Global, regional, and national comparative risk assessment of 84 behavioural, environmental and occupational, and metabolic risks or clusters of risks, 1990–2016: a systematic analysis for the Global Burden of Disease Study 2016
Full text
www. helance .com Vol 390 Sep embe 16, 2017
1345
Global Heal h Me ics
Global, egional, and na ional compa a i e isk assessmen
o 84 beha iou al, en i onmen al and occupa ional, and
me abolic isks o clus e s o isks, 1990–2016: a sys ema ic
analysis o he Global Bu den o Disease S udy 2016
GBD 2016 Risk Fac o s Collabo a o s*
Summa y
Backg ound The Global Bu den o Diseases, Inju ies, and Risk Fac o s S udy 2016 (GBD 2016) p o ides a
comp ehensi e assessmen o isk ac o exposu e and a ibu able bu den o disease. By p o iding es ima es o e a
long ime se ies, his s udy can moni o isk exposu e ends c i ical o heal h su eillance and in o m policy deba es
on he impo ance o add essing isks in con ex .
Me hods We used he compa a i e isk assessmen amewo k de eloped o p e ious i e a ions o GBD o es ima e
le els and ends in exposu e, a ibu able dea hs, and a ibu able disabili y-adjus ed li e-yea s (DALYs), by age g oup,
sex, yea , and loca ion o 84 beha iou al, en i onmen al and occupa ional, and me abolic isks o clus e s o isks
om 1990 o 2016. This s udy included 481 isk-ou come pai s ha me he GBD s udy c i e ia o con incing o
p obable e idence o causa ion. We ex ac ed ela i e isk (RR) and exposu e es ima es om 22 717 andomised
con olled ials, coho s, pooled coho s, household su eys, census da a, sa elli e da a, and o he sou ces, acco ding
o he GBD 2016 sou ce coun ing me hods. Using he coun e ac ual scena io o heo e ical minimum isk exposu e
le el (TMREL), we es ima ed he po ion o dea hs and DALYs ha could be a ibu ed o a gi en isk. Finally, we
explo ed ou d i e s o ends in a ibu able bu den: popula ion g ow h, popula ion ageing, ends in isk exposu e,
and all o he ac o s combined.
Findings Since 1990, exposu e inc eased signi ican ly o 30 isks, did no change signi ican ly o ou isks, and
dec eased signi ican ly o 31 isks. Among isks ha a e leading causes o bu den o disease, child g ow h ailu e and
household ai pollu ion showed he mos signi ican declines, while me abolic isks, such as body-mass index and high
as ing plasma glucose, showed signi ican inc eases. In 2016, a Le el 3 o he hie a chy, he h ee leading isk ac o s
in e ms o a ibu able DALYs a he global le el o men we e smoking (124·1 million DALYs [95% UI 111·2 million o
137·0 million]), high sys olic blood p essu e (122·2 million DALYs [110·3 million o 133·3 million], and low bi hweigh
and sho ges a ion (83·0 million DALYs [78·3 million o 87·7 million]), and o women, we e high sys olic blood
p essu e (89·9 million DALYs [80·9 million o 98·2 million]), high body-mass index (64·8 million DALYs [44·4 million
o 87·6 million]), and high as ing plasma glucose (63·8 million DALYs [53·2 million o 76·3 million]). In 2016 in
113 coun ies, he leading isk ac o in e ms o a ibu able DALYs was a me abolic isk ac o . Smoking emained
among he leading i e isk ac o s o DALYs o 109 coun ies, while low bi hweigh and sho ges a ion was he
leading isk ac o o DALYs in 38 coun ies, pa icula ly in sub-Saha an A ica and Sou h Asia. In e ms o impo an
d i e s o change in ends o bu den a ibu able o isk ac o s, be ween 2006 and 2016 exposu e o isks explains an
9·3% (6·9–11·6) decline in dea hs and a 10·8% (8·3–13·1) dec ease in DALYs a he global le el, while popula ion
ageing accoun s o 14·9% (12·7–17·5) o dea hs and 6·2% (3·9–8·7) o DALYs, and popula ion g ow h o 12·4%
(10·1–14·9) o dea hs and 12·4% (10·1–14·9) o DALYs. The la ges con ibu ion o ends in isk exposu e o disease
bu den is seen be ween ages 1 yea and 4 yea s, whe e a decline o 27·3% (24·9–29·7) o he change in DALYs be ween
2006 and 2016 can be a ibu ed o declines in exposu e o isks.
In e p e a ion Inc easingly de ailed unde s anding o he ends in isk exposu e and he RRs o each isk-ou come
pai p o ide insigh s in o bo h he magni ude o heal h loss a ibu able o isks and how modi ica ion o isk exposu e
has con ibu ed o heal h ends. Me abolic isks wa an pa icula policy a en ion, due o hei la ge con ibu ion o
global disease bu den, inc easing ends, and a iable pa e ns ac oss coun ies a he same le el o de elopmen .
GBD 2016 indings show ha , while i has huge po en ial o imp o e heal h, isk modi ica ion has played a ela i ely
small pa in he pas decade.
Funding The Bill & Melinda Ga es Founda ion, Bloombe g Philan h opies.
Copy igh © The Au ho (s). Published by Else ie L d. This is an Open Access a icle unde he CC BY 4.0 license.
Lance 2017; 390: 1345–422
*Collabo a o s lis ed a he end
o he A icle
Fo mo e on Bloombe g
Philan h opies see
www.bloombe g.o g
This online publica ion has been
co ec ed. The co ec ed e sion
i s appea ed a helance .com
on Sep embe 18, 2017
Co espondence o:
P o Emmanuela Gakidou,
Ins i u e o Heal h Me ics and
E alua ion, Sea le, WA 98121,
USA
[email protected]
Global Heal h Me ics
1346
www. helance .com Vol 390 Sep embe 16, 2017
In oduc ion
A co e p emise o public heal h is ha p e en ion can
be a powe ul ins umen o imp o ing human heal h,
one ha is o en cos -e ec i e and minimises ha m
o indi iduals om ill heal h. The co e objec i es
o p e en ion include he educ ion o modi ica ion o
exposu e o isks including me abolic, beha iou al,
en i onmen al, and occupa ional ac o s. Quan i ying
isks o heal h and hus he a ge s o many public heal h
ac ions is an essen ial p e equisi e o e ec i e public
heal h. The e idence on he ela ion be ween isk
exposu e and heal h is cons an ly e ol ing: new
in o ma ion abou he ela i e isks (RRs) associa ed wi h
di e en isks o di e en ou comes con inues o
eme ge om coho s udies, andomised ials, and case-
con ol s udies. These s udies can es ablish e idence o
new isks o isk-ou come pai s o educe he s eng h o
e idence o exis ing isks. New da a a e also egula ly
collec ed on he le els o exposu e in di e en popula ions
and in di e en se ings. Regula ly upda ed moni o ing
o he e idence base on isk ac o s is c ucial o public
heal h and o indi idual isk modi ica ion h ough
p ima y ca e and sel -managemen .
Se e al s udies explo e isk-a ibu able bu den o
indi idual isks1–3 a he global, egional, o na ional le el.
O he s udies p o ide assessmen s o exposu e o selec ed
isks. Howe e , he Global Bu den o Diseases, Inju ies,
and Risk Fac o s S udy (GBD) compa a i e isk assessmen
(CRA) is he only comp ehensi e and compa able
app oach o isk ac o quan i ica ion. The mos ecen o
hese assessmen s was GBD 2015.4–6 Wi h each cycle o
GBD, scien i ic discussions ha e eme ged on a ious
dimensions o isk quan i ica ion ha ha e led o
imp o emen s and modi ica ions o GBD. Many o hese
a e ocused on he s eng h o e idence suppo ing a causal
connec ion o speci ic isk-ou come pai s, while o he s
ela e o measu emen challenges.7–9 Fu he , new isk
ac o s ha e been added o impo an heal h condi ions
included in GBD, such as neona al ou comes and
Alzheime ’s demen ia,10 which ha e p e iously no had
associa ed isk ac o s. The ecen ials on blood p essu e
con ol a lowe le els o sys olic blood p essu e, including
Resea ch in con ex
E idence be o e his s udy
The Global Bu den o Diseases, Inju ies, and Risk Fac o s S udy
2016 (GBD 2016) emains he mos comp ehensi e e o o
conduc a popula ion-le el compa a i e isk assessmen ac oss
coun ies and isks. O he sou ces o popula ion-le el es ima es
o isk include WHO and UNICEF epo s as well as independen
scien i ic publica ions. No able di e ences in me hods and
de ini ions p oduce a ia ion in esul s, al hough in se e al
cases he e is gene al ag eemen in egional o global pa e ns.
The GBD s udy emains he only pee - e iewed, comp ehensi e,
and annual assessmen o isk ac o bu den by age, sex, cause,
and loca ion o a long ime se ies ha complies wi h he
Guidelines o Accu a e and T anspa en Heal h Es ima es
Repo ing (GATHER).
Added alue o his s udy
This s udy builds upon GBD 2015 and p o ides se e al impo an
imp o emen s as well as he quan i ica ion o i e new isks.
The inno a ions and imp o emen s om las yea can be
summa ised as ollows. Ac oss all isk ac o s, he e we e
7155 addi ional da a sou ces, acco ding o he GBD 2016 sou ce
coun ing me hods. Fo die , we included da a o die a y ecall,
household budge , and ood equency ques ionnai es. We also
inco po a ed sales da a om 170 coun ies as well as na ional
accoun ing o ood a ailable o popula ions in a gi en yea . In
GBD 2016, we a e p oducing es ima es o he ollowing
i e new isks: smokeless obacco, low bi hweigh and sho
ges a ion, low bi hweigh o ges a ion, sho ges a ion o
bi hweigh , and die low in legumes. We also ex ended he high
body-mass index (BMI) analysis o include childhood obesi y. We
ha e also added 93 new isk-ou come pai s. Majo e isions o
he es ima ion o he ollowing isk ac o s we e unde aken o
GBD 2016. Fo second-hand smoke, we changed he es ima ion
me hod o ensu e consis ency wi h he es ima es o smoking
p e alence. Fo alcohol, we es ima ed new ela i e isks (RRs) o
all ou comes, we inco po a ed mo e da a o exposu e and new
adjus men s o ou ism and un eco ded consump ion, and we
ede ined he heo e ical minimum isk exposu e le el (TMREL).
Fo die , we es ima ed he disease bu den o die a y isks based
on he absolu e le el o in ake a he han he in ake
s anda dised o 2000 kcal pe day. We de eloped an ensemble
model o di e en pa ame ic dis ibu ions o gene a e be e
i s o he dis ibu ions o con inuous isk ac o s. Media ion
e idence was e iewed and upda ed based on an analysis o
en pooled coho s. We ha e expanded he analysis o
geog aphic and empo al ends in isk exposu e and bu den by
de elopmen , using he Socio-demog aphic Index (SDI), and
ha e also explo ed whe e coun ies a e in he isk ansi ion. We
also imp o ed and modi ied ou decomposi ion me hods so ha
he esul s shown a e addi i e and can be agg ega ed o explain
ends in all-cause and cause-speci ic mo ali y, as well as ends
ac oss age g oups. The decomposi ion analysis has been
ex ended o examine how isk ac o s ha e con ibu ed o ends
in all-cause mo ali y by age and sex as well as by cause.
Implica ions o all he a ailable e idence
Inc easingly de ailed unde s anding o he ends in isk
exposu e and he RRs o each isk-ou come pai p o ides
insigh s in o bo h he magni ude o heal h loss a ibu able o
isks and how modi ica ion o isk exposu e has con ibu ed o
heal h ends. This analysis shows a misma ch be ween he
po en ial o isk modi ica ion o imp o e heal h and he
ela i ely modes ole ha isk modi ica ion has played in he
pas gene a ion in imp o ing global heal h.
Global Heal h Me ics
www. helance .com Vol 390 Sep embe 16, 2017
1347
he Sys olic Blood P essu e In e en ion T ial (SPRINT)11
and Hea Ou comes P e en ion E alua ion-3 (HOPE-3)
ial,12 ha e also b ough a en ion o he di e ence be ween
a popula ion heal h pe spec i e on he quan i ica ion o
isks and he clinical ques ion o isk e e sibili y. The
CRA amewo k p o ides an impo an insigh in o he
ole o di e en isks in con ibu ing o le els o popula ion
heal h bu does no necessa ily p o ide all he in o ma ion
necessa y o guide indi idual clinical decision making.
The GBD 2016 CRA includes 84 isk ac o s and an
associa ed 481 isk-ou come pai s. In addi ion o new
da a and upda ed me hods, we ha e included i e new
isks in he GBD 2016 CRA. The s udy was unde aken
o 195 coun ies and e i o ies and p o ides es ima es
o exposu e and a ibu able dea hs and disabili y-
adjus ed li e-yea s (DALYs) o 1990 h ough o 2016. We
explo ed how isks change wi h de elopmen , measu ed
by he Socio-demog aphic Index (SDI), and also
decomposed changes in dea hs and DALYs in o he
con ibu ions o popula ion ageing, popula ion g ow h,
ends in isk exposu e, and all o he ac o s combined.
As wi h p e ious i e a ions o GBD, he GBD 2016 CRA
esul s p esen ed he e supe sede all p e iously published
GBD CRA es ima es.
Me hods
O e iew
The CRA concep ual amewo k was de eloped by Mu ay
and Lopez,13 who es ablished a causal web o hie a chically
o ganised isks o causes ha con ibu e o heal h
ou comes (me hod appendix; appendix 1 p 432), which
allows quan i ica ion o isks o causes a any le el in he
amewo k. In GBD 2016, as in p e ious i e a ions o
GBD, we e alua ed a se o beha iou al, en i onmen al,
and occupa ional, and me abolic isks, whe e isk-
ou come pai s we e included based on e idence ules
(appendix 1 p 344). These isks we e o ganised in o i e
hie a chical le els as desc ibed in appendix 1 (p 374). A
Le el 0, he GBD 2016 p o ides es ima es o all isk
ac o s combined, a Le el 1 he GBD 2016
p o ides es ima es o h ee g oups: en i onmen al and
occupa ional, me abolic, and beha io al isk ac o s. A
Le el 2, he e a e 17 isks, a Le el 3 he e a e 50 isks, and
a Le el 4 he e a e 67 isks, o a o al o 84 isks o
clus e s o isks. To da e, we ha e no quan i ied he
con ibu ion o o he classes o isk ac o s
(appendix 1 p 376); howe e , using an analysis o he
ela ion be ween isk exposu es and socio-demog aphic
de elopmen , measu ed wi h he use o SDI, we p o ide
some insigh s in o he po en ial magni ude o dis al
social, cul u al, and economic ac o s.
Two ypes o isk assessmen a e possible wi hin he
CRA amewo k: a ibu able bu den and a oidable
bu den.13 A ibu able bu den is he educ ion in cu en
disease bu den ha would ha e been possible i pas
popula ion exposu e had shi ed o an al e na i e o
coun e ac ual dis ibu ion o isk exposu e. A oidable
bu den is he po en ial educ ion in u u e disease bu den
ha could be achie ed by changing he cu en dis ibu ion
o exposu e o a coun e ac ual dis ibu ion o exposu e.
Mu ay and Lopez13 iden i ied ou ypes o coun e ac ual
exposu e dis ibu ions: heo e ical, plausible, easible, and
cos -e ec i e minimum isk. In GBD s udies, o da e and
in his s udy, we ocus on a ibu able bu den using he
heo e ical minimum isk exposu e le el, which is he
dis ibu ion o isk comp ising he le els o exposu e ha
minimise isk o each indi idual in he popula ion.
O e all, his analysis ollows he CRA me hods used in
GBD 2015.4 The me hods desc ibed in his s udy p o ide
a high-le el o e iew o he analy ical logic, ocusing on
a eas o no able change om he me hods used in GBD
2015, wi h de ails p o ided in appendix 1 (p 10). This
s udy complies wi h he Guidelines o Accu a e and
T anspa en Heal h Es ima es Repo ing (GATHER)
s a emen 14 (appendix 1 p 377).
Geog aphical uni s o analysis and yea s o es ima ion
In GBD 2016, loca ions a e a anged as a se o hie a chical
ca ego ies: se en supe - egions, 21 egions nes ed wi hin
he se en supe - egions, and 195 coun ies and e i o ies
nes ed in he 21 egions. Addi ionally, we p esen es ima es
a he subna ional le el o i e coun ies wi h a popula ion
g ea e han 200 million in 2016: B azil, China, India,
Indonesia, and he USA. We p oduced a comple e se o
age-speci ic, sex-speci ic, cause-speci ic, and loca ion-
speci ic es ima es o isk ac o exposu e and a ibu able
bu den o 1990–2016 o all included isk ac o s.
A ibu able bu den es ima ion
Fou key componen s a e included in es ima ion o he
bu den a ibu able o a gi en isk ac o : he me ic o
bu den being assessed (numbe o dea hs, yea s o li e los
[YLLs], yea s li ed wi h disabili y [YLDs], o DALYs [ he
sum o YLLs and YLDs]), he exposu e le els o a isk
ac o , he ela i e isk o a gi en ou come due o exposu e,
and he coun e ac ual le el o isk ac o exposu e.
Es ima es o a ibu able DALYs o a isk-ou come pai a e
equal o DALYs o he ou come mul iplied by he
popula ion a ibu able ac ion (PAF) o he isk-ou come
pai o a gi en age, sex, loca ion, and yea . A simila logic
applies o es ima ion o a ibu able dea hs, YLLs, o
YLDs. Risks a e ca ego ised on he basis o how exposu e
was measu ed: dicho omous, poly omous, o con inuous.
The PAF ep esen s he p opo ion o ou come ha would
be educed in a gi en yea i he exposu e o a isk ac o in
he pas we e educed o he coun e ac ual le el o he
heo e ical minimum isk exposu e le el (supplemen a y
esul s, appendix 2 p 1).
Causal e idence o isk-ou come pai s
In his s udy, as in GBD 2015, we ha e included isk-
ou come pai s ha we ha e assessed as mee ing he
Wo ld Cance Resea ch Fund g ades o con incing o
p obable e idence (see appendix 1 p 10 o de ini ions o
See Online o appendix 1
See Online o appendix 2
Global Heal h Me ics
1348
www. helance .com Vol 390 Sep embe 16, 2017
hese g ades).15 Table 1 p o ides a summa y o he
e idence suppo ing a causal ela ion be ween a isk and
an ou come o each pai included in GBD 2016. Fo
each isk-ou come pai , we used ecen sys ema ic
e iews o iden i y independen p ospec i e s udies
( andomised con olled ials, non- andomised
in e en ions, and coho s) ha e alua ed he pu a i e
ela ionship. Fo isk-ou come pai s wi h ewe han i e
p ospec i e s udies, we e alua ed e idence om case-
con ol s udies as well (appendix 1 p 344). Table 1
summa ises he e idence using mul iple dimensions,
which suppo s ou assessmen ha each included isk-
ou come pai mee s he c i e ia o con incing o
p obable e idence (appendix 1 p 10 con ains a
jus i ica ion o he c i e ia p esen ed o suppo
causali y). In his summa y o e idence, we ha e ocused
on andomised con olled ials and p ospec i e
obse a ional s udies, along wi h suppo ing e idence,
like dose– esponse ela ionships and biologically
plausible mechanisms.
Es ima ion p ocess
In o ma ion abou he da a sou ces, es ima ion me hods,
compu a ional ools, and s a is ical analysis used in he
de i a ion o ou es ima es a e p o ided in appendix 1
(p 10). The analy ical s eps o es ima ion o bu den
a ibu able o single o clus e s o isk-ou come pai s a e
summa ised in appendix 1 (p 10). Table 2 p o ides
de ini ions o exposu e o each isk ac o , he heo e ical
minimum isk exposu e le el (TMREL) used, and me ics
o da a a ailabili y. Fo each isk, we es ima ed e ec size
as a unc ion o age and sex and exposu e le el, mean
exposu e, he dis ibu ion o exposu e ac oss indi iduals,
and he TMREL. The app oach aken is la gely simila o
GBD 2015 o each quan i y o each isk. Some
me hodological imp o emen s ha e been implemen ed
and new da a sou ces inco po a ed. Appendix 1 (p 34)
p o ides de ails o each s ep by isk. Ci a ion in o ma ion
o he da a sou ces used o ela i e isks a e p o ided in
sea chable o m h ough an online sou ce ool.
All poin es ima es a e epo ed wi h 95% unce ain y
in e als (UIs). UIs include unce ain y om each
ele an componen , consis ing o exposu e, ela i e
isks, TMREL, and bu den a es. Whe e pe cen age
change is epo ed (wi h 95% UIs), we compu ed i on
he basis o he poin es ima es being compa ed.
In GBD 2015, we p oduced a summa y measu e o
exposu e o each isk, called he summa y exposu e
alue (SEV), which is a me ic ha cap u es isk-weigh ed
exposu e o a popula ion, o isk-weigh ed p e alence o
an exposu e. The scale o SEV spans om 0% o 100%,
such ha an SEV o 0% e lec s no isk exposu e in a
popula ion and 100% indica es ha an en i e popula ion
is exposu e o he maximum possible le el o ha isk.
In GBD 2016, we show es ima es o SEVs o each isk
ac o and p o ide de ails on how SEVs a e compu ed o
ca ego ical and con inuous isks in appendix 1 (p 10).
Fi ing a dis ibu ion o exposu e da a
The mos in o ma i e da a desc ibing he dis ibu ion o
isk ac o s wi hin a popula ion come om indi idual-le el
da a; addi ional sou ces o da a include epo ed means
and a iances. In cases when a isk ac o also de ines a
disease, such as haemoglobin le el and anaemia, he
p e alence o disease is also equen ly epo ed. To model
he dis ibu ion o any pa icula isk ac o , we seek a
amily o p obabili y densi y unc ions (PDFs), a i ing
me hod, and a model selec ion c i e ion. To make use o
he mos da a desc ibing mos popula ions, we used he
me hod o momen s (MoM); he i s wo empi ical
momen s om a popula ion, he mean and a iance, we e
used o de e mine he PDF desc ibing he dis ibu ion o
isk wi hin any popula ion, whe e excep ions o his ule
a e jus i ied by con ex . We used he Kolmogo o -Smi no
es o measu e he goodness o i (GoF), bu in some
cases, he GoF was based on he p edic ion e o o he
p e alence o disease.
We used an ensemble echnique in which a model
selec ion algo i hm is used o choose he bes model o
each isk ac o .16 We d ew he ini ial se o candida e
models om commonly used PDF amilies. We i ed each
PDF candida e amily o each da ase using he MoM, and
used he Kolmogo o -Smi no es 17 as he measu e o GoF.
P elimina y analysis showed ha he GoF anking o PDF
amilies a ied ac oss da ase s o any pa icula isk ac o
and ha combining he p edic ions o di e en ly i ed
PDF amilies could d ama ically imp o e he GoF o each
da ase . The e o e, we de eloped a new model o p edic ion
using he ensemble o candida e models, which is a
weigh ed linea combina ion o all candida e models, { },
whe e a se o weigh s {w} is chosen such ha i is he sum
o he weigh s equals o one and he alues o he weigh s
we e de e mined by a second GoF c i e ion wi h i s own
alida ion p ocess. Because o basic di e ences among isk
ac o s, hei dis ibu ions, and he isk a ibu ion p ocess,
he model selec ion p ocess was o en sligh ly di e en o
each isk ac o . The de ails can be summa ised by (1) he
summa y s a is ics o each da ase ; (2) a able showing he
Kolmogo o -Smi no s a is ic o each candida e model
and URD; (3) he c i e ion used o de e mining he o e all
GoF; (4) summa y esul s o he alida ion p ocess; and (5)
he weigh s de ining he inal ensemble model o each
da ase .
New isks and isks wi h signi ican changes in he
es ima ion me hods compa ed wi h GBD 2015
We ook se e al s eps o imp o e he es ima ion o alcohol
use as a isk ac o . Fi s , on he exposu e side, we added
26 su ey se ies, which con ibu ed 12 195 da apoin s in
ou models. Second, we de eloped and implemen ed a
me hod ha adjus s o al consump ion o ou ism and
un eco ded consump ion o each loca ion-yea . Thi d,
we calcula ed he TMREL. We chose TMREL as being he
exposu e ha minimises an indi idual’s isk o su e ing
bu den om any gi en cause ela ed o alcohol
Fo he ool see
h p://ghdx.heal hda a.o g/
Global Heal h Me ics
www. helance .com Vol 390 Sep embe 16, 2017
1349
Risk Ou come RCTs
(n)
RCTs wi h
signi ican
e ec in
he
opposi e
di ec ion
(%)
RCTs
wi h null
indings
(%)
P ospec i e
obse a ional
s udies (n)*
P ospec i e
obse a ional
s udies wi h
signi ican
associa ion in
he opposi e
di ec ion (%)
Case-con ol
s udies
assessing
he isk-
ou come
pai
ela ionship
(n)†
Case-con ol
s udies ha
show
signi ican
associa ion
in he
opposi e
di ec ion (%)
Lowe
limi
o RR
>1·5
Dose–
esponse
ela ionship
Biological
plausibili y
‡
Analogy§
2 Unsa e wa e , sani a ion, and handwashing
3Unsa e wa e
sou ce– chlo ina ion
o sola (poin o use
ea men )
Dia hoeal
diseases
24 0 42 6 0 ·· ·· Yes ·· Yes No
3Unsa e wa e
sou ce–piped
Dia hoeal
diseases
1 0 0 9 11 ·· ·· Yes ·· Yes No
3Unsa e wa e
sou ce– il e
Dia hoeal
diseases
11 0 45 2 0 ·· ·· Yes ·· Yes No
3Unsa e wa e
sou ce– imp o ed
wa e
Dia hoeal
diseases
0 ·· ·· 5 0 ·· ·· Yes ·· Yes No
3 Unsa e sani a ion–
piped
Dia hoeal
diseases
0 ·· ·· 7 0 ·· ·· Yes ·· Yes No
3 Unsa e sani a ion–
imp o ed sani a ion
Dia hoeal
diseases
0 ·· ·· 9 0 ·· ·· Yes ·· Yes No
3No access o
handwashing acili y
Dia hoeal
diseases
19 0 42 0 ·· ·· ·· No ·· Yes No
3No access o
handwashing acili y
Lowe
espi a o y
in ec ions
8 0 50 11 0 ·· ·· No ·· Yes No
2 Ai pollu ion
3 Ambien pa icula e
ma e pollu ion
Lowe
espi a o y
in ec ions
0 ·· ·· 19 0 ·· ·· No Yes Yes No
3 Ambien pa icula e
ma e pollu ion
T acheal,
b onchus, and
lung cance
0 ·· ·· 27 0 ·· ·· No Yes Yes Yes
3 Ambien pa icula e
ma e pollu ion
Ischaemic hea
disease
0 ·· ·· 16 0 ·· ·· No Yes Yes Yes
3 Ambien pa icula e
ma e pollu ion
Ischaemic s oke 0 ·· ·· 25 0 ·· ·· No Yes Yes Yes
3 Ambien pa icula e
ma e pollu ion
Haemo hagic
s oke
0 ·· ·· 25 0 ·· ·· No Yes Yes Yes
3 Ambien pa icula e
ma e pollu ion
Ch onic
obs uc i e
pulmona y
disease
0 ·· ·· 12 0 ·· ·· No Yes Yes Yes
3 Household ai
pollu ion om solid
uels
Lowe
espi a o y
in ec ions
0 ·· ·· 0 ·· 9 0 No Yes Yes No
3 Household ai
pollu ion om solid
uels
T acheal,
b onchus, and
lung cance
0 ·· ·· 0 ·· 20 0 No Yes Yes Yes
3 Household ai
pollu ion om solid
uels
Ischaemic hea
disease
0 ·· ·· 16 0 ·· ·· No Yes Yes Yes
3 Household ai
pollu ion om solid
uels
Ischaemic s oke 0 ·· ·· 25 0 ·· ·· No Yes Yes Yes
3 Household ai
pollu ion om solid
uels
Haemo hagic
s oke
0 ·· ·· 25 0 ·· ·· No Yes Yes Yes
(Table 1 con inues on nex page)
Global Heal h Me ics
1350
www. helance .com Vol 390 Sep embe 16, 2017
Risk Ou come RCTs
(n)
RCTs wi h
signi ican
e ec in
he
opposi e
di ec ion
(%)
RCTs
wi h null
indings
(%)
P ospec i e
obse a ional
s udies (n)*
P ospec i e
obse a ional
s udies wi h
signi ican
associa ion in
he opposi e
di ec ion (%)
Case-con ol
s udies
assessing
he isk-
ou come
pai
ela ionship
(n)†
Case-con ol
s udies ha
show
signi ican
associa ion
in he
opposi e
di ec ion (%)
Lowe
limi
o RR
>1·5
Dose–
esponse
ela ionship
Biological
plausibili y
‡
Analogy§
(Con inued om p e ious page)
3 Household ai
pollu ion om solid
uels
Ch onic
obs uc i e
pulmona y
disease
0 ·· ·· 0 ·· 2 0 No Yes Yes Yes
3 Household ai
pollu ion om solid
uels
Ca a ac 0 ·· ·· 0 ·· 11 0 No Yes Yes No
3Ambien ozone
pollu ion
Ch onic
obs uc i e
pulmona y
disease
0 ·· ·· 4 0 0 0 No Yes Yes No
2 O he en i onmen al isks
3 Residen ial adon T acheal,
b onchus, and
lung cance
0 ·· ·· 1 0 29 0 No Yes Yes No
3 Lead exposu e Idiopa hic
de elopmen al
in ellec ual
disabili y
0 ·· ·· 8 0 ·· ·· No Yes Yes No
3 Lead exposu e Sys olic blood
p essu e
0 ·· ·· 3 0 1 0 No Yes Yes No
2 Occupa ional isks
4 Occupa ional
exposu e o asbes os
La ynx cance 0 ·· ·· 27 0 ·· ·· No ·· Yes Yes
4 Occupa ional
exposu e o asbes os
T acheal,
b onchus, and
lung cance
0 ·· ·· 18 0 ·· ·· Yes ·· Yes Yes
4 Occupa ional
exposu e o asbes os
O a ian cance 0 ·· ·· 15 0 ·· ·· No ·· Yes Yes
4 Occupa ional
exposu e o asbes os
Meso helioma 0 ·· ·· 5 0 ·· ·· Yes ·· Yes Yes
4 Occupa ional
exposu e o a senic
T acheal,
b onchus, and
lung cance
0 ·· ·· 9 0 ·· ·· No ·· Yes No
4 Occupa ional
exposu e o benzene
Leukaemia 0 ·· ·· 12 0 ·· ·· Yes ·· Yes No
4 Occupa ional
exposu e o
be yllium
T acheal,
b onchus, and
lung cance
0 ·· ·· 3 0 2 0 No ·· Yes No
4 Occupa ional
exposu e o
cadmium
T acheal,
b onchus, and
lung cance
0 ·· ·· 7 0 ·· ·· No ·· Yes No
4 Occupa ional
exposu e o
ch omium
T acheal,
b onchus, and
lung cance
0 ·· ·· 26 0 ·· ·· No ·· Yes No
4 Occupa ional
exposu e o diesel
engine exhaus
T acheal,
b onchus, and
lung cance
0 ·· ·· 17 0 ·· ·· No ·· Yes No
4 Occupa ional
exposu e o second-
hand smoke
T acheal,
b onchus, and
lung cance
0 ·· ·· 25 0 ·· ·· No ·· Yes No
4 Occupa ional
exposu e o
o maldehyde
Nasopha ynx
cance
0 ·· ·· 2 0 6 0 No ·· Yes Yes
(Table 1 con inues on nex page)
Global Heal h Me ics
www. helance .com Vol 390 Sep embe 16, 2017
1351
Risk Ou come RCTs
(n)
RCTs wi h
signi ican
e ec in
he
opposi e
di ec ion
(%)
RCTs
wi h null
indings
(%)
P ospec i e
obse a ional
s udies (n)*
P ospec i e
obse a ional
s udies wi h
signi ican
associa ion in
he opposi e
di ec ion (%)
Case-con ol
s udies
assessing
he isk-
ou come
pai
ela ionship
(n)†
Case-con ol
s udies ha
show
signi ican
associa ion
in he
opposi e
di ec ion (%)
Lowe
limi
o RR
>1·5
Dose–
esponse
ela ionship
Biological
plausibili y
‡
Analogy§
(Con inued om p e ious page)
4 Occupa ional
exposu e o
o maldehyde
Leukaemia 0 ·· ·· 13 0 ·· ·· No ·· Yes Yes
4 Occupa ional
exposu e o nickel
T acheal,
b onchus, and
lung cance
0 ·· ·· 6 0 ·· ·· No ·· Yes No
4 Occupa ional
exposu e o
polycyclic a oma ic
hyd oca bons
T acheal,
b onchus, and
lung cance
0 ·· ·· 39 0 ·· ·· No ·· Yes No
4 Occupa ional
exposu e o silica
T acheal,
b onchus, and
lung cance
0 ·· ·· 17 0 ·· ·· No ·· Yes No
4 Occupa ional
exposu e o sul u ic
acid
La ynx cance 0 ·· ·· 14 0 ·· ·· Yes ·· Yes No
4 Occupa ional
exposu e o
ichlo oe hylene
Kidney cance 0 ·· ·· 20 0 ·· ·· No ·· Yes No
3 Occupa ional
as hmagens
As hma 0 ·· ·· 16 0 ·· ·· No ·· Yes No
3 Occupa ional
pa icula e ma e ,
gases, and umes
Ch onic
obs uc i e
pulmona y
disease
0 ·· ·· 9 0 ·· ·· No ·· Yes No
3 Occupa ional noise Age- ela ed and
o he hea ing
loss
0 ·· ·· 5 0 ·· ·· Yes ·· Yes No
3 Occupa ional
e gonomic ac o s
Low back pain 0 ·· ·· 10 0 ·· ·· No ·· Yes No
2 Child and ma e nal malnu i ion
4 Non-exclusi e
b eas eeding
Dia hoeal
diseases
0 ·· ·· 5 0 ·· ·· Yes ·· Yes No
4 Non-exclusi e
b eas eeding
Lowe
espi a o y
in ec ions
0 ·· ·· 6 0 ·· ·· Yes ·· Yes No
4 Discon inued
b eas eeding
Dia hoeal
diseases
0 ·· ·· 2 0 ·· ·· No ·· Yes No
4Child unde weigh Dia hoeal
diseases
0 ·· ·· 7 0 ·· ·· Yes ·· Yes No
4Child unde weigh Lowe
espi a o y
in ec ions
0 ·· ·· 7 0 ·· ·· Yes ·· Yes No
4Child unde weigh Measles 0 ·· ·· 7 0 ·· ·· Yes ·· Yes No
4Child was ing Dia hoeal
diseases
0 ·· ·· 7 0 ·· ·· Yes ·· Yes No
4Child was ing Lowe
espi a o y
in ec ions
0 ·· ·· 7 0 ·· ·· Yes ·· Yes No
4Child was ing Measles 0 ·· ·· 7 0 ·· ·· Yes ·· Yes No
4 Child s un ing Dia hoeal
diseases
0 ·· ·· 7 0 ·· ·· No ·· Yes No
(Table 1 con inues on nex page)
Global Heal h Me ics
1352
www. helance .com Vol 390 Sep embe 16, 2017
Risk Ou come RCTs
(n)
RCTs wi h
signi ican
e ec in
he
opposi e
di ec ion
(%)
RCTs
wi h null
indings
(%)
P ospec i e
obse a ional
s udies (n)*
P ospec i e
obse a ional
s udies wi h
signi ican
associa ion in
he opposi e
di ec ion (%)
Case-con ol
s udies
assessing
he isk-
ou come
pai
ela ionship
(n)†
Case-con ol
s udies ha
show
signi ican
associa ion
in he
opposi e
di ec ion (%)
Lowe
limi
o RR
>1·5
Dose–
esponse
ela ionship
Biological
plausibili y
‡
Analogy§
(Con inued om p e ious page)
4 Child s un ing Lowe
espi a o y
in ec ions
0 ·· ·· 7 0 ·· ·· No ·· Yes No
4 Child s un ing Measles 0 ·· ·· 7 0 ·· ·· No ·· Yes No
4 Sho ges a ion o
bi hweigh
Dia hoeal
diseases
0 ·· ·· 20 0 ·· ·· Yes Yes Yes Yes
4 Sho ges a ion o
bi hweigh
Lowe
espi a o y
in ec ions
0 ·· ·· 20 0 ·· ·· Yes Yes Yes Yes
4 Sho ges a ion o
bi hweigh
Uppe
espi a o y
in ec ions
0 ·· ·· 20 0 ·· ·· Yes Yes Yes Yes
4 Sho ges a ion o
bi hweigh
O i is media 0 ·· ·· 20 0 ·· ·· Yes Yes Yes Yes
4 Sho ges a ion o
bi hweigh
Pneumococcal
meningi is
0 ·· ·· 20 0 ·· ·· Yes Yes Yes Yes
4 Sho ges a ion o
bi hweigh
Haemophilus
in luenzae ype B
meningi is
0 ·· ·· 20 0 ·· ·· Yes Yes Yes Yes
4 Sho ges a ion o
bi hweigh
Meningococcal
in ec ion
0 ·· ·· 20 0 ·· ·· Yes Yes Yes Yes
4 Sho ges a ion o
bi hweigh
O he meningi is 0 ·· ·· 20 0 ·· ·· Yes Yes Yes Yes
4 Sho ges a ion o
bi hweigh
Encephali is 0 ·· ·· 20 0 ·· ·· Yes Yes Yes Yes
4 Sho ges a ion o
bi hweigh
Neona al
p e e m bi h
complica ions
0 ·· ·· 20 0 ·· ·· Yes Yes Yes Yes
4 Sho ges a ion o
bi hweigh
Neona al
encephalopa hy
due o bi h
asphyxia and
auma
0 ·· ·· 20 0 ·· ·· Yes Yes Yes Yes
4 Sho ges a ion o
bi hweigh
Neona al sepsis
and o he
neona al
in ec ions
0 ·· ·· 20 0 ·· ·· Yes Yes Yes Yes
4 Sho ges a ion o
bi hweigh
Haemoly ic
disease and
o he neona al
jaundice
0 ·· ·· 20 0 ·· ·· Yes Yes Yes Yes
4 Sho ges a ion o
bi hweigh
O he neona al
diso de s
0 ·· ·· 20 0 ·· ·· Yes Yes Yes Yes
4 Sho ges a ion o
bi hweigh
Sudden in an
dea h synd ome
0 ·· ·· 20 0 ·· ·· Yes Yes Yes Yes
4 Low bi hweigh o
ges a ion
Dia hoeal
diseases
0 ·· ·· 20 0 ·· ·· Yes Yes Yes Yes
4 Low bi hweigh o
ges a ion
Lowe
espi a o y
in ec ions
0 ·· ·· 20 0 ·· ·· Yes Yes Yes Yes
4 Low bi hweigh o
ges a ion
Uppe
espi a o y
in ec ions
0 ·· ·· 20 0 ·· ·· Yes Yes Yes Yes
(Table 1 con inues on nex page)
Global Heal h Me ics
www. helance .com Vol 390 Sep embe 16, 2017
1353
Risk Ou come RCTs
(n)
RCTs wi h
signi ican
e ec in
he
opposi e
di ec ion
(%)
RCTs
wi h null
indings
(%)
P ospec i e
obse a ional
s udies (n)*
P ospec i e
obse a ional
s udies wi h
signi ican
associa ion in
he opposi e
di ec ion (%)
Case-con ol
s udies
assessing
he isk-
ou come
pai
ela ionship
(n)†
Case-con ol
s udies ha
show
signi ican
associa ion
in he
opposi e
di ec ion (%)
Lowe
limi
o RR
>1·5
Dose–
esponse
ela ionship
Biological
plausibili y
‡
Analogy§
(Con inued om p e ious page)
4 Low bi hweigh o
ges a ion
O i is media 0 ·· ·· 20 0 ·· ·· Yes Yes Yes Yes
4 Low bi hweigh o
ges a ion
Pneumococcal
meningi is
0 ·· ·· 20 0 ·· ·· Yes Yes Yes Yes
4 Low bi hweigh o
ges a ion
Haemophilus
in luenzae ype B
meningi is
0 ·· ·· 20 0 ·· ·· Yes Yes Yes Yes
4 Low bi hweigh o
ges a ion
Meningococcal
in ec ion
0 ·· ·· 20 0 ·· ·· Yes Yes Yes Yes
4 Low bi hweigh o
ges a ion
O he meningi is 0 ·· ·· 20 0 ·· ·· Yes Yes Yes Yes
4 Low bi hweigh o
ges a ion
Encephali is 0 ·· ·· 20 0 ·· ·· Yes Yes Yes Yes
4 Low bi hweigh o
ges a ion
Neona al
p e e m bi h
complica ions
0 ·· ·· 20 0 ·· ·· Yes Yes Yes Yes
4 Low bi hweigh o
ges a ion
Neona al
encephalopa hy
due o bi h
asphyxia and
auma
0 ·· ·· 20 0 ·· ·· Yes Yes Yes Yes
4 Low bi hweigh o
ges a ion
Neona al sepsis
and o he
neona al
in ec ions
0 ·· ·· 20 0 ·· ·· Yes Yes Yes Yes
4 Low bi hweigh o
ges a ion
Haemoly ic
disease and
o he neona al
jaundice
0 ·· ·· 20 0 ·· ·· Yes Yes Yes Yes
4 Low bi hweigh o
ges a ion
O he neona al
diso de s
0 ·· ·· 20 0 ·· ·· Yes Yes Yes Yes
4 Low bi hweigh o
ges a ion
Sudden in an
dea h synd ome
0 ·· ·· 20 0 ·· ·· Yes Yes Yes Yes
3Vi amin A de iciency Dia hoeal
diseases
19 0 63 0 ·· ·· ·· No ·· Yes No
3Vi amin A de iciency Measles 12 0 83 0 ·· ·· ·· Yes ·· Yes No
3Zinc de iciency Dia hoeal
diseases
14 0 29 0 ·· ·· ·· No ·· Yes No
3Zinc de iciency Lowe
espi a o y
in ec ions
6 0 17 0 ·· ·· ·· No ·· Yes No
2 Tobacco
3 Smoking Tube culosis 0 ·· ·· 4 0 10 0 No ·· Yes Yes
3 Smoking Lip and o al
ca i y cance
0 ·· ·· 5 0 ·· ·· Yes ·· Yes Yes
3 Smoking Nasopha ynx
cance
0 ·· ·· 4 0 28 0 Yes ·· Yes Yes
3 Smoking Oesophageal
cance
0 ·· ·· 5 0 ·· ·· Yes ·· Yes Yes
3 Smoking Colon and
ec um cance
0 ·· ·· 19 0 ·· ·· No ·· Yes Yes
3 Smoking Li e cance 0 ·· ·· 54 0 ·· ·· Yes ·· Yes Yes
3 Smoking Gas ic cance 0 ·· ·· 19 0 ·· ·· No ·· Yes Yes
(Table 1 con inues on nex page)
Global Heal h Me ics
1360
www. helance .com Vol 390 Sep embe 16, 2017
(appendix1 p 22 o mo e de ail). Fou h, we pe o med a
sys ema ic e iew o all coho and case-con ol s udies
epo ing a RR, haza d a io, o odds a io o any isk-
ou come pai s s udied in GBD 2016 and hen modelled a
dose- esponse ela ionship using DisMod o dina y
di e en ial equa ions (ODE).18 Fi h, we es ima ed inju y
PAFs om coho s udies and adjus ed hem o accoun
o ic ims.
Risk Ou come RCTs
(n)
RCTs wi h
signi ican
e ec in
he
opposi e
di ec ion
(%)
RCTs
wi h null
indings
(%)
P ospec i e
obse a ional
s udies (n)*
P ospec i e
obse a ional
s udies wi h
signi ican
associa ion in
he opposi e
di ec ion (%)
Case-con ol
s udies
assessing
he isk-
ou come
pai
ela ionship
(n)†
Case-con ol
s udies ha
show
signi ican
associa ion
in he
opposi e
di ec ion (%)
Lowe
limi
o RR
>1·5
Dose–
esponse
ela ionship
Biological
plausibili y
‡
Analogy§
(Con inued om p e ious page)
2 High body-mass
index (adul )
Ischaemic s oke 0 ·· ·· 102 ·· ·· ·· No Yes Yes Yes
2 High body-mass
index (adul )
Haemo hagic
s oke
0 ·· ·· 129 ·· ·· ·· No Yes Yes Yes
2 High body-mass
index (adul )
Hype ensi e
hea disease
0 ·· ·· 85 ·· ·· ·· No Yes Yes Yes
2 High body-mass
index (adul )
A ial ib illa ion
and lu e
0 ·· ·· 5 0 ·· ·· ·· No Yes Yes
2 High body-mass
index (adul )
As hma 0 ·· ·· 7 0 ·· ·· ·· Yes Yes No
2 High body-mass
index (adul )
Alzheime ’s
disease and
o he demen ias
0 ·· ·· 6 0 ·· ·· ·· No Yes No
2 High body-mass
index (adul )
Gallbladde
disease
0 ·· ·· 16 0 ·· ·· ·· Yes Yes Yes
2 High body-mass
index (adul )
Diabe es
melli us
0 ·· ·· 85 .. ·· ·· Yes Yes Yes No
2 High body-mass
index (adul )
Ch onic kidney
disease
0 ·· ·· 57 ·· ·· ·· No Yes Yes No
2 High body-mass
index (adul )
Os eoa h i is 0 ·· ·· 32 0 ·· ·· No Yes Yes Yes
2 High body-mass
index (adul )
Low back pain 0 ·· ·· 5 0 ·· ·· No Yes Yes Yes
2 High body-mass
index (adul )
Gou 0 ·· ·· 10 0 ·· ·· .. Yes Yes No
2 High body-mass
index (adul )
Ca a ac 0 ·· ·· 17 0 ·· ·· .. Yes Yes No
2 High body-mass
index (child)
As hma 0 ·· ·· 5 0 ·· ·· No Yes Yes No
2 Low bone mine al
densi y
Inju ies 0 ·· ·· 12 .. ·· ·· No Yes Yes Yes
2 Impai ed kidney
unc ion
Ischaemic hea
disease
0 ·· ·· 6 0 ·· ·· Yes ·· Yes Yes
2 Impai ed kidney
unc ion
Ischaemic s oke 0 ·· ·· 6 0 ·· ·· Yes ·· Yes Yes
2 Impai ed kidney
unc ion
Haemo hagic
s oke
0 ·· ·· 8 0 ·· ·· Yes ·· Yes Yes
2 Impai ed kidney
unc ion
Pe iphe al
ascula disease
0 ·· ·· 5 0 ·· ·· Yes ·· Yes Yes
2 Impai ed kidney
unc ion
Gou 0 ·· ·· 3 0 0 0 Yes ·· Yes No
I mul iple epo s exis ed om he same s udy, we coun ed hem as one s udy. We only assessed he dose– esponse ela ionship o con inuous isks. To e alua e he magni ude o he e ec size o con inuous
isks, we e alua ed he ela i e isk compa ing he 75 h pe cen ile wi h he 25 h pe cen ile o he exposu e dis ibu ion a he global le el. RCT= andomised con olled ial. RR= ela i e isk. *P ospec i e coho
s udies o non- andomised in e en ions. †Case-con ol s udies we e included o hose isk-ou come pai s whe e he sum o RCT and p ospec i e obse a ional s udies included was less han i e (whe e
applicable). ‡Whe he o no any biological o mechanis ic pa hway exis s ha could po en ially explain he ela ionship o he isk-ou come pai . §Whe he o no he isk is associa ed wi h ano he ou come
om he same ca ego y and whe he o no any e idence exis s ha i can cause he cu en ou come h ough he same pa hway.
