Clinical use of second-generation antipsychotics in children
Full text
77
Scandina ian Jou nal o Child and Adolescen Psychia y and Psychology
Vol. 5(2):77-88 (2017) DOI 10.21307/sjcapp-2017-009
Resea ch A icle Open Access
Clinical use o second-gene a ion an ipsycho ics in child en
Ki si Kakko1*, Leena Pihlakoski1, Raili Salmelin2, Päi i Keskinen3, Kaija Puu a1, Tuula Tamminen4
1Depa men o Child Psychia y, Tampe e Uni e si y Hospi al, Facul y o Medicine and Li e Sciences,
Uni e si y o Tampe e, Finland; 2Depa men o Child Psychia y, Tampe e Uni e si y Hospi al, Facul y o
Social Sciences/Heal h Sciences, Uni e si y o Tampe e, Finland; 3Depa men o Pedia ics, Tampe e
Uni e si y Hospi al, Cen e o Child Heal h Resea ch, Uni e si y o Tampe e, Finland;
4Facul y o Medicine and Li e Sciences, Uni e si y o Tampe e, Finland
*Co esponding au ho : [email p o ec ed]
Abs ac
Backg ound: The use o second-gene a ion an ipsycho ic (SGA) medica ion among child and adolescen psychia ic pa ien s
has inc eased wo ldwide in ecen yea s. The inc ease appea s o ha e been mo e ex ensi e in he USA han in Eu opean
coun ies, bu he endency is simila . Howe e , a e a peak he use seems o ha e declined in he USA. Simul aneously wi h
he inc easing numbe s, he du a ion o SGA use has leng hened, indica ions ha e b oadened, and o -label use has inc eased.
Despi e exis ing ollow-up ecommenda ions and e idence o he me abolic ad e se e ec s o SGAs in child en, esea ch
e idence has no ansla ed in o clinical p ac ice.
Objec i e: The aim o his s udy was o assess he clinical use and ollow-up p ac ices o SGA medica ion among child
psychia ic pa ien s o one uni e si y hospi al in Finland.
Me hod: This e ospec i e pa ien epo -based s udy was conduc ed a he Child Psychia ic Clinic o Tampe e Uni e si y
Hospi al, Finland. The s udy sample consis ed o 133 pa ien s who we e younge han 13 yea s when ini ia ing SGA ea men
and had an ongoing SGA medica ion du ing he s udy pe iod. The s udy sample was di ided in o wo g oups acco ding o
diagnosis o examine whe he he e we e di e ences be ween pa ien s wi h an au is ic o a de elopmen al diso de (F83-84)
and pa ien s wi h o he psychia ic diagnoses.
Resul s: This s udy showed ha SGA use in child en younge han 13 yea s was mainly o -label. I espec i e o diagnosis,
he mos common indica ion was agg ession. Especially child en wi h psychia ic diagnoses o he han de elopmen al
diso de s had mul iple socio-demog aphic isk ac o s and ad e se li e expe iences in hei backg ound. The ollow-up
p ac ices we e di e se and pa ly i egula .
Conclusions: A need o sys ema ic SGA moni o ing p ac ices and dialogue be ween he medical speciali ies ea ing child en
and hei amilies is e iden .
Keywo ds: an ipsycho ic medica ion; second-gene a ion an ipsycho ic; child en; ollow-up p ac ices; ad e se li e e en s
In oduc ion
The use o second-gene a ion an ipsycho ic (SGA)
medica ion among child and adolescen psychia ic
pa ien s has inc eased wo ldwide in ecen yea s (1-
5). The inc ease appea s o ha e been mo e ex ensi e
in he USA han in Eu opean coun ies, bu he
endency is he same (3,6). Howe e , a e a peak,
SGA use seems o ha e declined in he USA (7,8). A
he same ime, he du a ion o SGA use in child en
has leng hened, indica ions ha e b oadened, and o -
label use has inc eased (3,9,10). The use o SGAs in
child en and adolescen s seems o be inc easing om
he age o 7 o 8 yea s onwa ds, p edominan ly in
male pa ien s (2-5).
In Finland, he p e alence o an ipsycho ic use
among child en and adolescen s unde he age o 18
yea s has inc eased om 4.3 o 6.7/1000 be ween
2008 and 2015 (5). Simul aneously, he p opo ion o
child en and adolescen s in his age g oup using
an ipsycho ic medica ion and ha ing a diagnosis o a
psycho ic diso de o psycho ic symp oms dec eased
om 19% o 11% (5). Acco ding o he s a is ics o
Second-gene a ion an ipsycho ics in child en
78
he Social Insu ance Ins i u ion o Finland, du ing
he same pe iod, p e alence o use among child en
younge han 13 yea s inc eased om 1.7 o
2.8/1000. The h ee mos commonly used SGAs in
his age g oup we e ispe idone, a ipip azole, and
que iapine. The numbe o child en younge han 13
yea s using hese d ugs in Finland has s eadily
inc eased in ecen yea s, and he inc ease is mos
appa en o a ipip azole (14- old) and ispe idone
(1.5- old). Howe e , he p opo ion o child en
younge han 13 yea s among all SGA use s in
Finland has emained qui e s eady (1.4% o 1.6%) as
he numbe o all use s has also inc eased (Figu e 1).
Acco ding o a ecen Finnish s udy, SGAs we e he
mos common medica ion among child psychia ic
u gen -ca e in-pa ien s a Kuopio Uni e si y
Hospi al, and he use was mos ly o -label (11).
