(16 (/(&75267$7,& *(1(5$725 3+2720(7(5 , 9 26&,//26&23( Collector lens 60mm F#1.5 Slit dimensions 50μm×3mm Collimator lens 50mm F#8 Grism 1,855 lines/mm Camera lens 50mm F#8 Sensor area 56×128 pixels Recording speed 900 kfps Exposure time 0.79μs Central wavelength 656.2nm Spectral range 645–663nm Spectral dispersion 0.14nm/px Spatial dispersion 0.58mm/px Spectral resolution ≤0.38nm Table 1 GALIUS Setting Parameters
Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres PASSAS-VARO ET AL. 10.1029/2022JD036553 4 of 18 discharge are similar to those obtained in natural lightning (Orville,1968) and/or in triggered lightning (Walker & Christian,2019). However, spectra of non lightning-like plasmas in air like, for instance, laser-induced air plasmas (that also exhibit shorter times scales than the ones in lightning air plasmas), show intensities of atomic lines that are similar to those of ionic lines at times beyond 1μs (Cen etal.,2022). Another interesting feature is that in regular (non lightning-like) air plasmas at any time scale (early or late), the Hα line is much weaker than in the spectrum of lightning and/or lightning-like plasmas. This is well illustrated in the recent paper by Cen etal.(2022) where time resolved spectra of a real natural lightning is compared with time resolved spectra of a laser-produced plasma in air. Finally, early time temperatures in laser-produced plasmas in air are half of those in lightning and/or lightning-like air plasmas, and early time electron densities in laser-produced air plasmas are a factor of two lower than in lightning and/or lightning-like air plasmas. All the above support our approach of using a type of electric (spark) discharge in air that shares many similarities with real lightning and/or triggered lightning. Other types of air thermal plasmas should not be properly considered lightning-like discharges in air. 3.1. Time Resolved Spectra and Radial Profile of Brightness Figure2 shows a horizontal lightning-like discharge (spark) while the GALIUS slit is placed vertically. Hence, the 2D spatial-spectral images of the spark are the projection of the spectrum of a plasma slice on the CMOS sensor, with the vertical dimension including the spatial information, whereas the horizontal dimension corresponds to the spectral information. In other words, every column of pixels of the spatial-spectral image corre sponds to a different wavelength, and every row of pixels of the spatial-spectral image corresponds to a different radial position of the investigated sparks. After recording the raw spatial-spectral images, we reduced them as previously described in Kieu etal.(2020) and Passas-Varo etal.(2019). By analyzing the reduced spatial-spectral images row by row, we can estimate several physical parameters of the lightning-like discharges, such as the gas temperature and the electron density in every radial position of the region of the plasma discharge that is projected on the slit. To do so, we only consider those rows with an acceptable SNR, that is, we only accept the rows that show values of intensity at 648.20nm (N II ion line), 656.27nm (H I neutral line also known as Hα) and 661.05nm (N II ion line) higher than three times the standard deviation of the signal for that row. These are the lines used to quantify the electron density (Hα) and the electron/gas temperature (N II ions at 648.20 and 661.05nm). On the other hand, if we integrate the values of all columns of the reduced spatial-spectral images, we obtain the radial profiles of the brightness of the region of plasma discharges that are projected on the slit, and their evolution with time. 3.2. Electron/Gas Temperature We calculated the radial profile and its variation with time of the electron/gas temperature of every lightning-like plasma by following the procedure described in Prueitt(1963) and Uman(1963) for every row of the 2D reduced spatial-spectral image, considering that (a) the channel of the lightning-like discharge is optically thin (there is no light absorption through the line of sight), (b) the temperature is relatively uniform along the lightning-like channel radial cross section (temperatures are similar at the edge and the center of the lightning channel), and (c) that thermal equilibrium controls the concentration of the different atoms, molecules and ion energy levels emitting light due to spontaneous radiative deexcitation, that is, the density of excited atoms, molecules and ions follow Boltzmann's law. We also assume that local thermal equilibrium (LTE) applies so that the derived electron temperature equals the gas temperature. Note that in LTE all quantities depend only on the gas temperature. Figure 2. Spark number 7. The non-shadowed area is the region of the spark projected on the GrAnada Lightning Ultrafast Spectrograph (GALIUS) vertical slit.
Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres PASSAS-VARO ET AL. 10.1029/2022JD036553 5 of 18 Equation1 is found in Walker and Christian(2019) and it is used to calculate the electron/gas temperature of the lightning channel, from the ratio of the areas below N II ion lines at 648.20nm (Inr) and 661.05nm (Imp) of each row of the 2D reduced spatial-spectral image. We only take into account those rows which values of intensity of the N II ion lines that are three times higher than the standard deviation of the signal for that row (values over 3-sigma) (Thomsen etal.,2003). This ensures that we have real values of temperature instead of mathematical artifacts. Notice that k is the Boltzmann constant and Em,n, Am,n, gm,n, and νm,n are well-known constants associated to the upper energies (Em,n) of excited electronic levels m and n of atoms, molecules and ions that can be found in tables from the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) atomic spectra databases (Kramida etal.,2020). 𝑇𝑇 𝑒𝑒= 𝐸𝐸 𝑚𝑚− 𝐸𝐸 𝑛𝑛 𝑘𝑘𝑘𝑘𝑛𝑛 [ 𝐼𝐼𝑛𝑛𝑛𝑛𝐴𝐴𝑚𝑚𝑚𝑚𝜈𝜈𝑚𝑚𝑚𝑚𝑔𝑔𝑚𝑚 𝐼𝐼 𝑚𝑚𝑚𝑚 𝐴𝐴 𝑛𝑛𝑛𝑛 𝜈𝜈 𝑛𝑛𝑛𝑛 𝑔𝑔 𝑛𝑛] (1) 3.3. Electron Density We obtained the variation in time of the electron density radial profile of every spark by following the method described by Gigosos etal.(2003), which analyses the full width at half area (FWHA) of the H I neutral line at 656.27nm, the so-called Hα spectral line, for every row of the reduced 2D spatial-spectral images, and connects it with the electron density through Equation2. This method is independent of any assumptions on the equilibrium state of the air plasma. 𝑁 𝑒= 1017 ( 𝐹 𝑊 𝐻𝐴 1.098 )1.47135 𝑐𝑚−3 . (2) First, we isolated the Hα broadened spectral line from other emissions. To do so, we fitted every row spectrum with the sum of three Lorentzian curves, each of them centered in the wavelengths of the strongest spectral lines of the observed spectra: 648.20nm (N II), 656.27nm (Hα), and 661.05nm (N II). Then we calculated the FWHA of the Lorentzian curve obtained from the Hα fitting parameters. We only took into account those rows where the peak value of Hα was three times higher than the standard deviation of the signal for that row (values over 3-sigma) to ensure that we had real values of electron density instead of noise (Kieu etal.,2021). 3.4. Electrical Conductivity We calculated the radial profile and its variation with time of the electrical conductivity of every spark using the electron density and temperature radial profiles obtained before using the equations in Raizer and Allen(1991). To do so, we assume isotropic collisions so that the momentum transfer cross section σtr=σc, with σc being the cross section for electron-neutral collisions. As the heated channel is highly ionized (Ne/N≥10 −3), we also assume that the ion (Ni) and electron (Ne) densities are similar so the effective collision frequency for momentum transfer νm=Nνσtr+NeνσCoulomb≃NeνσCoulomb, where N is the gas density, ν is the mean thermal velocity of electrons, and σCoulumb is the cross section of electron-ion collisions dominated by Coulomb forces. We can consider that the electrical conductivity σ in the heated lightning-like channel is controlled by σCoulumb as (Raizer & Allen,1991): 𝜎𝜎 𝐶𝐶𝐶𝐶𝐶𝐶𝐶𝐶𝐶𝐶𝐶𝐶𝐶𝐶 =𝑒𝑒 2 𝑁𝑁𝑒𝑒 𝐶𝐶𝑚𝑚𝐶𝐶 =1.9×10 4𝑇𝑇𝑒𝑒(𝑒𝑒𝑒𝑒 )1.5× ln (Λ)−1 (𝑆𝑆𝐶𝐶−1) , (3) with e and m being the electron charge and mass, respectively, and ln(Λ) = 13.57+1.5log (𝑇𝑒(𝑒𝑉 ))−0.5log (𝑁𝑒(𝑐𝑚−3). (4) 3.5. Overpressure We obtained the variation in time of the radial profile of the overpressure in the heated plasma channel with respect to ambient pressure (δp=1) by following the method described in Kieu etal.(2021). For this we use the electron density and temperature radial profiles obtained, and compute the overpressure as
Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres PASSAS-VARO ET AL. 10.1029/2022JD036553 6 of 18 𝛿𝛿 𝑝𝑝=𝑁𝑁 exp 𝑒𝑒 𝑁𝑁 𝐿𝐿𝐿𝐿 𝐿𝐿(𝐿𝐿𝑔𝑔) 𝑒𝑒 , (5) where 𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴 exp 𝑒𝑒 is the electron density obtained experimentally and 𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴 𝐿𝐿𝐿𝐿 𝐿𝐿 ( 𝐿𝐿𝑔𝑔 ) 𝑒𝑒 is the electron density obtained when equilibrium is assumed at a certain gas temperature. 3.6. Equilibrium Composition in a Thermal Plasma of Humid Air We quantified the temporal variation of the radial profiles of the populations of key molecular species (N2, NO, O2, OH, H2, N2O, NO2, HO2, O3, and H2O) produced along the radius of a humid (50% relative humidity) and heated air plasma channel. For that we have scaled the composition of atmospheric pressure lightning-like air plasmas (78% N2 and 22% O2) calculated at local thermal equilibrium (Kieu etal.,2020) by the δp factor (overpressure) obtained for each time and radial position. The equilibrium calculations in the Supporting Information for Kieu etal.(2020) were performed in the temperature range 1,000–35,000K with a method based upon the mass action law and the chemical base concept (Godin & Trépanier,2004), assuming a relative humidity (RH) of 50% that corresponds to the ambient RH measured in the laboratory during experiments. The chemical species considered were 14 atomic, 24 diatomic, and 44 polyatomic species including electrons, negative ions and single and double positive ions. Internal partition functions were also calculated for atoms, diatomic and polyatomic molecules as well as for positive and negative ions. As an example, we obtain the populations of OH as 𝑂𝐻(𝑇𝑔)=𝛿𝑝×𝑂𝐻1𝑎𝑡𝑚,𝐿𝑇 𝐸 (𝑇𝑔), (6) where OH 1atm,LTE is the local thermal equilibrium of OH at atmospheric pressure. We estimate the populations of all the mentioned molecular species in the same way. 4. Results In this study we have recorded the electric features and the time-resolved images and spectra of 20 sparks of 30mm length and 8±2mm mean width, generated by a Wimshurst machine, in a synchronous way, being their mean peak voltage and current 32.70kV and 149.58A, respectively, with an injected mean total energy of ∼0.10J/cm, calculated for 0.06μs, which corresponds to the time that the current (intensity) pulse remains over the half of its maximum. We have chosen spark number 7 as an illustrative sample within the 20 measurements we have recorded. The goal of this work is not the comparison between a rare spark and the rest, but to show a real observation and the median value of a significant sample of sparks. Figure2 shows the section of spark number 7 projected on the GALIUS vertical slit. Figure3 shows its voltage and current, with maximum values of 29,134V and 315.24A, respectively. This provides an injected total electric energy of ∼0.18J/cm. Figures4 and5 show the correlative spatial-spectral images and the correlative reduced spectra of spark number 7, respectively, where we can find six strong spectral lines corresponding to two singly ionized N II lines (648.20 and 661.05nm), two singly ionized O II lines (648.65 and 656.54nm), the Hα line (656.27nm) and the First Positive System (FPS) of N2 (6, 3) line (660.80nm). Overlapping them, we also find several weaker spectral lines of N I, O II, N II, N2, 𝐴𝐴O+ 2 , Ar II, C I and Cu II. We can explain C I presence since, at typical temperatures (4,000–6,000K) of air in the edge of the expanding channel of a lightning-like discharge, ground state C ( 3P) atoms can be efficiently produced through the reaction CO(X 1 Σg, v1)+CO(X 1 Σg, v2) → CO2+C ( 3P) (Carbone etal.,2020). Cu II presence is due to the contamination from the Wimshurst machine copper brushes. Figures6 and7 show the radial profiles of the brightness of the spectral lines of N II (648.20nm), O II (648.65nm), Hα (656.27nm), O II (656.54nm), N2 FPS (6, 3) (660.80nm), and N II (661.05nm), at different sampling times, Figure 3. Voltage (blue) and current (red) used to generate spark number 7. Dotted gray areas correspond to the exposure time (0.79μs) of the correlative spectral images.
Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres PASSAS-VARO ET AL. 10.1029/2022JD036553 7 of 18 for spark number 7 and for the median value of the 20 recorded sparks respectively. We obtained these radial profiles by plotting the dimensionless brightness of the spectral image at each wavelength, for each radial position. In order to better explain the radial evolution of these ions, atom, and molecule optical emissions we have identified four different regions along the spark radius: an inner core of 2mm radius that includes regions I and II, wrapped by an outer sheath of up to 4mm±0.58mm radius (region III) and a dim glow region from 4 up to 16mm (region IV). When analyzing the radial profile of the spectrum obtained through the median value of the aligned spatial-spectral images of the 20 recorded sparks (Figure7) we find the same behavior that Figure6 shows for regions I to III. The nondimensional radial profile of the brightness of spark number 7 and its evolution in time is shown in all panels of Figure8 as a purple, blue and greenish transparent shadowed area. We obtained these brightness radial profiles from integrating all the columns of the correspondent spectral image, so the spectral information is lost and the signal-to-noise ratio is maximized in the spatial dimension. Overlapping these radial profiles of brightness, Figure8 also shows, in black, red and yellow solid lines, the evolution of the radial profile of (a) electron/ gas temperature, (b) electron density, (c) electrical conductivity, and (d) overpressure of spark number 7. Figure 4. 2D correlative spatial-spectral images of spark number 7. The colorbar indicates brightness in arbitrary units (a.u.). Note that in the first two images (0.72μs, 1.83μs) the brightness extends beyond ∼7–8mm.
Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres PASSAS-VARO ET AL. 10.1029/2022JD036553 8 of 18 From panel (a) of Figure8, we notice that the electron temperature of spark number 7 remains almost constant along the inner core of the spark whereas it increases in the external border of the spark sheath. This trend is consistent with the results obtained for times ≤5μs from 1D cylindrical radiation-hydrodynamic simulations using an exact (i.e., the discrete-ordinates method [DOM-S12]) and approximate (i.e., the P1 model approach) solutions of the radiation transfer equation, that are plotted in Figure 4 of Ripoll, Zinn, Jeffery, & Colestock(2014), especially if we compare the radial profile of the temperature of spark number 7 at 2.94μs, where the electron/ gas temperature ranges between 10,000 and 15,000K. Notice that the modeling considers a lightning of 200J/ cm. Hence, although the shapes of the radial profile of electron/gas temperature are comparable, both the radius and the time scale are far different from the experimental results presented here. This trend is also found in Sousa-Martins etal.(2016,2019) where the radial profile of the electron temperature of high current pulsed arcs is calculated from experimental data combined with the radiative transfer equation. Bocharov etal.(2021) also predicts this trend through a 2D numerical simulation of high-current pulsed arc discharge in air, and compares it to experimental results that provide the plasma temperature as a function of time and pressure, but not as a function of the radius (Robledo-Martinez etal.,2008). It is worthwhile to mention that the experiment does not provide valid values of temperature outside the outer sheath of the plasma channel since the SNR of the 2D spatial-spectral image is not high enough in region IV, but one might think that the radial profile of the electron/gas temperature would slowly decrease as we move away from the inner core as the radiative transfer equation (Ripoll, Zinn, Jeffery, & Colestock,2014; Sousa-Martins Figure 5. Reduced spectra of spark number 7 and its evolution with time at different radial positions (0.00mm, 1.16mm, 2.32mm, 3.48mm). Strongest emission lines are annotated in the top panel. Radial profiles and temporal evolution of bold emission lines (the six strongest ones) are shown in Figures6 and7.
Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres PASSAS-VARO ET AL. 10.1029/2022JD036553 9 of 18 etal.,2016,2019) suggests. We also found a decrease of the temperature in the inner core as time goes by. As conductivity depends directly on the electron/gas temperature, we also found this same trend in the conductivity radial profile, as panel (c) of Figure8 shows. This increase of electron/gas temperature and electrical conductivity in the border of the outer sheath of the lightning channel has not been observed neither in previous slit Figure 6. Left axes show the radial profile of the brightness (in arbitrary units) of N II (648.20nm), O II (648.65nm), Hα (656.27nm), O II (656.54nm), N2 FPS (6, 3) (660.80nm), and N II (661.05nm), at different sampling times, for spark number 7. Right axes show the radial profile of the temperature (black solid lines) and the expected decrease of temperature up to the border of the plasma sheath (black dashed lines). Bluish shape represents the radial profile of the brightness, normalized to the maximum brightness of the spectrum in the core of the spark. Left axes of the inner panels show a zoom in the radial profile of the brightness between 5 and 16mm. Four different regions are discerned along the spark radius: an inner core of 2mm radius that includes regions I and II, wrapped by an outer sheath of up to 4mm±0.58mm radius (region III) and a dim glow region from 4 up to 16mm (region IV).
Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres PASSAS-VARO ET AL. 10.1029/2022JD036553 16 of 18 reproduce the real spatial (radial) dimensions of an expanding lightning stroke channel. In spite of this, we can still consider small arcs as good analogs of real and/or triggered lightning but with the advantage of having an easier access to them in the laboratory. The challenge ahead is to study the late temporal stages that, because of the lower luminosity, complicates their optical diagnostics. The effort, however, could be worth because, according to modeling (Ripoll, Zinn, Jeffery, & Colestock,2014), the largest chemical production of NOx, OH, and HO2 in lightning strokes occurs during the cooling phase at lower gas temperatures (below 10,000K). 5. Summary and Conclusions In this work we analyzed the radial profiles of the spectral brightness of 20 lightning-like plasma discharges from experimental spectroscopic data recorded at 900 kfps and 0.79μs exposure time. This is the first direct measurement of the radial profiles of gas temperature, electron density, pressure and conductivity in lightning-like plasma channels. Previous works estimate these radial profiles from 1D (only spectral, no spatial) spectroscopy combined with the radiative transfer equation and modeling. This is the first time that these radial profiles are measured directly from 2D (spatial-spectral) images, without losing the spatial dimension of the spectra. Here we propose a method able to confirm the reliability of such 2D theoretical modeling. We found that the optical emissions of the sparks are initially (<1.11μs) dominated by the N2 first positive system at 660.8nm, while the N II ion line at 661.05nm is very significant below 4mm. N II ions at 648.20 and 661.05nm start to prevail over the rest of emissions within the outer dim glow region (10–14mm). A damped oscillating behavior along the radius of the spark is detected for all emissions, with a variable period. After 1.11μs and before 2.22μs we find that Hα and O II (656.54nm) spectral lines dominate clearly over the rest of emissions until 9mm, where N II ion line at 648.20nm rises up.After 2.22μs, Hα and O II (656.54nm) spectral lines dominate also below 4mm, and no spectral signatures are found beyond. From these measurements we found that the electron/gas temperature remains almost constant along the inner core of the spark whereas it increases in the external border of the spark sheath before 2.22 μs. This trend is consistent with the results obtained from 1D cylindrical radiation-hydrodynamic simulations using an exact (the discrete-ordinates method (DOM-S12)) and approximate (the P1 model approach) solutions of the radiation transfer equations (Ripoll, Zinn, Jeffery, & Colestock,2014). We also found a decrease of the electron/gas temperature in the inner core (up to ∼2mm) of the spark as time progresses. The electrical conductivity also follows this behavior. We found that the calculated trend of the radial profile of the electron density follows the shape of the radial profile of the brightness of the spark. This translates into an enhancement of the overpressure in the border of the inner core of the lightning-like plasma channel at the first (0.72μs) and third time (2.94μs) stages of the plasma discharge. Finally, we also estimated the evolution of the radial profile of the populations of NO, O2, OH, H2, N2O, NO2, HO2, O3, and H2O produced along the radius of the lightning-like plasma channels from the peak pressure δp and assuming that they were produced from humid (50%) air under equilibrium conditions. At initial time stages (0.72μs), the radial profiles of the above-mentioned populations follow a constant trend up to the inner core (up to ∼2mm), where the populations start to slightly decrease. Afterward, they show a small enhancement (up to ∼3mm) in between the inner and outer sheath regions to finally decrease in the outer region. We also found a huge increase (compared to the initial time stages) of the chemical species concentrations in the inner core of the plasma channel following the gas temperature decrease. Hydroxyl (OH) is found to be the second most abundant molecular species (only after nitrogen oxide (NO)) directly generated by heated lightning-like channels, while ozone is the least directly produced. Data Availability Statement Data sets for this research and related software for figure generation are available through GitHub (Passas-Varo etal.,2022), under GNU General Public License. Figures were made with Matplotlib version 3.5.1 (Hunter,2007), available under the Matplotlib license at https://matplotlib.org/.
Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres PASSAS-VARO ET AL. 10.1029/2022JD036553 17 of 18 References An, T., Yuan, P., Liu, G., Cen, J., Wang, X., Zhang, M., & An, Y. (2019). The radius and temperature distribution along radial direction of lightning plasma channel. Physics of Plasmas, 26(1), 013506. https://doi.org/10.1063/1.5059363 An, T., Yuan, P., Wan, R., Chen, R., Liu, G., Cen, J., & Wang, X. (2021). Conductivity characteristics and corona sheath radius of lightning return stroke channel. Atmospheric Research, 258, 105649. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.atmosres.2021.105649 Arns, J. A., Colburn, W. S., & Barden, S. C. (1999). Volume phase gratings for spectroscopy, ultrafast laser compressors, and wavelength division multiplexing. Current developments in optical design and optical engineering viii, 3779, 313–323. Bocharov, A., Mareev, E., & Popov, N. (2021). Numerical simulation of high-current pulsed arc discharge in air. Journal of Physics D: Applied Physics, 55(11), 115204. https://doi.org/10.1088/1361-6463/ac3866 Boggs, L. D., Liu, N., Nag, A., Walker, T. D., Christian, H. J., da Silva, C. L., et al. (2021). Vertical temperature profile of natural lightning return strokes derived from optical spectra. Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres, 126(8), e2020JD034438. https://doi. org/10.1029/2020jd034438 Bozem, H., Fischer, H., Gurk, C., Schiller, C., Parchatka, U., Koenigstedt, R., etal. (2014). Influence of corona discharge on the ozone budget in the tropical free troposphere: A case study of deep convection during Gabriel. Atmospheric Chemistry and Physics, 14(17), 8917–8931. https://doi.org/10.5194/acp-14-8917-2014 Brune, W., McFarland, P., Bruning, E., Waugh, S., MacGorman, D., Miller, D., etal. (2021). Extreme oxidant amounts produced by lightning in storm clouds. Science, 372(6543), 711–715. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.abg0492 Carbone, E., D’Isa, F., Hecimovic, A., & Fantz, U. (2020). Analysis of the C2 swan bands as a thermometric probe in CO2 microwave plasmas. Plasma Sources Science and Technology, 29(5), 055003. https://doi.org/10.1088/1361-6595/ab74b4 Cen, J., Yang, C., Yang, S., Li, Z., & Zhang, J. (2022). A spectral comparison of lightning discharge plasma and laser-induced air plasma. AIP Advances, 12(6), 065202. https://doi.org/10.1063/5.0093322 Dufay, M. (1926). Spectres des éclairs. Comptes Rendus, 182, 1331–1333. Fantz, U. (2006). Basics of plasma spectroscopy. Plasma Sources Science and Technology, 15(4), S137–S147. https://doi. org/10.1088/0963-0252/15/4/s01 Gigosos, M. A., González, M. A., & Cardeñoso, V. (2003). Computer simulated balmer-alpha, -beta and -gamma Stark line profiles for non-equilibrium plasmas diagnostics. Spectrochimica Acta Part B: Atomic Spectroscopy, 58(8), 1489–1504. (5th European Furnace Symposium and 10th International Solid Sampling Colloquium with Atomic Spectroscopy). https://doi.org/10.1016/S0584-8547(03)00097-1 Godin, D., & Trépanier, J. (2004). A robust and efficient method for the computation of equilibrium composition in gaseous mixtures. Plasma Chemistry and Plasma Processing, 24(3), 447–473. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11090-004-2279-8 Gordillo-Vázquez, F. J. (2008). Air plasma kinetics under the influence of sprites. Journal of Physics D, 41(23), 234016. https://doi. org/10.1088/0022-3727/41/23/234016 Gordillo-Vázquez, F. J., & Donkó, Z. (2009). Electron energy distribution functions and transport coefficients relevant for air plasmas in the troposphere: Impact of humidity and gas temperature. Plasma Sources Science and Technology, 18(3), 034021. https://doi. org/10.1088/0963-0252/18/3/034021 Gordillo-Vázquez, F. J., Passas, M., Luque, A., Sánchez, J., Van der Velde, O. A., & Montanyá, J. (2018). High spectral resolution spectroscopy of sprites: A natural probe of the mesosphere. Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres, 123(4), 2336–2346. https://doi. org/10.1002/2017jd028126 Hill, G. J., Wolf, M. J., Tufts, J. R., & Smith, E. C. (2003). Volume phase holographic (vph) grisms for optical and infrared spectrographs. In Specialized optical developments in astronomy (Vol. 4842(1–9)). Hunter, J. D. (2007). Matplotlib: A 2D graphics environment. Computing in Science & Engineering, 9(3), 90–95. https://doi.org/10.1109/ MCSE.2007.55 Jenkins, J. M., Brune, W. H., & Miller, D. O. (2021). Electrical discharges produce prodigious amounts of hydroxyl and hydroperoxyl radicals. Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres, 126(9), e2021JD034557. https://doi.org/10.1029/2021jd034557 Kieu, N., Gordillo-Vázquez, F. J., Passas, M., Sánchez, J., & Pérez-Invernón, F. J. (2021). High-speed spectroscopy of lightning-like discharges: Evidence of molecular optical emissions. Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres, 126(11), e2021JD035016. https://doi. org/10.1029/2021jd035016 Kieu, N., Gordillo-Vázquez, F. J., Passas-Varo, M., Sánchez, J., Pérez-Invernón, F. J., Luque, A., et al. (2020). Submicrosecond spectroscopy of lightning-like discharges: Exploring new time regimes. Geophysical Research Letters, 47(15), e2020GL088755. https://doi. org/10.1029/2020GL088755 Kramida, A., Ralchenko, Y., & Reader, J. (2020). NIST atomic spectra database. National Institute of Standards and Technology. (version 5.8), [Online]. Retrieved from https://physics.nist.gov/asd Lacroix, A., Coulouvrat, F., Marchiano, R., Farges, T., & Ripoll, J.-f. (2019). Acoustical energy of return strokes: A comparison between a statistical model and measurements. Geophysical Research Letters, 46(20), 11479–11489. https://doi.org/10.1029/2019gl085369 Li, D., Luque, A., Gordillo-Vázquez, F. J., Liu, F., Lu, G., Neubert, T., etal. (2021). Blue flashes as counterparts to narrow bipolar events: The optical signal of shallow in-cloud discharges. Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres, 126(13), e2021JD035013. https://doi. org/10.1029/2021jd035013 Mihalas, D., & Mihalas, B. (1984). Foundations of radiation hydrodynamics. Oxford University Press. Orville, R. E. (1968). A high-speed time-resolved spectroscopic study of the lightning return stroke: Part ii. a quantitative analysis. Journal of the Atmospheric Sciences, 25(5), 839–851. https://doi.org/10.1175/1520-0469(1968)025<0839:ahstrs>2.0.co;2 Parra-Rojas, F. C., Passas, M., Carrasco, E., Luque, A., Tanarro, I., Simek, M., & Gordillo-Vázquez, F. J. (2013). Spectroscopic diagnostics of laboratory air plasmas as a benchmark for spectral rotational (gas) temperature determination in tles. Journal of Geophysical Research: Space Physics, 118(7), 4649–4661. https://doi.org/10.1002/jgra.50433 Passas, M., Madiedo, J. M., & Gordillo-Vázquez, F. J. (2016). High resolution spectroscopy of an orionid meteor from 700 to 800 nm. Icarus, 266, 134–141. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.icarus.2015.11.020 Passas, M., Sánchez, J., Sánchez-Blanco, E., Luque, A., & Gordillo-Vázquez, F. J. (2016). Grassp: A spectrograph for the study of transient luminous events. Applied Optics, 55(23), 6436–6442. https://doi.org/10.1364/ao.55.006436 Passas-Varo, M., Sánchez, J., & Gordillo-Vázquez, F. J. (2022). Dataset and software to generate figures for jgr: “Atmospheres experimental radial profiles of early time neutral and ion spectroscopic signatures in lightning-like discharges”. [Dataset]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/ zenodo.6473251 Passas-Varo, M., Sánchez, J., Kieu, T. N., Sánchez-Blanco, E., & Gordillo-Vázquez, F. J. (2019). Galius: An ultrafast imaging spectrograph for the study of lightning. Applied Optics, 58(29), 8002–8006. https://doi.org/10.1364/AO.58.008002 Acknowledgments This work has received funding from the European Union Horizon 2020 research and innovation program under the Marie Sklodowska-Curie grant agreement SAINT 722337. Additionally, this work was supported by the Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation, MINECO, under project PID2019-109269RB-C43 and FEDER program. M. Passas-Varo, F. J. Gordillo-Vázquez, J. Sánchez, and N. Kieu acknowledge financial support from the State Agency for Research of the Spanish MCIU through the Center of Excellence Severo Ochoa's award for the Instituto de Astrofísica de Andalucía (SEV-2017-0709).
Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres PASSAS-VARO ET AL. 10.1029/2022JD036553 18 of 18 Prueitt, M. L. (1963). The excitation temperature of lightning. Journal of Geophysical Research, 68(3), 803–811. https://doi.org/10.1029/ JZ068i003p00803 Raizer, Y. P., & Allen, J. E. (1991). Gas discharge physics (Vol. 1). Springer. Ripoll, J. F., Zinn, J., Colestock, P.L., & Jeffery, C. A. (2014). On the dynamics of hot air plasmas related to lightning discharges: 2. Electrodynamics. Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres, 119(15), 9218–9235. https://doi.org/10.1002/2013jd020068 Ripoll, J. F., Zinn, J., Jeffery, C. A., & Colestock, P.L. (2014). On the dynamics of hot air plasmas related to lightning discharges: 1. Gas dynamics. Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres, 119(15), 9196–9217. https://doi.org/10.1002/2013jd020067 Robledo-Martinez, A., Sobral, H., & Ruiz-Meza, A. (2008). Time-resolved diagnostic of an impulse discharge in variable pressure air. Journal of Physics D, 41(17), 175207. https://doi.org/10.1088/0022-3727/41/17/175207 Sentman, D., Stenbaek-Nielsen, H., McHarg, M., & Morrill, J. (2008). Plasma chemistry of sprite streamers. Journal of Geophysical Research, 113(D11), D11112. https://doi.org/10.1029/2007jd008941 Simek, M., DeBenedictis, S., Dilecce, G., Babickỳ, V., Clupek, M., & Sunka, P. (2002). Time and space resolved analysis of N2(C 3Πu) vibrational distributions in pulsed positive corona discharge. Journal of Physics D, 35(16), 1981–1990. https://doi.org/10.1088/0022-3727/35/16/312 Slipher, V. M. (1917). The spectrum of lightning. Lowell Observatory Bulletin, 3, 55–58. Soler, S., Gordillo-Vázquez, F. J., Pérez-Invernón, F. J., Luque, A., Li, D., Neubert, T., etal. (2021). Global frequency and geographical distribution of nighttime streamer corona discharges (blues) in thunderclouds. Geophysical Research Letters, 48(18), e2021GL094657. https://doi. org/10.1029/2021gl094657 Soler, S., Pérez-Invernón, F. J., Gordillo-Vázquez, F. J., Luque, A., Li, D., Malagón-Romero, A., etal. (2020). Blue optical observations of narrow bipolar events by ASIM suggest corona streamer activity in thunderstorms. Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres, 125(16), e2020JD032708. https://doi.org/10.1029/2020jd032708 Sousa-Martins, R., Zaepffel, C., Chemartin, L., Lalande, P., & Lago, F. (2019). Characterization of high-current pulsed arcs ranging from 100–250 ka peak. Journal of Physics D: Applied Physics, 52(18), 185203. https://doi.org/10.1088/1361-6463/ab0190 Sousa-Martins, R., Zaepffel, C., Chemartin, L., Lalande, P., & Soufiani, A. (2016). Characterization of a high current pulsed arc using optical emission spectroscopy. Journal of Physics D: Applied Physics, 49(41), 415205. https://doi.org/10.1088/0022-3727/49/41/415205 Thomsen, V., Schatzlein, D., & Mercuro, D. (2003). Limits of detection in spectroscopy. Spectroscopy, 18(12), 112–114. Uman, M. (1963). The continuum spectrum of lightning. Journal of Atmospheric and Terrestrial Physics, 25(5), 287–295. https://doi. org/10.1016/0021-9169(63)90025-4 Walker, T. D., & Christian, H. J. (2017). Triggered lightning spectroscopy: Part 1. A qualitative analysis. Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres, 122(15), 8000–8011. https://doi.org/10.1002/2016jd026419 Walker, T. D., & Christian, H. J. (2019). Triggered lightning spectroscopy: Part 2. A quantitative analysis. Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres, 124(7), 3930–3942. https://doi.org/10.1029/2018jd029901 Weidman, C., Boye, A., & Crowell, L. (1989). Lightning spectra in the 850-to 1400-nm near-infrared region. Journal of Geophysical Research, 94(D11), 13249–13257. https://doi.org/10.1029/jd094id11p13249 Yamada, T., Sato, T., Adachi, T., Winkler, H., Kuribayashi, K., Larsson, R., etal. (2020). HO2 generation above sprite-producing thunderstorms derived from low-noise SMILES observation spectra. Geophysical Research Letters, 47(3), e60090. https://doi.org/10.1029/2019GL085529 Zahn, A., Brenninkmeijer, C., Crutzen, P., Parrish, D., Sueper, D., Heinrich, G., & Heintzenberg, J. (2002). Electrical discharge source for tropospheric “ozone-rich transients”. Journal of Geophysical Research, 107(D22), 4638. ACH–16. https://doi.org/10.1029/2002jd002345 Zel’Dovich, Y. B., & Raizer, Y. P. (2002). Physics of shock waves and high-temperature hydrodynamic phenomena. Courier Corporation. Zinn, J., & Anderson, R. (1973). Structure and luminosity of strong shock waves in air. The Physics of Fluids, 16(10), 1639–1644. https://doi. org/10.1063/1.1694190