Table 1: Desc ip i e ca aloguing o he epidemiological e idence used o assess whe he each isk-ou come pape mee s he causal c i e ia o inclusion in he Global Bu den o Disease
S udy 2016 by isk le el
Global Heal h Me ics
www. helance .com Vol 390 Sep embe 16, 2017
1361
Risk ac o s Exposu e de ini ion Theo e ical minimum isk exposu e
le el
Da a ep esen a i eness index
<2006 2006–16 To al
0 All ·· ·· 100·0% 100·0% 100·0%
1 En i onmen al and
occupa ional isks
·· ·· 100·0% 100·0% 100·0%
2Unsa e wa e , sani a ion,
and handwashing
·· ·· 58·0% 75·4% 70·0%
3Unsa e wa e sou ce P opo ion o households wi h access o di e en wa e sou ces
(unimp o ed, imp o ed excep piped, piped wa e supply) and
epo ed use o household wa e ea men me hods (boiling o
il e ing, chlo ina ing o sola il e ing, no ea men )
All households ha e access o wa e om
a piped wa e supply ha is also boiled o
il e ed be o e d inking
70·1% 88·4% 83·5%
3 Unsa e sani a ion P opo ion o households wi h access o di e en sani a ion
acili ies (unimp o ed, imp o ed excep sewe , sewe connec ion)
All households ha e access o oile s wi h
sewe connec ion
69·5% 88·4% 83·5%
3 No access o handwashing
acili y
P opo ion o households wi h access o handwashing acili y wi h
soap, wa e , and wash s a ion
All households ha e access o
handwashing acili y wi h soap, wa e ,
and wash s a ion
10·3% 33·3% 35·4%
2 Ai pollu ion ·· ·· 100·0% 100·0% 100·0%
3 Ambien pa icula e ma e
pollu ion
Annual a e age daily exposu e o ou doo ai concen a ions o
PM2·5
Uni o m dis ibu ion be ween 2·4 µg/m³
and 5·9 µg/m³
23·1% 56·9% 78·0%
3 Household ai pollu ion om
solid uels
Indi idual exposu e o PM2·5 due o use o solid cooking uels No households a e exposed o excess
indoo concen a ion o pa icles om
solid uel use (assuming PM2·5 in no uel
use is consis en wi h a TMREL o 2·4–5·9)
72·8% 59·5% 76·4%
3Ambien ozone pollu ion Seasonal (3 mon h) hou ly maximum ozone concen a ions,
measu ed in ppb
Uni o m dis ibu ion be ween 33·3 µg/m³
and 41·9 µg/m³, acco ding o
minimum/5 h pe cen concen a ions
100·0% 100·0% 100·0%
2 O he en i onmen al isks ·· ·· 48·7% 26·2% 51·8%
3 Residen ial adon A e age daily exposu e o indoo ai adon le els measu ed in
becque els ( adon disin eg a ions pe second) pe cubic me e (Bq/
m³)
10 Bq/m³, co esponding o he ou doo
concen a ion o adon
39·0% 0·0% 39·0%
3 Lead exposu e Blood lead le els in µg/dL o blood, bone lead le els in µg/g o
bone
2 ug/dL, co esponding o lead le els in
p e-indus ial humans as na u al sou ces
o lead p e en he easibili y o ze o
exposu e
37·4% 26·2% 43·6%
2 Occupa ional isks ·· ·· 92·3% 90·8% 100·0%
3 Occupa ional ca cinogens ·· ·· 86·7% 85·6% 92·8%
4Occupa ional exposu e o
asbes os
P opo ion o he popula ion wi h cumula i e exposu e o
asbes os
No occupa ional exposu e o asbes os 82·6% 74·9% 87·2%
4Occupa ional exposu e o
a senic
P opo ion o he popula ion e e exposed o a senic a wo k o
h ough hei occupa ion
No occupa ional exposu e o a senic 82·6% 74·9% 87·2%
4Occupa ional exposu e o
benzene
P opo ion o he popula ion e e exposed o benzene a wo k o
h ough hei occupa ion
No occupa ional exposu e o benzene 82·6% 74·9% 87·2%
4Occupa ional exposu e o
be yllium
P opo ion o he popula ion e e exposed o be yllium a wo k o
h ough hei occupa ion
No occupa ional exposu e o be yllium 82·6% 74·9% 87·2%
4Occupa ional exposu e o
cadmium
P opo ion o he popula ion e e exposed o cadmium a wo k o
h ough hei occupa ion
No occupa ional exposu e o cadmium 82·6% 74·9% 87·2%
4Occupa ional exposu e o
ch omium
P opo ion o he popula ion e e exposed o ch omium a wo k
o h ough hei occupa ion
No occupa ional exposu e o ch omium 82·6% 74·9% 87·2%
4Occupa ional exposu e o
diesel engine exhaus
P opo ion o he popula ion e e exposed o diesel engine
exhaus a wo k o h ough hei occupa ion
No occupa ional exposu e o diesel
engine exhaus
82·6% 74·9% 87·2%
4Occupa ional exposu e o
second-hand smoke
P opo ion o he popula ion e e exposed o second-hand smoke
a wo k o h ough hei occupa ion
No occupa ional exposu e o second-
hand smoke
82·6% 74·9% 87·2%
4Occupa ional exposu e o
o maldehyde
P opo ion o he popula ion e e exposed o o maldehyde a
wo k o h ough hei occupa ion
No occupa ional exposu e o
o maldehyde
82·6% 74·9% 87·2%
4Occupa ional exposu e o
nickel
P opo ion o he popula ion e e exposed o nickel a wo k o
h ough hei occupa ion
No occupa ional exposu e o nickel 82·6% 74·9% 87·2%
4Occupa ional exposu e o
polycyclic a oma ic
hyd oca bons
P opo ion o he popula ion e e exposed o polycyclic a oma ic
hyd oca bons a wo k o h ough hei occupa ion
No occupa ional exposu e o polycyclic
a oma ic hyd oca bons
82·6% 74·9% 87·2%
(Table 2 con inues on nex page)
Global Heal h Me ics
1362
www. helance .com Vol 390 Sep embe 16, 2017
Risk ac o s Exposu e de ini ion Theo e ical minimum isk exposu e
le el
Da a ep esen a i eness index
<2006 2006–16 To al
(Con inued om p e ious page)
4Occupa ional exposu e o
silica
P opo ion o he popula ion e e exposed o silica a wo k o
h ough hei occupa ion
No occupa ional exposu e o silica 82·6% 74·9% 87·2%
4Occupa ional exposu e o
sul u ic acid
P opo ion o he popula ion e e exposed o sul u ic acid a wo k
o h ough hei occupa ion
No occupa ional exposu e o sul u ic acid 80·5% 73·3% 85·1%
4Occupa ional exposu e o
ichlo oe hylene
P opo ion o he popula ion e e exposed o ichlo e hylene a
wo k o h ough hei occupa ion
No occupa ional exposu e o
ichlo oe hylene
80·5% 73·3% 85·1%
3 Occupa ional as hmagens P opo ion o he popula ion cu en ly exposed o as hmagens a
wo k o h ough hei occupa ion
Backg ound as hmagen exposu es 82·6% 74·9% 87·2%
3 Occupa ional pa icula e
ma e , gases, and umes
P opo ion o he popula ion e e exposed o pa icula es, gases,
o umes a wo k o h ough hei occupa ion
No occupa ional exposu e o pa icula es,
gases, o umes
83·6% 75·9% 88·2%
3 Occupa ional noise P opo ion o he popula ion e e exposed o noise g ea e han
85 dB a wo k o h ough hei occupa ion
Backg ound noise exposu e 83·6% 75·9% 88·2%
3 Occupa ional inju ies P opo ion o he popula ion a isk o inju ies ela ed o wo k o
h ough hei occupa ion
The a e o inju y dea hs pe
100 000 pe son-yea s is ze o
82·6% 75·4% 87·2%
3 Occupa ional e gonomic
ac o s
P opo ion o he popula ion who a e exposed o e gonomic isk
ac o s o low back pain a wo k o h ough hei occupa ion
All indi iduals ha e he e gonomic
ac o s o cle ical and ela ed wo ke s
82·6% 74·9% 87·2%
1 Beha iou al isks ·· ·· 100·0% 100·0% 100·0%
2 Child and ma e nal
malnu i ion
·· ·· 100·0% 100·0% 100·0%
3 Subop imal b eas eeding ·· ·· 67·1% 54·6% 73·9%
4 Non-exclusi e b eas eeding P opo ion o child en younge han 6 mon hs who ecei e
p edominan , pa ial, o no b eas eeding
All child en a e exclusi ely b eas ed o
i s 6 mon hs o li e
67·1% 54·6% 73·9%
4 Discon inued b eas eeding P opo ion o child en aged 6–23 mon hs who do no ecei e any
b eas milk
All child en con inue o ecei e
b eas milk un il 2 yea s o age
68·1% 65·3% 79·2%
3 Child g ow h ailu e ·· ·· 5·6% 0·0% 5·6%
4Child unde weigh P opo ion o child en less han –3 SD, –3 o –2 SD, and –2 o –1 SDs
o he WHO 2006 s anda d weigh - o -age cu e
All child en a e abo e –1 SD o WHO 2006
s anda d weigh - o -age cu e
77·4% 65·1% 81·0%
4Child was ing P opo ion o child en less han –3 SD, –3 o –2 SDs, and –2 o
–1 SD o he WHO 2006 s anda d weigh - o -leng h cu e
All child en a e abo e –1 SD o WHO 2006
s anda d weigh - o -heigh cu e
78·0% 66·2% 82·1%
4 Child s un ing P opo ion o child en less han –3 SD, –3 o –2 SD, and –2 o –1 SD
o he WHO 2006 s anda d heigh - o -age cu e
All child en a e abo e –1 SD o WHO 2006
s anda d heigh - o -age cu e
78·0% 66·2% 82·1%
3 Low bi hweigh and sho
ges a ion
·· ·· 3·6% 16·4% 18·0%
4 Sho ges a ion o
bi hweigh
P opo ion o bi hs occu ing in 2 week bands s a ing om
<24 weeks o 39–40 weeks
40–41 weeks ges a ion 3·6% 16·4% 18·0%
4 Low bi hweigh o
ges a ion
P opo ion o bi hs occu ing in 500 g ca ego ies s a ing om
<500 g o 4000–4499 g
4500–4999 g bi hweigh 3·6% 16·4% 18·0%
3I on de iciency Pe iphe al blood haemoglobin concen a ion in g/L Coun e ac ual haemoglobin
concen a ion in he abscence o i on
de iciency in g/L
81·5% 44·1% 85·1%
3Vi amin A de iciency P opo ion o child en aged 0–5 yea s wi h se um e inol
concen a ion <0·7 µmol/L
No childhood i amin A de iciency 54·9% 44·1% 56·4%
3Zinc de iciency P opo ion o he popula ion wi h inadequa e zinc in ake e sus
loss
No inadequa e zinc in ake 94·9% 93·3% 94·9%
2Tobacco ·· ·· 98·0% 100·0% 100·0%
3 Smoking Smoking Impac Ra io me hod: cumula i e exposu e o smoked
obacco p oduc s, p oxied by excess lung cance mo ali y; di ec
smoking: 5 yea lagged p opo ion o he popula ion who
cu en ly smoke daily
All indi iduals a e li elong non-smoke s 92·8% 96·9% 99·0%
3Smokeless obacco Cu en use o any smokeless obacco p oduc All indi iduals a e li elong non-use s o
smokeless obacco p oduc s
34·4% 70·8% 73·3%
3 Second-hand smoke A e age daily exposu e o ai pa icula e ma e in he home om
second-hand smoke wi h an ae odynamic diame e smalle han
2·5 µg, measu ed in µg/m3, among non-smoke s li ing wi h a
cu en daily smoke
No second-hand smoke exposu e 73·9% 67·7% 90·8%
2Alcohol and d ug use ·· ·· 54·9% 62·6% 79·0%
(Table 2 con inues on nex page)
Global Heal h Me ics
www. helance .com Vol 390 Sep embe 16, 2017
1363
Risk ac o s Exposu e de ini ion Theo e ical minimum isk exposu e
le el
Da a ep esen a i eness index
<2006 2006–16 To al
(Con inued om p e ious page)
3Alcohol use A e age daily alcohol consump ion o pu e alcohol (measu ed in g
pe day) in cu en d inke s who had consumed alcohol du ing he
pas 12 mon hs; binge d inking: p opo ion o he popula ion
epo ing binge consump ion o a leas 60 g o males and 48 g
o emales o pu e alcohol on a single occasion
No alcohol consump ion 52·3% 45·6% 69·7%
3D ug use P opo ion o he popula ion dependen upon opioids, cannabis,
cocaine, o amphe amines; p opo ion o he popula ion who
ha e e e injec ed d ugs
No d ug use 20·5% 37·4% 43·1%
2 Die a y isks ·· ·· 100·0% 100·0% 100·0%
3 Die low in ui s A e age daily consump ion o ui s ( esh, ozen, cooked,
canned, o d ied ui s, excluding ui juices and sal ed o pickled
ui s)
Consump ion o ui be ween 200 g and
300 g pe day
94·9% 94·9% 94·9%
3 Die low in ege ables A e age daily consump ion o ege ables ( esh, ozen, cooked,
canned, o d ied ege ables, excluding legumes and sal ed o
pickled ege ables, juices, nu s, and seeds, and s a chy ege ables
such as po a oes o co n)
Consump ion o ege ables be ween
290 g and 430 g pe day
100·0% 100·0% 100·0%
3 Die low in legumes A e age daily consump ion o legumes ( esh, ozen, cooked,
canned, o d ied legumes)
Consump ion o legumes be ween 50 g
and 70 g pe day
100·0% 100·0% 100·0%
3 Die low in whole g ains A e age daily consump ion o whole g ains (b an, ge m, and
endospe m in hei na u al p opo ion) om b eak as ce eals,
b ead, ice, pas a, biscui s, mu ins, o illas, pancakes, and o he
sou ces
Consump ion o whole g ains be ween
100 g and 150 g pe day
15·9% 13·9% 20·0%
3 Die low in nu s and seeds A e age daily consump ion o nu and seed oods Consump ion o nu s and seeds be ween
16 g and 25 g pe day
100·0% 100·0% 100·0%
3 Die low in milk A e age daily consump ion o milk including non- a , low- a , and
ull- a milk, excluding soy milk and o he plan de i a i es
Consump ion o milk be ween 350 g and
520 g pe day
100·0% 100·0% 100·0%
3 Die high in ed mea A e age daily consump ion o ed mea (bee , po k, lamb, and
goa bu excluding poul y, ish, eggs, and all p ocessed mea s)
Consump ion o ed mea be ween 18 g
and 27 g pe day
100·0% 100·0% 100·0%
3 Die high in p ocessed mea A e age daily consump ion o mea p ese ed by smoking, cu ing,
sal ing, o addi ion o chemical p ese a i es
Consump ion o p ocessed mea be ween
0 g and 4 g pe day
100·0% 100·0% 100·0%
3 Die high in suga -swee ened
be e ages
A e age daily consump ion o be e ages wi h ≥50 kcal pe 226·8 g
se ing, including ca bona ed be e ages, sodas, ene gy d inks,
ui d inks, bu excluding 100% ui and ege able juices
Consump ion o suga -swee ened
be e ages be ween 0 g and 5 g pe day
34·9% 30·3% 36·9%
3 Die low in ib e A e age daily in ake o ib e om all sou ces including ui s,
ege ables, g ains, legumes, and pulses
Consump ion o ib e be ween 19 g and
28 g pe day
100·0% 100·0% 100·0%
3 Die low in calcium A e age daily in ake o calcium om all sou ces, including milk,
yogu , and cheese
Consump ion o calcium be ween 1·00 g
and 1·50 g pe day
100·0% 100·0% 100·0%
3 Die low in sea ood omega 3
a y acids
A e age daily in ake o eicosapen aenoic acid and
docosahexaenoic acid
Consump ion o sea ood omega 3 a y
acids be ween 200 mg and 300 mg pe day
100·0% 100·0% 100·0%
3 Die low in polyunsa u a ed
a y acids
A e age daily in ake o omega 6 a y acids om all sou ces,
mainly liquid ege able oils, including soybean oil, co n oil, and
sa lowe oil
Consump ion o polyunsa u a ed a y
acids be ween 9% and 13% o o al daily
ene gy
96·9% 94·9% 96·9%
3 Die high in ans a y acids A e age daily in ake o ans a om all sou ces, mainly pa ially
hyd ogena ed ege able oils and uminan p oduc s
Consump ion o ans a y acids be ween
0% and 1% o o al daily ene gy
37·4% 38·5% 38·5%
3 Die high in sodium 24 h u ina y sodium measu ed in g pe day 24 h u ina y sodium be ween 1 g and 5 g
pe day
15·9% 21·5% 26·2%
2 Sexual abuse and iolence ·· ·· 68·2% 78·0% 87·2%
3 Childhood sexual abuse P opo ion o he popula ion e e ha ing had he expe ience o
in e cou se o o he con ac abuse (ie, ondling and o he sexual
ouching) when aged 15 yea s o younge , and he pe pe a o o
pa ne was mo e han 5 yea s olde han he ic im
No childhood sexual abuse 31·8% 18·5% 38·0%
3 In ima e pa ne iolence P opo ion o he popula ion who ha e e e expe ienced one o
mo e ac s o physical o sexual iolence by a p esen o o me
in ima e pa ne since age 15 yea s
No in ima e pa ne iolence 67·2% 76·4% 86·2%
2 Unsa e sex P opo ion o he popula ion wi h exposu e o sexual encoun e s
ha con ey he isk o disease
No exposu e o a disease agen h ough
sex
14·9% 51·3% 51·8%
2 Low physical ac i i y A e age weekly physical ac i i y a wo k, home, anspo - ela ed,
and ec ea ional measu ed by MET min pe week
All adul s expe ience 3000–4500 MET
min pe week
52·3% 35·9% 67·2%
(Table 2 con inues on nex page)
Global Heal h Me ics
1364
www. helance .com Vol 390 Sep embe 16, 2017
We made se e al imp o emen s in he p ocess o
es ima ing he bu den o disease a ibu able o die a y
isks. To imp o e he quali y and co e age o ou die a y
es ima es, we sys ema ically sea ched li e a u e o
na ionally o subna ionally ep esen a i e s udies p o-
iding in o ma ion on consump ion o each die a y ac o .
We also made a sys ema ic e o o ob ain indi idual-le el
da a o consump ion o die a y ac o s; e-ex ac ed da a
om all a ailable sou ces; and s anda dised he de ini ion
o die a y ac o s ac oss di e en sou ces. To cap u e
ecen ends in consump ion, we used da a on sales o
di e en esh and packaged oods o in o m ou es ima es.
To add ess he conce ns o e wi hin-pe son a ia ion in
in ake, we es ima ed usual in ake o each die a y ac o and
used ha o es ima e he a ibu able disease bu den. To
make he cu en and op imal le els o in ake mo e
compa able, we used absolu e in ake o each die a y ac o
( a he han in ake s anda dised o 2000 kcal pe day). Fo
mo e de ail, see appendix 1 (p 117).
The e we e wo subs an ial changes in he es ima ion o
second-hand smoke compa ed wi h GBD 2015. Fi s , we
es ima ed he p opo ion o a popula ion exposed o second-
hand smoke using in o ma ion abou household
composi ion and smoking s a us om household su eys
and censuses, a he han using ques ions ha ask di ec ly
abou exposu e o second-hand smoke in su eys. Second,
we modelled exposu e using spa io empo al Gaussian
p ocess eg ession (ST-GPR), bo owing s eng h ac oss
sexes and all ages, whe eas in GBD 2015 we an a DisMod
model sepa a ely by sex and age. Fu he , we ound
signi ican e idence o associa ions be ween second-hand
smoke exposu e and wo addi ional ou comes: b eas cance
and diabe es, which we e added o he lis o isk-ou come
pai s o second-hand smoke. Mo e de ails on he es i-
ma ion app oach a e p esen ed in appendix 1 (p 98).
Fo he i s ime in he GBD s udy, we es ima ed
exposu e o and bu den a ibu able o smokeless
obacco, de ined as cu en use o any smokeless obacco
p oduc . RR es ima es we e de i ed om p ospec i e
coho s udies and case-con ol s udies and a y
depending on he ype o p oduc used. Based on
a ailable e idence, o chewing obacco RRs we e
signi ican ly highe han one o o al cance and
oesophageal cance , while o snus o snu we did no
ind su icien e idence o a RR g ea e han one o any
heal h ou come. Addi ional de ails on he es ima ion
me hods and RRs a e p esen ed in appendix 1 (p 11, p 181).
Low bi hweigh o ges a ion and sho ges a ion o
bi hweigh a e included as new isk ac o s o GBD 2016.
The es ima ion has been pa ame e ised o be poly omous
by 500 g and 2 week ca ego ies. Low bi hweigh and
ges a ional age a e highly co ela ed isks and hey a e
es ima ed in a comple ely in e dependen manne . Fo
each uni a ia e analysis, iden i ica ion o TMREL and
calcula ion o PAFs is con ingen on he o he dimension.
In o he wo ds, we ound he lowes isk bi hweigh
ca ego y o each 2 week ges a ional age band and,
co espondingly, he lowes isk ges a ional age o each
500 g bi hweigh band. RRs we e hen es ima ed o each
500 g pe 2 week bin. Exposu e o each bin was es ima ed
in h ee s eps. Fi s , we es ima ed by gene a ing ensemble
dis ibu ion es ima es using modelled mean and
ca ego ical p e alence es ima es o each o bi hweigh
(mean, % <2500 g) and ges a ional age (mean, % <37 weeks,
% <28 weeks) o each loca ion, yea , and sex. Second, we
e alua ed all mic oda a whe e bo h ges a ional age and
bi hweigh we e a ailable and ound a high deg ee o
consis ency in he co ela ion be ween hem. Thi d, we
ook he pooled co ela ion coe icien om s ep 2
combined wi h uni a ia e ensemble dis ibu ions om
s ep 1 and used a copula linking unc ion o simula e he
join dis ibu ion which was hen summa ised in o each
500 g pe 2 week ca ego y. Join PAF calcula ion used a
TMREL de ined as he lowes o e all isk o he en i e
ma ix o bi hweigh and ges a ional age (see appendix1
p 77 o mo e de ails).
Risk ac o s Exposu e de ini ion Theo e ical minimum isk exposu e
le el
Da a ep esen a i eness index
<2006 2006–16 To al
(Con inued om p e ious page)
1 Me abolic isks ·· ·· 100·0% 100·0% 100·0%
2 High as ing plasma glucose Se um as ing plasma glucose measu ed in mmol/L 4·8–5·4 mmol/L 51·8% 53·3% 69·7%
2High o al choles e ol Se um o al choles e ol, measu ed in mmol/L 2·78–3·38 mmol/L 59·0% 48·2% 78·0%
2 High sys olic blood p essu e Sys olic blood p essu e, measu ed in mmHg 110–115 mm Hg 64·1% 65·1% 83·6%
2 High body-mass index Body-mass index, measu ed in kg/m² 25 kg/m² 91·3% 100·0% 100·0%
2 Low bone mine al densi y S anda dised mean bone mine al densi y alues measu ed by dual
x- ay abso p iome y a he emo al neck in g/cm²
99 h pe cen ile o NHANES 2005–14 by
age and sex
33·3% 12·3% 35·9%
2 Impai ed kidney unc ion P opo ion o he popula ion wi h ACR >30 mg/g and/o GFR
<60 mL/min pe 1·73m², excluding end-s age enal disease
ACR <30 mg/g and GFR >60 mL/min pe
1·73m²
10·3% 0·0% 10·3%
GBD=Global Bu den o Disease. MET=me abolic equi alen . NHANES=Na ional Heal h and Nu i ion Examina ion Su ey. PM2.5=pa icula e ma e wi h an ae odynamic diame e smalle han 2·5 µm, measu ed
in μg/m³. TMREL= heo e ical minimum isk exposu e le el. ppb=pa s pe billion. ACR=albumin- o-c ea ine a io. GFR=glome ula il a ion a e.
Table 2: GBD 2016 isk ac o hie a chy and accompanying exposu e de ini ions, heo e ical minimum isk exposu e le el, and da a ep esen a i eness index o each isk ac o ,
p e-2006, 2006–16, and o al (ac oss all yea s)
Global Heal h Me ics
www. helance .com Vol 390 Sep embe 16, 2017
1365
Media ion
In GBD 2016, we upda ed ou app oach o es ima ion o
he join e ec s o combina ions o isk ac o s
(appendix 1 p 23). Using indi idual-le el da a om
p ospec i e coho s udies, we es ima ed he p opo ion
o he e ec o beha iou al isks on ca diome abolic
ou comes media ed h ough me abolic isk ac o s. We
also es ima ed he p opo ion o he e ec o each
me abolic isk ac o on ca diome abolic ou comes
media ed h ough o he me abolic isks. Fo each
media ion pa hway, we only included he media o s o
which su icien e idence exis ed o hei causal
ela ionship wi h he disease endpoin .
Explaining he d i e s o ends in dea hs and DALYs
As in GBD 2015, we unde ook a decomposi ion analysis
o changes in DALYs o e he ime pe iod in o ou main
componen s, namely, changes in DALYs due o changes
in: (1) popula ion g ow h; (2) popula ion age s uc u e;
(3) exposu e o all isks o a disease; and (4) all o he
ac o s combined, app oxima ed as he isk-dele ed dea h
and DALY a es. Risk-dele ed a es e e s o dea h and
DALY a es ha would be obse ed i we emo ed all isk
ac o s included in GBD 2016, es ima ed as DALY a es
mul iplied by one minus he PAF o he se o isks. We
used me hods de eloped by Das Gup a,19 bu as
he me hods p esen ed he e do no esul in he
decomposi ion esul s being linea agg ega es o e ime
o isk, we adap ed hese me hods u he in GBD 2016.
Ou decomposi ion analysis was unde aken o each
5 yea ime pe iod, a he all- isk le el, aking in o accoun
isk media ion a he mos de ailed cause le el. The
con ibu ion o changes in exposu e o he indi idual
isks was scaled o he all- isk e ec a he mos de ailed
ou come le el. The con ibu ion o isk exposu es o e
longe ime pe iods—eg, 2000–16—o a highe cause
agg ega es—eg, all cause—we e calcula ed as he linea
agg ega e o he e ec o indi idual isks a he mos
de ailed cause le el and ime pe iod.
Risk ansi ion wi h de elopmen
We explo ed how exposu e o isks a ies ac oss le els o
de elopmen using he SDI, a composi e indica o o
de elopmen s a us cons uc ed o GBD 2015 whose
componen s a e s ongly co ela ed wi h heal h ou comes.
I is he geome ic mean o 0 o 1 o indices o o al
e ili y a e, mean educa ion o hose aged 15 yea s and
olde , and lag-dis ibu ed income pe capi a. Mo e de ails
on he es ima ion o SDI can be ound in appendix 1
(p 32).
Role o he unding sou ce
The unde s o he s udy had no ole in he s udy design,
da a collec ion, da a analysis, da a in e p e a ion, o
w i ing o he epo . The au ho s had ull access o all
da a in he s udy and had inal esponsibili y o he
decision o submi o publica ion.
Resul s
Global exposu e o isks
F om 1990 o 2016, ends in SEVs a ied ac oss he se o
isk ac o s included in GBD 2016. O no e, SEVs dec eased
by mo e han 40% o h ee isks: die high in ans a y
acids (51·3% [95% UI 34·1–70·1]), household ai pollu ion
om solid uels (43·1% [40·7–45·6]), and unsa e sani a ion
(40·3% [35·5–44·7]; able 3, appendix 2 p 1399). Du ing
he same pe iod, SEVs inc eased by mo e han 40% o
high body-mass index (BMI; 60·2% [45·1–79·1]), die high
in suga -swee ened be e ages (44·7% [36·1–52·7]), occu-
pa ional exposu e o diesel engine exhaus (41·8%
[41·3–42·2]), and occupa ional exposu e o ichlo o-
e hylene (40·6% [40·2–41·1]).
Ac oss coun ies he e is subs an ial a ia ion in isk
exposu e by le el o SDI. Some isk ac o s, such as high
as ing plasma glucose (FPG) and high sys olic blood
p essu e, show simila SEVs ac oss le els o SDI, while
o he s, including household ai pollu ion and unsa e
wa e sou ce, show ma ked ends wi h sociodemog aphic
de elopmen . Figu e 1 shows he ela ionship be ween
SEVs and SDI o he leading h ee me abolic, beha iou al,
and en i onmen al and occupa ional isk ac o s and how
ha changed be ween 1990 and 2016. Wi hin leading
me abolic isks (high BMI, high FPG, and high sys olic
blood p essu e [SBP]), isk-weigh ed exposu e shows an
inc easing end wi h inc easing SDI o only high BMI.
O e all, he SEV o high BMI has inc eased du ing he
ime pe iod. Looking a he leading h ee en i onmen al
isk ac o s (ambien ai pollu ion, household ai pollu ion,
and unsa e wa e ), igu e 2 shows an in e se ela ionship
wi h SDI o household ai pollu ion and unsa e wa e ,
wi h SEVs app oaching ze o a high le els o SDI, while
he ela ionship is less consis en wi h ambien ai
pollu ion. Finally, he ela ionship be ween SDI and he
leading beha iou al isk ac o s is mo e he e ogeneous,
wi h smoking and alcohol use ha ing a posi i e co ela ion
wi h SDI, and sho ges a ion o bi hweigh ha ing a
nega i e co ela ion wi h SDI.
Global a ibu able bu den o all isk ac o s combined
and hei o e lap
Globally, 59·9% (58·4–61·3) o dea hs and 45·2%
(43·2–47·3) o DALYs could be a ibu ed o he isk ac o s
assessed in GBD 2016. Fo dea hs, non-communicable
diseases (NCDs) show he la ges p opo ion a ibu able
o measu ed isk ac o s, a 64·4% (62·6–66·2), wi h
communicable, ma e nal, neona al, and nu i ional
(CMNN) causes a 57·9% (55·4–61·0), and inju ies a
25·8% (23·7–27·8). The pic u e was di e en o DALYs,
howe e , whe e we obse ed ha 58·2% (56·4–60·3) o
DALYs in CMNN causes a e a ibu able o isk ac o s,
compa ed wi h 43·5% (40·7–46·7) in NCDs and 21·0%
(19·3–22·7) o inju ies. Leading causes o DALYs in
CMNN causes, such as dia hoea and lowe espi a o y
in ec ions (LRI), also showed mo e han 80% o DALYs can
be a ibu ed o isk ac o s (appendix 2 p 1).
Global Heal h Me ics
1366
www. helance .com Vol 390 Sep embe 16, 2017
Risk Male Female Combined
pe cen
change
1990–2016
1990 2006 2016 Pe cen
change
1990–2006
Pe cen
change
2006–16
Pe cen
change
1990–2016
1990 2006 2016 Pe cen
change
1990–2006
Pe cen
change
2006–16
Pe cen
change
1990–2016
1 En i onmen al and occupa ional isks
2 Unsa e wa e , sani a ion, and handwashing
3Unsa e wa e
sou ce
23·27
(15·57 o
26·55)
21·27
(14·30 o
24·21)
20·08
(13·47 o
22·83)
–8·61
(–10·54 o
–6·62)*
–5·61
(–7·29 o
–3·75)*
–13·74
(–15·78 o
–11·37)*
22·94
(15·32 o
26·19)
21·12
(14·19 o
24·03)
20·04
(13·45 o
22·79)
–7·96
(–9·87 o
–6·01)*
–5·08
(–6·76 o
–3·25)*
–12·64
(–14·67 o
–10·28)*
–13·14
(–15·18 o
–10·78)*
3 Unsa e sani a ion 56·46
(53·29 o
60·79)
42·29
(38·91 o
46·94)
33·26
(29·47 o
38·52)
–25·10
(–28·04 o
–22·10)*
–21·36
(–25·52 o
–17·53)*
–41·10
(–45·39 o
–36·37)*
55·13
(51·99 o
59·44)
41·91
(38·53 o
46·70)
33·34
(29·49 o
38·67)
–23·97
(–27·05 o
–20·77)*
–20·45
(–24·51
o
–16·63)*
–39·51
(–44·05 o
–34·59)*
–40·28
(–44·73 o
–35·47)*
3No access o
handwashing
acili y
36·22
(35·56 o
36·95)
34·57
(34·00 o
35·14)
33·13
(32·66 o
33·62)
–4·57
(–6·31 o
–2·72)*
–4·15
(–5·29 o
–2·89)*
–8·53
(–10·53 o
–6·29)*
35·82
(35·15 o
36·53)
34·54
(33·98 o
35·11)
33·34
(32·87 o
33·83)
–3·57
(–5·34 o
–1·69)*
–3·46
(–4·64 o
–2·22)*
–6·91
(–8·94 o
–4·61)*
–7·67
(–9·69 o
–5·40)*
2 Ai pollu ion
3 Ambien
pa icula e
ma e pollu ion
44·42
(37·19 o
53·39)
45·74
(38·10 o
54·89)
49·56
(41·42 o
58·71)
2·96
(1·88 o
3·97)*
8·37
(6·79 o
9·43)*
11·57
(9·47 o
13·51)*
43·79
(36·57 o
52·71)
45·00
(37·47 o
54·11)
48·87
(40·79 o
58·02)
2·76
(1·69 o
3·76)*
8·58
(6·98 o
9·69)*
11·58
(9·44 o
13·55)*
11·60
(9·48 o
13·56)*
3 Household ai
pollu ion om
solid uels
34·05
(27·33 o
41·50)
25·65
(20·30 o
31·36)
18·95
(14·97 o
23·48)
–24·66
(–27·07 o
–22·55)*
–26·12
(–28·68
o
–23·75)*
–44·33
(–47·18 o
–41·84)*
35·67
(30·59 o
40·81)
27·57
(23·56 o
31·88)
20·69
(17·54 o
24·11)
–22·71
(–24·92 o
–20·85)*
–24·95
(–27·24
o
–22·68)*
–42·00
(–44·45 o
–39·54)*
–43·14
(–45·63 o
–40·73)*
3Ambien ozone
pollu ion
38·49
(13·87 o
68·02)
43·30
(15·71 o
74·16)
48·75
(18·05 o
78·30)
12·50
(8·84 o
14·03)*
12·57
(5·92 o
15·54)*
26·63
(15·49 o
31·29)*
38·22
(13·78 o
67·36)
42·66
(15·45 o
73·25)
47·94
(17·71 o
77·40)
11·61
(8·35 o
12·94)*
12·39
(5·99 o
15·22)*
25·44
(15·05 o
29·65)*
26·03
(15·27 o
30·47)*
2 O he en i onmen al isks
3 Residen ial adon 26·12
(22·17 o
30·31)
26·08
(22·09 o
30·34)
26·17
(22·17 o
30·54)
–0·12
(–1·27 o
1·03)
0·34
(–0·24 o
0·98)
0·22
(–1·41 o
1·95)
26·27
(22·33 o
30·45)
26·23
(22·25 o
30·48)
26·34
(22·32 o
30·69)
–0·12
(–1·32 o
1·09)
0·41
(–0·22 o
1·10)
0·29
(–1·45 o
2·12)
0·25
(–1·43 o
2·04)
3Lead exposu e 20·01
(8·93 o
33·97)
18·57
(8·35 o
31·87)
15·01
(6·28 o
27·06)
–7·19
(–10·97 o
–4·90)*
–19·20
(–25·88 o
–14·37)*
–25·01
(–32·80 o
–18·88)*
10·27
(2·82 o
21·64)
10·18
(3·19 o
21·15)
8·37
(2·47 o
18·17)
–0·80
(–4·67 o
13·60)
–17·86
(–24·00
o
–13·50)*
–18·52
(–24·51 o
–10·29)*
–22·68
(–30·06 o
–17·08)*
2 Occupa ional isks
3 Occupa ional ca cinogens
4 Occupa ional
exposu e o
asbes os
4·11
(3·85 o
4·44)
4·00
(3·76 o
4·30)
3·90
(3·65 o
4·21)
–2·68
(–5·60 o
–0·17)*
–2·41
(–3·52 o
–1·46)*
–5·03
(–7·49 o
–2·85)*
1·47
(1·36 o
1·68)
1·25
(1·17 o
1·40)
1·19
(1·11 o
1·32)
–14·74
(–16·66 o
–13·21)*
–4·97
(–6·27 o
–3·53)*
–18·98
(–21·23 o
–17·53)*
–6·91
(–8·97 o
–5·07)*
4 Occupa ional
exposu e o
a senic
0·91
(0·00 o
3·12)
0·96
(0·00 o
3·46)
1·02
(0·00 o
3·75)
6·31
(0·18 o
10·99)*
6·23
(3·89 o
8·29)*
12·94
(4·14 o
20·24)*
0·72
(0·00 o
2·37)
0·81
(0·00 o
2·84)
0·88
(0·00 o
3·16)
11·83
(2·14 o
19·69)*
8·82
(5·35 o
11·33)*
21·70
(8·33 o
33·09)*
16·81
(6·00 o
25·80)*
4 Occupa ional
exposu e o
benzene
0·77
(0·36 o
1·59)
0·87
(0·44 o
1·74)
0·96
(0·51 o
1·88)
12·93