Yea
2008 2010 2012 2014
Numbe o use s
0
1000
2000
3000
100000
120000
140000
160000
Que iapine
Rispe idon
A ipip a zole
All Q, R & A use s
FIGURE 1. Second-gene a ion an ipsycho ic use o 0 o 12-yea -old child en
and all use s in Finland (2008 o 2015)
The o icial c i e ia o SGA use by child en
younge han 13 yea s a y o some ex en among
coun ies. In he USA, he Food and D ug
Adminis a ion (FDA) app o es a ipip azole,
que iapine, and ispe idone o he ea men o
bipola diso de among child en olde han 10 yea s
(12). A ipip azole and ispe idone a e also app o ed
o he ea men o i i abili y associa ed wi h au ism
(12). In Finland, only ispe idone and zip asidone a e
app o ed o child en younge han 13 yea s.
Zip asidone is app o ed o manic episodes o
bipola disease in child en olde han 10 yea s and
ispe idone o sho - e m use (≤6 weeks) in he
ea men o conduc p oblems in child en olde han
i e yea s wi h de elopmen al diso de s o men al
e a da ion. As o icial indica ions o SGA use a e
sca ce, use among child en is mos ly o -label (2).
Child en and adolescen s wi h au ism spec um
diso de s and in ellec ual disabili y ep esen an
inc easing popula ion ea ed wi h SGAs (13). SGA
use is also common among child en wi h a en ion
de ici hype ac i i y diso de o dis up i e beha iou
diso de s (2,3). SGA medica ion is also used o
child en and adolescen s wi h a ious o he
diagnoses – such as psychosis, mood and ic
diso de s, and obsessi e compulsi e diso de – and
in symp oma ic ea men o agg essi e beha iou
despi e he p ima y diagnosis (1,2,8,10,14).
When looking a he socio-demog aphic
backg ound ac o s o paedia ic pa ien s using SGAs
in he USA, s udies show ha he inc ease in SGA
use has occu ed disp opo iona ely mo e o en
among publicly han p i a ely insu ed pa ien s (1,7).
Those in os e ca e seem o be especially p one o
an ipsycho ic p esc ip ions among publicly insu ed
child en (7). Child en in os e ca e ha e o en
expe ienced auma ic li e e en s, which a e, among
o he indi idual and en i onmen al ac o s, known
isk ac o s o se e al men al heal h dis u bances
(15-17). These kinds o expe iences a e p obably
mo e common in child en and adolescen s ea ed by
psychia ic se ices han in he gene al popula ion.
Fo example, ad e se li e e en s we e equen
among adolescen -aged psychia ic in-pa ien s
su e ing om bipola diso de ype I (58%) and
ca a onia (57%) (18). In a s udy by Fo d e al. (19), in
a clinical sample o child psychia y ou -pa ien s aged
ou o 18 yea s, one in h ee pa icipan s had a
his o y o exposu e o in e pe sonal iolence.
The e is some e idence o he bene i s o SGA use
in child en. SGAs, pa icula ly ispe idone and
a ipip azole, ha e shown o be e icien in he
ea men o i i abili y, agg ession, sel -inju y, and
possibly s e eo ypic beha iou in au ism (20-24).
SGAs also appea o educe challenging beha iou in
he sho e m among child en wi h in ellec ual
disabili ies (25). The e is some e idence ha
ispe idone has an e ec on dis up i e and agg essi e
beha iou in he sho e m e en among child en and
adolescen s wi h a no mal IQ (26,27). Rispe idone
and a ipip azole appea o be p omising o ea ing
ic symp oms in child en wi h Tou e e synd ome
(28,29). Wi h psychosis o schizoph enia, he e icacy
o SGAs appea s o be simila in child en,
adolescen s, and young adul s (30-32). A ipip azole
also appea s o be e ec i e in paedia ic bipola
disease (30,33). Howe e , he a ailable s udies mos ly
co e only he sho - e m use o SGAs, which
seldom i s he clinical eali y.
In child en, he he apeu ic p o ile and ad e se
e ec s o SGAs seem o di e om hose in adul s,
and child en also appea o be mo e ulne able han
adul s o some SGA-induced ad e se e ec s (34).
Seda ion, hype p olac inemia, and me abolic
dis u bances, such as weigh gain, dyslipidaemia, and
hype glycaemia, a e known SGA ad e se e ec s ha
Second-gene a ion an ipsycho ics in child en
79
can ha e a - eaching consequences h ough
me abolic, endoc inological, ca dio ascula , and
psychological e ec s (34-38). We also know e y
li le abou he long- e m e ec s o SGAs on he
de eloping cen al ne ous sys em.
The de ec ed inc ease in SGA use has induced
a emp s o moni o and imp o e SGA p esc ip ion
p ac ices a ound he wo ld (7,39,40). All moni o ing
ecommenda ions emphasize on he app op ia e use
o psychosocial in e en ions and he egula
moni o ing o me abolic and o he ad e se e ec s
(41). The guidelines o he Ame ican Academy o
Child and Adolescen Psychia y (AACAP), he
Canadian Alliance o Moni o ing E ec i eness and
Sa e y o An ipsycho ics in Child en (CAMESA),
and he Na ional Ins i u e o Heal h and Ca e
Excellence (NICE) in he UK include
ecommenda ions o moni o ing and managing he
ad e se e ec s o SGA in child en (Table 1)
(39,40,42). In Finland, he e a e na ional clinical
guidelines o he ea men o schizoph enia in
adul s, bu no o child en. Psycho opic
medica ions a e howe e , ecommended o be
ini ia ed o child en in specialis -le el heal h ca e
se ices (5), wi h he excep ion o a en ion de ici
hype ac i i y diso de medica ion (me hylphenida e).
TABLE 1
.
Recommenda ions o moni o ing
second
-
gene a ion an ipsycho ic
ea men acco ding o
Na ional Ins i u e o Heal h and Ca e
Excellence (NICE), Ame ican Academy o Child and Adolescen Psychia y (AACAP), and Canadian Alliance o Moni o ing E ec i eness and Sa e y
o An ipsycho ics in Child en (CAMESA) (39,40,42)
Follow
-
ups
Issued by
Baseline
1
2
3
4
NICE
Weekly ( i s 6 weeks)
12 weeks
E e y 6 mon hs
G ow h
cha *,
WHC, RR,
pulse, b-
gluc, HbA
1c
,
lipids,
p olac in,
MD,
nu i ional
s a us, die ,
physical
ac i i y
G ow h cha , MD,
e icacy, side-e ec s
G ow h cha , MD, RR,
pulse, b-gluc, HbA
1c
,
lipids, p olac in,
physical heal h,
e icacy, side e ec s
G ow h cha , MD, WHC,
RR, pulse, b-gluc, HbA
1c
,
lipids, p olac in, physical
heal h, e icacy, side e ec s
–
AACAP
Regula in e als
Family
his o y,
BMI, WC,
RR, pulse,
b-gluc,
lipids, MD
BMI, RR,
pulse, b-gluc (HbA
1c
i
needed), lipids
†
, MD
–
–
–
CAMESA
1, 2, 9 mon hs
3 mon hs
6 mon hs
1 yea
G ow h
cha , BMI,
WC, RR,
NEU, b-
gluc,
insulin,
lipids,
ASAT, ALAT,
TSH (wi h
que iapine),
p olac in
G ow h cha ,
BMI,
WC, RR, NEU
G ow h cha ,
BMI, WC,
RR, NEU, b-gluc,
insulin, lipids, p olac in
G ow h cha
, BMI, WC, RR,
NEU, b-gluc, insulin, lipids
ASAT, ALAT, TSH (wi h
que iapine)
Same as baseline
No e. ECG ecommenda ions a e no included
ALAT, alanine amino ans e ase; ASAT, aspa a e amino ans e ase; b-gluc, as ing glucose; HbA1c, glycosyla ed hemoglobin; lipids, blood lipid p o ile; MD,
mo emen diso de s; NEU, neu ological examina ion; TSH, hy oid-s imula ing ho mone; RR, blood p essu e; WC, wais ci cum e ence; WHC, wais and hip
ci cum e ence
*Includes weigh and heigh
†I signi ican weigh changes and/o a amily his o y indica ing isk
Second-gene a ion an ipsycho ics in child en
80
Recommenda ions and ollow-up p o ocols seem
o be help ul in clinical wo k and appea o inc ease
moni o ing and possibly ha e an e ec on
p esc ibing p ac ices (7,43,44). Despi e he al eady
exis ing ecommenda ions, he e has been a lag in he
ansla ion o esea ch e idence in o clinical p ac ice
(39,45). Ra es o me abolic moni o ing o SGA ha e
been low acco ding o se e al s udies. Rodday e al.
(46) ound ha 66% o psychia is s epo ed
ou inely asking abou he pa ien ’s medical his o y,
92% epo ed moni o ing he pa ien ’s g ow h, 81%
epo ed moni o ing he pa ien ’s plasma glucose and
lipids, 23% epo ed measu ing he pa ien ’s wais
ci cum e ence, and 12% epo ed moni o ing he
pa ien ’s ECG. Being able o measu e i al signs,
heigh , and weigh on si e was associa ed wi h a
highe p obabili y o moni o ing heigh and weigh
(46). In an audi pe o med in he UK, Pasha e al.
(44) disco e ed ha o in-pa ien s a a child and
adolescen men al heal h uni , he pa ame e s
measu ed mos o en be o e SGA ini ia ion included
BMI and hip- o-wais ci cum e ence; howe e , he
moni o ing a e o hese measu emen s was only
60%. In he USA, many moni o ing ini ia i es ha e
aken place in he os e ca e sys em, and as a esul ,
SGA- ea ed child en in os e ca e a e now mo e
likely han o he publically insu ed child en o ecei e
me abolic moni o ing, and, in addi ion, psychosocial
in e en ions (7). Ne e heless, bo h glucose and
lipid moni o ing ailed in 72% o hese os e
child en and in 82% o o he s (7).
Some child en appea o be mo e ulne able han
o he s in de eloping me abolic ad e se e ec s, and
an impo an goal o an SGA moni o ing p ocedu e
should be o iden i y as ea ly as possible hose
child en who a e a pa icula isk o ad e se e ec s
(36,47). Some speci ic genes ha e al eady been linked
wi h he inc eased isk o ad e se e ec s wi h SGAs,
bu he e a e no gene es s a ailable ye in e e yday
clinical wo k (47,48). In he ligh o cu en e idence,
sc eening and moni o ing p ac ices should hus be
emphasized.
Aims o he s udy
The aim o his s udy was o assess he clinical use,
indica ions, and ollow-up p ac ices o SGA
medica ion among child psychia ic pa ien s a
Tampe e Uni e si y Hospi al (TAUH), Finland. This
s udy also aims o desc ibe he medical and socio-
demog aphic backg ound ac o s o SGA- ea ed
child en as well as he possible bene i s and ad e se
e ec s o SGA medica ion.
Me hod
This s udy was conduc ed a he Child Psychia ic
Clinic o TAUH and was based on pa ien epo s.