(9·26 o
21·67)*
10·25
(8·22 o
14·21)*
24·50
(18·21 o
38·83)*
0·65
(0·27 o
1·43)
0·80
(0·37 o
1·68)
0·94
(0·46 o
1·91)
22·92
(17·94 o
37·88)*
17·04
(13·69 o
24·74)*
43·86
(34·03 o
71·79)*
33·27
(25·56 o
52·63)*
4 Occupa ional
exposu e o
be yllium
0·09
(0·09 o
0·09)
0·10
(0·10 o
0·10)
0·11
(0·11 o
0·11)
10·33
(10·18 o
10·46)*
6·40
(6·30 o
6·51)*
17·39
(17·17 o
17·62)*
0·07
(0·07 o
0·07)
0·08
(0·08 o
0·08)
0·09
(0·09 o
0·09)
23·36
(23·14 o
23·58)*
13·48
(13·35 o
13·61)*
39·99
(39·65 o
40·30)*
26·78
(26·60 o
26·96)*
4 Occupa ional
exposu e o
cadmium
0·18
(0·18 o
0·18)
0·20
(0·20 o
0·20)
0·22
(0·22 o
0·22)
13·27
(12·96 o
13·59)*
9·35
(9·15 o
9·58)*
23·86
(23·39 o
24·33)*
0·13
(0·13 o
0·14)
0·16
(0·16 o
0·17)
0·19
(0·18 o
0·19)
22·86
(22·14 o
23·54)*
13·76
(13·16 o
14·47)*
39·76
(38·93 o
40·61)*
30·69
(30·23 o
31·19)*
4 Occupa ional
exposu e o
ch omium
0·38
(0·38 o
0·39)
0·45
(0·44 o
0·45)
0·50
(0·49 o
0·51)
17·37
(17·03 o
17·72)*
11·82
(11·59 o
12·06)*
31·24
(30·77 o
31·73)*
0·28
(0·28 o
0·29)
0·36
(0·35 o
0·37)
0·42
(0·41 o
0·43)
26·61
(25·62 o
27·46)*
16·00
(15·33 o
16·77)*
46·86
(45·96 o
47·74)*
37·94
(37·46 o
38·43)*
4 Occupa ional
exposu e o diesel
engine exhaus
2·29
(2·26 o
2·32)
2·78
(2·74 o
2·81)
3·11
(3·07 o
3·14)
21·41
(20·94 o
21·81)*
11·86
(11·60 o
12·11)*
35·80
(35·28 o
36·30)*
1·22
(1·20 o
1·23)
1·61
(1·59 o
1·64)
1·86
(1·83 o
1·89)
32·59
(32·10 o
33·07)*
15·19
(14·80 o
15·65)*
52·73
(51·97 o
53·59)*
41·78
(41·29 o
42·22)*
(Table 3 con inues on nex page)
Global Heal h Me ics
www. helance .com Vol 390 Sep embe 16, 2017
1367
Risk Male Female Combined
pe cen
change
1990–2016
1990 2006 2016 Pe cen
change
1990–2006
Pe cen
change
2006–16
Pe cen
change
1990–2016
1990 2006 2016 Pe cen
change
1990–2006
Pe cen
change
2006–16
Pe cen
change
1990–2016
(Con inued om p e ious page)
4 Occupa ional
exposu e o
second-hand
smoke
12·58
(5·66 o
21·95)
12·96
(5·67 o
22·91)
13·77
(6·00 o
24·44)
3·02
(0·61 o
4·26)*
6·23
(5·39 o
6·83)*
9·44
(6·25 o
11·25)*
10·65
(4·83 o
18·85)
11·47
(5·11 o
20·49)
12·18
(5·39 o
21·86)
7·69
(5·75 o
8·77)*
6·17
(5·33 o
6·69)*
14·33
(11·51 o
15·87)*
11·63
(8·77 o
13·29)*
4 Occupa ional
exposu e o
o maldehyde
0·79
(0·77 o
0·81)
0·91
(0·88 o
0·93)
1·01
(0·98 o
1·03)
14·91
(14·45 o
15·39)*
10·67
(10·41 o
10·94)*
27·17
(26·49 o
27·88)*
0·57
(0·55 o
0·58)
0·70
(0·67 o
0·72)
0·80
(0·77 o
0·82)
22·93
(21·84 o
23·99)*
14·63
(14·06 o
15·25)*
40·92
(39·83 o
42·05)*
32·87
(32·25 o
33·48)*
4 Occupa ional
exposu e o
nickel
1·60
(0·00 o
7·78)
1·67
(0·00 o
8·37)
1·75
(0·00 o
8·89)
4·62
(–3·15 o
7·54)
4·52
(1·26 o
6·14)*
9·36
(–1·85 o
14·13)
1·07
(0·00 o
4·86)
1·18
(0·00 o
5·65)
1·27
(0·00 o
6·20)
10·38
(–1·64 o
15·93)
7·75
(3·07 o
10·22)*
18·93
(1·74 o
27·60)*
13·25
(–0·43 o
19·36)
4 Occupa ional
exposu e o
polycyclic
a oma ic
hyd oca bons
0·80
(0·79 o
0·81)
0·93
(0·92 o
0·94)
1·05
(1·03 o
1·06)
17·04
(16·72 o
17·34)*
11·89
(11·71 o
12·09)*
30·96
(30·53 o
31·40)*
0·58
(0·58 o
0·59)
0·74
(0·73 o
0·75)
0·86
(0·85 o
0·88)
26·50
(25·77 o
27·17)*
16·77
(16·27 o
17·29)*
47·71
(46·91 o
48·49)*
38·08
(37·65 o
38·52)*
4 Occupa ional
exposu e o silica
5·76
(2·34 o
14·58)
5·97
(2·59 o
14·73)
6·21
(2·78 o
15·06)
3·67
(0·97 o
10·72)*
4·05
(2·23 o
7·26)*
7·87
(3·25 o
18·79)*
3·11
(1·19 o
7·93)
3·16
(1·34 o
7·75)
3·29
(1·45 o
7·87)
1·62
(–2·33 o
12·08)
3·98
(1·53 o
8·05)*
5·66
(–0·80 o
21·02)
7·16
(1·90 o
19·77)*
4 Occupa ional
exposu e o
sul u ic acid
0·93
(0·56 o
1·94)
0·98
(0·63 o
1·95)
1·03
(0·67 o
2·00)
5·70
(0·98 o
11·50)*
4·63
(2·40 o
7·07)*
10·58
(3·34 o
19·35)*
0·68
(0·39 o
1·49)
0·77
(0·48 o
1·57)
0·83
(0·54 o
1·64)
12·54
(5·65 o
22·38)*
7·87
(4·54 o
11·75)*
21·39
(10·34 o
36·35)*
15·18
(6·51 o
26·46)*
4 Occupa ional
exposu e o
ichlo oe hylene
0·22
(0·22 o
0·22)
0·26
(0·26 o
0·27)
0·30
(0·29 o
0·30)
19·43
(19·07 o
19·87)*
11·90
(11·59 o
12·26)*
33·64
(33·15 o
34·20)*
0·16
(0·16 o
0·16)
0·21
(0·21 o
0·21)
0·24
(0·24 o
0·25)
29·39
(28·28 o
30·19)*
16·04
(15·52 o
16·69)*
50·15
(49·33 o
50·89)*
40·64
(40·23 o
41·07)*
3Occupa ional
as hmagens
23·14
(19·26 o
27·93)
23·44
(19·61 o
28·24)
23·97
(20·12 o
28·88)
1·30
(0·28 o
2·38)*
2·28
(1·75 o
2·92)*
3·61
(2·17 o
5·17)*
10·70
(8·71 o
13·08)
12·42
(10·13 o
15·13)
13·39
(10·96 o
16·30)
16·04
(14·27 o
17·83)*
7·80
(7·01 o
8·74)*
25·09
(22·75 o
27·86)*
10·50
(8·62 o
12·32)*
3 Occupa ional
pa icula e
ma e , gases,
and umes
12·28
(9·40 o
16·46)
12·53
(9·64 o
16·72)
12·60
(9·72 o
16·79)
1·99
(1·40 o
2·55)*
0·58
(0·19 o
0·97)*
2·59
(1·76 o
3·42)*
5·59
(4·29 o
7·66)
6·15
(4·78 o
8·35)
6·49
(5·05 o
8·81)
10·01
(8·28 o
11·78)*
5·44
(4·56 o
6·36)*
16·00
(13·53 o
18·35)*
7·30
(5·61 o
8·97)*
3 Occupa ional
noise
16·38
(13·89 o
19·41)
16·38
(14·00 o
19·31)
16·21
(13·92 o
18·94)
–0·01
(–0·92 o
0·79)
–1·06
(–2·04 o
–0·40)*
–1·07
(–2·82 o
0·37)
7·11
(6·22 o
8·05)
7·94
(6·98 o
8·97)
8·45
(7·45 o
9·52)
11·69
(11·00 o
12·54)*
6·47
(6·09 o
6·87)*
18·92
(17·89 o
20·19)*
5·41
(3·83 o
6·85)*
3 Occupa ional
e gonomic
ac o s
24·56
(23·13 o
26·22)
24·62
(23·05 o
26·43)
23·44
(22·01 o
25·12)
0·27
(–0·72 o
1·19)
–4·79
(–5·10 o
–4·46)*
–4·54
(–5·47 o
–3·62)*
12·46
(11·73 o
13·36)
14·70
(13·80 o
15·80)
15·15
(14·21 o
16·25)
17·95
(16·56 o
19·42)*
3·06
(2·72 o
3·41)*
21·56
(19·97 o
23·25)*
4·31
(3·39 o
5·27)*
1 Beha iou al isks
2 Child and ma e nal malnu i ion
3 Subop imal b eas eeding
4 Non-exclusi e
b eas eeding
24·03
(17·85 o
32·14)
22·62
(16·92 o
29·93)
22·72
(17·08 o
29·99)
–5·85
(–7·72 o
–3·89)*
0·43
(–1·59 o
2·60)
–5·45
(–7·72 o
–2·66)*
23·99
(17·82 o
32·11)
22·60
(16·88 o
29·95)
22·70
(17·05 o
30·00)
–5·79
(–7·61 o
–3·86)*
0·42
(–1·54 o
2·61)
–5·39
(–7·63 o
–2·63)*
–5·42
(–7·68 o
–2·65)*
4 Discon inued
b eas eeding
12·15
(12·04 o
12·30)
11·93
(11·84 o
12·07)
12·75
(12·60 o
12·93)
–1·80
(–3·03 o
–0·46)*
6·86
(5·55 o
8·28)*
4·94
(3·15 o
6·70)*
12·15
(12·04 o
12·30)
11·89
(11·80 o
12·03)
12·69
(12·53 o
12·86)
–2·12
(–3·35 o
–0·80)*
6·71
(5·40 o
8·14)*
4·45
(2·68 o
6·18)*
4·70
(2·92 o
6·45)*
3 Child g ow h ailu e
4 Child
unde weigh
14·90
(13·04 o
16·56)
12·52
(10·85 o
14·08)
9·19
(7·59 o
10·69)
–15·99
(–19·77 o
–12·69)*
–26·61
(–30·36 o
–23·72)*
–38·34
(–43·20 o
–34·46)*
14·04
(12·19 o
15·73)
11·14
(9·38 o
12·65)
8·41
(6·81 o
9·85)
–20·62
(–24·29 o
–17·36)*
–24·50
(–28·14
o
–21·50)*
–40·06
(–44·66 o
–35·98)*
–39·14
(–43·61 o
–35·50)*
4Child was ing 8·46
(7·11 o
9·72)
8·39
(7·08 o
9·60)
7·11
(5·84 o
8·33)
–0·85
(–3·11 o
1·33)
–15·26
(–18·20 o
–12·78)*
–15·98
(–19·31 o
–13·01)*
8·24
(6·88 o
9·49)
7·57
(6·30 o
8·78)
6·54
(5·36 o
7·69)
–8·16
(–10·86 o
–5·59)*
–13·56
(–15·99
o
–11·39)*
–20·61
(–24·15 o
–17·18)*
–18·19
(–21·38 o
–15·64)*
(Table 3 con inues on nex page)
Global Heal h Me ics
1368
www. helance .com Vol 390 Sep embe 16, 2017
Risk Male Female Combined
pe cen
change
1990–2016
1990 2006 2016 Pe cen
change
1990–2006
Pe cen
change
2006–16
Pe cen
change
1990–2016
1990 2006 2016 Pe cen
change
1990–2006
Pe cen
change
2006–16
Pe cen
change
1990–2016
(Con inued om p e ious page)
4 Child s un ing 24·71
(17·03 o
27·50)
21·31
(14·80 o
23·95)
17·07
(11·93 o
19·73)
–13·77
(–16·16 o
–11·88)*
–19·86
(–23·55 o
–17·01)*
–30·90
(–35·38 o
–27·56)*
23·49
(16·28 o
26·33)
19·53
(13·62 o
22·16)
15·48
(10·78 o
18·07)
–16·82
(–19·62 o
–14·76)*
–20·77
(–24·47
o
–17·65)*
–34·10
(–38·80 o
–30·53)*
–32·40
(–36·66 o
–29·30)*
3 Low bi hweigh and sho ges a ion
4 Sho ges a ion
o bi hweigh
10·22
(9·52 o
11·09)
10·55
(9·81 o
11·50)
10·78
(10·00 o
11·81)
3·28
(2·71 o
3·92)*
2·16
(1·46 o
3·30)*
5·51
(4·37 o
7·01)*
10·26
(9·44 o
11·25)
10·67
(9·76 o
11·76)
10·92
(9·95 o
12·11)
3·95
(3·26 o
4·71)*
2·34
(1·67 o
3·41)*
6·39
(5·17 o
7·92)*
5·94
(4·95 o
7·21)*
4 Low bi hweigh
o ges a ion
8·91
(7·92 o
10·06)
8·73
(7·80 o
9·80)
8·61
(7·71 o
9·64)
–2·04
(–3·00 o
–1·29)*
–1·34
(–1·93 o
–0·81)*
–3·36
(–4·65 o
–2·25)*
9·23
(8·23 o
10·59)
8·93
(8·04 o
10·16)
8·83
(7·96 o
10·03)
–3·22
(–4·53 o
–2·16)*
–1·14
(–1·68 o
–0·61)*
–4·32
(–5·85 o
–2·94)*
–3·83
(–5·10 o
–2·79)*
3I on de iciency ·· ·· ·· ·· ·· ·· 8·36
(6·25 o
10·98)
8·49
(6·35 o
11·11)
8·52
(6·38 o
11·16)
1·46
(1·27 o
1·69)*
0·39
(0·28 o
0·50)*
1·86
(1·65 o
2·09)*
1·87
(1·67 o
2·11)*
3Vi amin A
de iciency
20·37
(16·63 o
24·22)
16·91
(13·58 o
20·19)
15·30
(12·25 o
18·41)
–16·99
(–18·83 o
–15·00)*
–9·55
(–11·66 o
–7·57)*
–24·92
(–27·67 o
–22·08)*
19·12
(15·60 o
22·93)
16·03
(13·04 o
19·14)
14·44
(11·43 o
17·54)
–16·16
(–17·99 o
–13·29)*
–9·90
(–12·40
o
–7·72)*
–24·46
(–27·62 o
–21·13)*
–24·69
(–27·48 o
–21·70)*
3Zinc de iciency 11·26
(3·33 o
21·64)
9·36
(2·93 o
18·11)
7·96
(2·45 o
15·87)
–16·89
(–20·14 o
–10·22)*
–14·99
(–17·90 o
–11·14)*
–29·35
(–33·23 o
–21·63)*
11·31
(3·29 o
21·72)
9·35
(2·90 o
18·12)
7·96
(2·46 o
15·92)
–17·29
(–20·61 o
–11·41)*
–14·85
(–17·96
o
–10·84)*
–29·57
(–33·72 o
–22·15)*
–29·46
(–32·76 o
–23·49)*
2 Tobacco
3 Smoking 35·72
(32·76 o
39·76)
30·16
(27·23 o
34·44)
25·14
(22·69 o
28·74)
–15·57
(–18·63 o
–12·33)*
–16·63
(–20·29 o
–12·87)*
–29·61
(–33·96 o
–24·13)*
11·11
(9·22 o
14·19)
9·65
(7·88 o
12·63)
7·93
(6·49 o
10·55)
–13·15
(–16·68 o
–7·93)*
–17·83
(–23·41
o
–12·38)*
–28·63
(–34·48 o
–20·87)*
–28·99
(–33·00 o
–24·33)*
3 Smokeless
obacco
13·39
(12·68 o
14·11)
15·58
(15·10 o
16·07)
15·04
(14·34 o
15·80)
16·36
(9·65 o
23·26)*
–3·46
(–8·38 o
2·17)
12·33
(4·70 o
20·89)*
8·34
(7·65 o
9·00)
9·31
(8·82 o
9·80)
8·61
(7·88 o
9·37)
11·55
(1·46 o
23·48)*
–7·44
(–16·18
o 2·32)
3·25
(–8·03 o
16·93)
9·11
(2·16 o
16·49)*
3Second-hand
smoke
23·11
(22·52 o
23·63)
19·73
(19·48 o
19·96)
18·96
(18·60 o
19·28)
–14·62
(–16·80 o
–12·40)*
–3·91
(–4·99 o
–2·82)*
–17·96
(–20·68 o
–15·11)*
43·29
(42·00 o
44·40)
35·87
(35·10 o
36·55)
33·32
(32·49 o
33·97)
–17·13
(–18·78 o
–15·25)*
–7·11
(–8·22 o
–6·01)*
–23·03
(–25·21 o
–20·59)*
–21·39
(–23·64 o
–18·82)*
2Alcohol and d ug use
3Alcohol use 13·82
(11·94 o
15·70)
14·27
(12·36 o
16·27)
14·05
(12·28 o
15·85)
3·26
(–1·07 o
8·20)
–1·54
(–5·49 o
2·86)
1·68
(–3·97 o
8·77)
5·68
(4·57 o
6·78)
4·90
(3·97 o
5·88)
4·83
(3·93 o
5·78)
–13·70
(–17·59 o
–9·62)*
–1·49
(–6·97 o
4·13)
–14·98
(–20·47 o
–8·98)*
–2·84
(–8·09 o
3·36)
3D ug use 0·63
(0·32 o
1·13)
0·61
(0·31 o
1·09)
0·61
(0·31 o
1·10)
–2·98
(–3·70 o
–2·26)*
0·41
(–0·76 o
1·52)
–2·58
(–4·08 o
–0·98)*
0·38
(0·19 o
0·68)
0·35
(0·18 o
0·64)
0·36
(0·18 o
0·65)
–7·43
(–8·40 o
–6·57)*
1·19
(–0·04 o
2·29)
–6·33
(–7·94 o
–4·82)*
–3·84
(–5·28 o
–2·42)*
2 Die a y isks
3 Die low in ui s 74·84
(54·78 o
91·07)
67·49
(47·24 o
86·59)
61·77
(41·88 o
80·91)
–9·81
(–13·94 o
–4·92)*
–8·49
(–11·37 o
–6·45)*
–17·47
(–23·57 o
–11·01)*
72·47
(52·33 o
89·49)
63·10
(43·24 o
82·40)
56·95
(37·44 o
75·97)
–12·92
(–17·54 o
–7·87)*
–9·75
(–12·98
o
–7·61)*
–21·41
(–28·12 o
–15·01)*
–19·41
(–25·83 o
–13·02)*
3 Die low in
ege ables
54·19
(36·90 o
71·51)
45·87
(29·62 o
62·63)
41·55
(26·41 o
57·44)
–15·36
(–19·49 o
–12·55)*
–9·41
(–11·75 o
–7·67)*
–23·32
(–28·38 o
–19·69)*
56·42
(38·74 o
74·29)
48·11
(31·55 o
64·93)
43·79
(28·06 o
60·10)
–14·74
(–18·82 o
–12·04)*
–8·96
(–11·33
o
–7·32)*
–22·38
(–27·62 o
–18·87)*
–22·83
(–27·86 o
–19·31)*
3 Die low in
legumes
41·50
(28·42 o
54·90)
45·97
(33·03 o
58·84)
45·13
(32·40 o
57·73)
10·78
(6·42 o
17·21)*
–1·83
(–3·69 o
0·03)
8·75
(4·50 o
14·83)*
47·78
(33·68 o
61·80)
52·23
(38·14 o
65·93)
51·61
(37·74 o
65·20)
9·33
(6·14 o
13·95)*
–1·18
(–2·64 o
0·16)
8·04
(4·89 o
12·67)*
8·18
(4·89 o
13·01)*
3 Die low in whole
g ains
64·83
(45·85 o
83·18)
58·75
(41·16 o
76·64)
58·64
(41·07 o
76·49)
–9·37
(–10·53 o
–7·87)*
–0·20
(–0·52 o
0·11)
–9·55
(–10·79 o
–8·01)*
65·47
(46·12 o
83·94)
59·44
(41·30 o
77·68)
60·66
(42·41 o
78·76)
–9·21
(–10·80 o
–7·50)*
2·06
(1·26 o
2·80)*
–7·34
(–8·50 o
–6·19)*
–8·44
(–9·57 o
–7·11)*
(Table 3 con inues on nex page)
Global Heal h Me ics
www. helance .com Vol 390 Sep embe 16, 2017
1369
Risk Male Female Combined
pe cen
change
1990–2016
1990 2006 2016 Pe cen
change
1990–2006
Pe cen
change
2006–16
Pe cen
change
1990–2016
1990 2006 2016 Pe cen
change
1990–2006
Pe cen
change
2006–16
Pe cen
change
1990–2016
(Con inued om p e ious page)
3 Die low in nu s
and seeds
88·83
(68·81 o
99·29)
83·75
(63·76 o
95·14)
81·39
(60·77 o
94·85)
–5·72
(–7·32 o
–4·13)*
–2·82
(–4·85 o
–0·31)*
–8·38
(–11·67 o
–4·50)*
89·01
(68·93 o
99·33)
84·32
(64·20 o
95·78)
81·94
(61·27 o
95·19)
–5·27
(–6·94 o
–3·53)*
–2·82
(–4·65 o
–0·54)*
–7·94
(–11·18 o
–4·16)*
–8·16
(–11·38 o
–4·33)*
3 Die low in milk 81·31
(63·75 o
93·81)
83·31
(65·78 o
95·69)
83·48
(65·88 o
95·94)
2·47
(1·94 o
3·09)*
0·20
(–0·23 o
0·59)
2·67
(2·11 o
3·25)*
81·43
(63·96 o
94·04)
83·40
(65·84 o
95·88)
83·62
(65·94 o
96·11)
2·42
(1·83 o
3·19)*
0·27
(–0·14 o
0·64)
2·70
(2·11 o
3·43)*
2·71
(2·19 o
3·22)*
3 Die high in ed
mea
19·44
(16·17 o
22·95)
21·77
(18·13 o
25·66)
24·66
(21·03 o
28·64)
11·97
(6·60 o
17·58)*
13·28
(8·34 o
19·80)*
26·84
(20·66 o
34·20)*
8·50
(6·08 o
11·17)
8·96
(6·42 o
11·86)
10·84
(7·89 o
13·98)
5·35
(–2·82 o
16·00)
21·05
(10·94 o
34·59)*
27·53
(17·12 o
41·17)*
27·57
(21·74 o
34·70)*
3 Die high in
p ocessed mea
7·84
(6·20 o
10·03)
7·62
(6·12 o
9·88)
6·19
(4·58 o
8·67)
–2·79
(–8·00 o
1·77)
–18·81
(–26·23 o
–11·45)*
–21·08
(–29·56 o
–12·44)*
5·38
(3·82 o
7·35)
5·07
(3·69 o
7·09)
4·32
(2·95 o
6·49)
–5·92
(–11·73 o
0·09)
–14·62
(–22·25
o
–7·62)*
–19·68
(–27·67 o
–10·91)*
–20·45
(–27·41 o
–12·36)*
3 Die high in
suga -swee ened
be e ages
12·19
(11·19 o
13·25)
15·70
(14·48 o
16·87)
17·90
(16·52 o
19·25)
28·79
(22·74 o
35·00)*
14·06
(11·40 o
16·81)*
46·89
(38·49 o
55·16)*
9·47
(8·47 o
10·53)
11·79
(10·79 o
12·82)
13·45
(12·28 o
14·59)
24·47
(17·25 o
31·99)*
14·10
(10·72 o
17·61)*
42·02
(31·42 o
52·44)*
44·73
(36·08 o
52·69)*
3 Die low in ib e 59·23
(38·47 o
80·17)
56·12
(35·61 o
76·88)
53·27
(33·15 o
73·95)
–5·24
(–7·57 o
–3·74)*
–5·08
(–7·43 o
–3·57)*
–10·06
(–13·95 o
–7·46)*
66·96
(45·54 o
87·29)
64·02
(42·94 o
84·48)
61·76
(40·67 o
82·64)
–4·39
(–6·33 o
–3·04)*
–3·53
(–5·53 o
–2·10)*
–7·77
(–11·04 o
–5·33)*
–8·89
(–12·30 o
–6·46)*
3 Die low in
calcium
63·99
(44·32 o
82·99)
60·79
(41·37 o
80·23)
57·11
(37·87 o
76·76)
–5·01
(–6·88 o
–3·24)*
–6·05
(–8·50 o
–4·33)*
–10·75
(–14·66 o
–7·46)*
66·45
(46·60
o 85·13)
63·73
(43·96 o
83·09)
60·70
(41·09 o
80·49)
–4·09
(–5·70 o
–2·36)*
–4·76
(–6·69 o
–3·15)*
–8·66
(–11·87 o
–5·44)*
–9·67
(–13·21 o
–6·43)*
3Die low in
sea ood omega 3
a y acids
80·95
(62·89 o
93·16)
78·84
(60·21 o
92·11)
76·66
(57·55 o
91·30)
–2·61
(–4·24 o
–1·11)*
–2·76
(–4·41 o
–0·86)*
–5·31
(–8·41 o
–1·95)*
82·50
(64·41 o
94·45)
81·01
(62·43 o
93·88)
79·29
(60·18 o
93·34)
–1·81
(–3·21 o
–0·60)*
–2·12
(–3·59 o
–0·53)*
–3·89
(–6·61 o
–1·16)*
–4·59
(–7·46 o
–1·59)*
3 Die low in
polyunsa u a ed
a y acids
45·06
(43·63 o
46·41)
42·75
(41·51 o
43·97)
39·59
(38·34 o
40·95)
–5·12
(–8·80 o
–1·13)*
–7·39
(–10·43 o
–4·14)*
–12·13
(–15·52 o
–8·13)*
42·88
(41·39 o
44·43)
42·13
(40·86 o
43·41)
39·01
(37·71 o
40·27)
–1·75
(–6·01 o
2·86)
–7·42
(–10·78
o
–3·74)*
–9·03
(–13·10 o
–4·82)*
–10·66
(–13·33 o
–7·81)*
3 Die high in
ans a y acids
7·64
(3·38 o
13·77)
4·95
(1·69 o
10·43)
3·65
(0·96 o
8·75)
–35·13
(–52·63 o
–22·20)*
–26·21
(–45·06
o
–14·67)*
–52·13
(–72·97 o
–33·77)*
10·53
(5·22 o
17·83)
7·03
(2·87 o
13·30)
5·21
(1·73 o
11·02)
–33·22
(–46·91 o
–21·80)*
–25·92
(–42·55
o
–15·38)*
–50·53
(–68·52 o
–34·00)*
–51·32
(–70·08 o
–34·10)*
3 Die high in
sodium
44·14
(19·26 o
76·14)
40·66
(12·48 o
76·89)
39·77
(11·77 o
76·42)
–7·89
(–35·22 o
1·07)
–2·18
(–9·26 o
–0·40)*
–9·89
(–40·40 o
0·12)
43·80
(18·77 o
76·78)
37·98
(11·76 o
74·27)
36·22
(10·50 o
72·98)
–13·29
(–38·80 o
–2·86)*
–4·64
(–12·09
o
–1·57)*
–17·32
(–44·79 o
–4·79)*
–13·63
(–42·22 o
–2·33)*
2 Sexual abuse and iolence
3 Childhood sexual
abuse
6·78
(5·66 o
8·02)
6·81
(5·72 o
7·98)
7·09
(5·94 o
8·33)
0·46
(–0·56 o
1·57)
4·10
(3·41 o
4·77)*
4·58
(3·92 o
5·29)*
7·78
(6·57 o
9·20)
7·51
(6·39 o
8·83)
7·68
(6·46 o
9·06)
–3·44
(–4·40 o
–2·36)*
2·23
(1·23 o
3·13)*
–1·29
(–2·41 o
0·17)
1·46
(0·76 o
2·27)*
3 In ima e pa ne
iolence
·· ·· ·· ·· ·· ·· 11·80
(10·05 o
13·42)
10·90
(9·40 o
12·26)
10·32
(8·88 o
11·63)
–7·62
(–8·80 o
–6·28)*
–5·33
(–5·90 o
–4·79)*
–12·55
(–13·59 o
–11·39)*
–12·80
(–13·82 o
–11·65)*
2 Low physical
ac i i y
18·02
(9·66 o
28·42)
18·16
(9·81 o
28·87)
18·25
(9·81 o
28·80)
0·78
(–28·27 o
39·60)
0·51
(–27·42 o
41·11)
1·30
(0·94 o
1·72)*
15·32
(8·52 o
23·82)
15·12
(8·42 o
23·35)
15·05
(8·33 o
23·45)
–1·28
(–30·22 o
37·56)
–0·49
(–28·76
o 41·07)
–1·77
(–2·31 o
–1·28)*
0·07
(–0·32 o
0·38)
1 Me abolic isks
2 High as ing
plasma glucose
2·87
(1·79 o
4·14)
3·68
(2·37 o
5·23)
3·70
(2·36 o
5·22)
28·39
(19·48 o
41·24)*
0·60
(–7·76 o
8·12)
29·17
(21·33 o
40·03)*
2·46
(1·48 o
3·73)
3·34
(2·14 o
4·76)
3·14
(1·97 o
4·55)
35·71
(20·73 o
59·93)*
–5·93
(–15·95
o 1·66)
27·66
(18·53 o
42·31)*
28·77
(21·32 o
39·87)*
2High o al
choles e ol
17·43
(13·61 o
21·82)
16·87
(13·07 o
21·24)
16·75
(12·96 o
21·12)
–3·20
(–4·08 o
–2·45)*
–0·74
(–1·28 o
–0·21)*
–3·91
(–4·91 o
–2·98)*
20·14
(16·16 o
24·66)
19·30
(15·40 o
23·74)
19·05
(15·10 o
23·49)
–4·17
(–5·13 o
–3·34)*
–1·29
(–1·91 o
–0·68)*
–5·41
(–6·65 o
–4·34)*
–5·12
(–6·23 o
–4·19)*
(Table 3 con inues on nex page)
Global Heal h Me ics
1376
www. helance .com Vol 390 Sep embe 16, 2017
2006 dea hs
(in housands)
2016 dea hs
(in housands)
Pe cen age
change o dea hs
2006–16
Pe cen age
change o age-
s anda dised
dea hs a e
2006–16
2006 DALYs
(in housands)
2016 DALYs
(in housands)
Pe cen age
change o DALYs
2006–16
Pe cen age change
o age-
s anda dised
DALYs a e
2006–16
(Con inued om p e ious page)
·· A ial ib illa ion and
lu e
1·76
(0·65 o 3·49)
2·45
(0·88 o 4·91)
39·22
(29·86 o 46·04)*
0·69
(–2·60 o 4·79)
69·13
(28·74 o 129·13)
83·64
(32·94 o 159·75)
20·99
(12·73 o 25·56)*
–6·93
(–12·49 o –4·15)*
·· Ao ic aneu ysm 1·52
(0·54 o 2·93)
1·63
(0·55 o 3·25)
7·18
(–2·91 o 14·30)
–17·85
(–24·53 o –13·48)*
32·04
(11·44 o 61·16)
32·04
(10·70 o 62·83)
0·01
(–9·81 o 6·58)
–21·90
(–29·35 o –16·99)*
·· Pe iphe al ascula
disease
0·16
(0·03 o 0·41)
0·20
(0·03 o 0·53)
19·84
(–2·64 o 35·45)
–11·54
(–24·29 o –3·03)*
5·60
(1·52 o 12·98)
6·34
(1·62 o 15·16)
13·07
(2·26 o 20·57)*
–13·53
(–21·26 o –9·06)*
·· Endoca di is 0·83
(0·29 o 1·74)
0·97
(0·32 o 2·09)
16·60
(4·99 o 26·41)*
–9·45
(–17·23 o –4·25)*
20·69
(6·81 o 43·39)
21·53
(6·70 o 47·48)
4·04
(–6·57 o 13·03)
–16·42
(–25·07 o –10·13)*
·· O he ca dio ascula
and ci cula o y
diseases
5·41
(1·95 o 10·17)
5·94
(1·95 o 11·38)
9·71
(–0·49 o 16·74)
–16·12
(–23·01 o –11·62)*
152·85
(52·63 o 310·64)
153·78
(48·05 o 324·49)
0·60
(–9·13 o 6·44)
–20·84
(–28·73 o –16·05)*
·· Idiopa hic
de elopmen al
in ellec ual disabili y
·· ·· ·· ·· 2916·48
(1228·14 o
5089·94)
2920·47
(1234·48 o
5155·20)
0·14
(–3·18 o 2·41)
–8·99
(–12·03 o –6·90)*
·· Ch onic kidney
disease due o
diabe es melli us
10·10
(4·15 o 18·35)
12·65
(5·09 o 23·20)
25·28
(19·04 o 29·44)*
–4·60
(–8·89 o –1·68)*
260·59
(102·04 o 495·91)
302·16
(113·45 o 584·15)
15·96
(9·37 o 20·09)*
–10·04
(–15·36 o –6·87)*
·· Ch onic kidney disease
due o hype ension
6·22
(2·72 o 11·32)
8·27
(3·62 o 15·14)
33·02
(27·46 o 37·34)*
–2·02
(–5·80 o 0·78)
128·17
(54·29 o 242·87)
155·62
(64·33 o 297·32)
21·42
(15·72 o 25·19)*
–6·97
(–11·22 o –4·21)*
·· Ch onic kidney
disease due o
glome uloneph i is
2·42
(0·93 o 4·54)
2·92
(1·08 o 5·50)
20·90
(15·70 o 26·39)*
–7·48
(–11·06 o –4·04)*
65·59
(21·46 o 133·89)
70·02
(22·73 o 143·93)
6·76
(0·61 o 11·59)*
–15·00
(–20·26 o –11·29)*
·· Ch onic kidney disease
due o o he causes
4·42
(1·88 o 8·20)
5·69
(2·39 o 10·62)
28·68
(22·76 o 34·24)*
–2·47
(–6·62 o 1·13)
111·53
(43·93 o 213·01)
126·74
(48·88 o 248·43)
13·63
(7·40 o 18·08)*
–10·64
(–15·64 o –6·92)*
2 Occupa ional isks: all
causes
1409·60
(1288·25 o
1539·63)
1528·02
(1383·55 o
1680·97)
8·40
(6·20 o 10·41)*
–14·80
(–16·48 o
–13·37)*
68 543·89
(60 461·38 o
77 147·09)
75 925·43
(66 060·97 o
86 257·10)
10·77
(8·84 o 12·62)*
–8·98
(–10·61 o –7·49)*
3 Occupa ional
ca cinogens: all causes
628·39
(529·77 o
733·38)
746·54
(624·13 o
874·38)
18·80
(16·21 o 21·35)*
–8·62
(–10·42 o –6·83)*
17 462·68
(14 595·36 o
20 617·18)
20 682·73
(17 015·37 o
24 682·77)
18·44
(15·67 o 21·04)*
–7·56
(–9·50 o –5·67)*
4 Occupa ional exposu e
o asbes os: all causes
187·83
(142·94 o
233·46)
222·32
(168·96 o
277·92)
18·36
(15·32 o 21·47)*
–10·30
(–12·67 o –7·98)*
3197·37
(2410·48 o
4019·53)
3640·71
(2743·34 o
4594·60)
13·87
(11·05 o 16·82)*
–12·65
(–14·84 o –10·38)*
·· La ynx cance 3·25
(1·80 o 4·82)
3·74
(2·02 o 5·53)
15·08
(11·70 o 18·64)*
–13·01
(–15·58 o –10·35)*
59·03
(32·22 o 89·00)
65·51
(35·04 o 99·12)
10·97
(7·31 o 14·61)*
–15·26
(–18·03 o –12·51)*
·· T acheal, b onchus,
and lung cance
155·24
(111·10 o
201·47)
181·45
(128·29 o
236·62)
16·88
(13·29 o 20·48)*
–11·40
(–14·19 o –8·74)*
2539·55
(1770·09 o
3359·44)
2844·28
(1957·87 o
3803·22)
12·00
(8·53 o 15·59)*
–14·15
(–16·73 o –11·42)*
·· O a ian cance 5·16
(2·58 o 7·94)
6·02
(2·98 o 9·40)
16·73
(9·65 o 23·13)*
–13·33
(–18·64 o –8·71)*
82·25
(40·54 o 128·84)
93·12
(45·80 o 149·95)
13·21
(5·49 o 20·04)*
–13·97
(–19·78 o –8·87)*
·· Meso helioma 21·29
(20·16 o
22·57)
27·61
(25·56 o
29·34)
29·68
(23·73 o 34·79)*
–1·06
(–5·59 o 2·90)
443·53
(413·23 o 481·26)
553·97
(507·29 o 597·78)
24·90
(19·28 o
29·80)*
–3·39
(–7·70 o 0·41)
·· Asbes osis 2·89
(1·92 o 3·56)
3·49
(2·43 o 4·06)
21·00
(13·33 o 30·87)*
–7·91
(–13·67 o –0·40)*
73·00
(57·24 o 86·90)
83·83
(67·86 o 97·43)
14·83
(9·18 o 21·83)*
–9·23
(–13·68 o –3·33)*
4 Occupa ional exposu e
o a senic: all causes
6·55
(1·52 o 11·97)
8·07
(2·05 o 14·63)
23·27
(18·26 o 35·03)*
–5·27
(–9·14 o 4·00)
182·17
(43·97 o 330·51)
219·22
(57·76 o 395·48)
20·34
(15·23 o 31·54)*
–6·95
(–10·91 o 2·16)
·· T acheal, b onchus,
and lung cance
6·55
(1·52 o 11·97)
8·07
(2·05 o 14·63)
23·27
(18·26 o 35·03)*
–5·27
(–9·14 o 4·00)
182·17
(43·97 o 330·51)
219·22
(57·76 o 395·48)
20·34
(15·23 o 31·54)*
–6·95
(–10·91 o 2·16)
4 Occupa ional exposu e
o benzene: all causes
1·63
(0·52 o 2·67)
1·90
(0·60 o 3·12)
16·21
(11·28 o 21·54)*
–1·47
(–6·03 o 3·50)
74·24
(23·12 o 121·81)
83·87
(25·51 o 138·49)
12·97
(8·01 o 18·09)*
–2·29
(–6·92 o 2·56)
·· Leukaemia 1·63
(0·52 o 2·67)
1·90
(0·60 o 3·12)
16·21
(11·28 o 21·54)*
–1·47
(–6·03 o 3·50)
74·24
(23·12 o 121·81)
83·87
(25·51 o 138·49)
12·97
(8·01 o 18·09)*
–2·29
(–6·92 o 2·56)
·· Acu e lymphoid
leukaemia
0·28
(0·09 o 0·46)
0·37
(0·11 o 0·62)
32·70
(19·53 o 41·21)*
14·39
(3·02 o 21·87)*
13·95
(4·29 o 22·85)
18·08
(5·39 o 29·97)
29·59
(16·43 o 37·84)*
13·73
(2·19 o 21·17)*
(Table 4 con inues on nex page)
Global Heal h Me ics
www. helance .com Vol 390 Sep embe 16, 2017
1377
2006 dea hs
(in housands)
2016 dea hs
(in housands)
Pe cen age
change o dea hs
2006–16
Pe cen age
change o age-
s anda dised
dea hs a e
2006–16
2006 DALYs
(in housands)
2016 DALYs
(in housands)
Pe cen age
change o DALYs
2006–16
Pe cen age change
o age-
s anda dised
DALYs a e
2006–16
(Con inued om p e ious page)
·· Ch onic lymphoid
leukaemia
0·09
(0·03 o 0·15)
0·11
(0·04 o 0·19)
24·21
(16·84 o 35·39)*
0·43
(–6·33 o 10·47)
3·30
(1·12 o 5·43)
4·07
(1·35 o 6·69)
23·32
(15·50 o 33·93)*
1·98
(–5·31 o 11·94)
·· Acu e myeloid
leukaemia
0·41
(0·14 o 0·67)
0·54
(0·18 o 0·90)
32·16
(24·33 o 41·56)*
11·07
(3·73 o 20·10)*
17·90
(6·04 o 29·37)
23·24
(7·47 o 38·33)
29·83
(21·43 o 39·32)*
11·51
(3·58 o 20·44)*
·· Ch onic myeloid
leukaemia
0·15
(0·05 o 0·24)
0·15
(0·05 o 0·25)
4·79
(–3·59 o 14·00)
–11·79
(–18·96 o –3·60)*
6·60
(2·12 o 10·80)
6·86
(2·14 o 11·39)
4·04
(–4·07 o 13·79)
–10·84
(–18·16 o –2·42)*
·· O he leukaemia 0·70
(0·21 o 1·16)
0·71
(0·21 o 1·19)
1·61
(–4·21 o 7·56)
–13·30
(–18·31 o –8·34)*
32·49
(9·76 o 53·35)
31·62
(9·61 o 52·92)
–2·70
(–8·57 o 3·32)
–15·49
(–20·60 o –10·44)*
4 Occupa ional exposu e
o be yllium: all causes
0·20
(0·17 o 0·24)
0·26
(0·21 o 0·31)
28·93
(22·38 o 34·98)*
–0·80
(–4·98 o 2·96)
5·76
(4·76 o 6·81)
7·22
(5·89 o 8·59)
25·48
(18·89 o 31·61)*
–2·63
(–6·90 o 1·11)
·· T acheal, b onchus,
and lung cance
0·20
(0·17 o 0·24)
0·26
(0·21 o 0·31)
28·93
(22·38 o 34·98)*
–0·80
(–4·98 o 2·96)
5·76
(4·76 o 6·81)
7·22
(5·89 o 8·59)
25·48
(18·89 o 31·61)*
–2·63
(–6·90 o 1·11)
4 Occupa ional exposu e
o cadmium: all causes
0·46
(0·39 o 0·53)
0·61
(0·50 o 0·71)
31·38
(24·62 o 37·82)*
1·00
(–3·45 o 5·10)
13·15
(11·14 o 15·16)
16·83
(14·14 o 19·64)
28·00
(21·21 o 34·47)*
–0·75
(–5·34 o 3·51)
·· T acheal, b onchus,
and lung cance
0·46
(0·39 o 0·53)
0·61
(0·50 o 0·71)
31·38
(24·62 o 37·82)*
1·00
(–3·45 o 5·10)
13·15
(11·14 o 15·16)
16·83
(14·14 o 19·64)
28·00
(21·21 o 34·47)*
–0·75
(–5·34 o 3·51)
4 Occupa ional exposu e
o ch omium: all causes
0·96
(0·86 o 1·07)
1·28
(1·13 o 1·44)
33·02
(27·40 o 38·50)*
2·28
(–1·68 o 6·05)
27·33
(24·34 o 30·24)
35·45
(31·40 o 40·17)
29·71
(24·03 o 35·28)*
0·57
(–3·49 o 4·55)
·· T acheal, b onchus,
and lung cance
0·96
(0·86 o 1·07)
1·28
(1·13 o 1·44)
33·02
(27·40 o 38·50)*
2·28
(–1·68 o 6·05)
27·33
(24·34 o 30·24)
35·45
(31·40 o 40·17)
29·71
(24·03 o 35·28)*
0·57
(–3·49 o 4·55)
4 Occupa ional exposu e
o diesel engine
exhaus : all causes
13·41
(11·85 o
15·17)
17·50
(15·20 o
20·06)
30·45
(24·63 o 35·78)*
0·26
(–3·89 o 3·78)
381·69
(337·43 o 428·72)
485·69
(426·18 o 553·93)
27·25
(21·26 o 32·75)*
–1·40
(–5·65 o 2·19)
·· T acheal, b onchus,
and lung cance
13·41
(11·85 o
15·17)
17·50
(15·20 o
20·06)
30·45
(24·63 o 35·78)*
0·26
(–3·89 o 3·78)
381·69
(337·43 o 428·72)
485·69
(426·18 o 553·93)
27·25
(21·26 o 32·75)*
–1·40
(–5·65 o 2·19)
4 Occupa ional exposu e
o second-hand smoke:
all causes
364·05
(275·49 o
465·66)
433·15
(326·16 o
554·32)
18·98
(15·73 o 22·42)*
–7·67
(–9·82 o –5·44)*
12 060·36
(9008·45 o
15 202·22)
14 474·34
(10 754·05 o
18 289·00)
20·02
(16·70 o 23·11)*
–5·73
(–7·98 o –3·57)*
·· Lowe espi a o y
in ec ions
25·22
(11·95 o
41·26)
31·03
(14·71 o
51·31)
23·07
(18·77 o 27·30)*
–3·05
(–6·52 o 0·24)
754·30
(355·32 o
1235·87)
901·83
(424·90 o
1491·75)
19·56
(15·20 o 24·09)*
–4·55
(–7·93 o –1·02)*
·· O i is media 0·00
(0·00 o 0·00)
0·00
(0·00 o 0·00)
–51·34
(–68·17 o
–26·94)*
–53·19
(–69·51 o –29·77)*
0·00
(0·00 o 0·00)
0·00
(0·00 o 0·00)
–0·26
(–3·00 o 2·10)
–4·95
(–7·62 o –2·74)*
·· T acheal, b onchus,
and lung cance
36·79
(17·19 o
62·63)
44·38
(20·66 o
75·46)
20·63
(16·93 o 23·85)*
–7·23
(–10·03 o –4·78)*
1009·34
(472·19 o
1717·66)
1185·42
(551·75 o
2013·66)
17·45
(13·68 o 20·74)*
–9·21
(–12·08 o –6·69)*
·· B eas cance 3·93
(0·93 o 6·85)
4·86
(1·19 o 8·40)
23·68
(16·23 o 31·66)*
–3·23
(–9·07 o 2·90)
131·38
(30·86 o 228·23)
160·49
(39·88 o 276·83)
22·16
(14·48 o
30·64)*
–3·10
(–9·13 o 3·41)
·· Ischaemic hea
disease
145·11
(108·16 o
184·75)
177·23
(131·12 o
226·23)
22·13
(16·84 o 27·55)*
–4·86
(–7·90 o –1·79)*
4427·58
(3270·63 o
5659·16)
5337·92
(3904·37 o
6856·49)
20·56
(15·58 o 25·71)*
–4·76
(–7·77 o –1·66)*
·· Ischaemic s oke 24·76
(17·40 o
32·82)
28·32
(19·67 o
38·37)
14·40
(7·34 o 21·60)*
–12·26
(–16·32 o –8·12)*
749·82
(529·06 o
995·24)
892·52
(616·96 o
1211·73)
19·03
(12·07 o 26·19)*
–8·13
(–12·07 o –4·39)*
·· Haemo hagic s oke 52·38
(37·29 o
69·30)
56·78
(39·66 o
75·11)
8·39
(3·67 o 13·19)*
–15·19
(–17·69 o –12·61)*
1679·51
(1187·37 o
2237·60)
1799·87
(1247·86 o
2400·70)
7·17
(2·54 o 11·92)*
–14·80
(–17·22 o –12·28)*
·· Ch onic obs uc i e
pulmona y disease
48·15
(22·29 o
85·80)
51·90
(23·79 o
91·43)
7·78
(4·30 o 11·52)*
–17·01
(–19·72 o –14·14)*
1570·14
(727·09 o
2820·77)
1819·99
(831·20 o
3260·92)
15·91
(12·59 o 19·00)*
–10·63
(–13·17 o –8·26)*
·· Diabe es melli us 27·71
(10·20 o
43·82)
38·64
(14·31 o
60·82)
39·45
(37·04 o 42·10)*
7·38
(5·52 o 9·33)*
1738·30
(616·68 o
2847·07)
2376·30
(847·55 o
3851·52)
36·70
(34·59 o
39·02)*
7·55
(5·95 o 9·37)*
(Table 4 con inues on nex page)
Global Heal h Me ics
1378
www. helance .com Vol 390 Sep embe 16, 2017
2006 dea hs
(in housands)
2016 dea hs
(in housands)
Pe cen age
change o dea hs
2006–16
Pe cen age
change o age-
s anda dised
dea hs a e
2006–16
2006 DALYs
(in housands)
2016 DALYs
(in housands)
Pe cen age
change o DALYs
2006–16
Pe cen age change
o age-
s anda dised
DALYs a e
2006–16
(Con inued om p e ious page)
4 Occupa ional exposu e
o o maldehyde: all
causes
0·95
(0·78 o 1·15)
1·09
(0·90 o 1·32)
13·89
(5·40 o 22·94)*
–4·03
(–10·29 o 2·45)
42·70
(35·09 o 51·51)
46·93
(38·81 o 56·99)
9·90
(1·78 o 18·05)*
–5·67
(–12·09 o 0·77)
·· Nasopha ynx cance 0·42
(0·29 o 0·58)
0·48
(0·33 o 0·68)
13·08
(–1·13 o 29·19)
–6·37
(–16·69 o 4·83)
17·57
(11·88 o 24·10)
19·02
(12·99 o 27·09)
8·25
(–5·73 o 24·38)
–8·78
(–19·03 o 3·13)
·· Acu e lymphoid
leukaemia
0·09
(0·08 o 0·11)
0·13
(0·11 o 0·15)
34·88
(18·69 o 42·16)*
16·60
(3·46 o 22·11)*
4·72
(3·86 o 5·83)
6·21
(5·02 o 7·60)
31·43
(16·61 o 38·79)*
15·52
(2·59 o 21·35)*
·· Ch onic lymphoid
leukaemia
0·02
(0·02 o 0·03)
0·03
(0·03 o 0·04)
30·39
(20·80 o 38·61)*
7·25
(0·20 o 13·50)*
0·95
(0·79 o 1·17)
1·22
(1·02 o 1·44)
27·96
(16·27 o 37·10)*
7·86
(–0·97 o 15·12)
·· Acu e myeloid
leukaemia
0·11
(0·09 o 0·13)
0·15
(0·12 o 0·18)
35·38
(28·55 o 41·33)*
15·11
(9·74 o 19·69)*
5·06
(4·14 o 6·15)
6·70
(5·54 o 8·16)
32·57
(25·83 o 39·02)*
14·91
(9·32 o 20·00)*
·· Ch onic myeloid
leukaemia
0·04
(0·04 o 0·05)
0·05
(0·04 o 0·06)
6·23
(0·31 o 13·49)*
–9·89
(–14·91 o –4·16)*
2·05
(1·66 o 2·53)
2·15
(1·73 o 2·65)
4·77
(–1·61 o 12·57)
–9·72
(–15·13 o –3·27)*
·· O he leukaemia 0·26
(0·21 o 0·31)
0·26
(0·21 o 0·31)
–1·61
(–9·46 o 6·91)
–15·64
(–21·92 o –9·05)*
12·35
(9·66 o 14·91)
11·64
(9·27 o 14·19)
–5·80
(–13·73 o 2·60)
–17·95
(–24·52 o –11·12)*
4 Occupa ional exposu e
o nickel: all causes
6·68
(0·95 o 17·47)
8·10
(1·24 o 20·81)
21·35
(15·63 o 32·69)*
–6·73
(–11·14 o 2·03)
187·01
(27·49 o 483·87)
221·35
(34·93 o 563·34)
18·37
(12·66 o
29·20)*
–8·40
(–12·92 o 0·27)
·· T acheal, b onchus,
and lung cance
6·68
(0·95 o 17·47)
8·10
(1·24 o 20·81)
21·35
(15·63 o 32·69)*
–6·73
(–11·14 o 2·03)
187·01
(27·49 o 483·87)
221·35
(34·93 o 563·34)
18·37
(12·66 o
29·20)*
–8·40
(–12·92 o 0·27)
4 Occupa ional exposu e
o polycyclic a oma ic
hyd oca bons: all causes
3·41
(2·89 o 3·92)
4·53
(3·83 o 5·29)
32·92
(26·40 o 39·18)*
2·21
(–2·06 o 6·07)
97·03
(82·37 o 111·83)
125·78
(105·37 o 145·87)
29·63
(22·78 o 35·89)*
0·51
(–4·05 o 4·55)
·· T acheal, b onchus,
and lung cance
3·41
(2·89 o 3·92)
4·53
(3·83 o 5·29)
32·92
(26·40 o 39·18)*
2·21
(–2·06 o 6·07)
97·03
(82·37 o 111·83)
125·78
(105·37 o 145·87)
29·63
(22·78 o 35·89)*
0·51
(–4·05 o 4·55)
4 Occupa ional exposu e
o silica: all causes
50·95
(28·57 o
73·67)
58·40
(31·42 o
86·00)
14·63
(8·41 o 19·51)*
–12·09
(–16·90 o –8·34)*
1396·95
(774·36 o
2030·14)
1574·57
(860·21 o
2314·76)
12·71
(6·89 o 17·49)*
–12·64
(–17·10 o –8·94)*
·· T acheal, b onchus,
and lung cance
40·38
(17·91 o
63·22)
48·00
(21·24 o
75·45)
18·88
(13·37 o 24·69)*
–8·64
(–12·83 o –4·21)*
1123·77
(503·32 o
1756·69)
1303·95
(576·29 o
2042·00)
16·03
(10·58 o 21·66)*
–10·26
(–14·61 o –5·78)*
·· Silicosis 10·57
(9·77 o 12·23)
10·40
(9·57 o 11·68)
–1·60
(–14·72 o 5·54)
–24·35
(–34·05 o –18·99)*
273·19
(247·13 o 310·72)
270·62
(243·58 o 301·41)
–0·94
(–14·17 o 5·65)
–22·15
(–32·16 o –17·05)*
4 Occupa ional exposu e
o sul u ic acid: all
causes
2·96
(1·27 o 5·35)
3·54
(1·52 o 6·49)
19·47
(13·15 o 26·36)*
–8·14
(–12·96 o –2·92)*
89·85
(38·68 o 161·94)
105·23
(45·84 o 192·42)
17·12
(10·83 o 23·79)*
–9·04
(–13·97 o –3·84)*
·· La ynx cance 2·96
(1·27 o 5·35)
3·54
(1·52 o 6·49)
19·47
(13·15 o 26·36)*
–8·14
(–12·96 o –2·92)*
89·85
(38·68 o 161·94)
105·23
(45·84 o 192·42)
17·12
(10·83 o 23·79)*
–9·04
(–13·97 o –3·84)*
4 Occupa ional exposu e
o ichlo oe hylene: all
causes
0·04
(0·01 o 0·07)
0·06
(0·01 o 0·11)
48·91
(43·08 o 53·27)*
14·75
(10·28 o 18·08)*
1·17
(0·26 o 2·16)
1·72
(0·38 o 3·23)
47·21
(41·37 o 51·60)*
14·65
(10·09 o 17·96)*
·· Kidney cance 0·04
(0·01 o 0·07)
0·06
(0·01 o 0·11)
48·91
(43·08 o 53·27)*
14·75
(10·28 o 18·08)*
1·17
(0·26 o 2·16)
1·72
(0·38 o 3·23)
47·21
(41·37 o 51·60)*
14·65
(10·09 o 17·96)*
3 Occupa ional
as hmagens: all causes
36·83
(26·75 o
47·73)
37·57
(28·36 o
47·94)
2·02
(–6·22 o 10·50)
–19·40
(–25·79 o –12·65)*
2122·64
(1699·18 o
2619·54)
2339·48
(1860·90 o
2923·32)
10·22
(4·21 o 15·66)*
–8·91
(–14·66 o –3·71)*
·· As hma 36·83
(26·75 o
47·73)
37·57
(28·36 o
47·94)
2·02
(–6·22 o 10·50)
–19·40
(–25·79 o –12·65)*
2122·64
(1699·18 o
2619·54)
2339·48
(1860·90 o
2923·32)
10·22
(4·21 o 15·66)*
–8·91
(–14·66 o –3·71)*
3 Occupa ional pa icula e
ma e , gases, and
umes: all causes
407·53
(338·66 o
479·12)
424·27
(349·98 o
507·55)
4·11
(–0·16 o 8·15)
–21·37
(–23·97 o –18·61)*
8771·11
(7497·47 o
10 068·75)
9377·10
(7972·61 o
10 789·56)
6·91
(3·78 o 10·55)*
–17·84
(–19·96 o –15·42)*
·· Ch onic obs uc i e
pulmona y disease
399·93
(331·13 o
472·15)
416·68
(342·87 o
499·76)
4·19
(–0·04 o 8·27)
–21·32
(–23·94 o –18·63)*
8557·06
(7276·89 o
9859·70)
9154·55
(7771·09 o
10 539·37)
6·98
(3·85 o 10·70)*
–17·82
(–19·97 o –15·30)*
(Table 4 con inues on nex page)
Global Heal h Me ics
www. helance .com Vol 390 Sep embe 16, 2017
1379
2006 dea hs
(in housands)
2016 dea hs
(in housands)
Pe cen age
change o dea hs
2006–16
Pe cen age
change o age-
s anda dised
dea hs a e
2006–16
2006 DALYs
(in housands)
2016 DALYs
(in housands)
Pe cen age
change o DALYs
2006–16
Pe cen age change
o age-
s anda dised
DALYs a e
2006–16
(Con inued om p e ious page)
·· Coal wo ke s
pneumoconiosis
3·03
(1·91 o 3·49)
2·68
(1·79 o 3·07)
–11·29
(–19·54 o 0·39)
–32·63
(–38·84 o –23·91)*
87·45
(65·52 o 104·62)
89·05
(70·16 o 108·86)
1·83
(–6·81 o 12·73)
–21·65
(–28·21 o –13·50)*
·· O he
pneumoconiosis
4·57
(3·71 o 6·32)
4·91
(4·16 o 6·56)
7·27
(–1·26 o 15·86)
–17·49
(–24·05 o –11·05)*
126·59
(104·34 o 161·76)
133·51
(112·07 o 165·88)
5·46
(–2·23 o 13·23)
–16·68
(–22·73 o –10·63)*
3 Occupa ional noise: all
causes
·· ·· ·· ·· 5865·39
(4107·31 o
8092·94)
7108·28
(4978·56 o
9802·69)
21·19
(19·01 o 22·96)*
–0·74
(–2·21 o 0·56)
·· Age- ela ed and o he
hea ing loss
·· ·· ·· ·· 5865·39
(4107·31 o
8092·94)
7108·28
(4978·56 o
9802·69)
21·19
(19·01 o 22·96)*
–0·74
(–2·21 o 0·56)
3 Occupa ional inju ies: all
causes
352·96
(344·63 o
360·98)
335·71
(328·64 o
343·27)
–4·89
(–7·71 o –1·89)*
–17·78
(–20·22 o –15·20)*
21 906·21
(20 353·14 o
23 776·95)
21 774·60
(19 810·66 o
24 090·16)
–0·60
(–4·19 o 2·98)
–12·95
(–15·95 o –9·94)*
·· Pedes ian oad
inju ies
67·01
(62·03 o
73·85)
63·97
(59·35 o
69·72)
–4·53
(–10·63 o 0·01)
–18·09
(–23·28 o –14·24)*
3434·81
(3182·07 o
3771·04)
3278·98
(3037·91 o
3549·98)
–4·54
(–10·46 o
–0·04)*
–16·52
(–21·66 o –12·63)*
·· Cyclis oad inju ies 10·32
(9·27 o 11·62)
9·99
(8·96 o 11·51)
–3·16
(–8·97 o 5·60)
–17·77
(–22·81 o –10·17)*
673·49
(580·35 o 787·54)
707·70
(596·26 o 850·17)
5·08
(–0·72 o 11·51)
–9·29
(–14·16 o –3·79)*
·· Mo o cyclis oad
inju ies
44·53
(40·17 o
49·15)
42·56
(38·79 o
46·82)
–4·41
(–9·93 o 0·93)
–15·65
(–20·46 o
–10·89)*
2623·88
(2388·56 o
2894·57)
2549·86
(2330·54 o
2817·91)
–2·82
(–8·29 o 2·44)
–13·57
(–18·33 o –9·00)*
·· Mo o ehicle oad
inju ies
74·30
(65·78 o
85·66)
73·17
(67·36 o
83·11)
–1·51
(–6·37 o 7·20)
–13·94
(–18·25 o –6·31)*
4091·59
(3653·03 o
4667·92)
4058·76
(3712·02 o
4590·12)
–0·80
(–5·44 o 7·38)
–12·17
(–16·25 o –4·94)*
·· O he oad inju ies 1·98
(1·74 o 2·43)
1·88
(1·68 o 2·28)
–5·05
(–12·93 o 5·85)
–18·33
(–25·07 o –8·69)*
167·13
(137·60 o 207·71)
198·25
(158·96 o 254·29)
18·62
(9·95 o 27·66)*
2·77
(–4·57 o 10·39)
·· O he anspo
inju ies
14·25
(12·59 o
15·77)
13·71
(12·58 o
14·97)
–3·74
(–11·07 o 5·18)
–16·70
(–22·82 o –8·99)*
970·91
(855·69 o
1109·73)
969·10
(847·30 o
1119·40)
–0·19
(–6·23 o 6·80)
–12·66
(–17·77 o –6·62)*
·· Falls 38·58
(34·48 o
40·43)
39·52
(36·06 o
41·41)
2·42
(–3·75 o 8·20)
–14·40
(–19·49 o –9·55)*
3253·95
(2718·82 o
3890·24)
3637·49
(3004·39 o
4424·49)
11·79
(6·86 o 16·48)*
–4·69
(–8·77 o –0·73)*
·· D owning 29·91
(28·60 o
31·52)
26·74
(25·32 o
28·13)
–10·60
(–14·16 o
–6·83)*
–21·41
(–24·53 o –18·10)*
1558·83
(1491·01 o
1643·06)
1365·42
(1294·39 o
1433·95)
–12·41
(–15·98 o
–8·51)*
–21·39
(–24·55 o –17·92)*
.. Fi e, hea , and ho
subs ances
10·40
(9·05 o 11·29)
9·42
(8·02 o 10·46)
–9·40
(–14·52 o –4·17)*
–22·76
(–27·12 o –18·35)*
749·03
(646·32 o
879·73)
758·15
(626·89 o 922·03)
1·22
(–4·90 o 6·74)
–11·99
(–17·27 o –7·18)*
.. Poisonings 6·69
(5·21 o 7·55)
5·85
(4·37 o 6·54)
–12·57
(–23·95 o 3·86)
–24·93
(–34·60 o –11·05)*
351·08
(280·67 o 395·21)
313·70
(244·88 o 347·77)
–10·65
(–20·53 o 3·82)
–21·69
(–30·25 o –9·04)*
.. Unin en ional i ea m
inju ies
4·19
(3·23 o 4·60)
3·83
(2·80 o 4·20)
–8·61
(–17·66 o 0·01)
–19·38
(–27·38 o –11·76)*
253·51
(198·88 o
282·79)
240·12
(181·74 o 271·14)
–5·28
(–13·02 o 2·95)
–15·61
(–22·69 o –8·27)*
·· Unin en ional
su oca ion
0·77
(0·68 o 0·90)
0·92
(0·67 o 1·04)
19·08
(–7·56 o 34·67)
4·58
(–18·86 o 18·24)
69·06
(56·28 o 86·36)
80·23
(63·30 o 101·14)
16·18
(1·23 o 25·85)*
2·43
(–10·54 o 10·82)
·· O he exposu e o
mechanical o ces
17·58
(13·83 o
18·79)
15·29
(11·75 o
16·30)
–13·04
(–17·93 o
–8·65)*
–24·91
(–29·14 o –21·17)*
1292·58
(1072·42 o
1512·50)
1290·07
(1044·64 o
1570·19)
–0·19
(–5·99 o 5·81)
–13·26
(–18·20 o –8·29)*
·· Venomous animal
con ac
6·92
(6·26 o 7·56)
5·66
(5·21 o 6·27)
–18·20
(–25·20 o
–6·78)*
–30·45
(–36·32 o –20·64)*
446·07
(390·64 o
500·68)
389·47
(338·03 o 449·59)
–12·69
(–19·31 o
–3·42)*
–23·84
(–29·63 o –15·81)*
·· Non- enomous
animal con ac
1·47
(1·09 o 1·80)
1·32
(0·99 o 1·71)
–9·58
(–17·89 o 0·09)
–23·14
(–30·13 o –14·72)*
122·37
(93·44 o 157·70)
116·27
(88·44 o 149·33)
–4·98
(–11·38 o 1·81)
–17·63
(–22·98 o –11·96)*
·· Pulmona y aspi a ion
and o eign body in
ai way
5·70
(5·08 o 6·60)
6·15
(5·50 o 7·31)
8·00
(0·69 o 17·21)*
–8·88
(–15·06 o –1·29)*
368·39
(314·09 o 433·78)
400·88
(341·30 o 484·16)
8·82
(2·49 o 15·63)*
–5·71
(–11·16 o 0·22)
(Table 4 con inues on nex page)
Global Heal h Me ics
1380
www. helance .com Vol 390 Sep embe 16, 2017
2006 dea hs
(in housands)
2016 dea hs
(in housands)
Pe cen age
change o dea hs
2006–16
Pe cen age
change o age-
s anda dised
dea hs a e
2006–16
2006 DALYs
(in housands)
2016 DALYs
(in housands)
Pe cen age
change o DALYs
2006–16
Pe cen age change
o age-
s anda dised
DALYs a e
2006–16
(Con inued om p e ious page)
·· Fo eign body in o he
body pa
1·03
(0·70 o 1·32)
1·05
(0·76 o 1·32)
1·96
(–7·01 o 15·08)
–11·39
(–19·07 o –0·51)*
123·60
(91·48 o 162·21)
136·41
(101·25 o 180·00)
10·37
(3·84 o 16·97)*
–3·80
(–9·33 o 1·81)
·· O he unin en ional
inju ies
17·35
(15·52 o
18·15)
14·67
(12·87 o
15·41)
–15·45
(–19·85 o
–11·30)*
–26·15
(–30·00 o –22·53)*
1355·94
(1171·12 o
1583·40)
1283·74
(1074·02 o
1552·79)
–5·32
(–10·48 o
–0·38)*
–17·08
(–21·56 o –12·93)*
3Occupa ional e gonomic
ac o s: all causes
·· ·· ·· ·· 13 229·58
(9255·44 o
17 770·82)
15 479·93
(10 733·37 o
20 772·45)
17·01
(14·86 o 19·35)*
–1·74
(–3·26 o –0·45)*
·· Low back pain ·· ·· ·· ·· 13 229·58
(9255·44 o
17 770·82)
15 479·93
(10 733·37 o
20 772·45)
17·01
(14·86 o 19·35)*
–1·74
(–3·26 o –0·45)*
1 Beha iou al isks: all
causes
22 393·17
(21 227·31 o
23 619·19)
21 830·19
(20 450·24 o
23 314·12)
–2·51
(–4·89 o –0·13)*
–21·55
(–23·25 o
–19·81)*
910 996·12
(869 496·72 o
953 010·97)
781 103·69
(737 052·73 o
830 058·54)
–14·26
(–16·59 o
–11·83)*
–25·18
(–27·08 o –23·22)*
2 Child and ma e nal
malnu i ion: all causes
4301·09
(4107·68 o
4499·13)
2736·96
(2573·81 o
2904·34)
–36·37
(–39·81 o
–32·52)*
–36·99
(–40·42 o
–33·17)*
406 715·03
(385 244·16 o
429 424·87)
275 068·98
(255 117·96 o
296 600·82)
–32·37
(–36·04 o
–28·67)*
–33·64
(–37·18 o –30·01)*
3 Subop imal
b eas eeding: all causes
278·09
(223·03 o
332·55)
152·48
(124·06 o
183·65)
–45·17
(–50·75 o
–38·89)*
–45·59
(–51·13 o –39·40)*
24 214·14
(19 400·12 o
28 949·80)
13 373·25
(10 878·18 o
16 087·13)
–44·77
(–50·34 o
–38·57)*
–45·20
(–50·73 o –39·07)*
4 Non-exclusi e
b eas eeding: all causes
264·19
(210·54 o
318·37)
144·11
(116·21 o
173·92)
–45·45
(–51·08 o
–39·34)*
–45·79
(–51·39 o –39·70)*
22 971·14
(18 284·60 o
27 651·42)
12 598·41
(10 160·91 o
15 194·04)
–45·16
(–50·76 o
–39·06)*
–45·49
(–51·07 o –39·43)*
·· Dia hoeal diseases 169·62
(132·18 o
206·77)
88·76
(68·74 o
111·24)
–47·67
(–54·86 o
–39·28)*
–48·02
(–55·16 o –39·68)*
14 810·81
(11 518·55 o
18 077·32)
7821·54
(6057·18 o
9801·86)
–47·19
(–54·37 o
–38·91)*
–47·54
(–54·67 o –39·31)*
·· Lowe espi a o y
in ec ions
94·57
(62·35 o
130·16)
55·35
(35·96 o
75·66)
–41·47
(–46·49 o
–35·45)*
–41·79
(–46·78 o
–35·80)*
8160·33
(5381·55 o
11 233·53)
4776·87
(3103·20 o
6528·56)
–41·46
(–46·48 o
–35·45)*
–41·78
(–46·77 o –35·80)*
4 Discon inued
b eas eeding: all causes
16·70
(5·98 o 29·32)
10·04
(3·49 o 17·76)
–39·90
(–48·41 o
–29·27)*
–41·77
(–50·01 o –31·40)*
1490·66
(534·34 o
2615·99)
924·29
(322·52 o
1634·92)
–37·99
(–46·40 o
–27·87)*
–39·95
(–48·10 o –30·10)*
·· Dia hoeal diseases 16·70
(5·98 o 29·32)
10·04
(3·49 o 17·76)
–39·90
(–48·41 o
–29·27)*
–41·77
(–50·01 o –31·40)*
1490·66
(534·34 o
2615·99)
924·29
(322·52 o
1634·92)
–37·99
(–46·40 o
–27·87)*
–39·95
(–48·10 o –30·10)*
3 Child g ow h ailu e: all
causes
1874·90
(1718·60 o
2023·15)
1010·58
(908·98 o
1119·90)
–46·10
(–51·03 o
–40·34)*
–47·58
(–52·39 o –42·00)*
164 876·44
(151 738·69 o
177 603·01)
91 199·77
(82 272·24 o
100 948·47)
–44·69
(–49·42 o
–39·13)*
–46·23
(–50·84 o –40·81)*
4Child unde weigh : all
causes
615·18
(515·40 o
776·56)
312·61
(266·20 o
389·00)
–49·18
(–55·81 o
–41·66)*
–50·76
(–57·23 o –43·44)*
55 627·11
(46 807·75 o
69 301·37)
30 009·75
(25 768·76 o
36 212·38)
–46·05
(–52·86 o
–37·94)*
–47·77
(–54·35 o –39·88)*
·· Dia hoeal diseases 127·09
(100·36 o
161·58)
52·67
(40·79 o
66·71)
–58·56
(–64·86 o
–51·39)*
–59·80
(–65·94 o –52·78)*
11 105·27
(8743·61 o
14 096·57)
4690·97
(3642·30 o
5935·54)
–57·76
(–64·06 o
–50·68)*
–59·03
(–65·13 o –52·13)*
·· Lowe espi a o y
in ec ions
163·67
(110·46 o
282·27)
74·94
(50·68 o
134·75)
–54·21
(–59·84 o
–48·26)*
–55·36
(–60·85 o
–49·50)*
14 008·04
(9452·95 o
24 153·07)
6422·64
(4342·77 o
11 542·06)
–54·15
(–59·76 o
–48·19)*
–55·29
(–60·77 o –49·43)*
·· Measles 90·51
(19·16 o
218·56)
18·86
(3·38 o 49·55)
–79·17
(–85·30 o
–74·27)*
–80·02
(–85·90 o –75·33)*
7705·27
(1633·01 o
18 583·17)
1607·04
(288·75 o
4213·11)
–79·14
(–85·23 o
–74·24)*
–79·99
(–85·84 o –75·30)*
·· P o ein-ene gy
malnu i ion
233·90
(206·48 o
265·01)
166·14
(141·84 o
197·87)
–28·97
(–41·25 o
–12·92)*
–31·28
(–43·19 o –15·72)*
22 808·52
(20 316·73 o
25 669·57)
17 289·10
(14 869·06 o
20 449·39)
–24·20
(–35·67 o
–10·17)*
–26·77
(–37·78 o –13·18)*
4 Child was ing: all causes 1734·23
(1516·43 o
1927·79)
952·40
(813·72 o
1,078·99)
–45·08
(–50·29 o
–39·28)*
–46·57
(–51·63 o –40·95)*
152 812·32
(134 145·84 o
169 500·58)
86 165·42
(74 409·95 o
97 423·29)
–43·61
(–48·72 o
–37·94)*
–45·17
(–50·15 o –39·64)*
(Table 4 con inues on nex page)
Global Heal h Me ics
www. helance .com Vol 390 Sep embe 16, 2017
1381
2006 dea hs
(in housands)
2016 dea hs
(in housands)
Pe cen age
change o dea hs
2006–16
Pe cen age
change o age-
s anda dised
dea hs a e
2006–16
2006 DALYs
(in housands)
2016 DALYs
(in housands)
Pe cen age
change o DALYs
2006–16
Pe cen age change
o age-
s anda dised
DALYs a e
2006–16
(Con inued om p e ious page)
·· Dia hoeal diseases 681·26
(562·68 o
775·51)
358·50
(291·19 o
415·43)
–47·38
(–54·62 o
–38·82)*
–48·84
(–55·87 o –40·50)*
59 883·01
(49 482·08 o
68 365·76)
32 202·36
(26 200·00 o
37 322·59)
–46·22
(–53·39 o
–38·04)*
–47·73
(–54·71 o –39·75)*
·· Lowe espi a o y
in ec ions
710·19
(548·14 o
830·75)
400·91
(298·47 o
479·06)
–43·55
(–49·82 o
–37·17)*
–44·86
(–51·02 o –38·64)*
60 842·27
(46 968·94 o
71 152·73)
34 383·68
(25 595·42 o
41 070·89)
–43·49
(–49·75 o
–37·14)*
–44·79
(–50·93 o –38·62)*
·· Measles 108·87
(22·88 o
295·48)
26·85
(4·48 o 77·75)
–75·34
(–83·92 o
–69·78)*
–76·29
(–84·44 o
–70·99)*
9278·52
(1953·33 o
25 167·82)
2290·28
(383·79 o
6620·03)
–75·32
(–83·90 o
–69·75)*
–76·27
(–84·43 o –70·96)*
·· P o ein-ene gy
malnu i ion
233·90
(206·48 o
265·01)
166·14
(141·84 o
197·87)
–28·97
(–41·25 o
–12·92)*
–31·28
(–43·19 o –15·72)*
22 808·52
(20 316·73 o
25 669·57)
17 289·10
(14 869·06 o
20 449·39)
–24·20
(–35·67 o
–10·17)*
–26·77
(–37·78 o –13·18)*
4 Child s un ing: all causes 366·43
(184·02 o
613·94)
162·19
(74·85 o
301·18)
–55·74
(–63·28 o
–48·78)*
–57·10
(–64·53 o –50·28)*
31 579·40
(15 947·91 o
52 776·94)
14 114·74
(6609·85 o
26 162·13)
–55·30
(–62·90 o
–48·48)*
–56·68
(–64·19 o –50·03)*
·· Dia hoeal diseases 133·15
(51·03 o
233·07)
60·15
(21·84 o
112·30)
–54·83
(–61·70 o
–45·79)*
–56·28
(–62·91 o –47·53)*
11 661·60
(4481·93 o
20 495·06)
5381·00
(2025·40 o
10 118·70)
–53·86
(–60·50 o
–44·93)*
–55·35
(–61·80 o –46·71)*
·· Lowe espi a o y
in ec ions
173·89
(17·78 o
415·12)
88·31
(7·20 o
226·69)
–49·22
(–56·08 o
–37·47)*
–50·59
(–57·26 o –39·05)*
14 868·01
(1516·40 o
35 518·80)
7564·20
(616·04 o
19 419·68)
–49·12
(–55·96 o
–37·42)*
–50·49
(–57·14 o –38·99)*
·· Measles 59·38
(5·88 o
164·35)
13·73
(1·21 o 40·90)
–76·87
(–82·40 o
–71·74)*
–77·86
(–83·16 o –72·91)*
5049·80
(506·57 o
13 966·03)
1169·54
(103·24 o
3473·72)
–76·84
(–82·34 o
–71·73)*
–77·82
(–83·10 o –72·90)*
3 Low bi hweigh and
sho ges a ion: all
causes
2341·51
(2264·77 o
2427·94)
1673·60
(1589·23 o
1758·45)
–28·52
(–31·98 o
–24·88)*
–28·19
(–31·66 o –24·53)*
202 783·89
(196 133·92 o
210 268·23)
144 947·75
(137 645·54 o
152 301·77)
–28·52
(–31·97 o
–24·88)*
–28·19
(–31·66 o –24·53)*
4 Sho ges a ion o
bi hweigh : all causes
2064·01
(1949·93 o
2171·84)
1485·61
(1392·05 o
1580·00)
–28·02
(–31·59 o
–24·49)*
–27·69
(–31·27 o –24·14)*
178 754·75
(168 864·65 o
188 091·13)
128 668·91
(120 565·96 o
136 862·69)
–28·02
(–31·58 o
–24·49)*
–27·69
(–31·27 o –24·14)*
·· Dia hoeal diseases 55·68
(50·20 o
61·51)
23·63
(20·92 o
26·58)
–57·57
(–62·84 o
–51·19)*
–57·43
(–62·71 o –51·02)*
4820·28
(4345·76 o
5325·35)
2045·43
(1811·41 o
2301·28)
–57·57
(–62·84 o
–51·19)*
–57·43
(–62·71 o –51·02)*
·· Lowe espi a o y
in ec ions
183·79
(162·94 o
202·96)
104·40
(89·31 o
119·24)
–43·20
(–48·74 o
–37·39)*
–42·98
(–48·54 o –37·15)*
15 913·47
(14 107·71 o
17 572·78)
9039·55
(7732·87 o
10 324·80)
–43·20
(–48·74 o
–37·39)*
–42·97
(–48·54 o –37·15)*
.. Uppe espi a o y
in ec ions
0·09
(0·06 o 0·12)
0·05
(0·04 o 0·07)
–41·66
(–60·35 o
–14·21)*
–41·40
(–60·16 o –13·83)*
7·54
(5·36 o 10·34)
4·40
(3·13 o 6·32)
–41·66
(–60·35 o
–14·21)*
–41·40
(–60·16 o –13·82)*
·· O i is media 0·01
(0·01 o 0·02)
0·01
(0·00 o 0·01)
–55·23
(–72·96 o
–21·17)*
–55·11
(–72·91 o –20·94)*
1·13
(0·78 o 1·72)
0·51
(0·33 o 0·83)
–55·23
(–72·96 o
–21·18)*
–55·11
(–72·91 o –20·95)*
·· Pneumococcal
meningi is
0·74
(0·51 o 1·02)
0·62
(0·40 o 0·93)
–15·86
(–31·66 o 6·43)
–15·56
(–31·41 o 6·80)
63·93
(43·85 o 87·89)
53·80
(35·00 o 80·84)
–15·85
(–31·66 o 6·43)
–15·56
(–31·41 o 6·80)
·· H in luenzae ype B
meningi is
2·05
(1·48 o 2·68)
1·71
(1·22 o 2·40)
–16·55
(–32·62 o 6·20)
–16·25
(–32·37 o 6·59)
177·11
(127·74 o 231·69)
147·80
(105·37 o 207·64)
–16·55
(–32·62 o 6·20)
–16·25
(–32·37 o 6·59)
·· Meningococcal
in ec ion
7·44
(5·63 o 9·42)
4·67
(3·45 o 6·41)
–37·20
(–47·71 o
–22·35)*
–36·98
(–47·52 o –22·08)*
643·78
(487·60 o
815·98)
404·31
(298·70 o 555·31)
–37·20
(–47·71 o
–22·35)*
–36·98
(–47·52 o –22·08)*
·· O he meningi is 5·57
(4·16 o 7·06)
5·57
(4·05 o 8·31)
0·08
(–17·80 o 26·45)
0·43
(–17·54 o 26·88)
481·88
(360·51 o 611·08)
482·25
(350·92 o 719·69)
0·08
(–17·80 o 26·45)
0·43
(–17·53 o 26·88)
·· Encephali is 1·34
(1·00 o 1·56)
1·00
(0·79 o 1·24)
–24·98
(–43·32 o
–2·82)*
–24·73
(–43·13 o –2·52)*
115·89
(86·59 o 134·97)
86·95
(68·43 o 107·11)
–24·98
(–43·32 o
–2·82)*
–24·73
(–43·13 o –2·52)*
·· Neona al p e e m
bi h complica ions
819·36
(770·29 o
909·83)
590·38
(541·05 o
643·11)
–27·95
(–33·72 o
–22·15)*
–27·60
(–33·41 o –21·78)*
70 980·50
(66 730·62 o
78 805·17)
51 151·21
(46 878·45 o
55 713·15)
–27·94
(–33·70 o
–22·14)*
–27·59
(–33·39 o –21·77)*
(Table 4 con inues on nex page)
Global Heal h Me ics
1382
www. helance .com Vol 390 Sep embe 16, 2017
2006 dea hs
(in housands)
2016 dea hs
(in housands)
Pe cen age
change o dea hs
2006–16
Pe cen age
change o age-
s anda dised
dea hs a e
2006–16
2006 DALYs
(in housands)
2016 DALYs
(in housands)
Pe cen age
change o DALYs
2006–16
Pe cen age change
o age-
s anda dised
DALYs a e
2006–16
(Con inued om p e ious page)
·· Neona al
encephalopa hy due
o bi h asphyxia and
auma
477·77
(426·69 o
525·03)
370·94
(322·96 o
419·15)
–22·36
(–29·79 o
–14·36)*
–21·97
(–29·43 o –13·93)*
41 371·74
(36 949·03 o
45 464·08)
32 120·93
(27 966·29 o
36 295·65)
–22·36
(–29·79 o
–14·36)*
–21·97
(–29·43 o –13·93)*
·· Neona al sepsis and
o he neona al
in ec ions
170·34
(138·61 o
217·43)
151·23
(126·64 o
206·06)
–11·22
(–21·77 o 2·78)
–10·86
(–21·43 o 3·20)
14 749·24
(12 001·55 o
18 826·29)
13 094·15
(10 964·91 o
17 842·59)
–11·22
(–21·77 o 2·78)
–10·86
(–21·44 o 3·20)
·· Haemoly ic disease
and o he neona al
jaundice
55·72
(48·90 o
64·54)
32·45
(27·90 o
38·04)
–41·77
(–49·82 o
–32·96)*
–41·52
(–49·61 o
–32·68)*
4824·42
(4234·14 o
5587·98)
2809·45
(2416·02 o
3293·80)
–41·77
(–49·82 o
–32·96)*
–41·52
(–49·61 o –32·68)*
·· O he neona al
diso de s
282·16
(250·52 o
317·48)
197·44
(173·31 o
220·92)
–30·03
(–37·01 o
–21·73)*
–29·69
(–36·71 o –21·36)*
24 432·57
(21 692·72 o
27 491·34)
17 096·35
(15 006·94 o
19 130·02)
–30·03
(–37·01 o
–21·73)*
–29·69
(–36·71 o –21·36)*
·· Sudden in an dea h
synd ome
1·98
(1·47 o 2·54)
1·52
(1·16 o 1·87)
–23·02
(–39·72 o –8·37)*
–22·88
(–39·61 o –8·20)*
171·26
(127·36 o 219·51)
131·83
(100·77 o 161·72)
–23·02
(–39·72 o
–8·37)*
–22·88
(–39·61 o –8·20)*
4 Low bi hweigh o
ges a ion: all causes
1096·85
(1005·37 o
1207·52)
778·37
(705·63 o
864·12)
–29·04
(–33·70 o
–24·31)*
–28·69
(–33·38 o –23·94)*
95 009·64
(87 086·08 o
104 596·97)
67 430·06
(61 121·27 o
74 855·14)
–29·03
(–33·69 o
–24·30)*
–28·69
(–33·37 o –23·93)*
·· Dia hoeal diseases 8·81
(6·21 o 11·88)
3·44
(2·38 o 4·75)
–60·94
(–66·12 o
–55·24)*
–60·78
(–65·99 o –55·07)*
762·62
(537·68 o
1028·73)
297·89
(206·10 o 411·47)
–60·94
(–66·12 o
–55·24)*
–60·78
(–65·99 o –55·07)*
·· Lowe espi a o y
in ec ions
35·74
(25·03 o
48·36)
19·19
(12·83 o
26·70)
–46·30
(–52·21 o
–39·99)*
–46·06
(–51·99 o –39·72)*
3094·33
(2167·54 o
4187·61)
1661·65
(1111·03 o
2311·96)
–46·30
(–52·21 o
–39·99)*
–46·06
(–51·99 o –39·71)*
·· Uppe espi a o y
in ec ions
0·02
(0·01 o 0·03)
0·01
(0·01 o 0·02)
–44·27
(–64·75 o
–11·69)*
–44·00
(–64·57 o –11·28)*
1·71
(1·05 o 2·67)
0·95
(0·56 o 1·55)
–44·27
(–64·75 o
–11·69)*
–44·00
(–64·57 o –11·27)*
·· O i is media 0·00
(0·00 o 0·00)
0·00
(0·00 o 0·00)
–55·15
(–71·15 o
–26·78)*
–55·00
(–71·08 o –26·52)*
0·16
(0·09 o 0·25)
0·07
(0·04 o 0·12)
–55·15
(–71·15 o
–26·78)*
–55·00
(–71·08 o –26·52)*
·· Pneumococcal
meningi is
0·13
(0·08 o 0·20)
0·11
(0·06 o 0·17)
–19·39
(–35·79 o 2·80)
–19·04
(–35·49 o 3·25)
11·42
(6·55 o 17·49)
9·20
(5·13 o 15·15)
–19·39
(–35·79 o 2·80)
–19·04
(–35·49 o 3·25)
·· H in luenzae ype B
meningi is
0·36
(0·22 o 0·53)
0·29
(0·17 o 0·45)
–20·05
(–36·17 o 2·27)
–19·71
(–35·89 o 2·71)
31·35
(19·05 o 45·47)
25·07
(14·61 o 38·71)
–20·05
(–36·16 o 2·27)
–19·71
(–35·89 o 2·71)
·· Meningococcal
in ec ion
1·30
(0·81 o 1·86)
0·80
(0·46 o 1·25)
–38·84
(–50·93 o
–23·22)*
–38·58
(–50·72 o –22·88)*
112·69
(69·75 o 161·06)
68·92
(39·87 o 108·45)
–38·84
(–50·93 o
–23·22)*
–38·58
(–50·72 o –22·88)*
·· O he meningi is 1·00
(0·62 o 1·44)
0·94
(0·55 o 1·48)
–5·58
(–23·60 o 18·81)
–5·19
(–23·30 o 19·32)
86·49
(53·37 o 124·38)
81·66
(47·91 o 127·74)
–5·58
(–23·59 o 18·81)
–5·18
(–23·29 o 19·32)
·· Encephali is 0·20
(0·13 o 0·28)
0·14
(0·10 o 0·21)
–29·88
(–45·21 o
–11·08)*
–29·59
(–44·97 o –10·70)*
17·74
(11·22 o 24·41)
12·44
(8·28 o 17·83)
–29·88
(–45·21 o
–11·08)*
–29·59
(–44·97 o –10·70)*
·· Neona al p e e m
bi h complica ions
819·36
(770·29 o
909·83)
590·38
(541·05 o
643·11)
–27·95
(–33·72 o
–22·15)*
–27·60
(–33·41 o –21·78)*
70 980·50
(66 730·62 o
78 805·17)
51 151·21
(46 878·45 o
55 713·15)
–27·94
(–33·70 o
–22·14)*
–27·59
(–33·39 o –21·77)*
·· Neona al
encephalopa hy due
o bi h asphyxia and
auma
117·60
(83·00 o
156·33)
84·68
(58·86 o
116·05)
–27·99
(–35·44 o
–20·42)*
–27·62
(–35·10 o –20·01)*
10 183·45
(7187·60 o
13 537·45)
7332·98
(5096·63 o
10 049·16)
–27·99
(–35·44 o
–20·42)*
–27·62
(–35·10 o –20·01)*
·· Neona al sepsis and
o he neona al
in ec ions
35·50
(23·71 o
50·81)
29·56
(19·65 o
43·87)
–16·73
(–28·32 o –2·51)*
–16·34
(–27·98 o –2·04)*
3073·99
(2053·27 o
4400·09)
2559·70
(1701·26 o
3798·68)
–16·73
(–28·32 o
–2·51)*
–16·34
(–27·98 o –2·04)*
·· Haemoly ic disease
and o he neona al
jaundice
11·40
(7·99 o 15·92)
6·32
(4·34 o 9·07)
–44·53
(–53·03 o
–34·47)*
–44·26
(–52·80 o –34·17)*
987·26
(692·04 o
1378·49)
547·68
(375·55 o 785·14)
–44·52
(–53·03 o
–34·47)*
–44·26
(–52·80 o –34·17)*
(Table 4 con inues on nex page)
Global Heal h Me ics
www. helance .com Vol 390 Sep embe 16, 2017
1383
2006 dea hs
(in housands)
2016 dea hs
(in housands)
Pe cen age
change o dea hs
2006–16
Pe cen age
change o age-
s anda dised
dea hs a e
2006–16
2006 DALYs
(in housands)
2016 DALYs
(in housands)
Pe cen age
change o DALYs
2006–16
Pe cen age change
o age-
s anda dised
DALYs a e
2006–16
(Con inued om p e ious page)
·· O he neona al
diso de s
65·24
(45·86 o
88·09)
42·37
(28·62 o
57·94)
–35·06
(–42·81 o
–26·85)*
–34·73
(–42·52 o –26·48)*
5649·31
(3971·62 o
7628·08)
3668·67
(2478·27 o
5016·91)
–35·06
(–42·81 o
–26·85)*
–34·73
(–42·52 o –26·48)*
·· Sudden in an dea h
synd ome
0·19
(0·11 o 0·30)
0·14
(0·08 o 0·21)
–28·09
(–43·32 o
–14·05)*
–27·96
(–43·22 o –13·89)*
16·64
(9·23 o 26·37)
11·97
(6·94 o 18·10)
–28·09
(–43·32 o
–14·05)*
–27·96
(–43·22 o –13·89)*
3I on de iciency: all
causes
27·52
(12·14 o
43·69)
20·95
(9·79 o 33·31)
–23·88
(–30·25 o
–15·97)*
–31·14
(–36·96 o –24·17)*
33 835·12
(22 660·82 o
48 281·14)
35 849·87
(24 052·89 o
50 796·92)
5·95
(4·22 o 7·72)*
–3·09
(–4·68 o –1·56)*
·· Ma e nal
haemo hage
19·26
(7·33 o 32·35)
14·10
(5·33 o 24·29)
–26·80
(–34·82 o
–17·79)*
–33·34
(–40·64 o –25·27)*
1105·24
(420·28 o
1854·49)
798·94
(301·29 o
1366·56)
–27·71
(–35·87 o
–18·55)*
–33·84
(–41·20 o –25·64)*
·· Ma e nal sepsis and
o he p egnancy
ela ed in ec ions
5·54
(2·03 o 9·37)
3·89
(1·38 o 6·67)
–29·86
(–38·95 o
–20·14)*
–35·83
(–44·10 o
–26·86)*
325·54
(119·05 o 544·08)
227·22
(80·46 o 386·37)
–30·20
(–38·96 o
–20·38)*
–35·70
(–43·84 o –27·13)*
·· I on-de iciency
anaemia
2·72
(2·35 o 3·89)
2·96
(2·52 o 3·75)
8·94
(–9·11 o 27·26)
–11·59
(–27·78 o 4·94)
32 404·33
(21 523·57 o
46 641·55)
34 823·71
(23 073·25 o
49 667·43)
7·47
(6·17 o 8·89)*
–1·78
(–2·96 o –0·51)*
3Vi amin A de iciency: all
causes
108·40
(62·61 o
166·64)
42·18
(24·16 o
65·39)
–61·08
(–66·90 o
–53·83)*
–62·78
(–68·35 o –55·79)*
9600·08
(5604·44 o
14 578·34)
3979·05
(2357·30 o
6000·15)
–58·55
(–64·51 o
–51·19)*
–60·47
(–66·15 o –53·43)*
·· Dia hoeal diseases 64·17
(32·47 o
96·79)
30·04
(14·54 o
46·71)
–53·18
(–60·01 o
–44·61)*
–55·12
(–61·70 o –46·81)*
5620·97
(2833·29 o
8506·22)
2695·50
(1309·94 o
4149·27)
–52·05
(–58·86 o
–43·62)*
–54·05
(–60·63 o –45·90)*
·· Measles 44·23
(13·84 o
96·01)
12·14
(3·73 o 28·13)
–72·55
(–77·30 o
–67·69)*
–73·85
(–78·35 o –69·07)*
3753·95
(1185·75 o
8149·96)
1031·27
(318·97 o
2391·75)
–72·53
(–77·21 o
–67·68)*
–73·83
(–78·30 o –69·05)*
·· Vi amin A de iciency ·· ·· ·· ·· 225·16
(139·62 o 348·12)
252·29
(158·71 o 388·09)
12·05
(8·70 o 15·49)*
2·64
(–0·33 o 5·60)
3Zinc de iciency: all
causes
53·32
(2·85 o
141·73)
25·09
(1·32 o 69·47)
–52·95
(–60·88 o
–43·61)*
–55·43
(–62·95 o
–46·59)*
4651·43
(359·57 o
12 155·34)
2245·65
(213·63 o
5993·34)
–51·72
(–59·17 o
–38·63)*
–54·27
(–61·32 o –41·88)*
·· Dia hoeal diseases 31·31
(0·00 o 87·89)
14·67
(0·00 o 42·50)
·· ·· 2785·75
(132·69 o
7615·90)
1359·88
(108·32 o
3778·60)
–51·18
(–58·99 o
–14·97)*
–53·76
(–61·16 o –19·47)*
.. Lowe espi a o y
in ec ions
22·01
(0·00 o 86·72)
10·42
(0·00 o 42·20)
.. .. 1865·68
(2·95 o 7331·05)
885·77
(2·26 o 3568·53)
–52·52
(–60·86 o
–18·33)*
–55·03
(–62·93 o –22·65)*
2 Tobacco: all causes 6853·45
(6227·56 o
7447·85)
7131·38
(6503·23 o
7780·89)
4·06
(1·29 o 6·96)*
–20·37
(–22·48 o
–18·30)*
178 305·14
(163 133·82 o
194 298·17)
177 302·31
(162 327·84 o
194 250·39)
–0·56
(–3·34 o 2·52)
–21·31
(–23·35 o –19·05)*
3 Smoking: all causes 6081·95
(5443·81 o
6681·35)
6321·10
(5673·66 o
6962·35)
3·93
(0·87 o 7·06)*
–20·68
(–22·98 o –18·31)*
153 365·37
(138 408·89 o
167 887·88)
155 065·75
(140 025·42 o
170 602·15)
1·11
(–1·79 o 4·20)
–20·83
(–23·12 o –18·45)*
·· D ug-suscep ible
ube culosis
129·07
(66·60 o
195·37)
90·24
(44·98 o
139·18)
–30·08
(–34·42 o
–26·43)*
–44·49
(–48·00 o –41·50)*
4240·53
(2168·23 o
6389·84)
2934·12
(1440·35 o
4528·89)
–30·81
(–34·75 o
–27·37)*
–43·68
(–47·17 o –40·93)*
·· Mul id ug- esis an
ube culosis wi hou
ex ensi e d ug
esis ance
14·07
(7·18 o 21·44)
8·19
(4·00 o 12·82)
–41·80
(–48·21 o
–35·18)*
–53·46
(–58·72 o –48·18)*
458·79
(234·16 o
698·87)
257·57
(126·48 o 404·28)
–43·86
(–50·23 o
–37·69)*
–54·10
(–59·43 o –49·05)*
·· Ex ensi ely d ug-
esis an ube culosis
0·92
(0·48 o 1·40)
1·33
(0·66 o 2·11)
44·76
(19·92 o 72·63)*
16·94
(–2·69 o 38·90)
31·47
(16·42 o 48·08)
43·78
(21·82 o 68·67)
39·10
(14·10 o 68·50)*
14·83
(–5·56 o 38·75)
·· Lowe espi a o y
in ec ions
326·00
(257·89 o
397·51)
345·94
(270·42 o
426·72)
6·12
(0·26 o 10·80)*
–19·55
(–23·91 o –16·10)*
7002·64
(5630·01 o
8415·41)
7022·96
(5529·91 o
8607·77)
0·29
(–5·31 o 5·35)
–20·81
(–25·17 o –16·90)*
(Table 4 con inues on nex page)
Global Heal h Me ics
1384
www. helance .com Vol 390 Sep embe 16, 2017
2006 dea hs
(in housands)
2016 dea hs
(in housands)
Pe cen age
change o dea hs
2006–16
Pe cen age
change o age-
s anda dised
dea hs a e
2006–16
2006 DALYs
(in housands)
2016 DALYs
(in housands)
Pe cen age
change o DALYs
2006–16
Pe cen age change
o age-
s anda dised
DALYs a e
2006–16
(Con inued om p e ious page)
·· Lip and o al ca i y
cance
51·72
(44·13 o
60·07)
64·11
(53·04 o
77·13)
23·95
(15·31 o 32·49)*
–4·81
(–11·29 o 1·58)
1393·05
(1176·02 o
1627·58)
1658·72
(1362·64 o
2015·39)
19·07
(10·04 o
28·65)*
–6·71
(–13·94 o 0·57)
·· Nasopha ynx cance 21·46
(15·13 o
28·44)
22·33
(16·02 o
30·03)
4·05
(–6·14 o 14·01)
–18·25
(–25·96 o –10·94)*
635·38
(432·94 o
851·08)
618·24
(441·07 o 838·14)
–2·70
(–13·59 o 9·00)