Wi h a ca chmen a ea o app oxima ely hal a
million people, TAUH is one o i e uni e si y
hospi als in Finland o e ing specialis -le el heal h
ca e se ices. The Child Psychia ic Clinic gi es in-
pa ien and ou -pa ien se ices o child en aged 0
o 12 yea s. Child en aged 13 o 18 yea s a e aken
ca e o in adolescen psychia y, which in Finland is
a sepa a e speciali y. Child en wi h a diagnosis o
men al e a da ion a e e e ed o sepa a e se ices.
Child en a e e e ed o TAUH by he heal h ca e
cen es and communi y hospi als o he dis ic .
Guidelines a e a ailable o he e e al p ac ices o
specialis -le el child psychia ic se ices. Du ing he
s udy pe iod (1 Oc obe 2013 o 1 Oc obe 2014),
1633 child en we e ea ed a he clinic.
The inclusion c i e ia o he s udy we e ha he
pa ien was younge han 13 yea s when ini ia ing
SGA ea men , ha he medica ion was ini ia ed a
he TAUH clinic, and ha he SGA medica ion was
ongoing du ing he s udy pe iod. These c i e ia we e
me by 133 pa ien s, whose pa ien epo s we e
examined un il he da e he medica ion was
discon inued, he pa ien was e e ed o ano he
clinic, o un il 31 May 2015, whiche e came i s .
The i s au ho (K.K.) collec ed in o ma ion om
he pa ien epo s and eco ded hem. Selec ed
pa ien epo s we e e iewed by he second au ho
(L.P.), who also o e ed second opinion on eques
om he i s au ho . The da a collec ed om pa ien
epo s consis ed o he pa ien ’s age, he conclusion
o he cogni i e e alua ion, and o he socio-
demog aphic and medical ac o s a he SGA
ini ia ion phase. The conclusions o cogni i e
e alua ions we e dicho omized as in elligence wi hin
no mal a ia ion o below, based on pa ien epo
ma kings o ei he he a ending physician o a
psychologis . In o ma ion on SGA medica ion use
(gene ic name, du a ion, easons o discon inuing o
changing medica ion) and o he psycho opic
medica ions as well as in o ma ion on he pa ien ’s
diagnoses and indica ions (o main symp oms)
a ached o he SGA ini ia ion we e collec ed o
deduced om he pa ien epo s. The easons o
discon inua ion o changing he SGA we e
ca ego ized o analyses by he i s au ho as:
ad e se e ec , no bene i s, ad e se e ec s mo e
signi ican han possible bene i s (un a ou able isk–
bene i a io), symp oms diminished so ha he
medica ion was no longe needed, and no
in o ma ion. In addi ion, in o ma ion on he
psychia ic and o he medical his o y o he pa ien
and his/he amily was eco ded. The possible
bene i s and ad e se e ec s o SGA medica ion we e
ex ac ed om he physicians’ e alua ions eco ded
in he pa ien epo s. The a ailable in o ma ion o
possible bene i s was classi ied as: conside able
Second-gene a ion an ipsycho ics in child en
81
bene i , some bene i , unce ain, no bene i , and no
in o ma ion. The ad e se e ec s, such as weigh
gain, and neu ological, endoc inological (e.g.,
gynecomas ia, mens ua ion dis u bances), and o he
men ioned e ec s we e eco ded sepa a ely.
In o ma ion conce ning he ollow-up p o ocols,
such as medical e alua ions made du ing he ollow-
up pe iod (physical s a us, weigh , and heigh ) and
possible consul a ions made by child psychia is s o
o he medical special ies (e.g., ca diology o
paedia ics) we e eco ded. The pa ien ’s age-
adjus ed BMI sco e was calcula ed a he analysis
phase om he exis ing weigh and heigh da a (i
bo h measu emen s we e a ailable om he same
ime poin ) using he ables o he new Finnish
g ow h e e ences (49).
To examine whe he he e we e any di e ences
be ween pa ien s ha ing an au ism spec um o
de elopmen al diso de diagnosis and pa ien s wi h
o he psychia ic diagnoses, he s udy sample was
di ided in o wo g oups based on diagnosis using he
In e na ional S a is ical Classi ica ion o Diseases and
Rela ed Heal h P oblems, 10 h Re ision (ICD-10) (50).
The i s g oup ( he PDD/DD g oup) consis ed o
40 (30%) child en wi h a pe asi e de elopmen al
diso de (F84) diagnosis and se en (5%) pa ien s
wi h a diagnosis o mixed speci ic de elopmen al
diso de s (F83). The second g oup ( he non-
PDD/DD g oup) consis ed o 86 (65%) pa ien s
wi h a ious o he diagnoses. Resul s o he g oups
whe e he e a e s a is ically signi ican di e ences a e
epo ed sepa a ely; o he wise, he esul s a e
epo ed o he en i e sample.
The esul s o ca ego ized a iables a e epo ed as
equencies (pe cen ages o numbe o cases, as
app op ia e). Fo no mally dis ibu ed con inuous
a iables, means (M) and s anda d de ia ions (SD)
a e gi en, and o o he con inuous a iables,
medians and qua iles (Md, Q
1
, Q
3
) a e epo ed. Fo
es ing he signi icance o di e ences be ween he
PDD/DD and non-PDD/DD g oup, Pea son’s chi-
squa ed es , Fishe ’s exac es , o he Mann–
Whi ney U- es we e used, as app op ia e. A p- alue
o less han 0.05 is conside ed signi ican , and a alue
be ween 0.05 and 0.10 is conside ed indica i e; alues
up o 0.10 a e epo ed. SPSS .23 was used o all
s a is ical analyses.