–22·14
(–30·47 o –13·55)*
·· Oesophageal cance 144·04
(90·12 o
204·21)
144·40
(93·42 o
205·40)
0·25
(–5·55 o 8·89)
–23·33
(–27·74 o –17·01)*
3249·88
(2072·43 o
4607·13)
3104·99
(2025·56 o
4431·70)
–4·46
(–10·71 o 4·48)
–25·91
(–30·69 o –19·11)*
·· S omach cance 86·47
(50·10 o
134·64)
78·50
(45·61 o
124·13)
–9·21
(–15·82 o –2·65)*
–30·05
(–34·90 o –25·17)*
1985·62
(1151·90 o
3061·29)
1668·26
(961·69 o
2631·19)
–15·98
(–23·04 o
–8·83)*
–34·01
(–39·20 o –28·67)*
·· Colon and ec um
cance
46·29
(32·90 o
59·71)
49·01
(33·90 o
64·52)
5·88
(–0·09 o 11·90)
–19·96
(–24·42 o –15·55)*
973·58
(681·64 o
1272·87)
963·80
(667·18 o
1291·65)
–1·00
(–7·15 o 5·34)
–23·19
(–27·69 o –18·37)*
·· Li e cance due o
hepa i is B
41·56
(18·21 o
77·66)
43·39
(19·66 o
81·96)
4·41
(–6·80 o 17·06)
–17·17
(–24·98 o –8·46)*
1222·27
(522·08 o
2265·72)
1164·10
(521·30 o
2235·84)
–4·76
(–17·66 o 10·74)
–22·84
(–32·30 o –11·64)*
·· Li e cance due o
hepa i is C
19·24
(10·53 o
28·42)
22·01
(12·01 o
32·79)
14·35
(7·81 o 21·02)*
–12·81
(–17·64 o –8·10)*
414·97
(225·94 o 628·23)
448·80
(238·88 o 687·22)
8·15
(0·75 o 16·28)*
–16·20
(–21·61 o –10·61)*
·· Li e cance due o
alcohol use
14·69
(8·71 o 21·74)
16·71
(9·61 o 25·36)
13·74
(5·31 o 21·66)*
–12·48
(–18·79 o –6·56)*
343·61
(201·26 o
506·60)
377·43
(217·22 o 566·00)
9·84
(0·81 o 18·67)*
–14·44
(–20·97 o –7·97)*
·· Li e cance due o
o he causes
24·71
(11·36 o
45·81)
26·42
(12·15 o
49·30)
6·90
(–4·05 o 18·94)
–15·62
(–23·12 o –7·34)*
683·22
(286·75 o
1300·01)
662·38
(294·93 o
1262·06)
–3·05
(–15·91 o 13·35)
–21·80
(–31·15 o –10·21)*
·· Panc ea ic cance 61·47
(49·77 o
74·37)
70·90
(56·11 o
87·71)
15·34
(9·71 o 21·46)*
–12·20
(–16·27 o –7·87)*
1315·34
(1059·48 o
1601·29)
1431·89
(1125·82 o
1797·72)
8·86
(2·52 o 15·73)*
–15·66
(–20·48 o –10·57)*
·· La ynx cance 60·04
(50·50 o
68·78)
64·92
(53·57 o
76·19)
8·14
(2·92 o 13·33)*
–17·06
(–21·01 o –13·10)*
1524·37
(1284·41 o
1751·12)
1596·46
(1320·70 o
1877·67)
4·73
(–0·81 o 10·00)
–18·86
(–23·02 o –14·71)*
·· T acheal, b onchus,
and lung cance
1014·39
(875·09 o
1123·75)
1144·75
(973·82 o
1299·87)
12·85
(7·75 o 17·44)*
–13·53
(–17·47 o –10·01)*
22 094·05
(18 775·21 o
24 684·60)
23 701·45
(19 814·76 o
27 245·91)
7·28
(1·69 o 12·27)*
–16·85
(–21·09 o –13·12)*
·· B eas cance 16·88
(5·04 o 30·02)
17·91
(5·25 o 31·90)
6·11
(–0·34 o 13·11)
–18·14
(–22·76 o –13·09)*
457·80
(129·80 o 835·33)
452·41
(126·69 o 827·14)
–1·18
(–8·24 o 6·76)
–21·43
(–26·56 o –15·69)*
·· Ce ical cance 11·03
(3·91 o 19·39)
10·85
(3·81 o 18·98)
–1·66
(–10·26 o 7·78)
–22·54
(–28·68 o –15·43)*
331·91
(114·69 o 595·93)
306·32
(105·80 o 541·94)
–7·71
(–17·35 o 2·77)
–25·19
(–32·55 o –16·79)*
·· P os a e cance 15·29
(11·00 o
19·90)
16·68
(11·72 o
22·10)
9·09
(2·16 o 18·00)*
–19·29
(–24·05 o –12·77)*
257·95
(186·43 o 331·39)
268·27
(190·32 o 355·74)
4·00
(–3·76 o 12·92)
–21·25
(–26·88 o –14·50)*
·· Kidney cance 20·10
(13·46 o
26·02)
22·07
(14·53 o
29·44)
9·79
(1·71 o 18·14)*
–16·07
(–21·91 o –9·92)*
464·77
(311·24 o 604·80)
480·06
(316·13 o 639·24)
3·29
(–5·41 o 12·59)
–19·84
(–26·34 o –12·84)*
·· Bladde cance 44·33
(33·18 o
55·10)
49·84
(36·98 o
63·01)
12·42
(6·43 o 18·18)*
–15·76
(–20·05 o –11·55)*
820·50
(616·52 o
1016·68)
867·04
(639·82 o
1098·93)
5·67
(–0·75 o 11·94)
–19·01
(–23·71 o –14·36)*
·· Acu e lymphoid
leukaemia
2·45
(1·19 o 3·88)
2·65
(1·26 o 4·39)
8·51
(–1·79 o 18·19)
–14·18
(–21·95 o –6·75)*
74·37
(35·76 o 121·34)
77·25
(35·75 o 131·34)
3·87
(–8·05 o 15·59)
–16·04
(–25·20 o –6·72)*
·· Ch onic lymphoid
leukaemia
4·13
(2·06 o 6·30)
4·32
(2·09 o 6·76)
4·69
(–3·63 o 13·22)
–21·24
(–27·22 o –15·09)*
81·77
(41·39 o 125·41)
81·18
(39·93 o 126·38)
–0·73
(–9·78 o 8·35)
–23·72
(–30·52 o –17·08)*
·· Acu e myeloid
leukaemia
7·27
(3·54 o 11·03)
8·00
(3·82 o 12·46)
10·07
(2·74 o 16·47)*
–14·79
(–20·27 o –10·13)*
174·17
(88·65 o 265·91)
182·46
(89·93 o 285·57)
4·76
(–3·79 o 12·31)
–17·20
(–23·71 o –11·49)*
(Table 4 con inues on nex page)
Global Heal h Me ics
www. helance .com Vol 390 Sep embe 16, 2017
1385
2006 dea hs
(in housands)
2016 dea hs
(in housands)
Pe cen age
change o dea hs
2006–16
Pe cen age
change o age-
s anda dised
dea hs a e
2006–16
2006 DALYs
(in housands)
2016 DALYs
(in housands)
Pe cen age
change o DALYs
2006–16
Pe cen age change
o age-
s anda dised
DALYs a e
2006–16
(Con inued om p e ious page)
·· Ch onic myeloid
leukaemia
2·27
(1·10 o 3·48)
1·92
(0·89 o 3·02)
–15·62
(–22·48 o
–8·88)*
–34·65
(–39·76 o
–29·68)*
56·81
(27·53 o 88·46)
45·30
(21·19 o 72·34)
–20·26
(–27·97 o
–13·34)*
–36·45
(–42·56 o –30·76)*
·· O he leukaemia 8·73
(4·12 o 14·42)
8·74
(4·11 o 14·48)
0·05
(–8·87 o 8·12)
–21·85
(–28·03 o –16·79)*
220·47
(100·95 o 372·96)
198·49
(92·02 o 332·58)
–9·97
(–21·62 o 1·39)
–27·29
(–35·24 o –19·78)*
·· Ischaemic hea
disease
1346·04
(1125·86 o
1572·65)
1391·74
(1144·96 o
1649·56)
3·40
(–0·14 o 7·31)
–20·16
(–22·96 o –17·24)*
36 051·24
(30 135·29 o
41 836·78)
36 302·60
(29 797·02 o
42 911·24)
0·70
(–2·92 o 4·82)
–20·54
(–23·37 o –17·43)*
·· Ischaemic s oke 350·47
(292·23 o
407·20)
347·05
(290·43 o
408·73)
–0·98
(–5·13 o 3·31)
–24·72
(–27·99 o –21·50)*
8972·51
(7487·52 o
10 550·77)
9235·11
(7655·96 o
10 990·85)
2·93
(–1·37 o 6·94)
–20·73
(–24·06 o –17·62)*
·· Haemo hagic s oke 574·87
(485·95 o
664·83)
535·26
(448·47 o
627·04)
–6·89
(–10·16 o
–3·66)*
–27·91
(–30·41 o –25·36)*
16 024·57
(13 595·74 o
18 501·64)
14 873·84
(12 549·42 o
17 354·01)
–7·18
(–10·27 o
–4·08)*
–26·69
(–29·11 o –24·28)*
·· Hype ensi e hea
disease
92·58
(69·07 o
115·52)
104·36
(75·52 o
129·77)
12·72
(–0·81 o 23·61)
–13·06
(–23·84 o –4·65)*
2418·95
(1818·67 o
3023·75)
2611·14
(1927·81 o
3211·98)
7·95
(–2·72 o 17·76)
–14·97
(–23·65 o –7·28)*
·· A ial ib illa ion and
lu e
11·78
(8·34 o 15·89)
14·23
(10·02 o
19·31)
20·80
(16·34 o 24·92)*
–11·40
(–14·55 o –8·44)*
616·54
(429·29 o
846·49)
710·44
(488·75 o 984·65)
15·23
(12·91 o 17·40)*
–10·95
(–12·66 o –9·34)*
·· Ao ic aneu ysm 22·06
(17·20 o
26·40)
22·71
(17·69 o
27·64)
2·92
(–2·08 o 9·42)
–20·66
(–24·43 o –15·86)*
554·61
(435·81 o 658·02)
560·44
(442·97 o 678·22)
1·05
(–4·19 o 8·10)
–20·47
(–24·50 o –15·10)*
·· Pe iphe al ascula
disease
4·59
(3·26 o 5·98)
5·12
(3·60 o 6·91)
11·65
(–0·50 o 26·59)
–15·97
(–24·80 o –5·05)*
148·14
(100·88 o 203·55)
163·17
(110·40 o 225·34)
10·14
(0·93 o 20·74)*
–16·24
(–22·89 o –8·54)*
·· O he ca dio ascula
and ci cula o y
diseases
53·33
(40·77 o
70·74)
55·64
(41·83 o
73·98)
4·33
(–0·04 o 9·45)
–19·15
(–22·65 o –15·27)*
1998·90
(1531·92 o
2560·68)
2084·86
(1574·17 o
2694·49)
4·30
(0·52 o 8·39)*
–16·90
(–19·76 o –13·76)*
·· Ch onic obs uc i e
pulmona y disease
1190·52
(889·10 o
1462·49)
1253·30
(989·51 o
1520·42)
5·27
(–0·57 o 14·11)
–22·12
(–26·38 o –15·51)*
23 659·75
(18 550·88 o
28 461·63)
25 038·91
(20 395·51 o
29 918·00)
5·83
(–0·06 o 13·85)
–19·26
(–23·63 o –13·01)*
·· As hma 65·36
(44·88 o
91·56)
56·81
(39·28 o
78·57)
–13·08
(–20·43 o
–5·24)*
–32·94
(–38·71 o –26·92)*
2444·85
(1802·94 o
3242·52)
2291·51
(1694·45 o
2999·22)
–6·27
(–12·71 o –0·11)*
–25·66
(–30·95 o –20·73)*
·· O he ch onic
espi a o y diseases
3·07
(2·06 o 4·10)
3·77
(2·53 o 5·06)
22·95
(13·58 o 33·14)*
–5·85
(–12·82 o 1·88)
103·01
(73·48 o 140·16)
126·04
(88·32 o 176·23)
22·36
(12·41 o 32·01)*
–1·70
(–9·84 o 6·67)
·· Pep ic ulce disease 43·27
(31·46 o
55·50)
36·14
(26·26 o
47·09)
–16·48
(–21·32 o
–12·20)*
–35·23
(–39·05 o –31·93)*
1202·60
(882·23 o
1539·63)
1008·27
(740·13 o
1308·30)
–16·16
(–20·61 o
–11·83)*
–33·35
(–36·87 o –30·04)*
·· Gallbladde and bilia y
diseases
2·22
(1·49 o 2·91)
2·32
(1·55 o 3·09)
4·66
(–1·51 o 10·83)
–20·29
(–25·11 o –15·43)*
54·26
(36·94 o 71·95)
55·54
(36·83 o 74·21)
2·36
(–2·84 o 7·48)
–19·57
(–23·79 o –15·50)*
·· Alzheime ’s disease
and o he demen ias
67·57
(33·10 o
106·19)
82·80
(39·50 o
132·02)
22·55
(15·91 o 27·45)*
–11·65
(–17·20 o –7·77)*
1062·73
(491·18 o
1670·22)
1256·05
(555·38 o
1982·80)
18·19
(12·39 o 22·10)*
–11·38
(–16·39 o –8·22)*
·· Pa kinson’s disease –20·15
(–26·54 o
–14·37)
–23·16
(–30·39 o
–16·44)
14·93
(10·72 o 19·10)*
–12·99
(–16·05 o –9·98)*
–403·98
(–525·52 o
–283·21)
–461·19
(–599·84 o
–324·73)
14·16
(10·52 o 17·80)*
–12·22
(–14·86 o –9·59)*
·· Mul iple scle osis 1·70
(1·11 o 2·36)
1·68
(1·09 o 2·33)
–0·89
(–9·77 o 5·59)
–21·16
(–28·03 o –16·17)*
98·79
(62·61 o 138·27)
99·08
(62·16 o 140·65)
0·29
(–5·43 o 4·75)
–18·13
(–22·71 o –14·62)*
·· Diabe es melli us 56·47
(17·07 o
99·11)
66·30
(19·12 o
117·72)
17·40
(11·86 o 21·43)*
–9·78
(–14·35 o –6·53)*
2881·41
(847·72 o
5096·99)
3192·65
(911·95 o
5662·02)
10·80
(7·07 o 13·63)*
–12·37
(–15·58 o –10·13)*
·· Rheuma oid a h i is 1·45
(0·58 o 2·38)
1·37
(0·54 o 2·27)
–6·01
(–10·76 o –0·77)*
–28·01
(–31·59 o –24·03)*
224·49
(88·79 o 401·57)
241·06
(94·19 o 434·89)
7·38
(4·34 o 9·93)*
–14·89
(–17·34 o –12·89)*
(Table 4 con inues on nex page)
Global Heal h Me ics
1392
www. helance .com Vol 390 Sep embe 16, 2017
2006 dea hs
(in housands)
2016 dea hs
(in housands)
Pe cen age
change o dea hs
2006–16
Pe cen age
change o age-
s anda dised
dea hs a e
2006–16
2006 DALYs
(in housands)
2016 DALYs
(in housands)
Pe cen age
change o DALYs
2006–16
Pe cen age change
o age-
s anda dised
DALYs a e
2006–16
(Con inued om p e ious page)
·· Diabe es melli us 10·29
(1·45 o 18·98)
14·00
(1·98 o 25·60)
36·00
(29·34 o 43·64)*
4·40
(–0·81 o 10·51)
624·65
(87·34 o 1153·77)
869·55
(120·69 o
1598·30)
39·21
(32·22 o 47·76)*
10·89
(5·38 o 17·71)*
3 Die high in p ocessed
mea : all causes
146·70
(29·93 o
269·63)
139·62
(29·84 o
271·40)
–4·83
(–15·30 o 5·01)
–28·85
(–36·31 o –21·48)*
3499·30
(1121·42 o
6024·02)
3196·04
(1091·35 o
5836·23)
–8·67
(–19·23 o 2·16)
–28·87
(–36·93 o –20·27)*
·· Colon and ec um
cance
9·84
(5·09 o 15·48)
10·28
(5·24 o 16·68)
4·45
(–3·10 o 11·58)
–21·45
(–26·99 o
–16·30)*
196·63
(102·18 o 308·02)
194·85
(98·50 o 321·61)
–0·90
(–8·58 o 6·64)
–23·50
(–29·34 o –17·79)*
·· Ischaemic hea
disease
121·78
(5·27 o
240·19)
114·54
(4·50 o
238·06)
–5·94
(–17·54 o 5·48)
–29·84
(–38·03 o –21·64)*
2421·47
(107·64 o
4745·93)
2116·23
(82·94 o 4522·45)
–12·61
(–24·84 o 0·05)
–32·11
(–41·45 o –22·48)*
·· Diabe es melli us 15·09
(7·05 o 24·10)
14·80
(6·45 o 25·75)
–1·89
(–13·21 o 10·00)
–25·27
(–33·73 o –16·41)*
881·20
(420·66 o
1466·58)
884·96
(395·86 o
1583·28)
0·43
(–9·91 o 10·71)
–20·75
(–28·79 o –12·62)*
3 Die high in
suga -swee ened
be e ages: all causes
17·80
(11·49 o
29·39)
22·56
(15·33 o
33·36)
26·77
(–20·93 o 56·21)
–4·36
(–40·34 o 19·43)
605·81
(401·43 o
932·96)
779·51
(523·90 o
1145·18)
28·67
(–13·65 o 50·53)
1·96
(–32·16 o 19·85)
·· Oesophageal cance 0·29
(0·09 o 0·55)
0·37
(0·11 o 0·70)
28·96
(–25·95 o 56·82)
–1·48
(–44·00 o 19·43)
7·08
(2·10 o 13·48)
8·90
(2·55 o 17·04)
25·73
(–26·29 o 51·70)
–2·25
(–41·60 o 17·56)
·· Colon and ec um
cance
0·36
(0·21 o 0·69)
0·43
(0·27 o 0·65)
20·23
(–39·42 o 72·88)
–9·20
(–53·49 o 29·91)
8·10
(4·86 o 15·13)
9·67
(6·13 o 14·54)
19·38
(–40·62 o 73·22)
–7·22
(–53·29 o 33·26)
·· Li e cance due o
hepa i is B
0·11
(0·04 o 0·31)
0·16
(0·07 o 0·29)
46·97
(–48·94 o
107·46)
15·78
(–61·11 o 65·31)
3·43
(1·25 o 9·32)
4·91
(2·09 o 9·01)
43·11
(–47·86 o
105·26)
15·74
(–58·01 o 66·01)
·· Li e cance due o
hepa i is C
0·09
(0·04 o 0·17)
0·13
(0·06 o 0·22)
35·33
(–26·26 o 72·90)
2·46
(–42·04 o 30·86)
2·08
(0·95 o 3·96)
2·77
(1·23 o 4·80)
32·68
(–26·61 o
69·83)
2·19
(–45·21 o 30·56)
·· Li e cance due o
alcohol use
0·07
(0·03 o 0·14)
0·09
(0·04 o 0·15)
38·16
(–35·40 o 78·76)
5·72
(–51·04 o 33·84)
1·56
(0·67 o 3·18)
2·15
(0·98 o 3·68)
37·92
(–31·88 o 72·80)
7·05
(–47·30 o 34·90)
·· Li e cance due o
o he causes
0·07
(0·03 o 0·22)
0·11
(0·05 o 0·19)
47·23
(–49·13 o 98·67)
14·78
(–59·69 o 53·95)
2·05
(0·74 o 5·72)
2·93
(1·22 o 5·21)
42·72
(–40·63 o
97·68)
14·45
(–56·86 o 57·63)
·· Gallbladde and bilia y
ac cance
0·10
(0·06 o 0·17)
0·12
(0·07 o 0·20)
21·19
(–26·26 o 53·17)
–8·78
(–44·49 o 16·53)
2·17
(1·19 o 3·59)
2·56
(1·49 o 4·06)
18·44
(–25·82 o 54·57)
–8·47
(–43·46 o 17·51)
·· Panc ea ic cance 0·12
(0·04 o 0·25)
0·15
(0·05 o 0·27)
20·30
(–51·55 o 98·90)
–9·06
(–63·71 o 47·86)
2·64
(0·91 o 6·08)
3·12
(1·12 o 5·98)
18·12
(–53·72 o 96·56)
–8·66
(–65·03 o 47·86)
·· B eas cance 0·15
(0·06 o 0·38)
0·17
(0·08 o 0·32)
14·33
(–56·82 o
109·36)
–14·46
(–67·38 o 58·17)
3·61
(1·40 o 9·75)
4·14
(1·92 o 7·86)
14·87
(–62·30 o
129·42)
–12·26
(–69·56 o 74·33)
·· U e ine cance 0·10
(0·07 o 0·16)
0·13
(0·09 o 0·20)
31·24
(–14·19 o 56·34)
–1·19
(–31·40 o 16·65)
2·50
(1·60 o 3·91)
3·32
(2·20 o 4·84)
32·82
(–12·54 o 58·57)
2·48
(–32·80 o 21·96)
·· O a ian cance 0·03
(0·00 o 0·11)
0·03
(0·00 o 0·07)
–5·42
(–97·18 o
231·08)
–27·30
(–97·63 o 169·46)
0·81
(0·06 o 2·86)
0·75
(0·00 o 1·90)
–7·10
(–97·19 o
231·03)
–26·75
(–97·31 o 156·14)
·· Kidney cance 0·13
(0·08 o 0·20)
0·17
(0·11 o 0·26)
34·51
(–0·86 o 60·98)
2·17
(–24·86 o 21·78)
3·08
(1·96 o 4·80)
4·06
(2·61 o 6·04)
31·80
(–2·65 o 56·85)
2·54
(–25·05 o 22·42)
·· Thy oid cance 0·02
(0·01 o 0·03)
0·02
(0·01 o 0·04)
23·74
(–45·68 o 71·02)
–5·05
(–56·07 o 32·19)
0·48
(0·23 o 0·95)
0·58
(0·31 o 0·95)
22·78
(–42·37 o 72·84)
–2·72
(–53·99 o 35·78)
·· Non-Hodgkin
lymphoma
0·07
(0·03 o 0·14)
0·08
(0·04 o 0·14)
14·80
(–48·12 o 89·49)
–11·36
(–59·15 o 44·86)
1·93
(0·88 o 3·84)
2·17
(1·02 o 3·70)
12·11
(–53·36 o
89·82)
–9·92
(–61·71 o 50·34)
·· Mul iple myeloma 0·04
(0·02 o 0·07)
0·04
(0·02 o 0·08)
20·90
(–36·98 o 86·20)
–8·58
(–52·81 o 40·23)
0·80
(0·33 o 1·52)
0·96
(0·43 o 1·68)
19·88
(–41·55 o 79·48)
–7·25
(–53·09 o 39·99)
·· Acu e lymphoid
leukaemia
0·01
(0·01 o 0·03)
0·02
(0·01 o 0·03)
21·67
(–42·96 o 84·50)
–0·50
(–52·49 o 49·86)
0·60
(0·33 o 1·16)
0·72
(0·44 o 1·15)
20·31
(–42·71 o 77·73)
2·35
(–50·81 o 53·90)
(Table 4 con inues on nex page)
Global Heal h Me ics
www. helance .com Vol 390 Sep embe 16, 2017
1393
2006 dea hs
(in housands)
2016 dea hs
(in housands)
Pe cen age
change o dea hs
2006–16
Pe cen age
change o age-
s anda dised
dea hs a e
2006–16
2006 DALYs
(in housands)
2016 DALYs
(in housands)
Pe cen age
change o DALYs
2006–16
Pe cen age change
o age-
s anda dised
DALYs a e
2006–16
(Con inued om p e ious page)
·· Ch onic lymphoid
leukaemia
0·02
(0·01 o 0·03)
0·02
(0·01 o 0·03)
11·87
(–40·76 o 59·76)
–17·04
(–56·19 o 17·59)
0·31
(0·17 o 0·60)
0·34
(0·20 o 0·57)
9·98
(–47·66 o
65·06)
–15·46
(–59·33 o 28·08)
·· Acu e myeloid
leukaemia
0·04
(0·02 o 0·06)
0·04
(0·03 o 0·07)
20·64
(–33·37 o 72·72)
–5·40
(–47·60 o 32·17)
1·08
(0·62 o 1·88)
1·27
(0·79 o 2·04)
17·65
(–34·43 o
64·82)
–3·94
(–45·68 o 33·05)
·· Ch onic myeloid
leukaemia
0·01
(0·01 o 0·02)
0·01
(0·01 o 0·02)
–11·77
(–55·23 o 31·96)
–31·15
(–64·52 o 1·81)
0·31
(0·17 o 0·64)
0·26
(0·16 o 0·42)
–15·95
(–62·20 o 24·58)
–31·30
(–68·51 o 2·27)
·· O he leukaemia 0·04
(0·02 o 0·10)
0·04
(0·02 o 0·07)
7·12
(–62·16 o 97·24)
–16·02
(–65·44 o 48·79)
1·08
(0·54 o 3·48)
1·09
(0·64 o 1·86)
1·35
(–70·91 o 82·39)
–16·40
(–73·68 o 53·84)
·· Ischaemic hea
disease
5·98
(3·78 o 9·98)
7·03
(4·58 o 10·61)
17·56
(–29·12 o 52·55)
–11·34
(–46·57 o 15·33)
150·69
(97·37 o 229·60)
176·63
(116·37 o 263·07)
17·21
(–23·17 o 43·80)
–7·75
(–40·83 o 13·00)
·· Ischaemic s oke 1·09
(0·61 o 2·32)
1·17
(0·73 o 1·80)
7·45
(–54·16 o 58·69)
–19·02
(–66·03 o 20·18)
31·26
(19·20 o 57·90)
36·59
(24·19 o 54·00)
17·06
(–40·45 o 50·57)
–9·27
(–55·99 o 17·68)
·· Haemo hagic s oke 2·14
(1·36 o 3·88)
2·47
(1·65 o 3·69)
15·27
(–38·70 o 39·47)
–9·12
(–52·40 o 11·93)
72·43
(47·51 o 116·88)
84·66
(57·32 o 122·05)
16·90
(–28·03 o 35·60)
–4·88
(–42·13 o 11·16)
·· Hype ensi e hea
disease
0·94
(0·53 o 1·57)
1·33
(0·73 o 2·21)
41·34
(1·13 o 61·93)*
5·33
(–25·08 o 21·50)
22·35
(14·24 o 34·30)
30·09
(18·45 o 46·26)
34·67
(1·67 o 50·99)*
5·72
(–20·06 o 18·87)
·· A ial ib illa ion and
lu e
0·18
(0·10 o 0·30)
0·25
(0·15 o 0·39)
44·03
(–1·62 o 70·54)
–0·79
(–32·88 o 17·51)
5·37
(3·13 o 8·88)
7·33
(4·22 o 11·54)
36·35
(0·50 o 59·28)*
2·11
(–24·17 o 18·00)
·· As hma 0·15
(0·08 o 0·36)
0·14
(0·09 o 0·23)
–3·48
(–64·53 o 42·11)
–25·38
(–72·46 o 10·94)
15·00
(8·45 o 25·64)
17·32
(10·00 o 28·61)
15·47
(–28·42 o
40·68)
–3·65
(–40·85 o 18·12)
·· Gallbladde and bilia y
diseases
0·13
(0·08 o 0·21)
0·19
(0·12 o 0·28)
45·16
(5·28 o 65·76)*
7·18
(–20·39 o 22·76)
3·01
(1·95 o 4·61)
4·24
(2·75 o 6·19)
40·81
(3·82 o 57·89)*
10·74
(–18·83 o 24·22)
.. Alzheime ’s disease
and o he demen ias
1·09
(0·44 o 2·12)
1·57
(0·66 o 2·80)
43·79
(–31·20 o 81·61)
–1·32
(–48·85 o 25·19)
13·62
(5·90 o 27·29)
18·90
(7·82 o 34·07)
38·78
(–28·85 o
85·48)
0·35
(–48·69 o 32·06)
.. Diabe es melli us 2·68
(1·80 o 3·83)
3·72
(2·50 o 5·30)
38·65
(13·79 o 51·31)*
6·23
(–14·28 o 15·85)
160·49
(104·01 o 235·77)
228·01
(146·36 o 338·55)
42·07
(24·20 o 52·10)*
14·03
(–0·94 o 22·21)
·· Ch onic kidney
disease due o
diabe es melli us
0·69
(0·34 o 1·18)
1·05
(0·53 o 1·79)
51·91
(15·47 o 70·56)*
14·19
(–12·15 o 27·71)
21·91
(9·80 o 37·27)
32·96
(15·37 o 55·88)
50·42
(16·36 o
69·24)*
15·99
(–9·49 o 29·45)
·· Ch onic kidney disease
due o hype ension
0·28
(0·12 o 0·51)
0·43
(0·18 o 0·78)
52·70
(–0·59 o 74·23)
10·13
(–27·47 o 28·35)
6·42
(3·12 o 10·98)
9·82
(4·86 o 16·38)
52·91
(2·60 o 73·37)*
15·09
(–21·34 o 31·55)
·· Ch onic kidney
disease due o
glome uloneph i is
0·29
(0·14 o 0·50)
0·43
(0·20 o 0·73)
46·29
(22·10 o 61·05)*
11·21
(–7·71 o 21·11)
9·59
(3·88 o 17·35)
13·85
(5·67 o 24·73)
44·51
(18·51 o 60·36)*
13·38
(–7·28 o 24·40)
·· Ch onic kidney disease
due o o he causes
0·30
(0·14 o 0·52)
0·45
(0·21 o 0·78)
51·23
(14·95 o 70·98)*
13·60
(–11·31 o 26·17)
9·12
(3·96 o 16·64)
13·55
(5·90 o 24·85)
48·59
(10·10 o 67·56)*
15·55
(–13·97 o 28·71)
·· Os eoa h i is ·· ·· ·· ·· 12·25
(6·32 o 21·91)
17·50
(9·15 o 29·79)
42·81
(–10·75 o 77·51)
12·04
(–30·98 o 38·72)
·· Low back pain ·· ·· ·· ·· 23·67
(12·74 o 49·51)
27·62
(16·04 o 44·45)
16·69
(–41·75 o 83·77)
–2·98
(–51·67 o 51·38)
·· Gou ·· ·· ·· ·· 1·82
(0·94 o 3·25)
2·48
(1·29 o 4·40)
36·03
(8·43 o 49·14)*
9·54
(–13·22 o 20·02)
·· Ca a ac ·· ·· ·· ·· 1·12
(0·43 o 3·45)
1·27
(0·64 o 2·43)
13·37
(–69·99 o
140·46)
–13·50
(–77·20 o 81·95)
3 Die low in ib e: all
causes
769·74
(446·50 o
1159·77)
877·85
(502·37 o
1337·53)
14·05
(10·69 o 17·13)*
–13·93
(–16·34 o –11·62)*
18 522·14
(10 865·99 o
27 596·25)
20 119·47
(11 653·46 o
30 430·15)
8·62
(5·17 o 11·61)*
–14·06
(–16·63 o –11·74)*
·· Colon and ec um
cance
77·72
(39·53 o
121·45)
92·53
(46·61 o
146·52)
19·05
(13·44 o 23·86)*
–10·11
(–14·25 o –6·60)*
1658·67
(852·86 o
2584·40)
1905·91
(965·68 o
3008·24)
14·91
(8·93 o 19·90)*
–10·61
(–15·08 o –6·81)*
(Table 4 con inues on nex page)
Global Heal h Me ics
1394
www. helance .com Vol 390 Sep embe 16, 2017
2006 dea hs
(in housands)
2016 dea hs
(in housands)
Pe cen age
change o dea hs
2006–16
Pe cen age
change o age-
s anda dised
dea hs a e
2006–16
2006 DALYs
(in housands)
2016 DALYs
(in housands)
Pe cen age
change o DALYs
2006–16
Pe cen age change
o age-
s anda dised
DALYs a e
2006–16
(Con inued om p e ious page)
·· Ischaemic hea
disease
692·02
(395·74 o
1063·40)
785·32
(440·85 o
1225·40)
13·48
(9·90 o 16·76)*
–14·36
(–16·96 o –11·96)*
16 863·47
(9820·85 o
25 673·28)
18 213·56
(10 409·47 o
28 118·37)
8·01
(4·25 o 11·19)*
–14·42
(–17·20 o –11·94)*
3 Die low in calcium: all
causes
135·49
(86·00 o
194·76)
159·88
(101·07 o
232·62)
18·00
(11·94 o 22·51)*
–10·61
(–15·09 o –7·34)*
2935·65
(1882·89 o
4176·04)
3353·07
(2127·08 o
4832·47)
14·22
(7·84 o 18·84)*
–11·07
(–15·93 o –7·61)*
·· Colon and ec um
cance
135·49
(86·00 o
194·76)
159·88
(101·07 o
232·62)
18·00
(11·94 o 22·51)*
–10·61
(–15·09 o –7·34)*
2935·65
(1882·89 o
4176·04)
3353·07
(2127·08 o
4832·47)
14·22
(7·84 o 18·84)*
–11·07
(–15·93 o –7·61)*
3 Die low in sea ood
omega 3 a y acids: all
causes
1347·53
(575·06 o
2186·21)
1538·76
(641·93 o
2518·12)
14·19
(11·23 o 17·24)*
–13·43
(–15·57 o –11·15)*
30 245·39
(13 187·67 o
48 313·74)
33 347·84
(14 222·64 o
53 678·05)
10·26
(7·23 o 13·38)*
–13·56
(–15·86 o –11·20)*
·· Ischaemic hea
disease
1347·53
(575·06 o
2186·21)
1538·76
(641·93 o
2518·12)
14·19
(11·23 o 17·24)*
–13·43
(–15·57 o –11·15)*
30 245·39
(13 187·67 o
48 313·74)
33 347·84
(14 222·64 o
53 678·05)
10·26
(7·23 o 13·38)*
–13·56
(–15·86 o –11·20)*
3 Die low in
polyunsa u a ed a y
acids: all causes
373·71
(152·88 o
579·39)
404·13
(167·80 o
628·84)
8·14
(1·10 o 15·92)*
–18·99
(–24·21 o –13·07)*
8077·08
(3337·50 o
12 512·69)
8351·81
(3443·29 o
12 916·37)
3·40
(–2·82 o 10·23)
–18·99
(–23·72 o –13·61)*
·· Ischaemic hea
disease
373·71
(152·88 o
579·39)
404·13
(167·80 o
628·84)
8·14
(1·10 o 15·92)*
–18·99
(–24·21 o –13·07)*
8077·08
(3337·50 o
12 512·69)
8351·81
(3443·29 o
12 916·37)
3·40
(–2·82 o 10·23)
–18·99
(–23·72 o –13·61)*
3 Die high in ans a y
acids: all causes
236·27
(80·11 o
490·84)
223·64
(62·82 o
513·16)
–5·34
(–25·31 o 5·65)
–29·61
(–44·81 o –21·00)*
5426·02
(1751·02 o
11 428·66)
5111·02
(1348·61 o
11 683·02)
–5·81
(–24·90 o 4·01)
–26·47
(–41·85 o –18·49)*
·· Ischaemic hea
disease
236·27
(80·11 o
490·84)
223·64
(62·82 o
513·16)
–5·34
(–25·31 o 5·65)
–29·61
(–44·81 o –21·00)*
5426·02
(1751·02 o
11 428·66)
5111·02
(1348·61 o
11 683·02)
–5·81
(–24·90 o 4·01)
–26·47
(–41·85 o –18·49)*
3 Die high in sodium: all
causes
2093·86
(641·82 o
4027·16)
2310·47
(654·70 o
4498·83)
10·35
(1·14 o 14·18)*
–17·24
(–23·87 o –14·54)*
44 080·70
(14 013·37 o
84 853·20)
47 567·08
(14 436·69 o
92 411·61)
7·91
(0·83 o 11·33)*
–16·81
(–22·41 o –14·20)*
·· S omach cance 87·78
(29·91 o
169·46)
82·00
(25·89 o
164·38)
–6·58
(–19·18 o 0·49)
–28·70
(–37·72 o –24·32)*
1858·76
(665·42 o
3570·13)
1677·96
(551·88 o
3313·52)
–9·73
(–21·11 o
–2·91)*
–30·26
(–38·59 o –25·91)*
·· Rheuma ic hea
disease
18·85
(5·42 o 40·97)
16·56
(4·21 o 36·93)
–12·11
(–24·41 o
–3·58)*
–32·10
(–41·39 o –26·32)*
508·22
(141·81 o
1117·27)
433·72
(110·18 o 999·89)
–14·66
(–26·19 o
–7·04)*
–31·92
(–41·31 o –26·21)*
·· Ischaemic hea
disease
933·02
(228·66 o
1899·86)
1097·91
(271·71 o
2220·51)
17·67
(12·33 o 22·92)*
–12·43
(–16·13 o –8·54)*
18 024·31
(4595·42 o
37 082·96)
20 494·46
(5230·42 o
41 448·18)
13·70
(9·53 o 19·27)*
–12·58
(–15·65 o –8·42)*
·· Ischaemic s oke 298·64
(87·80 o
607·24)
312·00
(88·62 o
643·83)
4·48
(–3·00 o 9·19)
–21·85
(–27·22 o –18·72)*
6331·08
(2048·13 o
12 479·99)
6939·12
(2243·57 o
13 630·21)
9·60
(4·34 o 14·91)*
–16·53
(–20·56 o –12·41)*
·· Haemo hagic s oke 462·49
(172·54 o
842·63)
432·53
(147·88 o
808·61)
–6·48
(–16·08 o
–1·80)*
–29·05
(–36·48 o –25·70)*
10 650·45
(3995·11 o
19 583·09)
9962·38
(3520·25 o
18 774·49)
–6·46
(–14·68 o
–2·50)*
–27·53
(–34·08 o –24·41)*
·· Hype ensi e hea
disease
142·05
(27·30 o
351·99)
181·96
(33·21 o
464·61)
28·10
(2·03 o 45·37)*
–5·27
(–24·95 o 6·83)
2731·43
(670·95 o
6388·79)
3298·57
(730·16 o
7748·68)
20·76
(1·85 o 35·50)*
–7·33
(–22·43 o 3·79)
·· O he
ca diomyopa hy
10·66
(2·22 o 23·96)
12·52
(2·32 o 28·86)
17·39
(–3·70 o 28·91)
–11·88
(–28·39 o –2·67)*
242·84
(51·24 o 538·45)
270·46
(53·89 o 606·34)
11·38
(–5·12 o 20·11)
–12·68
(–26·01 o –5·61)*
·· A ial ib illa ion and
lu e
11·26
(2·54 o 25·22)
15·56
(3·33 o 35·44)
38·19
(25·76 o 43·79)*
–1·98
(–9·57 o 1·66)
382·36
(95·58 o 800·54)
501·90
(124·45 o
1052·73)
31·26
(25·19 o 34·93)*
–0·58
(–4·89 o 2·57)
·· Ao ic aneu ysm 9·57
(2·18 o 20·52)
11·02
(2·31 o 24·08)
15·18
(2·55 o 21·25)*
–13·17
(–22·38 o –9·02)*
184·54
(43·83 o 391·55)
204·79
(44·97 o 436·91)
10·97
(–0·89 o 17·09)
–14·32
(–23·42 o –9·77)*
·· Pe iphe al ascula
disease
1·88
(0·25 o 4·56)
2·51
(0·34 o 6·25)
33·19
(16·18 o 51·41)*
–3·46
(–14·44 o 10·20)
50·71
(9·14 o 121·19)
62·48
(10·88 o 148·77)
23·20
(11·72 o 32·25)*
–7·07
(–15·48 o –0·73)*
(Table 4 con inues on nex page)
Global Heal h Me ics
www. helance .com Vol 390 Sep embe 16, 2017
1395
2006 dea hs
(in housands)
2016 dea hs
(in housands)
Pe cen age
change o dea hs
2006–16
Pe cen age
change o age-
s anda dised
dea hs a e
2006–16
2006 DALYs
(in housands)
2016 DALYs
(in housands)
Pe cen age
change o DALYs
2006–16
Pe cen age change
o age-
s anda dised
DALYs a e
2006–16
(Con inued om p e ious page)
·· Endoca di is 4·12
(0·77 o 9·81)
5·16
(0·90 o 12·34)
25·41
(14·57 o 30·73)*
–5·45
(–13·78 o –1·43)*
92·56
(16·37 o 222·32)
111·10
(18·80 o 270·10)
20·04
(11·39 o 25·25)*
–5·37
(–13·40 o –1·59)*
·· O he ca dio ascula
and ci cula o y
diseases
29·97
(6·67 o 64·98)
34·19
(7·06 o 77·30)
14·10
(–1·52 o 21·18)
–14·37
(–25·64 o –9·26)*
866·90
(215·87 o
1874·08)
970·65
(226·05 o
2134·15)
11·97
(0·73 o 17·31)*
–12·89
(–21·61 o –8·68)*
·· Ch onic kidney disease
due o diabe es melli us
38·25
(9·51 o 82·81)
47·89
(10·61 o
105·42)
25·21
(10·95 o 29·75)*
–5·22
(–15·38 o –2·14)*
1047·19
(279·10 o
2297·95)
1269·79
(302·82 o
2829·29)
21·26
(8·49 o 25·52)*
–5·96
(–15·38 o –2·85)*
·· Ch onic kidney disease
due o hype ension
23·28
(5·93 o 50·23)
30·37
(7·11 o 66·16)
30·44
(17·26 o 35·06)*
–4·36
(–12·78 o –1·54)*
497·97
(135·51 o
1054·49)
626·30
(162·35 o
1355·19)
25·77
(15·42 o 29·65)*
–4·23
(–11·72 o –1·41)*
·· Ch onic kidney disease
due o
glome uloneph i is
8·03
(1·35 o 19·34)
9·84
(1·48 o 24·04)
22·57
(8·58 o 26·59)*
–6·75
(–16·15 o –4·18)*
241·64
(42·80 o 581·91)
282·61
(47·47 o 682·09)
16·95
(5·24 o 20·87)*
–7·52
(–15·54 o –5·01)*
·· Ch onic kidney disease
due o o he causes
14·03
(2·72 o 33·20)
18·43
(3·17 o 44·06)
31·38
(15·39 o 36·18)*
–1·84
(–13·73 o 1·01)
369·73
(73·40 o 902·50)
460·78
(84·25 o 1145·85)
24·62
(11·02 o 28·56)*
–2·97
(–13·68 o –0·33)*
2 Sexual abuse and
iolence: all causes
149·42
(94·83 o
204·16)
73·83
(53·79 o
94·09)
–50·59
(–54·93 o
–41·98)*
–57·82
(–61·57 o
–50·49)*
11 095·59
(8127·52 o
13 985·73)
8201·58
(6354·86 o
10 332·83)
–26·08
(–34·79 o
–15·42)*
–36·15
(–43·53 o –27·22)*
3 Childhood sexual abuse:
all causes
8·98
(6·58 o 11·81)
8·74
(6·40 o 11·74)
–2·66
(–13·60 o 10·23)
–20·18
(–28·78 o –10·11)*
2495·64
(1766·89 o
3377·91)
2748·30
(1920·53 o
3735·79)
10·12
(7·71 o 12·41)*
–6·09
(–8·31 o –4·17)*
·· Alcohol use diso de s 8·98
(6·58 o 11·81)
8·74
(6·40 o 11·74)
–2·66
(–13·60 o 10·23)
–20·18
(–28·78 o –10·11)*
814·13
(574·56 o
1131·70)
854·71
(596·52 o
1200·17)
4·98
(–1·17 o 10·82)
–10·40
(–15·87 o –5·29)*
·· Majo dep essi e
diso de
·· ·· ·· ·· 1681·51
(1101·62 o
2354·77)
1893·59
(1235·31 o
2667·57)
12·61
(11·02 o 14·30)*
–4·04
(–5·26 o –2·80)*
3 In ima e pa ne
iolence: all causes
140·45
(86·78 o
194·82)
65·09
(44·85 o
85·84)
–53·65
(–57·43 o
–45·90)*
–60·39
(–63·74 o –53·55)*
8702·76
(6067·70 o
11 437·85)
5575·29
(4224·54 o
7079·58)
–35·94
(–43·21 o
–25·04)*
–44·53
(–50·72 o –35·17)*
·· D ug-suscep ible HIV/
AIDS– ube culosis
26·36
(12·66 o
43·52)
9·23
(4·43 o 14·96)
–64·97
(–67·40 o
–62·15)*
–70·87
(–72·90 o –68·73)*
1146·54
(540·62 o
1916·16)
423·59
(203·21 o 687·99)
–63·05
(–65·77 o
–59·57)*
–68·63
(–70·89 o –65·77)*
·· Mul id ug- esis an
HIV/AIDS– ube culosis
wi hou ex ensi e
d ug esis ance
2·07
(0·93 o 3·52)
0·71
(0·32 o 1·22)
–65·82
(–72·96 o
–56·64)*
–71·63
(–77·56 o –64·16)*
88·64
(39·75 o 152·39)
31·67
(14·10 o 54·75)
–64·27
(–71·71 o
–54·47)*
–69·71
(–75·98 o –61·51)*
·· Ex ensi ely d ug-
esis an HIV/AIDS –
ube culosis
0·02
(0·01 o 0·04)
0·02
(0·01 o 0·04)
13·96
(–2·84 o 32·78)
–4·23
(–18·41 o 11·39)
0·96
(0·42 o 1·70)
1·12
(0·48 o 1·97)
16·38
(–0·88 o 36·31)
–0·47
(–15·26 o 16·38)
·· HIV/AIDS esul ing in
o he diseases
84·54
(43·40 o
129·36)
31·10
(16·08 o
47·65)
–63·22
(–66·05 o
–59·87)*
–68·71
(–71·09 o –65·93)*
4027·09
(2046·13 o
6160·95)
1584·24
(814·13 o
2425·13)
–60·66
(–63·52 o
–57·44)*
–66·07
(–68·50 o –63·31)*
·· Ma e nal abo ion,
misca iage, and
ec opic p egnancy
4·11
(2·45 o 6·19)
3·00
(1·75 o 4·79)
–27·02
(–36·19 o
–17·03)*
–34·53
(–42·83 o –25·55)*
233·81
(137·40 o 351·12)
170·68
(97·12 o 270·75)
–27·00
(–35·84 o
–17·85)*
–34·18
(–42·23 o –25·85)*
·· Majo dep essi e
diso de
·· ·· ·· ·· 1582·91
(966·13 o
2381·34)
1870·82
(1146·94 o
2801·23)
18·19
(15·62 o 21·12)*
–1·74
(–3·69 o 0·18)
·· Assaul by i ea m 4·73
(3·09 o 5·60)
4·77
(3·13 o 6·06)
0·75
(–8·07 o 24·07)
–10·75
(–18·39 o 9·61)
250·39
(163·69 o 295·57)
246·14
(163·72 o 308·71)
–1·70
(–10·63 o 22·32)
–10·98
(–19·00 o 10·46)
·· Assaul by sha p
objec
6·88
(4·69 o 8·17)
6·00
(4·41 o 7·87)
–12·69
(–23·31 o 21·78)
–23·39
(–32·53 o 6·30)
367·54
(255·41 o 435·61)
314·12
(235·32 o 404·00)
–14·54
(–24·84 o 18·52)
–23·58
(–32·59 o 5·48)
·· Sexual iolence ·· ·· ·· ·· 291·29
(191·88 o 418·18)
298·83
(195·75 o 428·19)
2·59
(0·69 o 4·22)*
–6·63
(–7·90 o –5·72)*
(Table 4 con inues on nex page)
Global Heal h Me ics
1396
www. helance .com Vol 390 Sep embe 16, 2017
2006 dea hs
(in housands)
2016 dea hs
(in housands)
Pe cen age
change o dea hs
2006–16
Pe cen age
change o age-
s anda dised
dea hs a e
2006–16
2006 DALYs
(in housands)
2016 DALYs
(in housands)
Pe cen age
change o DALYs
2006–16
Pe cen age change
o age-
s anda dised
DALYs a e
2006–16
(Con inued om p e ious page)
·· Assaul by o he
means
11·73
(8·71 o 14·49)
10·26
(8·02 o 13·17)
–12·56
(–24·54 o 5·66)
–23·23
(–33·65 o –7·28)*
713·59
(558·79 o
866·06)
634·08
(509·27 o 793·77)
–11·14
(–22·12 o 4·98)
–20·79
(–30·38 o –7·10)*
2 Unsa e sex: all causes 1799·64
(1709·98 o
1892·29)
1100·90
(1048·42 o
1148·40)
–38·83
(–40·96 o
–36·41)*
–47·76
(–49·54 o
–45·78)*
86 860·81
(81 591·84 o
92 234·51)
54 603·03
(51 340·06 o
58 075·62)
–37·14
(–39·35 o
–34·64)*
–45·34
(–47·21 o –43·21)*
·· D ug-suscep ible HIV/
AIDS– ube culosis
363·54
(244·52 o
481·15)
177·41
(121·51 o
236·50)
–51·20
(–54·00 o
–48·03)*
–58·56
(–60·94 o
–56·00)*
17 186·87
(11 569·46 o
22 809·50)
8948·63
(6232·62 o
11 865·25)
–47·93
(–50·95 o
–44·18)*
–54·73
(–57·35 o –51·55)*
·· Mul id ug- esis an
HIV/AIDS– ube culosis
wi hou ex ensi e
d ug esis ance
30·65
(18·73 o
45·88)
14·52
(8·81 o 21·68)
–52·62
(–61·10 o
–42·60)*
–59·80
(–67·03 o –51·32)*
1423·49
(866·21 o
2131·53)
714·22
(433·23 o
1064·03)
–49·83
(–58·78 o
–39·15)*
–56·42
(–64·22 o –47·18)*
·· Ex ensi ely d ug-
esis an HIV/AIDS–
ube culosis
0·52
(0·33 o 0·79)
0·77
(0·47 o 1·20)
48·49
(29·74 o 70·40)*
27·46
(11·27 o 46·30)*
24·64
(15·40 o 37·14)
36·82
(22·60 o 56·99)
49·44
(30·40 o 72·32)*
30·37
(13·77 o 50·30)*
·· HIV/AIDS esul ing in
o he diseases
1165·31
(1020·87 o
1330·03)
652·04
(578·82 o
729·70)
–44·05
(–46·83 o
–40·95)*
–51·77
(–54·17 o –49·13)*
58 595·06
(51 311·35 o
66 970·36)
34 615·61
(30 661·75 o
38 960·02)
–40·92
(–43·71 o
–37·90)*
–48·30
(–50·71 o –45·70)*
·· Syphilis 3·31
(2·85 o 3·91)
3·02
(2·55 o 3·44)
–8·89
(–18·77 o 9·37)
–24·89
(–33·13 o –9·95)*
277·24
(229·80 o
328·03)
305·18
(247·07 o 367·04)
10·08
(1·88 o 18·96)*
–8·03
(–14·11 o –0·79)*
·· Chlamydial in ec ion 1·24
(0·99 o 1·37)
1·19
(0·98 o 1·33)
–4·51
(–11·73 o 12·18)
–20·70
(–26·52 o –7·57)*
519·31
(341·24 o 781·67)
562·13
(370·06 o 850·69)
8·25
(5·89 o 10·42)*
–3·33
(–5·56 o –1·40)*
·· Gonococcal in ec ion 3·51
(2·81 o 3·85)
3·37
(2·76 o 3·80)
–4·05
(–11·10 o 12·51)
–20·87
(–26·48 o –7·90)*
581·90
(412·15 o 823·83)
674·77
(467·35 o 974·12)
15·96
(10·35 o 21·76)*
2·68
(–2·71 o 7·83)
·· T ichomoniasis ·· ·· ·· ·· 170·83
(65·10 o 361·77)
198·07
(75·83 o 420·49)
15·95
(14·84 o 17·09)*
1·82
(0·94 o 2·72)*
·· Geni al he pes ·· ·· ·· ·· 187·73
(60·91 o 427·68)
221·21
(71·15 o 506·61)
17·84
(15·47 o 19·69)*
–0·16
(–1·64 o 1·54)
·· O he sexually
ansmi ed diseases
1·73
(1·40 o 1·90)
1·63
(1·35 o 1·83)
–5·92
(–12·96 o 11·16)
–21·03
(–26·82 o –7·18)*
858·99
(589·04 o
1221·09)
942·39
(643·29 o
1348·57)
9·71
(7·38 o 12·17)*
–2·62
(–4·83 o –0·42)*
·· Ce ical cance 229·83
(195·46 o
245·84)
246·95
(203·95 o
263·27)
7·45
(1·21 o 15·47)*
–15·99
(–20·69 o –9·78)*
7034·76
(5873·55 o
7509·99)
7384·00
(6014·77 o
7862·78)
4·96
(–1·30 o 13·23)
–15·71
(–20·76 o –9·21)*
2 Low physical ac i i y:
all causes
1159·60
(607·84 o
1790·07)
1373·34
(717·65 o
2084·16)
18·43
(–7·89 o 55·46)
–12·88
(–31·98 o 13·86)
21 078·75
(11 156·78 o
32 368·81)
24 315·86
(12 811·32 o
36 604·69)
15·36
(–12·15 o 55·44)
–11·79
(–32·55 o 18·47)
·· Colon and ec um
cance
20·87
(1·07 o 50·40)
25·51
(1·28 o 61·93)
22·21
(–46·00 o
212·87)
–8·42
(–59·11 o 136·31)
411·01
(23·10 o 991·31)
488·61
(26·82 o 1183·40)
18·88
(–48·29 o
205·64)
–8·33
(–59·81 o 136·94)
·· B eas cance 6·71
(0·04 o 14·74)
7·85
(0·03 o 17·15)
16·97
(–19·98 o 88·93)
–10·88
(–38·58 o 44·86)
175·07
(1·05 o 388·06)
200·14
(0·80 o 440·98)
14·33
(–24·10 o 90·78)
–10·01
(–39·82 o 49·21)
·· Ischaemic hea
disease
835·44
(347·97 o
1353·66)
1005·58
(425·31 o
1640·08)
20·37
(–6·38 o 58·30)
–11·49
(–30·93 o 15·93)
14 658·37
(6114·10 o
23 953·87)
16 943·23
(7260·81 o
27 786·10)
15·59
(–11·49 o 54·73)
–11·42
(–31·91 o 18·08)
·· Ischaemic s oke 267·12
(53·52 o
511·96)
295·28
(49·52 o
562·19)
10·54
(–19·06 o 49·40)
–18·82
(–40·33 o 9·53)
4725·12
(1026·32 o
9141·81)
5268·62
(938·08 o
10 006·35)
11·50
(–18·88 o
54·06)
–15·63
(–38·34 o 16·18)
·· Diabe es melli us 29·46
(7·36 o 52·61)
39·12
(8·65 o 71·86)
32·80
(–11·95 o
104·74)
–0·40
(–33·63 o 52·78)
1109·18
(248·01 o
2082·98)
1415·26
(312·14 o
2604·08)
27·59
(–17·68 o
104·26)
–0·58
(–35·47 o 58·06)
(Table 4 con inues on nex page)
Global Heal h Me ics
www. helance .com Vol 390 Sep embe 16, 2017
1397
2006 dea hs
(in housands)
2016 dea hs
(in housands)
Pe cen age
change o dea hs
2006–16
Pe cen age
change o age-
s anda dised
dea hs a e
2006–16
2006 DALYs
(in housands)
2016 DALYs
(in housands)
Pe cen age
change o DALYs
2006–16
Pe cen age change
o age-
s anda dised
DALYs a e
2006–16
(Con inued om p e ious page)
1 Me abolic isks: all
causes
14 834·47
(13 966·55 o
15 690·95)
17 493·53
(16 427·65 o
18 524·26)
17·92
(15·73 o 20·58)*
–11·86
(–13·47 o –9·94)*
348 438·17
(324 520·78 o
374 936·88)
401 813·92
(372 407·65 o
434 394·06)
15·32
(13·16 o
17·52)*
–10·29
(–11·98 o –8·60)*
2 High as ing plasma
glucose: all causes
4700·40
(3722·99 o
5906·04)
5612·45
(4457·29 o
6987·54)
19·40
(15·54 o 23·19)*
–10·32
(–13·29 o –7·61)*
123 096·04
(102 887·96 o
146 660·95)
144 088·58
(119 872·60 o
171 585·77)
17·05
(13·94 o
19·89)*
–8·83
(–11·35 o –6·55)*
·· D ug-suscep ible
ube culosis
125·08
(78·55 o
175·35)
99·60
(62·39 o
140·59)
–20·36
(–24·38 o
–16·57)*
–37·14
(–40·10 o
–34·46)*
4013·77
(2581·12 o
5546·25)
3126·64
(2002·75 o
4288·46)
–22·10
(–25·60 o
–18·55)*
–37·09
(–39·78 o –34·65)*
·· Mul id ug- esis an
ube culosis wi hou
ex ensi e d ug
esis ance
12·50
(7·74 o 18·06)
8·80
(5·32 o 12·83)
–29·61
(–36·56 o
–22·33)*
–44·21
(–49·66 o
–38·40)*
394·88
(253·40 o 557·02)
266·97
(168·75 o 375·02)
–32·39
(–38·90 o
–25·48)*
–45·28
(–50·42 o –39·77)*
·· Ex ensi ely d ug-
esis an ube culosis
0·54
(0·33 o 0·79)
0·94
(0·58 o 1·39)
73·66
(50·32 o
101·15)*
37·94
(20·01 o 59·36)*
17·18
(10·63 o 24·33)
28·42
(17·68 o 40·36)
65·41
(42·36 o
90·02)*
34·13
(15·91 o 54·00)*
·· Colon and ec um
cance
46·54
(11·36 o
101·41)
56·18
(13·51 o
122·80)
20·70
(15·48 o 25·34)*
–9·50
(–13·53 o –5·91)*
884·79
(208·91 o
1926·46)
1047·94
(242·88 o
2300·07)
18·44
(13·03 o 23·15)*
–9·42
(–13·57 o –5·78)*
·· Li e cance due o
o he causes
10·01
(2·06 o 23·07)
11·82
(2·44 o
26·96)
18·12
(13·22 o 22·67)*
–8·69
(–12·24 o –5·26)*
247·67
(51·70 o 571·25)
279·35
(58·20 o 649·12)
12·79
(7·38 o 17·65)*
–11·62
(–15·55 o –7·90)*
·· Panc ea ic cance 21·37
(4·71 o 46·72)
27·75
(6·10 o 60·79)
29·86
(26·27 o 33·12)*
–2·11
(–4·96 o 0·48)
406·22
(90·54 o 891·18)
518·70
(115·69 o
1142·16)
27·69
(24·05 o 30·83)*
–2·46
(–5·20 o 0·04)
·· T acheal, b onchus,
and lung cance
100·11
(22·74 o
219·56)
117·06
(26·22 o
256·14)
16·93
(13·75 o 19·76)*
–10·83
(–13·19 o –8·64)*
2028·69
(457·34 o
4483·59)
2304·26
(517·29 o
5093·70)
13·58
(10·25 o 16·54)*
–12·74
(–15·22 o –10·53)*
·· B eas cance 26·09
(4·93 o 59·11)
31·03
(5·96 o 69·25)
18·94
(11·73 o 26·02)*
–10·02
(–15·31 o –4·93)*
637·43
(120·29 o
1460·33)
749·77
(144·08 o
1694·69)
17·62
(9·76 o 25·72)*
–8·95
(–14·91 o –2·97)*
·· O a ian cance 8·11
(1·53 o 19·32)
10·01
(1·88 o 23·94)
23·40
(18·12 o 28·40)*
–6·84
(–10·75 o –3·13)*
182·64
(34·17 o 438·11)
226·27
(41·63 o 545·49)
23·89
(18·46 o
29·09)*
–5·00
(–9·13 o –1·10)*
·· Bladde cance 10·79
(2·22 o 23·92)
13·47
(2·80 o 29·79)
24·87
(20·66 o 28·68)*
–6·86
(–10·10 o –3·96)*
185·65
(37·01 o 413·28)
225·37
(45·96 o 501·26)
21·39
(16·66 o 25·27)*
–7·62
(–11·16 o –4·73)*
·· Ischaemic hea
disease
1576·70
(935·55 o
2479·20)
1883·33
(1104·82 o
2942·53)
19·45
(13·37 o 25·39)*
–11·29
(–15·21 o –7·64)*
29 401·46
(18 681·34 o
45 481·26)
33 937·53
(21 184·55 o
51 236·60)
15·43
(10·21 o 20·56)*
–11·40
(–15·50 o –7·55)*
·· Ischaemic s oke 449·06
(229·48 o
849·74)
472·53
(246·22 o
879·04)
5·23
(–1·90 o 12·75)
–21·44
(–26·20 o –17·05)*
8810·40
(4539·51 o
14 964·85)
9467·73
(5021·42 o
15 876·46)
7·46
(0·60 o 13·96)*
–18·27
(–23·34 o –13·54)*
·· Haemo hagic s oke 484·34
(304·87 o
745·37)
473·30
(301·08 o
720·04)
–2·28
(–8·77 o 3·28)
–25·71
(–30·75 o –21·17)*
10 790·83
(6746·12 o
15 844·21)
10 638·08
(6692·27 o
15 613·04)
–1·42
(–7·28 o 3·80)
–23·88
(–28·89 o –19·71)*
·· Pe iphe al ascula
disease
8·67
(6·23 o 12·26)
11·73
(8·71 o 17·62)
35·33
(24·67 o 48·64)*
–2·51
(–9·98 o 6·88)
213·89
(150·72 o 302·55)
271·68
(195·01 o 383·83)
27·02
(21·52 o 34·82)*
–4·49
(–8·52 o 1·11)
·· Alzheime ’s disease
and o he demen ias
123·02
(26·35 o
274·89)
174·35
(37·30 o
388·04)
41·73
(38·26 o 45·05)*
–1·20
(–3·44 o 1·60)
1584·88
(330·04 o
3563·61)
2138·24
(445·48 o
4857·92)
34·92
(32·10 o 37·60)*
–1·28
(–3·30 o 1·10)
·· Diabe es melli us 1095·53
(1065·39 o
1121·32)
1436·26
(1401·25 o
1469·57)
31·10
(28·92 o 33·39)*
–0·87
(–2·52 o 0·84)
45 947·41
(38 659·07 o
54 662·94)
57 175·71
(47 919·49 o
68 211·91)
24·44
(22·70 o 26·24)*
–1·66
(–3·03 o –0·22)*
·· Ch onic kidney
disease due o
diabe es melli us
384·78
(349·87 o
418·93)
500·41
(452·11 o
543·57)
30·05
(26·18 o 32·84)*
–0·63
(–3·43 o 1·30)
11 723·50
(10 608·16 o
12 883·32)
14 649·82
(13 196·95 o
16 191·89)
24·96
(21·91 o 27·57)*
–1·37
(–3·51 o 0·51)
(Table 4 con inues on nex page)
Global Heal h Me ics
1398
www. helance .com Vol 390 Sep embe 16, 2017
2006 dea hs
(in housands)
2016 dea hs
(in housands)
Pe cen age
change o dea hs
2006–16
Pe cen age
change o age-
s anda dised
dea hs a e
2006–16
2006 DALYs
(in housands)
2016 DALYs
(in housands)
Pe cen age
change o DALYs
2006–16
Pe cen age change
o age-
s anda dised
DALYs a e
2006–16
(Con inued om p e ious page)
·· Ch onic kidney
disease due o
hype ension
103·23
(70·71 o
134·57)
135·31
(92·80 o
176·80)
31·08
(24·95 o 37·33)*
–3·63
(–7·93 o 0·57)
2165·18
(1452·61 o
2857·87)
2724·97
(1827·82 o
3615·75)
25·85
(20·11 o 31·49)*
–4·20
(–8·66 o 0·03)
·· Ch onic kidney
disease due o
glome uloneph i is
42·94
(28·57 o
57·82)
54·38
(36·92 o
73·20)
26·63
(21·53 o 31·75)*
–3·73
(–7·53 o 0·00)
1251·76
(815·12 o
1731·15)
1519·82
(1004·85 o
2100·93)
21·42
(17·17 o 25·92)*
–4·39
(–7·34 o –1·01)*
·· Ch onic kidney
disease due o o he
causes
71·01
(48·20 o
94·44)
94·20
(63·89 o
125·10)
32·66
(26·70 o 38·48)*
–0·15
(–4·43 o 3·81)
1866·69
(1234·98 o
2533·02)
2346·56
(1566·99 o
3183·01)
25·71
(20·33 o
30·88)*
–2·03
(–6·05 o 1·77)
·· Glaucoma ·· ·· ·· ·· 25·15
(5·71 o 58·51)
33·85
(7·75 o 78·65)
34·62
(31·92 o 37·57)*
1·52
(–0·42 o 3·66)
·· Ca a ac ·· ·· ·· ·· 315·98
(65·93 o 735·41)
410·89
(85·82 o 961·77)
30·04
(27·58 o 32·78)*
–1·16
(–3·06 o 1·06)
2High o al choles e ol:
all causes
3802·10
(2971·09 o
4832·93)
4392·51
(3374·22 o
5619·87)
15·53
(11·51 o 19·77)*
–14·14
(–16·62 o –11·41)*
83 976·46
(70 004·69 o
98 804·76)
93 844·03
(78 027·31 o
111 266·48)
11·75
(8·59 o 15·13)*
–13·29
(–15·68 o –10·73)*
·· Ischaemic hea
disease
3343·63
(2597·25 o
4187·22)
3896·10
(2982·29 o
4940·40)
16·52
(12·29 o 20·89)*
–13·22
(–15·68 o –10·56)*
73 403·57
(61 220·12 o
86 047·11)
82 187·03
(68 385·19 o
96 854·44)
11·97
(8·76 o 15·47)*
–12·88
(–15·33 o –10·24)*
·· Ischaemic s oke 458·46
(185·09 o
924·24)
496·40
(196·69 o
990·11)
8·28
(1·92 o 14·44)*
–20·63
(–23·82 o –17·08)*
10 572·88
(6206·10 o
17 681·57)
11 657·00
(6791·38 o
19 428·74)
10·25
(6·20 o 14·39)*
–16·02
(–19·10 o –12·79)*
2 High sys olic blood
p essu e: all causes
9083·07
(8209·73 o
9963·14)
10 455·86
(9381·88 o
11 507·49)
15·11
(12·53 o 18·15)*
–14·05
(–15·90 o –11·81)*
188 635·23
(171 004·50 o
205 178·38)
212 105·09
(191 466·22 o
230 661·27)
12·44
(10·03 o 15·07)*
–13·27
(–15·09 o –11·25)*
·· Rheuma ic hea
disease
85·51
(58·24 o
126·10)
80·86
(55·41 o
124·17)
–5·43
(–12·76 o 3·81)
–26·92
(–32·20 o –20·72)*
2412·32
(1643·79 o
3500·44)
2234·54
(1547·75 o
3250·51)
–7·37
(–13·42 o 0·51)
–25·82
(–30·59 o –19·76)*
·· Ischaemic hea
disease
4476·47
(3732·81 o
5193·76)
5261·72
(4374·30 o
6188·35)
17·54
(14·19 o 21·12)*
–12·69
(–14·94 o –10·11)*
85 975·47
(74 665·22 o
97 205·97)
97 886·68
(84 378·88 o
110 500·79)
13·85
(10·72 o 17·14)*
–12·44
(–14·77 o –9·97)*
·· Ischaemic s oke 1283·00
(989·81 o
1551·76)
1372·51
(1053·44 o
1670·88)
6·98
(3·05 o 11·54)*
–20·42
(–23·09 o –17·59)*
25 564·17
(20 155·09 o
29 832·63)
28 119·95
(21 993·71 o
32 960·56)
10·00
(6·27 o 13·81)*
–16·42
(–19·14 o –13·56)*
·· Haemo hagic s oke 1636·18
(1343·27 o
1897·92)
1672·64
(1375·89 o
1947·04)
2·23
(–0·33 o 4·87)
–22·45
(–24·32 o –20·60)*
37 920·74
(31 833·70 o
43 655·27)
38 611·64
(32 491·61 o
44 204·86)
1·82
(–0·41 o 4·22)
–20·91
(–22·79 o –19·01)*
·· Hype ensi e hea
disease
694·18
(579·81 o
760·86)
893·14
(698·18 o
982·33)
28·66
(14·46 o 42·90)*
–4·39
(–14·79 o 5·66)
13 562·97
(11 596·54 o
15 040·61)
16 323·95
(13 447·14 o
17 832·20)
20·36
(10·19 o 32·88)*
–6·60
(–14·56 o 2·76)
·· O he
ca diomyopa hy
60·64
(44·14 o
77·33)
74·93
(54·83 o
95·99)
23·56
(16·20 o 31·99)*
–7·84
(–13·17 o –1·67)*
1352·53
(1021·85 o
1642·20)
1599·77
(1242·11 o
1935·40)
18·28
(11·07 o 26·29)*
–7·37
(–12·73 o –1·09)*
·· A ial ib illa ion and
lu e
61·68
(45·24 o
81·70)
85·31
(62·06 o
113·83)
38·31
(33·98 o 42·56)*
–2·78
(–5·10 o –0·60)*
1865·37
(1396·49 o
2444·60)
2439·54
(1822·85 o
3211·02)
30·78
(28·89 o
32·53)*
–1·52
(–2·73 o –0·44)*
·· Ao ic aneu ysm 51·01
(40·98 o
60·67)
60·10
(48·02 o
72·42)
17·81
(13·84 o 22·53)*
–11·62
(–14·32 o –8·15)*
961·55
(799·00 o
1113·52)
1100·81
(930·12 o
1274·73)
14·48
(10·15 o 19·96)*
–11·71
(–14·92 o –7·65)*
·· Pe iphe al ascula
disease
12·49
(8·26 o 18·74)
16·55
(10·89 o
25·60)
32·49
(20·21 o 47·35)*
–4·83
(–12·82 o 5·05)
290·81
(199·85 o 436·13)
360·60
(246·52 o 530·75)
24·00
(17·02 o 32·57)*
–6·80
(–11·75 o –0·54)*
·· Endoca di is 25·33
(19·02 o
32·47)
33·12
(24·85 o
42·80)
30·76
(25·24 o 36·10)*
–1·38
(–5·39 o 2·95)
589·46
(447·95 o 744·37)
745·71
(570·49 o 942·16)
26·51
(21·03 o 31·79)*
0·16
(–4·21 o 4·17)
·· O he ca dio ascula
and ci cula o y
diseases
174·04
(148·57 o
214·23)
208·84
(177·87 o
255·72)
20·00
(15·44 o 25·66)*
–10·49
(–13·75 o –6·47)*
4740·48
(3978·63 o
5703·94)
5577·83
(4690·60 o
6705·53)
17·66
(14·21 o 22·09)*
–8·60
(–11·32 o –5·34)*
(Table 4 con inues on nex page)
Global Heal h Me ics
www. helance .com Vol 390 Sep embe 16, 2017
1399
2006 dea hs
(in housands)
2016 dea hs
(in housands)
Pe cen age
change o dea hs
2006–16
Pe cen age
change o age-
s anda dised
dea hs a e
2006–16
2006 DALYs
(in housands)
2016 DALYs
(in housands)
Pe cen age
change o DALYs
2006–16
Pe cen age change
o age-
s anda dised
DALYs a e
2006–16
(Con inued om p e ious page)
·· Ch onic kidney
disease due o
diabe es melli us
176·23
(128·84 o
227·68)
233·70
(170·75 o
301·63)
32·61
(29·00 o 35·48)*
–0·06
(–2·77 o 1·94)
4755·11
(3375·01 o
6163·36)
6154·78
(4359·36 o
7973·15)
29·44
(26·62 o 32·07)*
–0·01
(–2·10 o 1·78)
·· Ch onic kidney
disease due o
hype ension
222·32
(199·99 o
248·86)
299·48
(268·03 o
335·26)
34·71
(30·47 o 38·02)*
–0·96
(–3·95 o 1·00)
5166·00
(4517·97 o
5842·00)
6602·34
(5756·41 o
7488·87)
27·80
(24·67 o
30·62)*
–1·02
(–3·31 o 0·87)
·· Ch onic kidney
disease due o
glome uloneph i is
47·82
(34·20 o
62·17)
60·17
(42·74 o
78·14)
25·83
(22·33 o 29·04)*
–4·69
(–6·90 o –2·70)*
1443·70
(1010·81 o
1931·01)
1739·55
(1207·79 o
2320·30)
20·49
(17·59 o 23·37)*
–4·97
(–6·98 o –2·95)*
·· Ch onic kidney
disease due o o he
causes
76·17
(51·67 o
99·57)
102·79
(69·50 o
135·39)
34·95
(30·99 o 38·74)*
0·84
(–1·83 o 3·10)
2034·56
(1366·91 o
2688·13)
2607·39
(1738·64 o
3467·30)
28·16
(25·16 o 31·01)*
–0·11
(–2·27 o 1·77)
2 High body-mass index:
all causes
3519·12
(2136·48 o
5165·34)
4525·10
(2867·22 o
6434·24)
28·59
(23·43 o 35·93)*
–2·71
(–6·52 o 2·81)
105 257·57
(65 833·95 o
150 547·40)
135 381·33
(88 608·73 o
187 363·70)
28·62
(23·09 o
36·63)*
0·88
(–3·40 o 7·02)
·· Oesophageal cance 57·66
(18·86 o
112·99)
70·33
(22·52 o
133·63)
21·97
(11·96 o 36·08)*
–6·97
(–14·64 o 3·67)
1357·91
(431·31 o
2647·91)
1622·45
(516·51 o
3060·94)
19·48
(9·83 o 33·83)*
–7·80
(–15·24 o 3·26)
·· Colon and ec um
cance
49·63
(26·72 o
79·41)
65·11
(35·86 o
102·02)
31·19
(25·23 o 38·71)*
–0·94
(–5·50 o 4·74)
1075·85
(579·66 o
1714·70)
1394·02
(775·82 o
2160·04)
29·57
(22·96 o
37·66)*
–0·04
(–4·94 o 6·05)
·· Li e cance due o
hepa i is B
26·37
(8·91 o 55·20)
37·72
(13·44 o
74·28)
43·05
(31·18 o 64·94)*
11·96
(2·72 o 28·75)*
782·13
(261·88 o
1631·20)
1078·26
(379·06 o
2124·71)
37·86
(25·99 o
60·04)*
10·01
(0·61 o 27·39)*
·· Li e cance due o
hepa i is C
15·00
(6·11 o 28·01)
21·21
(8·95 o 38·36)
41·40
(33·58 o 52·25)*
6·97
(1·14 o 15·12)*
328·28
(134·34 o 602·47)
459·82
(197·62 o 813·07)
40·07
(31·65 o 52·24)*
7·44
(1·26 o 16·40)*
·· Li e cance due o
alcohol use
11·43
(4·52 o 21·77)
16·59
(6·67 o 31·05)
45·18
(35·92 o 58·24)*
10·99
(3·90 o 20·62)*
265·54
(104·88 o
498·00)
383·17
(157·32 o 707·88)
44·30
(34·95 o 57·95)*
11·45
(4·17 o 21·82)*
·· Li e cance due o
o he causes
14·98
(4·98 o 31·65)
21·93
(7·78 o 43·51)
46·36
(35·51 o 64·87)*
13·85
(5·45 o 27·54)*
415·44
(136·60 o
884·65)
586·63
(208·44 o
1183·29)
41·21
(29·77 o 61·17)*
12·10
(3·36 o 27·26)*
·· Gallbladde and bilia y
ac cance
19·19
(10·00 o
31·40)
24·23
(12·96 o
38·93)
26·31
(20·46 o 33·91)*
–5·19
(–9·47 o 0·48)
398·83
(206·71 o 659·38)
501·99
(271·35 o 804·62)
25·87
(19·54 o
33·96)*
–3·50
(–8·43 o 2·52)
·· Panc ea ic cance 17·09
(6·73 o 32·72)
23·80
(9·45 o 45·36)
39·31
(33·12 o 46·65)*
5·04
(0·00 o 10·77)
355·53
(132·75 o 689·18)
488·30
(185·48 o 937·58)
37·34
(31·04 o
44·82)*
5·41
(0·50 o 11·10)*
·· B eas cance 24·50
(9·01 o 45·25)
34·14
(14·17 o
61·44)
39·33
(26·71 o 66·63)*
1·49
(–7·17 o 17·88)
478·48
(134·90 o 931·31)
696·82
(241·06 o
1278·23)
45·63
(28·58 o
100·78)*
4·33
(–6·57 o 30·51)
·· U e ine cance 25·33
(16·84 o
34·86)
31·98
(22·02 o
42·77)
26·29
(17·00 o 39·60)*
–4·35
(–11·15 o 5·40)
616·37
(406·52 o 852·11)
777·06
(534·09 o
1037·37)
26·07
(16·24 o 39·81)*
–2·75
(–10·14 o 7·44)
·· O a ian cance 3·96
(–0·06 o 8·73)
5·16
(–0·08 o
11·22)
30·36
(21·79 o 40·84)*
–0·87
(–7·38 o 6·92)
100·08
(–1·45 o 221·53)
130·91
(–2·01 o 284·65)
30·81
(22·13 o 41·76)*
1·63
(–5·03 o 10·00)
·· Kidney cance 18·46
(10·70 o
28·15)
24·80
(14·55 o
37·29)
34·35
(28·83 o 41·33)*
1·72
(–2·45 o 6·95)
414·68
(240·63 o
629·90)
545·45
(324·36 o 818·33)
31·53
(25·96 o
38·50)*
1·48
(–2·72 o 6·69)
·· Thy oid cance 2·91
(1·43 o 5·04)
3·99
(2·04 o 6·86)
37·08
(28·94 o 47·41)*
4·67
(–1·57 o 12·41)
75·91
(37·37 o 132·41)
104·28
(53·14 o 180·08)
37·39
(29·21 o
48·00)*
7·53
(1·34 o 15·42)*
·· Non-Hodgkin
lymphoma
8·76
(3·45 o 15·95)
12·11
(4·73 o 21·66)
38·22
(32·55 o 44·75)*
5·46
(1·16 o 10·68)*
214·81
(83·04 o 391·23)
295·53
(117·37 o 532·38)
37·58
(31·28 o 43·90)*
8·27
(3·38 o 13·37)*
·· Mul iple myeloma 4·86
(2·10 o 8·71)
6·66
(2·89 o 11·78)
37·06
(31·43 o 44·71)*
3·30
(–1·17 o 9·24)
103·69
(45·00 o 186·13)
142·21
(62·40 o 249·59)
37·15
(31·41 o 45·43)*
5·30
(0·94 o 11·53)*
(Table 4 con inues on nex page)
Global Heal h Me ics
1400
www. helance .com Vol 390 Sep embe 16, 2017
2006 dea hs
(in housands)
2016 dea hs
(in housands)
Pe cen age
change o dea hs
2006–16
Pe cen age
change o age-
s anda dised
dea hs a e
2006–16
2006 DALYs
(in housands)
2016 DALYs
(in housands)
Pe cen age
change o DALYs
2006–16
Pe cen age change
o age-
s anda dised
DALYs a e
2006–16
(Con inued om p e ious page)
·· Acu e lymphoid
leukaemia
1·59
(0·75 o 2·73)
2·22
(1·11 o 3·78)
39·14
(29·44 o 48·47)*
10·63
(3·24 o 17·88)*
53·85
(25·63 o 93·15)
73·29
(36·49 o 125·61)
36·10
(26·03 o
46·07)*
12·10
(3·94 o 19·97)*
·· Ch onic lymphoid
leukaemia
2·36
(1·18 o 3·92)
2·92
(1·50 o 4·80)
23·58
(17·80 o 31·41)*
–8·23
(–13·00 o –2·59)*
45·52
(22·50 o 75·54)
55·53
(28·44 o 89·89)
21·98
(15·87 o 30·42)*
–6·69
(–11·35 o –0·57)*
·· Acu e myeloid
leukaemia
4·65
(2·33 o 7·66)
6·22
(3·15 o 10·05)
33·79
(28·67 o 40·45)*
3·44
(–0·54 o 8·61)
119·03
(59·43 o 197·90)
156·14
(79·64 o 253·37)
31·17
(26·04 o
38·42)*
4·62
(0·50 o 10·33)*
·· Ch onic myeloid
leukaemia
1·50
(0·74 o 2·54)
1·56
(0·79 o 2·62)
3·86
(–0·97 o 9·84)
–20·41
(–24·02 o –15·73)*
38·75
(18·95 o 66·00)
39·64
(20·22 o 66·66)
2·32
(–2·78 o 8·83)
–18·45
(–22·36 o –13·42)*
·· O he leukaemia 5·65
(2·63 o 9·91)
6·91
(3·43 o 11·92)
22·36
(13·74 o 33·25)*
–5·39
(–11·58 o 2·67)
150·74
(68·70 o 270·44)
175·88
(86·80 o 306·17)
16·67
(6·35 o 30·31)*
–6·03
(–13·63 o 3·83)
·· Ischaemic hea
disease
1288·03
(750·54 o
1915·37)
1592·33
(949·29 o
2325·60)
23·62
(18·28 o 31·01)*
–6·63
(–10·33 o –1·34)*
30 281·04
(18 069·07 o
44 440·56)
36 991·70
(22 899·69 o
52 749·96)
22·16
(17·05 o 29·82)*
–4·63
(–8·58 o 1·24)
·· Ischaemic s oke 283·31
(157·87 o
446·42)
318·39
(179·56 o
494·72)
12·38
(6·06 o 21·03)*
–14·52
(–19·22 o –8·07)*
7636·97
(4439·93 o
11 465·75)
9139·16
(5520·94 o
13 559·93)
19·67
(13·90 o 27·73)*
–7·74
(–12·19 o –1·69)*
·· Haemo hagic s oke 517·26
(299·18 o
797·22)
592·91
(364·88 o
872·03)
14·63
(7·65 o 24·31)*
–10·40
(–15·68 o –2·82)*
15 913·88
(9447·13 o
23 465·66)
18 284·39
(11 769·74 o
25 665·62)
14·90
(7·94 o 24·58)*
–8·36
(–13·89 o –0·19)*
·· Hype ensi e hea
disease
215·62
(115·71 o
340·33)
300·81
(162·11 o
482·35)
39·51
(23·49 o 54·97)*
4·14
(–6·93 o 14·90)
4745·65
(2865·31 o
6909·68)
6328·03
(3954·75 o
8998·62)
33·34
(20·77 o 46·93)*
3·67
(–6·03 o 13·90)
·· A ial ib illa ion and
lu e
30·66
(15·59 o
50·28)
46·15
(23·86 o
74·25)
50·50
(44·68 o 57·96)*
4·01
(0·15 o 9·07)*
847·22
(424·79 o
1434·95)
1206·94
(614·35 o
2008·58)
42·46
(38·94 o
47·40)*
6·27
(3·63 o 10·00)*
·· As hma 50·50
(26·16 o
85·76)
60·27
(33·27 o
99·29)
19·33
(9·60 o 32·81)*
–7·72
(–15·43 o 2·78)
3096·98
(1685·64 o
5065·91)
3888·00
(2214·88 o
6203·97)
25·54
(19·00 o 34·22)*
4·23
(–2·03 o 11·64)
·· Gallbladde and bilia y
diseases
22·65
(14·01 o
33·32)
31·11
(20·15 o
44·30)
37·32
(30·32 o 47·23)*
1·35
(–3·54 o 8·56)
478·24
(295·15 o 708·79)
634·28
(413·77 o 904·27)
32·63
(25·47 o 42·16)*
3·09
(–2·47 o 10·47)
·· Alzheime ’s disease
and o he demen ias
185·54
(67·16 o
358·86)
286·44
(106·50 o
545·02)
54·38
(48·77 o 62·72)*
6·35
(2·04 o 13·00)*
2357·11
(900·89 o
4607·68)
3493·12
(1387·03 o
6739·85)
48·20
(43·46 o
55·36)*
7·68
(4·04 o 13·61)*
·· Diabe es melli us 390·47
(263·53 o
530·40)
553·44
(386·74 o
727·93)
41·74
(35·95 o 49·03)*
8·24
(3·84 o 14·15)*
20 585·42
(13 617·44 o
29 152·97)
28 645·74
(19 660·88 o
39 287·38)
39·16
(33·19 o 47·36)*
10·31
(5·57 o 16·73)*
·· Ch onic kidney
disease due o
diabe es melli us
98·46
(43·76 o
164·31)
146·40
(65·81 o
237·24)
48·69
(39·03 o 60·84)*
12·65
(7·32 o 19·88)*
3124·61
(1338·04 o
5247·93)
4566·00
(2050·51 o
7410·10)
46·13
(38·14 o 58·53)*
13·04
(7·74 o 20·08)*
·· Ch onic kidney
disease due o
hype ension
47·69
(18·11 o
89·54)
73·45
(26·32 o
135·91)
54·03
(38·50 o 66·89)*
12·85
(7·10 o 23·44)*
1176·40
(503·88 o
2012·81)
1785·47
(805·84 o
2934·09)
51·77
(41·13 o 65·00)*
15·47
(9·33 o 24·63)*
·· Ch onic kidney
disease due o
glome uloneph i is
30·93
(13·32 o
52·67)
41·71
(18·41 o
69·06)
34·87
(25·53 o 45·01)*
2·81
(–1·47 o 7·98)
1032·52
(417·03 o
1809·69)
1358·82
(567·29 o
2326·03)
31·60
(25·38 o
40·49)*
3·51
(–0·63 o 8·87)
·· Ch onic kidney
disease due o o he
causes
42·14
(18·81 o
71·07)
62·11
(26·60 o
104·77)
47·39
(32·26 o 59·95)*
11·26
(5·17 o 18·01)*
1301·30
(581·61 o
2232·05)
1867·87
(883·35 o
3113·60)
43·54
(35·86 o 54·17)*
11·97
(7·12 o 18·59)*
·· Os eoa h i is ·· ·· ·· ·· 2173·98
(1045·13 o
3867·70)
3225·98
(1624·93 o
5586·80)
48·39
(42·88 o
57·06)*
15·18
(11·04 o 21·86)*
·· Low back pain ·· ·· ·· ·· 2684·27
(1366·73 o
4685·98)
3630·51
(1919·27 o
6254·44)
35·25
(30·07 o
42·46)*
9·39
(5·70 o 14·83)*
(Table 4 con inues on nex page)
Global Heal h Me ics
www. helance .com Vol 390 Sep embe 16, 2017
1401
2006 dea hs
(in housands)
2016 dea hs
(in housands)
Pe cen age
change o dea hs
2006–16
Pe cen age
change o age-
s anda dised
dea hs a e
2006–16
2006 DALYs
(in housands)
2016 DALYs
(in housands)
Pe cen age
change o DALYs
2006–16
Pe cen age change
o age-
s anda dised
DALYs a e
2006–16
(Con inued om p e ious page)
·· Gou ·· ·· ·· ·· 229·32
(105·94 o
410·88)
321·88
(154·53 o 568·22)
40·37
(35·33 o 47·42)*
10·69
(6·98 o 16·07)*
·· Ca a ac ·· ·· ·· ·· 201·26
(82·62 o 397·74)
306·06
(132·21 o 586·28)
52·08
(45·72 o 61·98)*
15·83
(10·93 o 23·62)*
2 Low bone mine al
densi y: all causes
341·07
(288·70 o
360·77)
441·23
(374·93 o
466·70)
29·37
(24·07 o 34·07)*
–5·78
(–9·63 o –2·34)*
9412·32
(8030·50 o
11 131·37)
11 955·49
(10 090·79 o
14 196·27)
27·02
(23·65 o
29·65)*
–3·07
(–5·68 o –1·03)*
·· Pedes ian oad
inju ies
40·74
(38·39 o
43·41)
46·93
(44·13 o
49·88)
15·20
(9·02 o 18·80)*
–13·11
(–17·62 o –10·45)*
1094·99
(979·92 o
1226·14)
1293·53
(1143·70 o
1463·75)
18·13
(12·36 o 21·58)*
–8·69
(–12·96 o –6·11)*
·· Cyclis oad inju ies 5·17
(4·64 o 5·66)
6·03
(5·44 o 6·73)
16·64
(11·21 o 23·63)*
–10·21
(–14·32 o –5·00)*
343·04
(267·55 o
438·99)
447·83
(343·84 o 583·35)
30·55
(26·30 o 34·15)*
1·26
(–1·80 o 3·89)
·· Mo o cyclis oad
inju ies
8·60
(7·58 o 9·40)
10·61
(9·08 o 11·55)
23·37
(16·31 o 29·85)*
–3·30
(–8·74 o 1·71)
516·37
(422·92 o 630·17)
665·90
(537·39 o 824·92)
28·96
(24·64 o 32·55)*
1·63
(–1·65 o 4·24)
·· Mo o ehicle oad
inju ies
29·15
(26·52 o
32·31)
33·42
(30·60 o
37·18)
14·65
(10·86 o 20·30)*
–12·30
(–15·19 o –8·05)*
1053·30
(916·84 o
1212·20)
1227·50
(1055·45 o
1420·62)
16·54
(13·17 o 21·00)*
–9·15
(–11·70 o –5·87)*
·· O he oad inju ies 1·11
(0·97 o 1·42)
1·34
(1·19 o 1·71)
20·66
(10·56 o 35·98)*
–10·20
(–17·75 o 1·23)
85·10
(62·48 o 115·48)
129·35
(92·12 o 178·79)
51·99
(46·52 o 56·32)*
16·84
(12·28 o 20·37)*
·· O he anspo
inju ies
7·41
(6·74 o 7·98)
8·91
(8·22 o 10·00)
20·29
(13·83 o 28·79)*
–8·50
(–13·44 o –2·28)*
330·22
(273·06 o 402·51)
394·33
(321·20 o 482·74)
19·41
(15·51 o 24·18)*
–7·29
(–10·26 o –3·74)*
·· Falls 237·28
(186·55 o
254·10)
321·08
(254·50 o
344·23)
35·32
(28·08 o 41·49)*
–3·51
(–8·60 o 0·81)
5306·53
(4397·57 o
6284·03)
6968·79
(5750·97 o
8276·40)
31·32
(26·75 o 34·67)*
–1·34
(–4·93 o 1·31)
·· O he exposu e o
mechanical o ces
6·42
(5·21 o 6·94)
7·62
(5·85 o 8·28)
18·75
(11·69 o 23·63)*
–11·15
(–16·26 o –7·33)*
401·92
(305·39 o 523·87)
513·05
(380·93 o 681·19)
27·65
(23·66 o
30·49)*
–1·40
(–4·33 o 0·74)
·· Non- enomous
animal con ac
0·68
(0·53 o 0·88)
0·76
(0·59 o 1·02)
12·06
(4·71 o 23·04)*
–15·81
(–21·13 o –7·87)*
21·55
(16·66 o 27·50)
23·45
(18·15 o 30·34)
8·80
(3·65 o 14·68)*
–15·77
(–19·71 o –11·18)*
·· Assaul by o he
means
3·91
(3·13 o 4·64)
4·14
(3·51 o 5·31)
5·95
(–3·67 o 21·09)
–18·19
(–25·57 o –7·12)*
236·94
(182·44 o
304·08)
268·81
(204·14 o 351·16)
13·45
(7·54 o 19·57)*
–11·45
(–15·88 o –6·82)*
·· Fo ces o na u e,
con lic and e o ism,
and s a e ac o
iolence
0·60
(0·40 o 0·81)
0·37
(0·21 o 0·57)
–38·05
(–56·98 o
–20·83)*
–51·96
(–66·57 o –38·70)*
22·35
(13·90 o 36·70)
22·95
(10·58 o 47·82)
2·68
(–28·79 o 30·32)
–19·58
(–43·89 o 1·64)
2 Impai ed kidney
unc ion: all causes
2108·45
(1943·12 o
2277·00)
2554·21
(2346·59 o
2766·51)
21·14
(18·37 o 23·96)*
–9·08
(–10·89 o –7·16)*
52 009·54
(48 088·99 o
55 861·74)
60 482·18
(55 678·63 o
65 319·35)
16·29
(13·87 o 18·61)*
–8·10
(–9·94 o –6·30)*
·· Ischaemic hea
disease
753·35
(627·96 o
868·81)
906·02
(749·80 o
1056·12)
20·27
(15·84 o 24·87)*
–11·91
(–14·40 o –9·02)*
13 095·90
(11 202·99 o
14 872·74)
15 068·46
(12 896·50 o
17 267·64)
15·06
(11·42 o 18·84)*
–11·75
(–14·21 o –9·06)*
·· Ischaemic s oke 201·59
(153·59 o
247·89)
219·00
(164·95 o
274·84)
8·63
(2·78 o 14·64)*
–19·04
(–22·23 o –15·40)*
4041·29
(3235·99 o
4810·89)
4478·73
(3577·63 o
5417·18)
10·82
(6·20 o 15·37)*
–15·45
(–18·71 o –12·11)*
·· Haemo hagic s oke 227·29
(185·54 o
269·78)
236·16
(191·40 o
283·30)
3·91
(0·62 o 7·40)*
–20·50
(–22·52 o –18·46)*
5431·74
(4452·60 o
6455·91)
5578·78
(4537·14 o
6686·22)
2·71
(–0·10 o 5·74)
–19·77
(–21·70 o –17·83)*
·· Pe iphe al ascula
disease
5·64
(3·81 o 8·18)
7·32
(4·82 o 11·42)
29·76
(16·19 o 45·98)*
–4·33
(–12·92 o 6·28)
170·24
(121·08 o 237·00)
210·83
(147·41 o 296·25)
23·84
(16·07 o 32·93)*
–5·65
(–11·04 o 0·58)
·· Ch onic kidney
disease due o
diabe es melli us
384·78
(349·87 o
418·93)
500·41
(452·11 o
543·57)
30·05
(26·18 o 32·84)*
–0·63
(–3·43 o 1·30)
11 723·50
(10 608·16 o
12 883·32)
14 649·82
(13 196·95 o
16 191·89)
24·96
(21·91 o 27·57)*
–1·37
(–3·51 o 0·51)
(Table 4 con inues on nex page)
Global Heal h Me ics
1408
www. helance .com Vol 390 Sep embe 16, 2017
a e la ge, inc easing, and a iable ac oss coun ies a he
same le el o de elopmen likely wa an pa icula policy
a en ion. Ou analysis showed ha componen s o die ,
obesi y, FPG, and SBP a e he mos p ominen global isks
ul illing hese c i e ia. Because o he s ong in e -
ela ionships be ween hese isks, he ue d i e o his
clus e is likely die , he isk in BMI, o bo h, wi h knock-
on consequences o FPG and SBP. The ise o obesi y and
he associa ed inc eases in FPG and SBP wa an con-
side able global policy a en ion. O he majo isks ha
should con inue o ecei e a en ion—e en in ensi ied
a en ion in some loca ions—such as smoking, a e ne e -
heless declining a he global le el. The unique
combina ion o la ge cu en e ec and inc easing
exposu e pu s obesi y in a special ca ego y o isks. Obesi y
is likely o no only in luence u u e popula ion heal h in
many loca ions, bu will ha e conside able inancial
implica ions o heal h sys ems, gi en wha we know abou
ea men cos s o he associa ed diseases. Since impo an
d i e s o obesi y such as physical ac i i y and die pa e ns
a e adop ed in childhood and adolescence, mo e wo k is
needed o p oac i ely add ess he adop ion o hese isks in
hese younge age g oups.