Resul s
Eigh y-one pe cen o he s udy sample we e boys.
The mean age a he ime o SGA ini ia ion was 9.3
yea s (SD, 2.1 yea s). In he PDD/DD g oup, he
child en we e younge a he ime o SGA ini ia ion
han he child en in he non-PDD/DD g oup (M 8.6
yea s, SD, 2.0; and M, 9.7 yea s, SD, 2.0, espec i ely;
p = .002). The age dis ibu ion o he pa ien s showed
wo peaks, one du ing he ea ly yea s o school (6 o
8 yea s) and he second a p e-pube y (11 o 12
yea s). Cogni i e e alua ion was pe o med o 85%
o he child en, and a conclusion abou in elligence
s a us was a ailable o all bu h ee o hem. Eigh y-
one pe cen o hose e alua ed had an in elligence
p o ile wi hin no mal age a ia ion. One pa ien had
a diagnosis o men al e a da ion. In o ma ion on
whe he he cogni i e e alua ion was pe o med o
no was lacking in ou pa ien epo s. Cogni i e
e alua ion was pe o med mo e equen ly in he
PDD/DD g oup han in he non-PDD/DD g oup
(96% s. 78%, p =.010), bu he e we e no s a is ically
signi ican di e ences be ween g oups in he esul s
o he e alua ions. Se en y-nine pe cen o he s udy
pa ien s had been ea ed a leas once in hei
li e ime a a psychia ic in-pa ien wa d.
The mos common SGA d ug a ini ia ion was
ispe idone (93%). Que iapine (6%) and a ipip azole
(2%) we e less common. Rispe idone was
indica i ely mo e common han o he SGAs in he
PDD/DD g oup han in he non-PDD/DD g oup
(98% s. 90%, p = .097). Six een pe cen o he
pa ien s had hei medica ion swi ched o ano he
SGA once, 6% wice, and wo pa ien s h ee imes.
The mos common easons o swi ching he SGA
we e ad e se e ec s (52%) and an un a ou able isk–
bene i a io – ha is, he a ending physician had
judged ha ad e se e ec s we e mo e signi ican
han possible bene i s (48%). Thi y- wo pe cen o
he pa ien s who had hei SGA swi ched had no
bene i s om he ini ia ion d ug. In he PDD/DD
g oup, he e we e ewe al e a ions in SGA
medica ions han in he non-PDD/DD g oup (17%
s. 34%, p = .035), and he eason o swi ching was
less equen ly an ad e se e ec (31% s. 73%, p =
.032).
Pa ien s who discon-
inued medica ion
Du a ion o SGA medica ion
(mon hs; median and qua iles)
0 10 20 30 40 50 60
All pa ien s
All
Non-PDD/DD
PDD/DD
All
Non-PDD/DD
PDD/DD
p = 0.036
p < 0.001
FIGURE 2. Du a ion o second-gene a ion an ipsycho ic (SGA) medica ion.
Figu es in he “all pa ien s” g oup do no desc ibe he genuine du a ion o
SGA medica ion because he du a ion a e he endpoin o he ollow-up is
no known
Second-gene a ion an ipsycho ics in child en
82
Figu e 2 shows he du a ion o SGA medica ion in
his s udy. Almos one- i h o he pa ien s
discon inued medica ion comple ely du ing he s udy
pe iod. The median du a ion o SGA medica ion
among hese pa ien s was 14.4 mon hs. In he
PDD/DD g oup, he du a ion o SGA ea men
was longe han in he non-PDD/DD g oup (Md,
22.7 s. 10.8 mon hs, p = .036). The mos common
easons o discon inua ion we e ha he pa ien ’s
symp oms had diminished o a le el whe e
medica ion was no longe needed (52%) o ha he
isk–bene i a io was conside ed un a ou able
(30%). When aking all s udy pa ien s in o accoun ,
he median du a ion o SGA medica ion by he end
o he s udy pe iod was 22.2 mon hs. In he
PDD/DD g oup, he du a ion was longe han in
non-PDD/DD g oup (Md, 33.7 s. 18.4, p < .001).
Howe e , his igu e does no desc ibe he ac ual
du a ion o SGA medica ion in his g oup because
he du a ion a e he end o ollow-up is no known.
TABLE 2.
In e na ional S a is ical Classi ica ion o Diseases and Rela ed Heal h P oblems, 10 h Re ision
,
diagnoses o
second
-
gene a ion
an ipsycho ic (SGA)- ea ed child en (n=133)
Diagnoses
ICD
-
10 class
%
Hype kine ic diso de s
F90
50
Conduc /mixed conduc and emo ional diso de
F91
-
92
40
Pe asi e de elopmen al diso de s
F84
30
Obsessi e compulsi e diso de
F42
13
Diso de s o social unc ioning wi h onse speci ic o childhood and adolescence
*
F94
13
Reac ion o se e e s ess/adjus men diso de s
F43
10
Tic diso de s
F95
8
Emo ional diso de wi h onse speci ic o childhood
F93
7
Diso de s o psychological
de elopmen
F80
-
82
7
Dep essi e episode
F32
6
Bipola a ec i e diso de
F31
5
Psycho ic diso de s
F23, F29
5
Mixed speci ic de elopmen al diso de s
F83
5
O he mood (a ec i e) diso de s
F38
5
Phobic and o he anxie y diso de s
F40
-
41
3
Dissocia i e (con e sion) diso de s
F44
3
O he beha iou al and emo ional diso de s wi h onse usually occu ing in childhood and adolescence
†
F98
2
Ea ing diso de s
F50
1
Unspeci ied men al e a da ion
F79
1
No e. Each child could ha e mo e han one diagnosis
ICD-10, In e na ional S a is ical Classi ica ion o Diseases and Rela ed Heal h P oblems, 10 h Re ision
*Reac i e a achmen diso de F94.1 (n=5), o he childhood diso de s o social unc ioning F94.8 (n=12)
†Non-o ganic enu esis F98.0 (n=1), non-o ganic encop esis F98.1 (n=1)
Polypha macy was common among he pa ien s in
he s udy. Nine pa ien s we e simul aneously using
ano he an ipsycho ic medica ion, mos commonly
( i e pa ien s) le omep omazine. The ac ual a e o
simul aneous use o wo di e en an ipsycho ic
agen s was highe due o c oss- i a ion pe iods when
swi ching om one medica ion o ano he . Six y-
eigh pe cen o he s udy pa ien s had unde gone a
leas a sho - e m ea men ial wi h some o he
psycho opic medica ion (no including mela onin)
in addi ion o SGA du ing hei ea men a he
Child Psychia ic Clinic. Fi y- h ee pe cen had used
one medica ion o he han SGA and 14% wo o
h ee. The use o me hylphenida e was mo e
common in he PDD/DD g oup han in he non-
PDD/DD g oup (79% s. 58%, p = .022). Twen y-
i e pe cen had had a leas a ial wi h a omoxe ine
and 16% wi h selec i e se o onin eup ake inhibi o s.
Fou een pe cen o he s udy pa ien s had had
benzodiazepines as equisi e medica ion a some
poin o hei ea men . Almos wo- hi ds (63%) o
he pa ien s had unde gone a leas a sho - e m
mela onin ea men o sleep p oblems.
All o he s udy child en had a leas one ICD-10
F-ca ego y psychia ic diagnosis (50) a he ime o
SGA ini ia ion and 75% had a leas wo F diagnoses,
he maximum being ou (Table 2). Child en in he
PDD/DD g oup had mo e o en como bid
diso de s, 55% o hem ha ing wo F ca ego y
diagnoses and 38% ha ing h ee o ou , while he
espec i e numbe s in he non-PDD/DD g oup
we e 47% and 19% (p = .001). The mos common
diagnoses in he non-PDD/DD g oup we e F91-92
(conduc /mixed conduc and emo ional diso de ;
49%, n = 42) and F90 (hype kine ic diso de s; 44%,
n = 38). F91-92 and F31 (bipola a ec i e diso de )
diagnoses we e mo e common in he non-PDD/DD
g oup han in he PDD/DD g oup (49% s. 23%, p
Second-gene a ion an ipsycho ics in child en
83
= .005, and 8% s. none, p = .051, espec i ely).
Thi y-nine pe cen o he pa ien s had also a leas
one ICD-10 Z diagnosis ( ac o s in luencing heal h
s a us and con ac wi h heal h se ices), implying
mul iple en i onmen al ac o s in luencing he
pa ien ’s men al well-being.
The indica ion o SGA ini ia ion was clea ly s a ed
in 61% o pa ien epo s. In gene al, indica ions and
symp oms we e di e se, and 92% o he pa ien s had
wo o mo e indica ions o main symp oms. The
mos common indica ions o co e/main symp oms
o SGA ini ia ion we e agg ession (in 75% o he
pa ien s) and beha iou p oblems (74%)
independen o diagnosis. Mood swings we e a mo e
common indica ion in he non-PDD/DD g oup
(24% s. 9%, p = .035) and sleep p oblems as
indica ion indica i ely associa ed wi h he PDD/DD
g oup (17% s. 6%, p = .063). The o icially
app o ed c i e ia o SGA medica ion (he e
ispe idone, which was he mos commonly used
SGA in his s udy) use in Finland is sho - e m
ea men o conduc p oblems o child en olde
han 5 yea s wi h de elopmen al diso de s o men al
e a da ion. None o he SGA-medica ed child en in
his s udy ul illed all hese c i e ia. Wi h loose
in e p e a ion, he 47 (35%) pa ien s in he
PDD/DD g oup ul illed he o icial c i e ion o
diagnosis o de elopmen al diso de s o men al
e a da ion. Fo y- i e o hese pa ien s also ul illed
he c i e ion o age (> 5 yea s) and 34 ul illed he
indica ion c i e ion o agg ession/agg essi e
beha iou , bu in none o he s udy pa ien s was he
medica ion sho - e m.
TABLE 3.