Fo he i s ime, we assess he con ibu ion o changes
o isk exposu es o he o e all global end o dea hs and
DALYs; o example, in he pas 10 yea s, changes in all isk
exposu es con ibu ed o an 10·8% (8·3–13·1) decline in
DALYs, while o he ac o s con ibu ed o a 16·5%
(14·1–18·8) dec ease in DALYs. Mo e de ailed assessmen s
show la ge declines in CMNN causes and inc eases in
inju ies and non-communicable DALYs. In each case, he
con ibu ion o o he ac o s was subs an ially la ge han
he con ibu ion o isk educ ion. Ou indings o he
ela i ely small con ibu ion o isk educ ion o he
declines in NCDs a e no a odds wi h published s udies
o he UK and he USA,20–22 because we a e epo ing a
he global le el; ou esul s a he na ional le el sugges a
la ge ole o isk educ ion in some high-SDI loca ions.
These obse a ions lead o wo di ec ions o u he
analysis. Fi s , wha is he explana ion o he declines
d i en by o he ac o s? Some o his e ec migh be social
policy wo king h ough a ious causal channels, and some
is likely due o imp o emen s in access o high-quali y
heal h ca e. This is pa icula ly ue o condi ions such as
selec ed cance s, ischaemic hea disease, ce eb o ascula
disease, ch onic kidney diseases, HIV/AIDS, ube culosis,
and ma e nal mo ali y, o which heal h ca e is known o
ha e la ge e ec s. Second, in iew o he eno mous
po en ial o isk educ ion o change heal h ou comes as
documen ed in his and many o he s udies, why has
p og ess on many isks been compa a i ely slow? Fo
example, e en hough global obacco consump ion is
declining in e ms o a es, he pace o decline has been
ema kably slow on a e age, despi e mo e han 50 yea s o
good e idence on he ha ms o obacco. The ela i ely poo
ack eco d o global isk educ ion migh in pa e lec
he low a e o in es men in isk educ ion compa ed wi h
cu a i e heal h ca e. I migh also e lec he con inuing
challenge o changing many isky beha iou s. Rela i ely
li le unding o esea ch on changing beha iou s
compa ed wi h new diagnos ics and he apeu ics migh
also be pa o he explana ion o he p e en ion pa adox.23,24
Changing beha iou al isks could also equi e mo e han
go e nmen ac ion; ha nessing he p i a e sec o o
acili a e beha iou al change migh also be c ucial.
Impo an changes in GBD 2016 compa ed wi h in GBD
2015 ( isks o de ed by global ank)
Sys olic blood p essu e
Inc eased SBP emains he leading global isk a Le el 3 in
he GBD isk hie a chy. Highly e ec i e in e en ions exis
o manage blood p essu e a he p ima y ca e le el, as do a
ange o public heal h in e en ions, so i is qui e ema kable
ha global exposu e o inc eased SBP is inc easing. Pa o
his inc ease migh be ied o he global ise in high BMI,
bu he inc ease in SBP ep esen s signi ican missed
oppo uni y o he wo ld’s heal h sys ems. In 54 coun ies
high SBP is ac ually declining, while i s inc ease in China is
now well documen ed in a se ies o popula ion-based
su eys.25–27 Tackling ising SBP is a global conce n, bu his
is pa icula ly impo an in hose loca ions whe e a es a e
inc easing. In iew o he e ec o he isk and he la ge
a ay o a ailable, e ec i e in e en ions, heal h sys ems
and he global heal h communi y need o mobilise inc eased
esou ces and policy a en ion o ackle his p oblem. I
migh be necessa y o design a a ie y o public policies
including ood e o mula ion o educe sodium con en and
e o s o incen i ise p ima y ca e p o ide s o gi e p io i y
o he managemen o SBP.28–30
Tobacco
In mo ing owa d de eloping a comp ehensi e pic u e o
obacco use globally, in GBD 2016, we ha e o he i s
ime included smokeless obacco use as a isk ac o . While
he bu den o smokeless obacco is minimal in he
majo i y o coun ies, i is o huge impo ance in sou h
Asia, whe e he highes isk-weigh ed exposu e is obse ed
in Bangladesh ( isk-weigh ed exposu e o 0·75 [0·61–0·87]),
Bhu an (0·53 [0·44–0·62]), Myanma (0·50 [0·42–0·59]),
Nepal (0·50 [0·42–0·58]), and India (0·45 [0·43–0·47]). In
hese coun ies mo e women use smokeless obacco
p oduc s han smoked obacco p oduc s, and we ind ha
use o any obacco p oduc s, smoked o smokeless,
con inuously inc eases wi h age, a egional age pa e n
ha di e s om he global and male egional age pa e n.
The combina ion o high exposu e and la ge popula ion
esul s in a majo i y o global dea hs a ibu able o
smokeless obacco in 2016 occu ing in India, whe e i is
also he leading isk ac o o o al cance .
In GBD 2016, we also imp o ed he es ima ion o bu den
a ibu able o second-hand smoke. A he global le el,
while he bu den o second-hand smoke emains sub-
s an ial, exposu e o second-hand smoke has been
declining signi ican ly a an annualised a e o change o
Global Heal h Me ics
www. helance .com Vol 390 Sep embe 16, 2017
1409
1·9% (1·5–2·4). These educ ions a e likely a ibu able o
a wide ange o public heal h measu es o con ol obacco,
which ha e accele a ed in a la ge numbe o coun ies
since he implemen a ion o he F amewo k Con en ion
on Tobacco Con ol (FCTC).31
P og ess comba ing he obacco epidemic has esul ed
in global declines in p e alence o obacco use and second-
hand smoke exposu e, ye he numbe o dea hs and
DALYs a ibu able o obacco has inc eased since 1990.
Inc eases in bu den we e d i en by a combina ion o
popula ion g ow h and popula ion ageing, along wi h
pe sis en ly high smoking p e alence in some o he mos
populous coun ies o he wo ld. Taken oge he , we can
expec he bu den o obacco o emain high in yea s o
come, unless he a e o p og ess is signi ican ly
accele a ed. Many coun ies wi h pe sis en ly high le els o
daily smoking eco ded ma ginal p og ess in he pas
decade, and smoking emains a leading isk ac o in mos
coun ies. The ac ha obacco use pa e ns di e ge by
loca ion, le el o de elopmen , and sex highligh s he need
o mo e ailo ed app oaches o change smoking
beha iou s in he u u e. Pa icula ly wo isome a e he
ends among young men and women. Fo example, in
Indonesia, a coun y ha has no ye a i ied he FCTC,31
mo e han hal o men aged 20–24 yea s a e daily smoke s.
Unde s anding wha wo ks—and wha does no — o
obacco con ol ac oss con ex s and wi hin subpopula ions
(ie, men and women, younge and olde indi iduals,
a ious socioeconomic g oups) is o g owing p io i y. To
signi ican ly and pe manen ly change he oll o obacco, a
enewed and sus ained ocus is needed on comp ehensi e
obacco con ol policies a ound he wo ld.
Fas ing plasma glucose
The global inc ease in FPG is likely ied o he inc ease in
BMI. While exposu e is inc easing, age-s anda dised
a ibu able mo aliy a e is no ; a ela ed pa e n is ha he
p e alence o diabe es is inc easing, bu dea hs om
diabe es ha e been declining, likely because clinical
managemen o he mac o ascula complica ions o
diabe es has imp o ed in many (bu no all) loca ions.
P e en ion ials show ha wi h in ensi e esou ces
de o ed o weigh loss and physical ac i i y, educ ions in
FPG can be achie ed; howe e , hese in e en ions ha e
no been implemen ed a a na ional scale and adhe ence in
he long un is challenging. Sys ema ic e o s o sc een o
high FPG implemen ed in some coun ies may inc ease
awa eness and ac ion in mo e pa ien s bu can be esou ce-
in ensi e. Clinical in e en ions o educe FPG can be
e ec i e, al hough he e a e mo e ecen deba es on he
app op ia e a ge s o ea men in some cases. Wi h FPG
inc easing in many se ings, i is di icul o de e mine he
popula ion e ec o ea men o blood suga on popula ion
FPG. FPG emains one o he isk ac o s ha is mos
likely in luenced a he p ima y heal h-ca e le el,
emphasising he ole o uni e sal co e age o p ima y ca e
in a mul ip onged esponse o his inc easing p oblem.
Body-mass index
One o he mos ala ming isks in he analysis is inc eased
BMI, because i s bu den is la ge and inc easing, and i is
p e alen ac oss all le els o SDI.32,33 The po en ial d i e s
o his global epidemic include changes in ood indus ies
and sys ems, which inc ease a ailabili y, accessibili y, and
a o dabili y o ene gy-dense oods, along wi h in ense
ma ke ing o such oods, as well as educed oppo uni ies
o physical ac i i y.34 A ange o in e en ions ha e been
p oposed o educe obesi y, including es ic ing he
ad e isemen o unheal hy oods o child en, imp o ing
school meals, axa ion o suga -swee ened be e ages, and
axa ion o educe consump ion o o he unheal hy oods
and subsidies o inc ease in ake o heal hy oods, and
using supply-chain incen i es o inc ease p oduc ion o
heal hy oods.35 Howe e , he e idence base ha many o
hese in e en ions can a ec ends in obesi y a scale is
cu en ly weak.36 Wha we know wi hou a doub is ha
obesi y a es con inue o inc ease in almos all loca ions.
Low-SDI and middle-SDI coun ies gene ally ha e li le
inancial esou ces o nu i ion p og ams and mos ly ely
on ex e nal dono s whose p og ammes o en p e e en ially
a ge unde nu i ion.37 The inc ease in exposu e o high
BMI is g ea e han he inc ease in a ibu able bu den
la gely because ca dio ascula disease dea h a es con inue
o decline because o o he changes, pa icula ly imp o e-
men s in ea men and declines in smoking and high
choles e ol. P oposed policies, e en i ully imple men ed,
a e unlikely o apidly educe he p e alence o obesi y.
While no a solu ion o he ise o o e weigh and obesi y,
clinical in e en ions ha con ol high SBP, choles e ol,
and FPG ( he majo isk ac o s o ca dio ascula disease)
can be used o mi iga e some o he ca dio ascula ill-
e ec s.20 Expanded use o such in e en ions among obese
people could e ec i ely educe he disease bu den o high
BMI. Sus ained p og ess, howe e , will equi e policies
ha e ec i ely con ol weigh in childhood and in young
and middle-aged adul s.
Die
In GBD 2016, poo die a y habi s we e he second leading
isk ac o a Le el 2 o he hie a chy o mo ali y globally,
accoun ing o nea ly one in e e y i e dea hs. The o e all
bu den o die a y isks a he global le el was 14·8%
(11·7–18·5) lowe han in GBD 2015. Addi ionally,
impo an di e ences we e obse ed in he a ibu able
bu den and he anking o indi idual die a y isks. Mul iple
ac o s ha e con ibu ed o hese di e ences, including
using mo e da a sou ces, as well as imp o ing he me hod
o es ima ion o he mean and dis ibu ion o in ake o
each die a y ac o . In GBD 2016, o he i s ime, we used
sales da a o in o m ou es ima es o consump ion o mos
die a y ac o s. Using sales da a, in addi ion o imp o ing
ou o e all da a co e age, allowed us o cap u e ecen
ends in consump ion. This was pa icula ly impo an o
speci ic die a y ac o s, such as suga -swee ened be e ages,
which ha e been he a ge o die a y policies in se e al
Global Heal h Me ics
1410
www. helance .com Vol 390 Sep embe 16, 2017
coun ies.38–43 Addi ionally, o imp o e he consis ency o
de ini ions o die a y isk ac o s ac oss su eys, we made a
sys ema ic e o o ob ain and e-ex ac indi idual-le el
da a om nu i ion su eys. To make he cu en le el o
in ake and op imal le el o in ake mo e compa able, we
used he absolu e le el o in ake ( a he han he in ake
s anda dised o 2000 kcal pe day) as he p ima y exposu e
in GBD 2016. We also co ec ed ou es ima ed daily in ake
o each indi idual die a y ac o o wi hin-pe son a ia ion
and cha ac e ised he usual in ake a he popula ion le el.
Finally, gi en he di e ences in he heal h e ec s and
pa e ns o in ake o legumes and ege ables, we es ima ed
he bu den o disease a ibu able o low in ake o legumes
and low in ake o ege ables sepa a ely.
The decade o 2016–25 has been decla ed as he Decade
o Ac ion on Nu i ion by he Uni ed Na ions Gene al
Assembly.44 GBD 2016 p o ides a comp ehensi e pic u e
o a ious o ms o malnu i ion (ie, unde nu i ion,
o e weigh o obesi y, and poo die a y habi s) ac oss all
coun ies a he s a o he Decade o Ac ion on Nu i ion
and can in o m p io i ies o e idence-based in e en ions
in each coun y. GBD also p o ides an independen a enue
o annually moni o he p og ess o coun ies owa d
achie ing hei nu i ion- ela ed goals in a compa able and
consis en manne . Ou esul s show ha among all o ms
o malnu i ion, poo die a y habi s, pa icula ly low in ake
o heal hy oods, is he leading isk ac o o mo ali y. This
inding has impo an implica ions o na ional go e n-
men s and in e na ional o ganisa ions aiming a ending
malnu i ion o e he nex decade, highligh ing he need
o comp ehensi e ood sys em in e en ions o p omo e
he p oduc ion, dis ibu ion, and consump ion o heal hy
oods ac oss na ions.
Low bi hweigh and sho ges a ion
Low bi hweigh and sho ges a ion ha e been added o
GBD 2016; hey a e he hi d-leading global isk a Le el 3
in he GBD isk hie a chy. Imp o emen s in bu den
a ibu able o low bi hweigh and sho ges a ion ha e
been la gely d i en by o he ac o s in luencing neona al
dea h a es, gi en ha exposu e o low bi hweigh and
sho ges a ion ha e no imp o ed much o e he pas
27 yea s. Li le p og ess in exposu e sugges s subop imal
co e age o in e en ions and p og ammes ha can p e en
low bi hweigh and sho ges a ion. These include women-
cen ed se ices o op imising nu i ion (including
minimising obesi y), in ec ion con ol, smoking cessa ion,
and p e en i e ca e o p egnan women o hose
con empla ing p egnancy.45–47 E o s should also ocus on
maximising he quali y o an ena al ca e se ices o iden i y
and app op ia ely manage a - isk and high- isk
p egnancies,48 including a oidance o p o ide -ini ia ed
p e e m deli e y. I e idence-based in e en ions a e
employed, i should be possible e en in esou ce-limi ed
se ings o shi he isk cu e o hose babies who will be
bo n ea ly, small, o bo h, despi e bes e o s. Be o e bi h,
his includes po en ially an ena al s e oid adminis a ion o
p omo e lung de elopmen ;49 a bi h, his equi es
p esence o adequa ely ained and equipped neona al
esusci a ion se ices;50,51 pos -deli e y, i should include
physicians wi h neona al specialisa ion and a ailabili y o
suppo i e equipmen such as con inuous posi i e ai way
p essu e.52 Facili y-based in ec ion con ol measu es a e
c ucial o p e en nosocomial ansmission, as such e en s
a e highly le hal in low bi hweigh o sho ges a ion
neona es.53 The inclusion o his isk o a majo cause o
DALYs—namely, neona al mo ali y—also expands he
sha e o o e all bu den ha can be a ibu ed o isks in
gene al. Mo e wo k emains, howe e , o unde s and he
ela ionship be ween low bi hweigh and sho ges a ion
and childhood g ow h ailu e a e 1 mon h. Ou analysis o
da e may ac ually unde es ima e he impo ance o his isk
i he sha e o childhood g ow h ailu e ha can be aced o
low bi hweigh and ges a ional age is ully es ablished.
Alcohol
Globally, alcohol is es ima ed o be he se en h-leading isk
ac o in 2016 in bo h DALYs (4·2% [3·7–4·6]) and dea hs
(5·2% [4·4–6·0]). P e ious s udies ha e no ed he
possibili y ha he p e en i e e ec s o alcohol migh ha e
been o e s a ed due o selec ion bias and choice o he
e e ence popula ion.2,54–56 Ou indings lend u he
c edence o hese hypo heses; wi h he excep ion o IHD,
ou esul s show ei he a mino o non-signi ican
p e en i e e ec o causes p e iously es ima ed o ha e
la ge p e en i e e ec s. Fu he , ou analysis no ed a much
la ge isk o neoplasms due o alcohol use han p e iously
epo ed. Combined wi h ou new da a o alcohol use
exposu e, alcohol use is anked as one o he leading isk
ac o s, su passing choles e ol as a sha e o o al DALYs,
compa ied wi h p e ious i e a ions o GBD.4–6
Ensemble dis ibu ions
In GBD 2016 we ha e in oduced a mo e accu a e me hod
o de eloping he dis ibu ions o exposu e o many isk
ac o s. Ou wo k on dis ibu ions and he shi o ensemble
dis ibu ions shows ha he assessmen o a ibu able
bu den is sensi i e o dis ibu ional assump ions. Gi en
ha a numbe o isks, such as BMI, SBP, choles e ol, and
FPG, ise exponen ially as a unc ion o exposu e, he
es ima ion o he ail o he dis ibu ion has an impo an
e ec on he esul s. The ensemble modelling app oach
can p o ide mo e accu a e es ima ion o he ull
dis ibu ion, including he ails o he dis ibu ion. In
gene al, we belie e ha he assessmen o he dis-
ib u ion o he isks dese es mo e ca e ul a en ion in
u u e esea ch.
Compa ison o GBD 2016 o o he es ima es
The GBD s udy is he mos comp ehensi e e o o
conduc a popula ion-le el CRA ac oss coun ies and isks.
Di e ences be ween GBD 2016 es ima es and o he global
es ima es a e gene ally ela ed o app oaches o da a
p ocessing, access o da a sou ces, and analysis decisions.
Global Heal h Me ics
www. helance .com Vol 390 Sep embe 16, 2017
1411
Fo se e al isks, including smoking,57 ambien ozone
pollu ion, household ai pollu ion om solid uels, lead
exposu e,58 in ima e pa ne iolence,59 unsa e wa e
sou ce,60 and b eas eeding, GBD es ima es we e lowe
han published WHO es ima es.57–60 These disc epancies
can be a ibu ed o di e en de ini ions, me hodological
decisions, g anula i y, and inpu da a. Fo some indings,
annual es ima es migh disag ee, bu egional pa e ns
we e consis en be ween WHO and GBD. UNICEF61
p oduces es ima es o child s un ing ha a e lowe han
GBD es ima es wi h some disag eemen whe e p og ess
has been made globally. The e is mo e consis ency in
es ima es be ween UNICEF and GBD o child was ing
and child unde weigh .61 GBD es ima es o he p e alence
o low bi hweigh and sho ges a ion a e sligh ly lowe
when compa ed wi h WHO es ima es, bu show simila
geog aphical pa e ns.62 Scien i ic li e a u e e eals simila
esul s o GBD o impai ed kidney unc ion63 and low
bi hweigh and sho ges a ion;64,65 esea ch analysing
ambien ai pollu ion66 di e ed om GBD es ima es due o
olde me hods and less g anula i y. Resea ch published on
i on-de iciency anaemia67 di e s om GBD in me hods
and de ini ions, esul ing in gene ally highe GBD
es ima es. GBD es ima es we e much lowe han published
esea ch on occupa ional es ima es,3,68,69 la gely due o
di e en cause-ou come pai s and GBD’s applica ion o he
CRA app oach (see appendix 1 p 10).
Fu u e di ec ions
In e p e a ion o ou esul s and p io i isa ion a he
na ional le el migh also need o ake in o accoun he
a iable s eng h o e idence suppo ing he causal
connec ion o each isk-ou come pai . In GBD 2016, we
ha e con inued o use he Wo ld Cance Resea ch Fund
c i e ia o con incing o p obable e idence o selec isk-
ou come pai s o inclusion. Some aspec s o hese
de ini ions a e subjec i e. No all esea che s would ag ee
on he in e p e a ion o he a ailable e idence as ul illing
hese c i e ia. Fo example, he e a e six s udies on non-
exclusi e b eas eeding and LRI; he e a e wo s udies on
discon inued b eas eeding and dia hoeal diseases. We
ha e sough o quan i y he numbe o s udies o di e en
kinds ha a e a ailable o suppo hese judgemen s in
able 1, bu no all s udies suppo causali y o he same
ex en . Randomised ials, i well conduc ed, p o ide he
s onges e idence o causali y, because hey a e likely no
a ec ed by con ounding. Bu e en andomised ials can
ha e biases when he e a e missing obse a ions, as is
o en he case. Randomised ials a e also no easible in
many cases, o i easible, no ep esen a i e o many
isks, including en i onmen al isks. Coho s udies can
p o ide compelling e idence, bu many coho s do no
adequa ely con ol o socioeconomic con ounde s and can
su e om many o he issues ela ed o he quali y o
exposu e measu emen o ou come asce ainmen . To go
beyond, he quan i ica ion o he numbe o s udies o each
ype we ha e p o ided he e will necessi a e a deepe
analysis o he po en ial limi a ions o all 2579 s udies used
ac oss he isk-ou come pai s. In u u e wo k, we plan o
e alua e he quali y o each o hese s udies wi h a
s anda dised app oach and wo k owa d an o e all e idence
summa y. The e is also a mo e undamen al philosophical
ques ion abou he p esen a ion o isk in o ma ion.
Should decision make s only pay a en ion o isk ac o
quan i ica ion o hose isks suppo ed by he s onges
causal e idence such as andomised ials? O do no ions
such as he p ecau iona y p inciple sugges ha we should
pay a en ion o isk quan i ica ion e en o isk-ou come
pai s whe e he e idence is less de ini i e.70–72 Because he
social esponse o isks, pa icula ly isks ha migh be
eme ging, can ake conside able ime, igno ing isks o
which he e idence is less de ini i e migh ac ually lead o
wo se ou comes o socie y. Con e sely, in a wo ld o sca ce
poli ical and inancial esou ces, de o ing a en ion o isks
ha migh u n ou no o be causal migh lead o less
ac ion on mo e well documen ed isks.
As pa o u u e i e a ions o GBD, we plan o quan i y
he bu den a ibu able o some dis al social isks. We ha e
emba ked on his wo k, bu i p o es o ha e challenges
ha a e quali a i ely di e en han many o he isks
included he e. Fo nea ly all isk-ou come pai s, we
assume in he absence o o he e idence ha he RRs by
age and sex a e gene alisable ac oss popula ions ( he
excep ion is o BMI in Asian and non-Asian popula ions
o b eas cance ). In p inciple, i he e is e idence o
s a is ically signi ican RRs o di e en popula ion g oups,
we would inco po a e hese in o he CRA. Fo dis al social
isks, he pa hways o ou comes can be modi ied in many
ways by o he isks o by heal h-sys em in e en ions. We
expec ha he RR due o low educa ion o 40-yea -old
men would be di e en in No way han in Kenya. Gi en
he g ea e po en ial o a ia ion in RRs o dis al isks,
inclusion in GBD will equi e mo e local quan i ica ion o
RRs and hen a u he modelling s ep o es ima e RRs o
hese de e minan s o all loca ions. Ou i s planned
a ge o his quan i ica ion is educa ional a ainmen .
Gi en he global policy ocus on he po en ial heal h
e ec s o clima e change d i en by ising le els o
g eenhouse gases, and consequen ly empe a u e, we will
add empe a u e and p ecipi a ion as isk ac o s ha a e
quan i ied on an annual basis in u u e i e a ions o GBD.
E en hough mos o he po en ial ha m ha migh come
om ising empe a u es o ex eme wea he e en s will
occu in he u u e, in some loca ions, we migh al eady
ind signi ican a ibu able bu den.73 This analysis will
need o examine he ela ionship be ween disease and
mo ali y isk and empe a u e o each ele an ou come.
Fo some ou comes, hese ela ionships a e likely o be
U shaped, wi h an op imal empe a u e o minimum isk.
These U-shaped ela ionships could mean ha o some
ou comes in some loca ions, ising empe a u e migh
educe ha m, e en i in mos loca ions i will inc ease
bu den. Likewise, a majo issue in unde s anding he
empe a u e and heal h ou come ela ionships is ha we
Global Heal h Me ics
1412
www. helance .com Vol 390 Sep embe 16, 2017
would expec hese o be a enua ed in high-SDI se ings,
whe e many indi iduals can p o ec hemsel es om some
o he consequences. In o he wo ds, gene alising om
s udies in high-SDI loca ions o o he loca ions migh
unde es ima e he isk ela ionships.
In he GBD CRA app oach, he TMREL is he le el o
isk exposu e ha leads o minimum isk o indi iduals.
In p inciple, he TMREL could a y by loca ion, age, and
sex. To da e, he TMREL in he GBD wo k has been
selec ed o be uni e sal. Fo mo e de ail on TMREL, see
appendix 1 (p 22). The analysis o alcohol, whe e o IHD
he e is a p o ec i e e ec a mild o mode a e consump ion
bu a ha m ul e ec o neoplasms and inju ies, is a good
example o whe e i would be desi able o a y TMREL by
age. In younge ages, inju ies will be mo e impo an han
ca dio ascula diseases, pushing he TMREL owa d ze o
consump ion o alcohol, whe eas a olde ages, he TMREL
migh be highe . Le ing he TMREL a y by age and sex
and e en loca ion will add an ex a analy ical s ep o GBD;
like all o he es ima ion s eps, his can ha e es ima ion
e o . To da e, we ha e hough he es ima ion e o
associa ed wi h a TMREL ha a ies may no make he
e o wo hwhile. As e idence accumula es on some isks
like alcohol, we will ca e ully e alua e his posi ion.
Limi a ions
A s udy o his scope has many limi a ions. He e we discuss
he limi a ions ha apply o he o e all isk ac o analy ical
amewo k and limi a ions in he es ima ion app oach o
new isks and isks ha ha e unde aken signi ican
e isions om GBD 2015. Mo e de ails and limi a ions o
he analy ical app oach o each isk ac o a e p esen ed in
appendix 1 (p 43). Fi s , we con inue o include isk-ou come
pai s ha mee he Wo ld Cance Resea ch Fund c i e ia o
con incing o p obable e idence o causali y. While hese
c i e ia ha e p o en a use ul ba o inclusion, he e is an
impo an subjec i e elemen o hei in e p e a ion. Some
isk-ou come pai s included in his s udy migh no mee
hese c i e ia o al e na i e c i e ia ha a e de eloped as
new andomised ials, coho s udies, o case-con ol
s udies a e published. Second, we used published coho
s udies o e alua e he deg ee o which di e en isks a e
media ed h ough o he isks. Es ima es o pa hways o
media ion a e used o compu e he bu den a ibu able o
agg ega es o isk ac o s such as all beha iou al isks o all
isks combined. While we ha e conduc ed pooled coho
analyses o s eng hen he assessmen o media ion, his
wo k was no ye eady o inclusion in his assessmen .
Pooled coho s udies ha e he ad an age o p o iding a
mo e s anda dised amewo k o assessing media ion
ac oss mul iple isks. A ela ed issue is he alida ion o he
agg ega ion o isks in GBD. Pooled coho s udies will
allow (in some ci cums ances) he oppo uni y o es ima e
i he agg ega ion o GBD RRs is as p edic i e o ou comes
as sugges ed by he isk-by- isk analysis wi h media ion.
Thi d, we ha e used he Das Gup a o mula applied o
each 5-yea in e al and o GBD Le el 3 causes.
Agg ega ions a highe le els o causes and o longe
pe iods o ime a e based on hese mo e g anula analyses
o gua an ee consis ency. Gi en he non-linea na u e o he
Das Gup a decomposi ion o mula, howe e , al e na i e
esul s a e possible using di e en ime pe iods and causes
in he o mula. Fou h, we ha e in oduced he use o
ensemble dis ibu ions o imp o e he empi ical i ing o
dis ibu ions o isk exposu e in se ings whe e only mean
and s anda d de ia ion a e known o whe e we use models
o p edic he mean and s anda d de ia ion o exposu e.
Ensemble models p o ide mo e accu a e i s as assessed
ou o sample o se ings wi h mic oda a. The unde lying
assump ion is ha he same ensemble weigh s a e
applicable ac oss all se ings. I is possible ha he shape o
dis ibu ions o isk exposu e migh a y ac oss loca ions,
o example because o he e ec s o access o ea men .
Limi a ions ha apply o new isks in GBD 2016 o isks
wi h signi ican es ima ion upda es a e p esen ed he e. Fo
low bi hweigh and sho ges a ion, we ha e included he
e ec o low bi hweigh and sho ges a ion only on
neona al ou comes; we ha e no ound he e idence o mee
ou inclusion c i e ia o he link be ween low bi hweigh
and sho ges a ion and NCDs in adul age g oups. Ou
analysis o RRs has used a e y la ge US-linked bi h coho
da ase and much mo e limi ed da a om middle-SDI and
low-SDI popula ions. Gi en he la ge numbe o obse a ions
om he USA, ou esul s a e hea ily in luenced by he
pa e n o RRs ac oss bi hweigh and ges a ional age in ha
popula ion. The mic oda a used o de elop he ensemble
dis ibu ions o bi hweigh and ges a ional age a e la gely
om middle-SDI and high-SDI loca ions. The es i ma ion o
alcohol use elies hea ily on sales da a, which a e limi ed
and whose quali y we canno easily assess. Also, he
es ima ion o un eco ded con sump ion o alcohol is based
on limi ed da a and has signi ican unce ain y; ne e heless,
we eel i is impo an o include i and plan o con inue o
look o addi ional sou ces o in o ma ion o imp o e he
es ima ion o un eco ded consump ion in u u e i e a ions
o GBD. Las ly, me hods o calcula ing TMREL ely on
obse ed DALYs o a gi en ime a he han on he expec ed
sha e o DALYs es ima ed om alcohol use alone. Fu u e
i e a ions o GBD will likely need o es his assump ion
u he and de e mine i sepa a e TMREL by age and sex
should be calcula ed.
Conclusion
Unde s anding he le els and ends o majo isks o
human heal h is essen ial o p io i ise public heal h ac ion
and e alua e he success o di e en p og ammes and
policies. This s udy p o ides a comp ehensi e and
compa able assessmen o 84 me abolic, en i onmen al,
occupa ional, and beha iou al isks ac oss loca ions and
ime. Ou indings show ha isk modi ica ion has been an
impo an con ibu o o educ ions in communicable,
ma e nal, neona al, and nu i ional causes, bu has played a
ela i ely small pa in ends in NCDs. Con lic ing ends
in isks o NCDs a he global le el, such as he decline in
Global Heal h Me ics
www. helance .com Vol 390 Sep embe 16, 2017
1413
smoking p e alence coupled wi h he ise in obesi y, FPG,
and SBP, accoun o his inding. By con as wi h ends
in diseases and inju ies a he global le el and e en a he
na ional le el, he e is much g ea e he e ogenei y o global
ends ac oss isks and conside able geog aphical a ia ion
in leading isks as well. Public heal h ac ion in each coun y
and egion needs o ocus on he majo isks in ha
communi y. Ou indings ein o ce he c ucial need o
obus moni o ing o he exposu e o isks o heal h and
assessmen o he e idence suppo ing causal e ec s o
each isk-ou come pai ; GBD p o ides he main global
mechanism o his moni o ing unc ion.
GBD 2016 Risk Fac o s Collabo a o s
Emmanuela Gakidou, Ashkan A shin, Amanuel Alemu Abajobi ,
Kalkidan Hassen Aba e, C is iana Abba a i, Kaja M Abbas, Foad Abd-Allah,
Abdishaku M Abdulle, Semaw Fe ede Abe a, Vic o Aboyans,
Lai h J Abu-Raddad, Ni een M E Abu-Rmeileh, Geb e Yi ayih Abyu,
Isaac Akinkunmi Adedeji, Ola unji Ade okunboh, Mohsen A a ideh,
Anu ag Ag awal, Su apa Ag awal, Aliasgha Ahmad Kiadali i, Hamid
Ahmadieh, Muk a Beshi Ahmed, Amani Nidhal Aichou , Ib ihel Aichou ,
Miloud Taki Eddine Aichou , Ru us Olusola Akinyemi, Nadia Aksee ,
Fa es Alahdab, Ziyad Al-Aly, Khu shid Alam, Noo e Alam, Tahiya Alam,
Deena Alas oo , Ke yalew Addis Alene, Komal Ali, Reza Alizadeh-Na aei,
Ala’a Alke wi, F ançois Alla, Pe e Allebeck, Rajaa Al-Raddadi,
Ubai Alsha i , Khalid A Al i kawi, Nelson Al is-Guzman,
Azme aw T Ama e, E an Amini, Walid Amma , Yaw Ampem Amoako,
Hossein Ansa i, Josep M An ó, Ca l Abela do T An onio, Palwasha Anwa i,
Nicholas A ian, Johan Ä nlö , Al A aman, K ishna Kuma A yal,
Hamid Asayesh, Solomon Weldegeb eal Asgedom, Tes ay Meha i A ey,
Le icia A ila-Bu gos, Eu ipide F inel G A hu A okpaho, Ashish Awas hi,
Pe e Azzopa di, Uma Bacha, Alaa Badawi, Kalpana Balak ishnan,
Shoshana H Ballew, Aleksand a Ba ac, Ryan M Ba be ,
Suzanne L Ba ke -Collo, Till Bä nighausen, Simon Ba que a,
La s Ba ega d, Lope H Ba e o, Ca olina Ba is, Ka he ine E Ba le,
Be nha d T Baune, Jus in Bea dsley, Nee aj Bedi, E o e Beghi,
Michelle L Bell, De ick A Benne , James R Benne , Isabela M Benseno ,
Adugnaw Be hane, De bew Fikadu Be he, Edua do Be nabé,
Balem Dem su Be su, Mi cea Beu an, Addisu Shunu Beyene,
Anil Bhansali, Zul iqa A Bhu a, Bo is Bikbo , Cha les Bi ungi,
S an Bi yuko , Ch is ophe D Blosse , Dube Ja a Boneya,
Ib ahim R Bou-O m, Michael B aue , Nicholas J K B ei bo de,
He mann B enne , T aolach S B ugha, Lemma Negesa Bul o Bul o,
Blai R Baumga ne , Zahid A Bu , Luce o Cahuana-Hu ado,
Rosa io Cá denas, Juan Jesus Ca e o, Ca los A Cas añeda-O juela,
Fe án Ca alá-López, Kelly Ce cy, Hsing-Yi Chang, Fiona J Cha lson,
Odge el Chimed-Ochi , Vespe Hichilombwe Chisumpa,
Abdulaal A Chi hee , Hanne Ch is ensen,
De asahayam Jesudas Ch is ophe , Massimo Ci illo, Aa on J Cohen,
Haley Com o , Cy us Coope , Jose Co esh, Leslie Co naby,
Paolo Angelo Co esi, Michael H C iqui, John A C ump, Lali Dandona,
Rakhi Dandona, José das Ne es, Gail Da ey, D agos V Da i oiu, Kai a
Da le o , Ba bo a de Cou en, Louisa Degenha d , Selina Deipa ine,
Robe P Della alle, Kebede De ibe, Ani uddha Deshpande,
Sama h D Dha ma a ne, E ic L Ding, Shi in Djalalinia, Huyen Phuc Do,
Kla a Doko a, Da id Teye Doku, E Ray Do sey, Tim R D iscoll,
Manisha Dubey, B uce Ba holow Duncan, Sa ah Duncan, Na alie Ebe ,
Hedyeh Eb ahimi, Ziad Ziad El-Kha ib, Ahmadali Enaya i,
Aman Yesu End ies, Se gey Pe o ich E mako , Holly E E skine,
Babak Esh a i, Sha a eh Eskanda ieh, Ali eza Es eghama i, Ka a Es ep,
Eme i o Jose Aquino Fa aon, Ca la So ia e Sa Fa inha,
And é Fa o, Fa shad Fa zad a , Kai s en Fay, Vale y L Feigin,
Seyed-Mohammad Fe esh ehnejad, João C Fe nandes, Alize J Fe a i,
Tes aye Regassa Feyissa, I ina Filip, Flo ian Fische , Ch is ina Fi zmau ice,
Ab aham D Flaxman, Na aliya Foig , Kyle J Fo eman, Joseph J F os ad,
Nancy Fullman, Thomas Fü s , Joao M Fu ado, Mo saleh Ganji,
Albe o L Ga cia-Bas ei o, Tsegaye Tewelde Geb ehiwo ,
Johanna M Geleijnse, Ayele Gele o, Bikila Lencha Gemechu,
Hailay Ab ha Gesesew, Pe e W Ge hing, Ali eza Ghaja ,
Ka he ine B Gibney, Pa amji Singh Gill, Richa d F Gillum,
Ababi Ze gaw Gi e , Melkamu Dede o Gishu, Gio gia Giussani,
William W Godwin, Philimon N Gona, Amado Good idge,
Samee Vali Gopalani, Ye geniy Go yakin, Alessand a Ca alho Goula ,
Nicholas G ae z, Ha ish Chande Gugnani, Jingwen Guo, Rajee Gup a,
Tanush Gup a, Vipin Gup a, Reyna A Gu ié ez, Vladimi Hachinski,
Nima Ha ezi-Nejad, Gessessew Bugssa Hailu, Randah Ribhi Hamadeh,
Same Hamidi, Mouhanad Hammami, Alexis J Handal, G aeme J Hankey,
Hilda L Ha b, Hab amu Abe a Ha e i, Mohammad Sadegh Hassan and,
Rasmus Ha moelle , Cai lin Hawley, Simon I Hay, Mohammad T Hedaya i,
Delia Hend ie, Ileana Bea iz He edia-Pi, Hans W Hoek, Nobuyuki Ho i a,
H Dean Hosgood, So in Hos iuc, Damian G Hoy, Mohamed Hsai i,
Guoqing Hu, Hsiang Huang, John J Huang, Kim Moesgaa d Ibu g,
Chad Ikeda, Manami Inoue, Caleb Mackay Salpe e I ine,
Ma ia Delo es Jackson, Ka h yn H Jacobsen, Nade Jahanmeh ,
Mihajlo (Michael) B Jako lje ic, Alejand a Jau egui, Mehdi Ja anbakh ,
Panniyammakal Jeemon, La s R K Johansson, Ca he ine O Johnson,
Jos B Jonas, Mikk Jü isson, Zubai Kabi , Rajend a Kadel, Amaha Kahsay,
Ri ul Kamal, And é Ka ch, Co ine Kakizi Ka ema, Ami Kasaeian,
Nicholas J Kassebaum, Anshul Kas o , S ini asa Vi al Ka iki eddi,
No i o Kawakami, Pe e Njenga Keiyo o, Se onias Ge achew Kelbo e,
Lau a Kemme , And e Pascal Kengne,
Chand asekha an Nai Kesa achand an, Youse Saleh Khade ,
Ib ahim A Khalil, Ejaz Ahmad Khan, Young-Ho Khang, A deshi Khos a i,
Jagdish Khubchandani, Ch is ian Kieling, Daniel Kim, Jun Y Kim,
Yun Jin Kim, Ru h W Kimoko i, Yohannes Kin u, Adnan Kisa,
Ka a zyna A Kissimo a-Ska bek, Mika Ki imaki, Luke D Knibbs,
Ann K is in Knudsen, Jacek A Kopec, Soewa a Kosen, Pa aiz A Koul,
Ai Koyanagi, Michael K a chenko, K is ophe J K ohn, Hans K omhou ,
Ba helemy Kua e De o, Bu cu Kucuk Bice , G Anil Kuma , Michael Ku z,
Hmwe H Kyu, Dha mesh Kuma Lal, Ra ilal Lalloo, Tea Lallukka,
Qing Lan, Van C Lansingh, Ande s La sson, Alexande Lee, Paul H Lee,
James Leigh, Janni Leung, Mi iam Le i, Yichong Li, Yongmei Li,
Xiao eng Liang, Misgan Legesse Liben, Shai Linn, Pa ick Liu, Rakesh
Lodha, Gianca lo Log oscino, Ka he ine J Looke , Alan D Lopez,
S e an Lo kowski, Paulo A Lo u o, Ra ael Lozano, Raimundas Lune icius,
E lyn Rachelle King Maca ayan, Hassan Magdy Abd El Razek, Mohammed
Magdy Abd El Razek, Ma ek Majdan, Reza Majdzadeh, Azeem Majeed,
Reza Malekzadeh, Rajesh Malho a, Debo ah Ca alho Mal a,
Abdullah A Mamun, Helena Mangue a, Lo enzo G Man o ani,
Chabila C Mapoma, Randall V Ma in, Jose Ma inez-Raga,
F ancisco Roge lândio Ma ins-Melo, Manu Raj Ma hu ,
Kunihi o Ma sushi a, Richa d Ma zopoulos, Mohsen Mazidi,
Colm McAlinden, John J McG a h, Su esh Meha a,
Man Mohan Mehndi a a, Toni Meie , Yohannes Adama Melaku,
Pe e Memiah, Ziad A Memish, Wal e Mendoza,
Melkamu Me id Mengesha, Geo ge A Mensah, Ge B M Mensink,
Seid Tiku Me e a, A e Me e oja, Tuomo J Me e oja,
Ha ay Be hane Mezgebe, Rena a Micha, Anoushka Millea , Ted R Mille ,
Shawn Minnig, Mojde Mi a e in, E kin M Mi akhimo , Awoke Misganaw,
Shi a Raj Mish a, Ka zan Abdulmuhsin Mohammad,
Kedi End is Mohammed, Sha iu Mohammed, No linah Mohamed
Ib ahim, Mu ali B V Mohan, Ali H Mokdad, Lo enzo Monas a,
Julio Cesa Mon añez He nandez, Ma cella Mon ico, Mazia Mo adi-Lakeh,
Paula Mo aga, Lidia Mo awska, Shane D Mo ison,
Cli Moun joy-Venning, Ul ich O Muelle , E in C Mullany, Ka e Mulle ,
Gudla alle i Venka a Sa yana ayana Mu hy, Kama ul Im an Musa,
Mohsen Nagha i, Aliya Naheed, Vinay Nangia, Gopalak ishnan Na a ajan,
Ionu Negoi, Ruxand a I ina Negoi, Cuong Ta Nguyen, G an Nguyen,
Minh Nguyen, Quyen Le Nguyen, T ang Huyen Nguyen, Emma Nichols,
Dina Nu Angg aini Ning um, Ma ika Nomu a, Vuong Minh Nong,
Ole F No heim, Bo No ing, Jean Jacques N Noubiap, Ca la Makhlou
Obe meye , Felix Akpojene Ogbo, In-Hwan Oh, Olan ewaju Oladimeji,
And ew Toyin Olagunju, Tinuke Oluwase unmi Olagunju,
Ped o R Oli a es, Helen E Olsen, Bolajoko Olubukunola Olusanya,
Jacob Olusegun Olusanya, John Nelson Opio, Eyal O en, Albe o O iz,
E ika O a, Mayowa O Owolabi, Mahesh PA, Rosana E Pacella, Ad ian Pana,
Basan Kuma Panda, Songhomi a Panda-Jonas, Jeya aj D Pandian,
Ch is ina Papach is ou, Eun-Kee Pa k, Cha les D Pa y, Sco B Pa en,
Geo ge C Pa on, Da id M Pe ei a, No be o Pe ico, Kon ad Pesudo s,
Max Pe zold, Michael Robe Phillips, Julian Da id Pillay,
Global Heal h Me ics
1414
www. helance .com Vol 390 Sep embe 16, 2017
Michael A Pi ado , Fa had Pishga , Die ich Plass, Ma in A Ple che ,
Suzanne Polinde , S e lana Popo a, Richie G Poul on, Fa shad Pou malek,
Na ayan P asad, Ca ie Pu cell, Mos a a Qo bani, Ami Rad a ,
Anwa Ra ay, A a in Rahimi-Mo agha , Va a Rahimi-Mo agha ,
Mah uza Rahman, Mohammad Hi z U Rahman,
Muhammad Aziz Rahman, Rajesh Kuma Rai, Sasa Rajsic, Usha Ram,
Salman Rawa , Colin D Rehm, Jü gen Rehm, Robe C Reine ,
Ma issa B Rei sma, Luz My iam Reynales-Shigema su, Giuseppe Remuzzi,
And e M N Renzaho, Se ge Resniko , Sa a Rezaei, An onio L Ribei o,
Juan A Ri e a, Kedi Teji Roba, Da id Rojas-Rueda, Yesenia Roman,
Robin Room, Gholam eza Roshandel, G ego y A Ro h,
Die ich Ro henbache , En ico Rubago i, Lesley Rush on, Na is Sada ,
Mahdi Sa da ian, Sa e Sa i, Saeid Sa i i, Ramesh Saha he an,
Joseph Salama, Joshua A Salomon, Abdallah M Samy,
Juan Ramon Sanab ia, Ma ia Dolo es Sanchez-Niño,
Tania G Sánchez-Pimien a, Damian San omau o, I ama S San os,
Milena M San ic Milice ic, Benn Sa o ius, Maheswa Sa pa hy,
Monika Sawhney, Sonia Saxena, Elke Schae ne , Ma ia Inês Schmid ,
Ione J C Schneide , Ale a E Schu e, Da id C Schwebel, Falk Schwendicke,
So aya Seeda , Sada G Sepanlou, Be in Se da , Edson E Se an-Mo i,
Ga in Shaddick, Ami a Shaheen, Saeid Shah az, Masood Ali Shaikh,
Te esa Shamah Le y, Mansou Shamsipou , Mo eza Shamsizadeh,
Sheikh Mohammed Sha i ul Islam, Jayend a Sha ma, Rajesh Sha ma,
Jun She, Jiabin Shen, Peilin Shi, Kenji Shibuya, Chloe Shields,
Mekonnen Sisay Shi e aw, Mika Shigema su, Min-Jeong Shin,
Rahman Shi i, Reza Shi koohi, Kawkab Shishani, Hai ham Shoman,
Ma k G Sh ime, Inga Do a Sig usdo i , Diego Augus o San os Sil a,
João Ped o Sil a, Dayane Gab iele Al es Sil ei a, Jas inde A Singh,
Vi end a Singh, Dhi end a Na ain Sinha, Ei ini Skiada esi,
E ica Leigh Slepak, Da id L Smi h, Ma i Smi h, Bad H A Sobaih,
Eugene Sobngwi, Sami Soneji, Reed J D So ensen, Luciano A Sposa o,
Chand ashekha T S ee ama eddy, Vinay S ini asan, Nicholas S eel,
Dan J S ein, Cai lyn S eine , Sabine S einke, Ma k And ew S okes,
B yan S ub, Michelle Suba , Muawiyyah Babale Su iyan,
Rizwan Abdulkade Sulianka chi, Pa ick J Su , Soumya Swamina han,
B yan L Sykes, Cassand a E I Szoeke, Ra ael Taba és-Seisdedos,
San osh Kuma Tadakamadla, Ken Takahashi, Jukka S Takala,
Nikhil Tandon, Ma cel Tanne , Yihunie L Ta ekegn, Mohammad Ta akkoli,
Teke o Kassaw Tegegne, A ash Teh ani-Banihashemi,
Abdullah Sulieman Te kawi, Belay Tesssema, JS Thaku ,
O nwipa Thamsuwan, Ka umpu a hu Raman Thankappan,
And ew M Theis, Ma hew Lloyd Thomas, Alan J Thomson,
Amanda G Th i , Taa i Tillmann, Ruoyan Tobe-Gai, My iam Tobollik,
Me e C Tollanes, Ma cello Tonelli, Roman Topo -Mad y, Anna To e,
Miguel To ajada, Ma hilde Tou ie , Bach Xuan T an, Thomas T uelsen,
Kald Beshi Tuem, Emin Mu a Tuzcu, S e anos Ty o olas,
Kingsley Nnanna Ukwaja, Chigozie Jesse Uneke, Rachel Updike,
Olalekan A U hman, Job F M an Bo en, Aa on an Donkelaa ,
San osh Va ughese, Tommi Vasanka i, Lenne J Vee man,
Vidhya Venka eswa an, Na ayanaswamy Venke asub amanian,
F ancesco S Violan e, Se gey K Vladimi o , Vasiliy Vic o o ich Vlasso ,
S ein Emil Vollse , Theo Vos, Fiseha Wadilo, Tolassa Wakayo,
Mi chell T Wallin, Yuan-Pang Wang, Sco Weichen hal,
Elisabe e Weide pass, Robe G Wein aub, Daniel J Weiss,
And ea We decke , Ronny Wes e man, Ha ey A Whi e o d,
Cha les Shey Wiysonge, Bele e Ge ahun Woldeyes, Cha les D A Wol e,
Rachel Woodb ook, Abdulhalik Wo kicho, Sa ah Wul Hanson,
Denis Xa ie , Gelin Xu, Simon Yadgi , Be eke Yakob, Lijing L Yan,
Mehdi Yase i, Hassen Hamid Yimam, Paul Yip, Naohi o Yonemo o,
Seok-Jun Yoon, Ma cel Yo ebieng, Mus a a Z Younis, Zoubida Zaidi,
Maysaa El Sayed Zaki, Luis Za ala-A ciniega, Xueying Zhang,
S ephanie Raman M Zimsen, Ben Zipkin, Sanjay Zodpey, S ephen S Lim,
Ch is ophe J L Mu ay.