Family backg ound o he
second
-
gene a ion an ipsycho ic
-
ea ed child en
All
(%)
PDD/DD
(%)
Non
-
PDD/DD
(%)
p
Family s a us (n=133)
<.001
Biological pa en s
37
57
26
Pa en al sepa a ion
40
36
42
Fos e home
18
6
24
O he (e.g. adop ion)
5
0
8
Numbe o siblings (n=126)
NS
None
21
23
20
One
38
40
37
Two o mo e
41
36
43
Mo he ’s wo king s a us (n=133)
.018
Wo king a
leas pa ime
53
68
45
O he o no known
47
32
55
Fa he ’s wo king s a us (n=133)
NS
Wo king a leas pa ime
57
64
54
O he o no known
43
36
47
Alcohol/d ugs (n=83)
60
44
71
.021
Psychia ic his o y o i s
-
deg ee ela i es
Schizoph enia, bipola disease o o he psychosis
(n=67)
33
15
45
.016
Dep ession (n=88)
67
61
72
NS
Suicide (n=133)
NS
Commi ed
2
2
2
A leas one a emp
7
2
9
Child exposed o iolence (n=133)
41
30
48
.065
Exposed o domes ic iolence
11
4
15
Been objec o physical punishmen o o he
domes ic iolence
12
13
12
Bo h exposed and been objec
11
6
13
O he kind o iolence exposu e (e.g. wa
expe iences)
8
6
8
No e. In a iables conce ning suicide and exposu e o iolence, missing in o ma ion was ca ego ized as “no”. In all o he a iables
missing in o ma ion was sepa a ed. The e o e, he o al numbe o cases a y by a iable
Second-gene a ion an ipsycho ics in child en
84
The s udy pa ien s had di e se social s ess ac o s
and ad e se li e e en s in hei pas (Table 3). Less
han 40% o he pa ien s had bo h biological pa en s
as ca egi e s a he ime o SGA ini ia ion. Pa en al
sepa a ion was common (40%), and 18% o he
pa ien s we e in os e ca e. The e was pa en al
subs ance abuse in mo e han hal o he amilies. A
amily his o y o psychia ic diso de s was eco ded
o 84% o he pa ien s (whe eas a amily his o y o
soma ic diseases was eco ded o 53% o he
pa ien s). The e was a i s -deg ee amily membe
who had a diagnosis o schizoph enia, bipola
disease, o o he psychosis in one- hi d o he
amilies. O e a hal o he pa ien s had a dep essed
amily membe and abou one- en h had a amily
membe who had a emp ed o commi ed suicide.
Exposu e o some kind o iolence was men ioned
in 41% o he pa ien epo s.
The e e yday unc ioning o he pa ien ’s pa en s
in he PDD/DD g oup appea ed o be be e han
ha in he non-PDD/DD g oup. Abou hal o he
mo he s and a he s o he s udy pa ien s we e
wo king a leas pa ime. Howe e , he employmen
o mo he s was s a is ically signi ican ly mo e
common in he PDD/DD g oup han in he non-
PDD/DD g oup, and child en in he PDD/DD
g oup also had bo h biological pa en s as ca egi e s
mo e o en. In he PDD/DD g oup, ou -o -home
placemen s we e a e han in he non-PDD g oup,
and he e was signi ican ly less pa en al subs ance
abuse and ewe i s -deg ee ela i es wi h bipola o
o he psychoses. Exposu e o iolence was also
indica i ely less common in he PDD/DD g oup
han in he non-PDD/DD g oup (see Table 3).
In 36% o he pa ien epo s, he e was no
in o ma ion on g ow h his o y a he ime o SGA
ini ia ion. When epo ed, g ow h his o y was no mal
in 68% o he pa ien s, while he e was some
de iance (e.g., o e weigh , slow g ow h) in he
emainde p io o SGA ini ia ion. Six pa ien s we e
epo ed o ha e been d inking alcohol and i e
pa ien s we e epo ed o be smoking. One o he
pa ien s had olun a ily old he physician abou
expe imen al subs ance use. In gene al, in o ma ion
on he pa ien ’s possible subs ance use was missing.
In 81% o he cases, he a ending physician
epo ed ei he conside able o a leas some bene i
due o he SGA medica ion. Th ee pe cen had no
bene i s om he SGA medica ion. In 16% o he
cases, he possible bene i s emained unce ain o he
in o ma ion was lacking. In many cases, he e was
also luc ua ion in symp oms despi e he medica ion.
In 28% o he cases, he a ending physician epo ed
no ad e se e ec s. One ad e se e ec was epo ed
in 32% o he pa ien s and 40% had wo o mo e
ad e se e ec s. The mos equen ad e se e ec s
we e inc eased appe i e and weigh gain, which we e
epo ed in 36% and 35% o he cases, espec i ely.
Somnolence, usually in he SGA ini ia ion phase, was
epo ed in 33% o cases and o he neu ological
ad e se e ec s in 10% o he pa ien epo s. All
o he epo ed ad e se e ec s (inc eased i i a ion,
mammilla y gland symp oms, dis u bances in
mens ual cycle, u ina y symp oms, headaches,
nosebleeds, abdominal pain o swelling, and loss o
appe i e) we e each men ioned a mos in 7% o he
pa ien epo s.
Numbe o child en
0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140
Labo a o y es s
BMI measu emen s
Physical examina ion
Baseline
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70
Labo a o y es s
BMI measu emen s
Physical examina ion
6-12 mon hs
Labo a o y es s
BMI measu emen s
Physical examina ion
0-6 mon hs
Numbe o child en
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70
Labo a o y es s
BMI measu emen s
Physical examina ion
o e 24 mon hs
Labo a o y es s
BMI measu emen s
Physical examina ion
12-24 mon hs
0
1-2
3-5
6-8
> 8
Numbe o
measu emen s
Du a ion o
medica ion
FIGURE 3. Physical examina ion, BMI measu emen s, and labo a o y es s
pe o med du ing he second-gene a ion an ipsycho ic ea men
Figu e 3 shows a summa y o he equency o
physical examina ion, labo a o y es s, and BMI
measu emen s pe o med du ing he s udy pe iod. A
SGA ini ia ion (baseline), some kind o physical
examina ion o he han measu emen o heigh o
weigh was pe o med on 33% o he pa ien s.
Almos he same p opo ion o he pa ien s (29%)
had no physical examina ion du ing ollow-up.
App oxima ely one- i h o he pa ien s in he
longes ea men ca ego y (o e 24 mon hs) had no
physical examina ions du ing ollow-up. A baseline,
38% o he pa ien s had hei weigh measu ed and
34% had hei heigh measu ed. Twen y pe cen had
Second-gene a ion an ipsycho ics in child en
85
hei heigh measu ed once and 69% had hei heigh
measu ed wice o mo e o en du ing he ollow-up.
Weigh was measu ed once in 16% o he pa ien s,
and 77% had a leas wo weigh measu emen s
du ing he ollow-up. Ten (8%) pa ien s had no
in o ma ion on weigh and ou een (11%) pa ien s
had no in o ma ion on heigh du ing he ollow-up.
In some epo s, i was men ioned ha g ow h was
ollowed elsewhe e, bu he in o ma ion did no
always each he a ending physician. Baseline
labo a o y es s we e mo e equen han physical
examina ion. A baseline, some labo a o y es s we e
pe o med o 67% o he pa ien s and plasma lipids
and glucose, as indica o s o me abolic condi ion,
we e checked o 55% and 61% o he pa ien s,
espec i ely.
Twen y- i e pe cen o he pa ien s had one and
10% wo o h ee consul a ions wi h a paedia ic
ca diologis du ing he s udy pe iod. A consul a ion
was mos o en pe o med as a pape consul a ion.
Indica ions o consul a ions we e di e se, bu
mos ly in ol ed he in e p e a ion o an ECG i he
psychia is conside ed i abe an . The ca diologis
did no ind absolu e obs acles o SGA use in any o
he consul a ions. Howe e , in wo pa ien s,
ca diological ad e se e ec s (p olonged QT in e al)
we e men ioned as a eason o discon inuing o
swi ching he SGA. O he paedia icians (e.g.,
neu ologis o endoc inologis ) we e consul ed a
leas once o 32% o he pa ien s. Nine pa ien s we e
e e ed o a nu i ionis o die a y ad ice.
Discussion
In his s udy we assessed he clinical use o SGAs in
133 child psychia ic pa ien s aged 12 yea s o
younge . Child en in he s udy had mul iple
diagnoses, and polypha macy was common. Mos
(79%) o he pa ien s had had in-pa ien ea men ,
e lec ing hei symp om se e i y and poo unc ional
capaci y. Como bidi y was common, wi h 75% o all
child en ecei ing mo e han one psychia ic
diagnosis. Independen ly o he diagnoses, he main
SGA a ge symp om was agg ession; howe e , he
indica ion was clea ly s a ed in only 61% o he
pa ien epo s. The o icial indica ions o SGA
medica ion o child en younge han 13 yea s a e
ew. Ne e heless, hese medica ions a e equen ly
used o a ying indica ions in his age g oup
(1,2,8,10,14). In his s udy, he da a we e collec ed
om a geog aphically es ic ed a ea in Finland.
Howe e , he indings a e in line wi h p e ious
s udies (2,10,11). SGA use was mos ly o -label, since
none o he pa ien s ul illed all o he o icial
indica ion c i e ia.
Va ious s udies show ha he signi ican isk o
me abolic and o he SGA-induced ad e se e ec s
calls o app op ia e moni o ing (34-38). Howe e ,
he con en and schedule o he physical e alua ions
and ollow-up p ac ices o SGA medica ions ha e
been di e se in child psychia ic clinical wo k
(7,39,44-46), as was also obse ed in his s udy. Only
abou one- hi d o he s udy pa ien s had unde gone
a physical e alua ion a SGA ini ia ion.
App oxima ely one- i h o he pa ien s medica ed
o o e 24 mon hs had no physical examina ion a
any o he ollow-up isi s. Fu he mo e, in o ma ion
on g ow h his o y was lacking o abou one- hi d o
he pa ien s. I is also no ewo hy ha in o ma ion
on he child’s amily his o y o soma ic diseases,
which is o impo ance when assessing isk ac o s
associa ed wi h, o example, me abolic diso de s,
was o en incomple e and less ho oughly
documen ed han he amily his o y o psychia ic
illnesses.
E alua ing he bene i s and isks o SGA
medica ion among child en is complex. SGA
ea men o child en is o en associa ed wi h he
symp oma ic ea men o de elopmen al o o he
diso de s wi h a long du a ion (1,2,8,14,21,22,25).
The a e age du a ion o he SGA medica ion was
long in his s udy as well: he median du a ion was
almos wo yea s. Mos o he SGA- ea ed pa ien s
(81%) in his s udy had an imp o emen in hei
symp oms a leas o some ex en , bu symp om
con ol seemed a imes insu icien . In many cases,
he e was luc ua ion in he symp oms despi e he
con inuous medica ion and he possible bene i s
gained a he beginning did no emain so e iden in
he long un. Du ing he ea ly yea s, biopsychosocial
de elopmen is apid, and many aspec s a ec he
possible symp om de elopmen . The wo peaks in
he SGA ini ia ion age obse ed in his s udy – he
i s school yea s and p e-pube y – may bo h e lec
imes o inc easing en i onmen al and social
demands o he child, and hese imes a e also
challenging om a amily pe spec i e. The many
o he psycho opic medica ion ials obse ed in his
s udy may also ha e in luenced symp om
imp o emen o de e io a ion. In 16% o he pa ien s
in his s udy, he e ec o he medica ion emained
unclea . Despi e his, he medica ion was o en
con inued. The use o sys ema ic assessmen
me hods o examining changes in pa ien s’
unc ioning o esponse o medica ion was no
possible in his s udy due o he sou ce o
in o ma ion being pa ien eco ds, which a e o en
incomple e and somewha unsys ema ic. Fu he
s udies on he subjec a e needed, and sys ema ic
assessmen o unc ional capaci y a he baseline and
du ing ollow-up should be encou aged.
In his s udy, he majo i y o child en medica ed
wi h an ipsycho ics had ema kable ad e se li e