A ilia ions
Ins i u e o Heal h Me ics and E alua ion (P o E Gakidou PhD,
A A shin MD, T Alam MPH, K Ali BSc, N A ian BA, R M Ba be BS,
J R Benne BA, S Bi yuko BS, P o M B aue ScD, B Bumga ne MBA,
K Ce cy BS, F J Cha lson PhD, A J Cohen DSc, H Com o BS,
L Co naby BS, P o L Dandona MD, P o R Dandona PhD,
P o L Degenha d PhD, S Deipa ine, A Deshpande MPH, S Duncan,
H E E skine PhD, K Es ep MPA, K Fay BS, A J Fe a i PhD,
C Fi zmau ice MD, A D Flaxman PhD, K J Fo eman PhD, J J F os ad MPH,
N Fullman MPH, W W Godwin BS, N G ae z MPH, J Guo BS,
C Hawley MSPH, P o S I Hay DSc, C Ikeda BS, C M S I ine BA,
C O Johnson PhD, N J Kassebaum MD, L Kemme PhD, I A Khalil MD,
J Y Kim BS, K J K ohn BA, M Ku z BS, H H Kyu PhD, A Lee BA,
J Leung PhD, P o S S Lim PhD, P Liu MPH, H Mangue a BS,
A Millea BA, S Minnig MS, M Mi a e in MPH, A Misganaw PhD,
P o A H Mokdad PhD, C Moun joy-Venning BA, E C Mullany BA,
K Mulle MPH, P o M Nagha i PhD, G Nguyen MPH, M Nguyen BS,
E Nichols BA, H E Olsen MA, M A Ple che BS, C Pu cell BS, R C Reine
PhD, M B Rei sma BS, Y Roman MLIS, G A Ro h MD, N Sada MA,
J Salama MSc, D San omau o PhD, C Shields BS, E L Slepak MLIS,
P o D L Smi h PhD, M Smi h MPA, R J D So ensen MPH,
V S ini asan BA, C S eine MPH, B S ub BS, M Suba BA, P J Su BA,
O Thamsuwan PhD, A M Theis BA, A To e BS, R Updike AB,
V Venka eswa an BDS, P o S E Vollse D PH, P o T Vos PhD,
P o H A Whi e o d PhD, R Woodb ook MLIS, S Wul Hanson MPH,
S Yadgi BS, S R M Zimsen MA, B Zipkin BS, P o C J L Mu ay DPhil),
Di ision o Hema ology, Depa men o Medicine (C Fi zmau ice MD),
Cen e o Heal h T ends and Fo ecas s, Ins i u e o Heal h Me ics and
E alua ion (P o M B Jako lje ic PhD), Uni e si y o Washing on, Sea le,
WA, USA (C D Blosse MD, S D Mo ison MD); School o Public Heal h
(A A Abajobi MPH, F J Cha lson PhD, H E E skine PhD, A J Fe a i PhD,
L D Knibbs PhD, J Leung PhD, D San omau o PhD, L J Vee man PhD,
P o H A Whi e o d PhD), School o Den is y (P o R Lalloo PhD),
Uni e si y o Queensland, B isbane, QLD, Aus alia (S R Mish a MPH);
Depa men o Epidemiology, College o Heal h Sciences
(M B Ahmed MPH), Jimma Uni e si y, Jimma, E hiopia (K H Aba e MS,
P o T T Geb ehiwo MPH, H A Gesesew MPH, S T Me e a PhD,
T Wakayo MS, A Wo kicho MPH); La Sapienza Uni e si y, Rome, I aly
(C Abba a i PhD); Vi ginia Tech, Blacksbu g, VA, USA
(P o K M Abbas PhD); Depa men o Neu ology, Cai o Uni e si y, Cai o,
Egyp (P o F Abd-Allah MD); New Yo k Uni e si y Abu Dhabi, Abu Dhabi,
Uni ed A ab Emi a es (A M Abdulle PhD); School o Public Heal h
(S F Abe a MSc, Y A Melaku MPH), College o Heal h Sciences
(S F Abe a MSc, K E Mohammed MPH), School o Pha macy
(D F Be he MS), Mekelle Uni e si y, Mekelle, E hiopia (P o G Y Abyu MS,
S W Asgedom MS, T M A ey MS, B D Be su MS, G B Hailu MSc,
A Kahsay MPH, H B Mezgebe MS, K B Tuem MS); Food Secu i y and
Ins i u e o Biological Chemis y and Nu i ion, Uni e si y o Hohenheim,
S u ga , Ge many (S F Abe a MSc); Dupuy en Uni e si y Hospi al,
Limoges, F ance (P o V Aboyans PhD); In ec ious Disease Epidemiology
G oup, Weill Co nell Medical College in Qa a , Doha, Qa a
(L J Abu-Raddad PhD); Ins i u e o Communi y and Public Heal h, Bi zei
Uni e si y, Ramallah, Pales ine (N M Abu-Rmeileh PhD); Olabisi Onabanjo
Uni e si y, Ago-Iwoye, Nige ia (I A Adedeji MS); Depa men o Psychia y
(P o C D Pa y PhD), S ellenbosch Uni e si y, Cape Town, Sou h A ica
(O Ade okunboh MD, P o S Seeda PhD, P o C S Wiysonge PhD);
CSIR - Ins i u e o Genomics and In eg a i e Biology, Delhi, India
(A Ag awal PhD); Depa men o In e nal Medicine, Baylo College o
Medicine, Hous on, TX, USA (A Ag awal PhD); Cen e o Con ol o
Ch onic Condi ions (P Jeemon PhD), Indian Ins i u e o Public Heal h
(P o G V S Mu hy MD), Public Heal h Founda ion o India, Gu ug am,
India (S Ag awal PhD, P o L Dandona MD, P o R Dandona PhD,
G A Kuma PhD, D K Lal MD, M R Ma hu PhD, P o S Zodpey PhD);
Depa men o Clinical Sciences Lund, O hopedics, Clinical Epidemiology
Uni (A Ahmad Kiadali i PhD), Skane Uni e si y Hospi al, Depa men o
Clinical Sciences Lund, Neu ology (P o B No ing PhD), Lund Uni e si y,
Lund, Sweden; Oph halmic Resea ch Cen e (H Ahmadieh MD, S Sa i MS,
M Yase i PhD), School o Public Heal h (N Jahanmeh PhD), Shahid
Behesh i Uni e si y o Medical Sciences, Teh an, I an; Depa men o
Oph halmology, Labba inejad Medical Cen e , Teh an, I an
(H Ahmadieh MD); Uni e si y Fe ha Abbas o Se i , Se i , Alge ia
(A N Aichou BS); Na ional Ins i u e o Nu sing Educa ion, Se i , Alge ia
(I Aichou MS); High Na ional School o Ve e ina y Medicine, Algie s,
Alge ia (M T Aichou MD); Uni e si y o Ibadan, Ibadan, Nige ia
(R O Akinyemi PhD); Newcas le Uni e si y, Newcas le upon Tyne, UK
(R O Akinyemi PhD); Cen e o Global Child Heal h, The Hospi al o Sick
Child en, To on o, ON, Canada (N Aksee MSc, Z A Bhu a PhD); Dalla
Lana School o Public Heal h (N Aksee MSc, P o J Rehm PhD),
Global Heal h Me ics
www. helance .com Vol 390 Sep embe 16, 2017
1415
Depa men o Nu i ional Sciences, Facul y o Medicine (A Badawi PhD),
Cen e o Addic ion and Men al Heal h (S Popo a PhD), Uni e si y o
To on o, To on o, ON, Canada; Mayo Clinic Founda ion o Medical
Educa ion and Resea ch, Roches e , MN, USA (F Alahdab MD); Sy ian
Ame ican Medical Socie y, Washing on, DC, USA (F Alahdab MD);
Washing on Uni e si y in S Louis, S Louis, MO, USA (Z Al-Aly MD);
Mu doch Child ens Resea ch Ins i u e (K Alam PhD, P Azzopa di PhD,
R G Wein aub MBBS), Depa men o Paedia ics (P Azzopa di PhD,
P o G C Pa on MD), Melbou ne School o Popula ion and Global Heal h
(P o A D Lopez PhD), Depa men o Medicine (A Me e oja PhD),
Ins i u e o Heal h and Ageing (P o C E I Szoeke PhD), The Uni e si y o
Melbou ne, Melbou ne, VIC, Aus alia (K Alam PhD, M A Rahman PhD,
R G Wein aub MBBS); Sydney School o Public Heal h
(P o T R D iscoll PhD), The Uni e si y o Sydney, Sydney, NSW, Aus alia
(K Alam PhD, J Leigh PhD); Depa men o Heal h, Queensland, B isbane,
QLD, Aus alia (N Alam MAppEpid); Minis y o Heal h, Al Khuwai ,
Oman (D Alas oo MSc); Depa men o Epidemiology and Bios a is ics,
Ins i u e o Public Heal h (K A Alene MPH), Uni e si y o Gonda , Gonda ,
E hiopia (B Tesssema PhD); Depa men o Global Heal h, Resea ch School
o Popula ion Heal h, Aus alian Na ional Uni e si y, Canbe a, ACT,
Aus alia (K A Alene MPH); Gas oin es inal Cance Resea ch Cen e
(R Alizadeh-Na aei PhD), Depa men o Medical Mycology and
Pa asi ology, School o Medicine (P o M T Hedaya i PhD), Mazanda an
Uni e si y o Medical Sciences, Sa i, I an; Luxembou g Ins i u e o Heal h,
S assen, Luxembou g (A Alke wi PhD); School o Public Heal h,
Uni e si y o Lo aine, Nancy, F ance (P o F Alla PhD); Depa men o
Public Heal h Sciences (P Allebeck PhD, Z Z El-Kha ib PhD), Depa men
o Neu obiology, Ca e Sciences and Socie y, Di ision o Family Medicine
and P ima y Ca e (P o J Ä nlö PhD), Depa men o Medical
Epidemiology and Bios a is ics (P o J J Ca e o PhD, E Weide pass PhD),
Depa men o Neu obiology, Ca e Sciences and Socie y (NVS)
(S Fe esh ehnejad PhD), Ka olinska Ins i u e , S ockholm, Sweden
(R Ha moelle PhD); Join P og am o Family and Communi y Medicine,
Jeddah, Saudi A abia (R Al-Raddadi PhD); Cha i é Uni e si ä smedizin,
Be lin, Ge many (U Alsha i MPH, N Ebe MD, P o E Schae ne MSc);
King Saud Uni e si y, Riyadh, Saudi A abia (K A Al i kawi MD,
B H A Sobaih MD); Uni e sidad de Ca agena, Ca agena de Indias,
Colombia (P o N Al is-Guzman PhD); School o Medicine
(A T Ama e MPH, P o B T Baune PhD, Y A Melaku MPH), Discipline o
Psychia y, School o Medicine (A T Olagunju MD), Uni e si y o Adelaide,
Adelaide, Sou h Aus alia, Aus alia; College o Medicine and Heal h
Sciences, Bahi Da Uni e si y, Bahi Da , E hiopia (A T Ama e MPH);
U o-Oncology Resea ch Cen e (E Amini MD, F Pishga MD), Non-
Communicable Diseases Resea ch Cen e (H Eb ahimi MD,
F Fa zad a MD, A Khos a i PhD, F Pishga MD), Endoc inology and
Me abolism Resea ch Cen e (E Amini MD, P o A Es eghama i MD,
N Ha ezi-Nejad MD, A Kasaeian PhD), Cen e o Ai Pollu ion Resea ch,
Ins i u e o En i onmen al Resea ch (M S Hassan and PhD), Hema ology-
Oncology and S em Cell T ansplan a ion Resea ch Cen e
(A Kasaeian PhD), Knowledge U iliza ion Resea ch Cen e and Communi y
Based Pa icipa o y Resea ch Cen e (P o R Majdzadeh PhD), Li e and
Panc ea icobilia y Diseases Resea ch Cen e (H Eb ahimi MD), Diges i e
Diseases Resea ch Ins i u e (P o R Malekzadeh MD, G Roshandel PhD,
S G Sepanlou PhD), I anian Na ional Cen e o Addic ion S udies (INCAS)
(A Rahimi-Mo agha MD), Sina T auma and Su ge y Resea ch Cen e
(P o V Rahimi-Mo agha MD, M Sa da ian MD), Ins i u e o
En i onmen al Resea ch (M Shamsipou PhD), Cance Resea ch Cen e
(P o R Shi koohi PhD), Teh an Uni e si y o Medical Sciences, Te han,
I an (M A a ideh MD, M Ganji MD, A Ghaja MD, M Yase i PhD);
Minis y o Public Heal h, Bei u , Lebanon (W Amma PhD,
I R Bou-O m MD, H L Ha b MPH); Depa men o Medicine, Kom o
Anokye Teaching Hospi al, Kumasi, Ghana (Y A Amoako MD); Heal h
P omo ion Resea ch Cen e , Depa men o Epidemiology and Bios a is ics,
Zahedan Uni e si y o Medical Sciences, Zahedan, I an (H Ansa i PhD);
ISGlobal Ba celona Ins i u e o Global Heal h, Ba celona, Spain
(P o J M An ó MD); Depa men o Heal h Policy and Adminis a ion,
College o Public Heal h (C A T An onio MD, E J A Fa aon MD), Uni e si y
o he Philippines Manila, Manila, Philippines; Sel -employed, Kabul,
A ghanis an (P Anwa i MS); School o Heal h and Social S udies, Dala na
Uni e si y, Falun, Sweden (P o J Ä nlö PhD); Uni e si y o Mani oba,
Winnipeg, MB, Canada (A A aman PhD); Nepal Heal h Resea ch Council,
Ka hmandu, Nepal (K K A yal MPH); Uni e si y o Oslo, Oslo, No way
(K K A yal MPH); Depa men o Medical Eme gency, School o Pa amedic,
Qom Uni e si y o Medical Sciences, Qom, I an (H Asayesh MS); Na ional
Council o Science and Technology (C Ba is PhD), Na ional Ins i u e o
Public Heal h, Cue na aca, Mexico (L A ila-Bu gos PhD, S Ba que a PhD,
L Cahuana-Hu ado PhD, I B He edia-Pi PhD, A Jau egui MSc,
R Lozano PhD, J C Mon añez He nandez MSc,
LMReynales-Shigema suPhD, P o J A Ri e a PhD,
T G Sánchez-Pimien a MSc, P o E E Se an-Mo i MSc,
T Shamah Le y PhD, L Za ala-A ciniega MS); Ins i u de Reche che
Clinique du Bénin (IRCB), Co onou, Benin (E F G A A okpaho MPH);
Labo a oi e d’E udes e de Reche che-Ac ion en San é (LERAS A ique),
Pa akou, Benin (E F G A A okpaho MPH); Indian Ins i u e o Public
Heal h, Gandhinaga , India (A Awas hi PhD); Bu ne Ins i u e, Melbou ne,
VIC, Aus alia (P Azzopa di PhD); Wa dlipa ingga Abo iginal Resea ch
Uni , Sou h Aus alian Heal h and Medical Resea ch Ins i u e, Adelaide,
Sou h Aus alia, Aus alia (P Azzopa di PhD); School o Heal h Sciences,
Uni e si y o Managemen and Technology, Laho e, Pakis an
(U Bacha PhD); Public Heal h Agency o Canada, To on o, ON, Canada
(A Badawi PhD); Depa men o En i onmen al Heal h Enginee ing,
S i Ramachand a Uni e si y, Chennai, India (K Balak ishnan PhD);
Johns Hopkins Bloombe g School o Public Heal h (S H Ballew PhD,
J Co esh PhD, K Ma sushi a PhD), Johns Hopkins Uni e si y, Bal imo e,
MD, USA (B X T an PhD); Facul y o Medicine (A Ba ac PhD), Ins i u e o
Social Medicine, Facul y o Medicine (M M San ic Milice ic PhD), Cen e
School o Public Heal h and Heal h Managemen , Facul y o Medicine
(M M San ic Milice ic PhD), Uni e si y o Belg ade, Belg ade, Se bia;
School o Psychology, Uni e si y o Auckland, Auckland, New Zealand
(S L Ba ke -Collo PhD); Depa men o Global Heal h and Popula ion,
Ha a d T H Chan School o Public Heal h (P o T Bä nighausen MD,
J A Salomon PhD), Ha a d T H Chan School o Public Heal h
(E L Ding ScD), A iadne Labs (E R K Maca ayan PhD), Ha a d Uni e si y,
Bos on, MA, USA; A ica Heal h Resea ch Ins i u e, M uba uba, Sou h
A ica (P o T Bä nighausen MD); Ins i u e o Public Heal h, Heidelbe g
Uni e si y, Heidelbe g, Ge many (P o T Bä nighausen MD,
S Mohammed PhD); Depa men o Occupa ional and En i onmen al
Medicine, Sahlg enska Academy, Uni e si y o Go henbu g, Go henbu g,
Sweden (P o L Ba ega d MD); Depa men o Indus ial Enginee ing,
School o Enginee ing, Pon i icia Uni e sidad Ja e iana, Bogo a, Colombia
(L H Ba e o ScD); Mala ia A las P ojec , Ox o d Big Da a Ins i u e
(K E Ba le DPhil), Li Ka Shing Cen e o Heal h In o ma ion and
Disco e y (P o S I Hay DSc), Nu ield Depa men o Popula ion Heal h
(D A Benne PhD), Depa men o Zoology (P W Ge hing PhD), Uni e si y
o Ox o d, Ox o d, UK (D J Weiss PhD); Ox o d Uni e si y, Ho Chi Minh
Ci y, Vie nam (J Bea dsley MBChB); College o Public Heal h and T opical
Medicine, Jazan, Saudi A abia (N Bedi MD); IRCCS - Is i u o di Rice che
Fa macologiche Ma io Neg i, Be gamo, I aly (E Beghi MD, B Bikbo MD,
G Giussani BiolD, N Pe ico MD, P o G Remuzzi MD); Yale Uni e si y,
New Ha en, CT, USA (P o M L Bell PhD, J J Huang MD); Cen e o
Clinical and Epidemiological Resea ch Cen e , Hospi al Uni e si a io
(A C Goula PhD), In e nal Medicine Depa men (P o I S San os PhD),
Uni e si y o São Paulo, São Paulo, B azil (I M Benseno PhD,
P o P A Lo u o D PH); College o Heal h Sciences, Deb e Be han
Uni e si y, Deb e Be han, E hiopia (A Be hane PhD); Uni e si y Medical
Cen e G oningen (D F Be he MS), Depa men o Psychia y, Uni e si y
Medical Cen e G oningen (P o H W Hoek MD), Uni e si y o G oningen,
G oningen, Ne he lands (J F M an Bo en PhD); Di ision o Heal h and
Social Ca e Resea ch (P o C D Wol e MD), King’s College London,
London, UK (E Be nabé PhD); Ca ol Da ila Uni e si y o Medicine and
Pha macy, Bucha es , Romania (P o M Beu an PhD, D V Da i oiu PhD,
S Hos iuc PhD, I Negoi PhD, R I Negoi PhD); Eme gency Hospi al o
Bucha es , Bucha es , Romania (P o M Beu an PhD, I Negoi PhD);
College o Heal h and Medical Sciences (A S Beyene MPH,
M M Mengesha MPH), Ha amaya Uni e si y, Ha a , E hiopia
(L N B Bul o MS, A Gele o MPH, M D Gishu MS, K T Roba PhD,
M S Shi e aw MS); Pos g adua e Ins i u e o Medical Educa ion and
Resea ch, Chandiga h, India (A Bhansali DM); Cen e o Excellence in
Women and Child Heal h, Aga Khan Uni e si y, Ka achi, Pakis an
(Z A Bhu a PhD); Depa men o Epidemiology and Public Heal h
(P o M Ki imaki PhD), Ins i u e o Epidemiology & Heal h
(T Tillmann MSc), Uni e si y College London, London, UK (C Bi ungi MS,
Global Heal h Me ics
1416
www. helance .com Vol 390 Sep embe 16, 2017
M R Ma hu PhD); Depa men o Public Heal h (D J Boneya MPH), Deb e
Ma kos Uni e si y, Deb e Ma kos, E hiopia (T K Tegegne MPH); Uni e si y
o B i ish Columbia, Vancou e , BC, Canada (P o M B aue ScD,
J A Kopec PhD, F Pou malek PhD); College o Medicine (J Shen PhD), The
Ohio S a e Uni e si y, Columbus, OH, USA (P o N J K B ei bo de PhD,
M Yo ebieng PhD); Ge man Cance Resea ch Cen e , Heidelbe g, Ge many
(P o H B enne MD); Uni e si y o Leices e , Leices e , UK
(P o T S B ugha MD); Al Shi a T us Eye Hospi al, Rawalpindi, Pakis an
(Z A Bu PhD); Me opoli an Au onomous Uni e si y, Mexico Ci y, Mexico
(R Cá denas ScD); Colombian Na ional Heal h Obse a o y, Ins i u o
Nacional de Salud, Bogo a, Colombia (C A Cas añeda-O juela MSc);
Epidemiology and Public Heal h E alua ion G oup, Public Heal h
Depa men , Uni e sidad Nacional de Colombia, Bogo a, Colombia
(C A Cas añeda-O juela MSc); Depa men o Medicine, Uni e si y o
Valencia, INCLIVA Heal h Resea ch Ins i u e and CIBERSAM, Valencia,
Spain (F Ca alá-López PhD, P o R Taba és-Seisdedos PhD); Clinical
Epidemiology P og am, O awa Hospi al Resea ch Ins i u e, O awa, ON,
Canada (F Ca alá-López PhD); Na ional Heal h Resea ch Ins i u es, Zgunan
Town, Taiwan (H Chang D PH); Na ional Yang-Ming Uni e si y, Taipei,
Taiwan (H Chang D PH); Queensland Cen e o Men al Heal h Resea ch,
B isbane, QLD, Aus alia (F J Cha lson PhD, H E E skine PhD,
A J Fe a i PhD, D San omau o PhD, P o H A Whi e o d PhD);
Depa men o En i onmen al Epidemiology, Uni e si y o Occupa ional
and En i onmen al Heal h, Ki akyushu, Japan (O Chimed-Ochi MPH);
Uni e si y o Zambia, Lusaka, Zambia (V H Chisumpa MPhil,
C C Mapoma PhD); Uni e si y o Wi wa e s and, Johannesbu g,
Sou h A ica (V H Chisumpa MPhil); Minis y o Heal h, Baghdad, I aq
(A A Chi hee MD); Bispebje g Uni e si y Hospi al, Copenhagen,
Denma k (P o H Ch is ensen DMSCi); Ch is ian Medical College, Vello e,
India (P o D J Ch is ophe MD, P o S Va ughese DM); Uni e si y o
Sale no, Ba onissi, I aly (P o M Ci illo MD); Heal h E ec s Ins i u e,
Bos on, MA, USA (A J Cohen DSc); MRC Li ecou se Epidemiology Uni ed,
Uni e si y o Sou hamp on, Sou hamp on, UK (P o C Coope MD); NIHR
Biomedical Resea ch Cen e, Uni e si y o Sou hamp on and Uni e si y
Hospi al Sou hamp on NHS Founda ion T us , Sou hamp on, UK
(P o C Coope MD); Resea ch Cen e on Public Heal h (CESP), Uni e si y
o Milan-Bicocca, Monza, I aly (P A Co esi PhD); Uni e si y o Cali o nia,
San Diego, La Jolla, CA, USA (M H C iqui MD); Cen e o In e na ional
Heal h, Dunedin School o Medicine (P o J A C ump MD), Uni e si y o
O ago, Dunedin, New Zealand (P o R G Poul on PhD); i3S - Ins i u o de
In es igação e Ino ação em Saúde and INEB - Ins i u o de Engenha ia
Biomédica (J das Ne es PhD), UCIBIO@REQUIMTE, Toxicology G oup,
Facul y o Pha macy (J P Sil a PhD), Uni e si y o Po o, Po o, Po ugal;
Wellcome T us B igh on & Sussex Cen e o Global Heal h Resea ch,
B igh on, UK (P o G Da ey MD); Republican Ins i u e o Ca diology and
In e nal Diseases, Alma y, Kazakhs an (K Da le o PhD); School o Public
Heal h, Kazakh Na ional Medical Uni e si y, Alma y, Kazakhs an
(K Da le o PhD); Depa men o Medicine, School o Clinical Sciences a
Monash Heal h (P o A G Th i PhD), Monash Uni e si y, Melbou ne,
VIC, Aus alia (P o B de Cou en PhD); Na ional D ug and Alcohol
Resea ch Cen e (P o L Degenha d PhD), B ien Holden Vision Ins i u e
(P o S Resniko MD), School o Op ome y and Vision Science
(P o S Resniko MD), Uni e si y o New Sou h Wales, Sydney, NSW,
Aus alia; Uni e si y o Colo ado School o Medicine and he Colo ado
School o Public Heal h, Au o a, CO, USA (R P Della alle MD); B igh on
and Sussex Medical School, B igh on, UK (K De ibe MPH); School o
Public Heal h (K De ibe MPH), Addis Ababa Uni e si y, Addis Ababa,
E hiopia (A Z Gi e PhD, H A Ha e i MS, S G Kelbo e MPH,
B G Woldeyes MPH); Depa men o Communi y Medicine, Facul y o
Medicine, Uni e si y o Pe adeniya, Pe adeniya, S i Lanka
(S D Dha ma a ne MD); Unde sec e a y o Resea ch & Technology,
Minis y o Heal h & Medical Educa ion, Teh an, I an (S Djalalinia PhD);
Ins i u e o Global Heal h Inno a ions, Duy Tan Uni e si y, Da Nang,
Vie nam (H P Do MSc, C T Nguyen MSc, Q L Nguyen MD,
T H Nguyen MSc, V M Nong MSc); Depa men o Social Medicine,
Facul y o Public Heal h, Medical Uni e si y - Va na, Va na, Bulga ia
(K Doko a PhD); Uni e si y o Cape Coas , Cape Coas , Ghana
(D T Doku PhD); Uni e si y o Tampe e, Tampe e, Finland
(D T Doku PhD); Uni e si y o Roches e Medical Cen e , Roches e , NY,
USA (E R Do sey MD); In e na ional Ins i u e o Popula ion Sciences,
Mumbai, India (M Dubey MPhil, A Kas o MPhil, B K Panda MPhil,
M H U Rahman MPhil, P o U Ram PhD); Fede al Uni e si y o Rio
G ande do Sul, Po o Aleg e, B azil (B B Duncan PhD, C Kieling MD,
P o M I Schmid MD); Uni e si y o No h Ca olina, Chapel Hill, NC,
USA (B B Duncan PhD); Depa men o Global Heal h and Social
Medicine, Ha a d Medical School, Kigali, Rwanda (Z Z El-Kha ib PhD);
School o Public Heal h and Heal h Sciences Resea ch Cen e , Sa i, I an
(P o A Enaya i PhD); A ba Minch Uni e si y, A ba Minch, E hiopia
(A Y End ies MPH); The Ins i u e o Social and Economic S udies o
Popula ion, Russian Academy o Sciences, Moscow, Russia
(P o S P E mako DSc); Fede al Resea ch Ins i u e o Heal h
O ganiza ion and In o ma ics, Minis y o Heal h o he Russian
Fede a ion, Moscow, Russia (P o S P E mako DSc); Minis y o Heal h
and Medical Educa ion, Teh an, I an (B Esh a i PhD); A ak Uni e si y o
Medical Sciences, A ak, I an (B Esh a i PhD); Mul iple Scle osis Resea ch
Cen e , Teh an, I an (S Eskanda ieh PhD); Depa men o Heal h, Manila,
Philippines (E J A Fa aon MD); DGS Di ec o a e Gene al o Heal h, Lisboa,
Po ugal (C S E S Fa inha MSc); Uni e sidade Abe a, Lisboa, Po ugal
(C S E S Fa inha MSc); Fede al Uni e si y o Se gipe, A acaju, B azil
(P o A Fa o PhD); Na ional Ins i u e o S oke and Applied
Neu osciences, Auckland Uni e si y o Technology, Auckland, New Zealand
(V L Feigin PhD); CBQF - Cen e o Bio echnology and Fine Chemis y -
Associa e Labo a o y, Facul y o Bio echnology, Ca holic Uni e si y o
Po ugal, Po o, Po ugal (J C Fe nandes PhD); Wollega Uni e si y,
Nekem e, E hiopia (T R Feyissa MPH); Kaise Pe manen e, Fon ana, CA,
USA (I Filip MD); School o Public Heal h, Biele eld Uni e si y, Biele eld,
Ge many (F Fische PhD); F ed Hu chinson Cance Resea ch Cen e ,
Sea le, WA, USA (C Fi zmau ice MD); Ins i u e o Ge on ology, Academy
o Medical Science, Kyi , Uk aine (N Foig PhD); Depa men o In ec ious
Disease Epidemiology (T Fü s PhD), Depa men o P ima y Ca e &
Public Heal h (P o A Majeed MD), Impe ial College London, London, UK
(K J Fo eman PhD, P o S Rawa MD, L Rush on PhD, S Saxena MD,
H Shoman MPH); Depa men o Epidemiology and Public Heal h
(T Fü s PhD), Swiss T opical and Public Heal h Ins i u e, Basel,
Swi ze land (C K Ka ema MSc); Swiss T opical and Public Heal h Ins i u e
(P o M Tanne PhD), Uni e si y o Basel, Basel, Swi ze land
(T Fü s PhD); Faculdade de Medicina de Ribei ão P e o, Uni e sidade de
São Paulo, Ribei ão P e o, B azil (J M Fu ado MD); Manhiça Heal h
Resea ch Cen e , Manhiça, Mozambique (A L Ga cia-Bas ei o MSc);
Ba celona Ins i u e o Global Heal h, Ba celona, Spain
(A L Ga cia-Bas ei o MSc); Di ision o Human Nu i ion, Wageningen
Uni e si y, Wageningen, Ne he lands (J M Geleijnse PhD); Uni e si y o
Newcas le, Newcas le, NSW, Aus alia (A Gele o MPH); Madda Walabu
Uni e si y, Bale Goba, E hiopia (B L Gemechu MPH); Flinde s Uni e si y,
Adelaide, SA, Aus alia (H A Gesesew MPH, P o K Pesudo s PhD); The
Pe e Dohe y Ins i u e o In ec ion and Immuni y, The Uni e si y o
Melbou ne & The Royal Melbou ne Hospi al, Melbou ne, VIC, Aus alia
(K B Gibney MBBS); Wa wick Medical School, Uni e si y o Bi mingham,
Bi mingham, UK (P o P S Gill DM); Howa d Uni e si y, Washing on, DC,
USA (R F Gillum MD); Ke sa Heal h and Demog aphic Su eillance
Sys em, Ha a , E hiopia (M D Gishu MS); Uni e si y o Massachuse s
Bos on, Bos on, MA, USA (P o P N Gona PhD); Ins i u o de
In es igaciones Cien i icas y Se icios de Al a Tecnologia - INDICASAT-
AIP, Cuidad del Sabe , Panama (A Good idge PhD); Depa men o Heal h
and Social A ai s, Go e nmen o he Fede a ed S a es o Mic onesia,
Paliki , Fede a ed S a es o Mic onesia (S V Gopalani MPH); O ganisa ion
o Economic Co-ope a ion and De elopmen , Pa is, F ance
(Y Go yakin PhD); Cen e o Check o Hospi al Si io Libanes, São Paulo,
B azil (A C Goula PhD); Depa men s o Mic obiology and Epidemiology
& Bios a is ics, Sain James School o Medicine, The Qua e , Anguilla
(P o H C Gugnani PhD); E e nal Hea Ca e Cen e and Resea ch
Ins i u e, Jaipu , India (R Gup a PhD); Mon e io e Medical Cen e , B onx,
NY, USA (T Gup a MD, C D Rehm PhD); Albe Eins ein College o
Medicine, B onx, NY, USA (T Gup a MD, P o H D Hosgood PhD);
Depa men o An h opology, Uni e si y o Delhi, Delhi, India
(V Gup a PhD); Na ional Ins i u e o Psychia y Ramon de la Fuen e,
Mexico Ci y, Mexico (R A Gu ié ez PhD); Depa men o Clinical
Neu ological Sciences (L A Sposa o MD), Wes e n Uni e si y, London, ON,
Canada (P o V Hachinski DSc, T O Olagunju MD); Kil e Awlaelo Heal h
and Demog aphic Su eillance Sys em, Mekelle, E hiopia (G B Hailu MSc);
A abian Gul Uni e si y, Manama, Bah ain (P o R R Hamadeh DPhil);
Hamdan Bin Mohammed Sma Uni e si y, Dubai, Uni ed A ab Emi a es
Global Heal h Me ics
www. helance .com Vol 390 Sep embe 16, 2017
1417
(S Hamidi D PH); Wayne Coun y Depa men o Heal h and Human
Se ices, De oi , MI, USA (M Hammami MD); Uni e si y o New Mexico,
Albuque que, NM, USA (A J Handal PhD); School o Medicine and
Pha macology, Uni e si y o Wes e n Aus alia, Pe h, WA, Aus alia
(P o G J Hankey MD); Ha y Pe kins Ins i u e o Medical Resea ch,
Nedlands, WA, Aus alia (P o G J Hankey MD); Wes e n Aus alian
Neu oscience Resea ch Ins i u e, Nedlands, WA, Aus alia
(P o G J Hankey MD); School o Public Heal h (D Hend ie PhD), Cen e
o Popula ion Heal h (T R Mille PhD), Cu in Uni e si y, Pe h, WA,
Aus alia; Depa men o Epidemiology, Mailman School o Public Heal h,
Columbia Uni e si y, New Yo k, NY, USA (P o H W Hoek MD);
Depa men o Pulmonology, Yokohama Ci y Uni e si y G adua e School
o Medicine, Yokohama, Japan (N Ho i a MD); Public Heal h Di ision, The
Paci ic Communi y, Noumea, New Caledonia (D G Hoy PhD); Depa men
o Epidemiology, Salah Azaiz Ins i u e, Tunis, Tunisia (P o M Hsai i MD);
Depa men o Epidemiology and Heal h S a is ics, School o Public
Heal h, Cen al Sou h Uni e si y, Changsha, China (G Hu PhD);
Camb idge Heal h Alliance, Camb idge, MA, USA (H Huang MD);
Na ional Cen e o Regis e -Based Resea ch, Aa hus School o Business
and Social Sciences (P o J J McG a h PhD), Aa hus Uni e si y, Aa hus,
Denma k (K M Ibu g PhD); Di ision o Coho Conso ium Resea ch,
Epidemiology and P e en ion G oup, Cen e o Public Heal h Sciences,
Na ional Cance Cen e , Tokyo, Japan (M Inoue MD); Uni e si y o he
Wes Indies, Kings on, Jamaica (P o M D Jackson PhD); Depa men o
Global and Communi y Heal h, Geo ge Mason Uni e si y, Fai ax, VA,
USA (K H Jacobsen PhD); Facul y o Medical Sciences, Uni e si y o
K aguje ac, K aguje ac, Se bia (P o M B Jako lje ic PhD); Uni e si y o
Abe deen, Abe deen, UK (M Ja anbakh PhD); Cen e o Ch onic Disease
Con ol, New Delhi, India (P Jeemon PhD); Independen Consul an , Oslo,
No way (L R K Johansson PhD); Depa men o Oph halmology, Medical
Facul y Mannheim, Rup ech -Ka ls-Uni e si y Heidelbe g, Mannheim,
Ge many (P o J B Jonas MD); Ins i u e o Family Medicine and Public
Heal h, Uni e si y o Ta u, Ta u, Es onia (M Jü isson MD); Uni e si y
College Co k, Co k, I eland (Z Kabi PhD); London School o Economics
and Poli ical Science, London, UK (R Kadel MPH); CSIR - Indian Ins i u e
o Toxicology Resea ch, Lucknow, India (R Kamal MSc,
C N Kesa achand an PhD); Epidemiological and S a is ical Me hods
Resea ch G oup, Helmhol z Cen e o In ec ion Resea ch, B aunschweig,
Ge many (A Ka ch MD); Hanno e -B aunschweig Si e, Ge man Cen e o
In ec ion Resea ch, B aunschweig, Ge many (A Ka ch MD); Quali y and
Equi y Heal h Ca e, Kigali, Rwanda (C K Ka ema MSc); Depa men o
Anes hesiology & Pain Medicine, Sea le Child en’s Hospi al, Sea le, WA,
USA (N J Kassebaum MD); MRC/CSO Social & Public Heal h Sciences
Uni , Uni e si y o Glasgow, Glasgow, UK (S V Ka iki eddi PhD); School o
Public Heal h (P o N Kawakami MD), Uni e si y o Tokyo, Tokyo, Japan
(K Shibuya MD); Ins i u e o T opical and In ec ious Diseases, Nai obi,
Kenya (P N Keiyo o PhD); School o Con inuing and Dis ance Educa ion,
Nai obi, Kenya (P N Keiyo o PhD); Alcohol, Tobacco & O he D ug
Resea ch Uni (P o C D Pa y PhD), UKZN Gas oin es inal Cance
Resea ch Cen e (P o B Sa o ius PhD), Sou h A ican Medical Resea ch
Council, Cape Town, Sou h A ica (A P Kengne PhD, R Ma zopoulos PhD);
School o Public Heal h and Family Medicine (R Ma zopoulos PhD),
Depa men o Psychia y (P o D J S ein PhD), Uni e si y o Cape Town,
Cape Town, Sou h A ica (A P Kengne PhD, J J N Noubiap MD);
Depa men o Communi y Medicine, Public Heal h and Family Medicine,
Jo dan Uni e si y o Science and Technology, I bid, Jo dan
(P o Y S Khade ScD); Heal h Se ices Academy, Islamabad, Pakis an
(E A Khan MD); Depa men o Heal h Policy and Managemen , Seoul
Na ional Uni e si y College o Medicine, Seoul, Sou h Ko ea
(P o Y Khang MD); Ins i u e o Heal h Policy and Managemen , Seoul
Na ional Uni e si y Medical Cen e , Seoul, Sou h Ko ea
(P o Y Khang MD); I anian Minis y o Heal h and Medical Educa ion,
Teh an, I an (A Khos a i PhD); Depa men o Nu i ion and Heal h
Science, Ball S a e Uni e si y, Muncie, IN, USA (J Khubchandani PhD);
Hospi al de Clinicas de Po o Aleg e, Po o Aleg e, B azil (C Kieling MD);
Depa men o Heal h Sciences, No heas e n Uni e si y, Bos on, MA,
USA (P o D Kim D PH); School o Medicine, Xiamen Uni e si y Malaysia
Campus, Sepang, Malaysia (Y J Kim PhD); Simmons College, Bos on, MA,
USA (R W Kimoko i MD); Cen e o Resea ch and Ac ion in Public
Heal h, Uni e si y o Canbe a, Canbe a, ACT, Aus alia (Y Kin u PhD);
Oslo Uni e si y, Oslo, No way (P o A Kisa PhD); Ins i u e o Public
Heal h, Facul y o Heal h Sciences (R Topo -Mad y PhD), Jagiellonian
Uni e si y Medical College, K akow, Poland (K A Kissimo a-Ska bek PhD);
Clinicum, Facul y o Medicine (P o M Ki imaki PhD), Finnish Ins i u e o
Occupa ional Heal h, Wo k O ganiza ions, Wo k Disabili y P og am,
Depa men o Public Heal h, Facul y o Medicine (T Lallukka PhD,
R Shi i PhD), Uni e si y o Helsinki, Helsinki, Finland (T J Me e oja PhD);
Cen e o Disease Bu den, No wegian Ins i u e o Public Heal h, Be gen,
No way (A K Knudsen PhD, P o S E Vollse D PH); Depa men o
Psychosocial Science (A K Knudsen PhD), Depa men o Global Public
Heal h and P ima y Ca e (P o S E Vollse D PH), Uni e si y o Be gen,
Be gen, No way (P o O F No heim PhD, M C Tollanes PhD); Cen e o
Communi y Empowe men , Heal h Policy and Humani ies, Na ional
Ins i u e o Heal h Resea ch & De elopmen , Jaka a, Indonesia
(S Kosen MD); She -i-Kashmi Ins i u e o Medical Sciences, S inaga ,
India (P o P A Koul MD); Resea ch and De elopmen Uni , Pa c Sani a i
San Joan de Deu (CIBERSAM), Ba celona, Spain (A Koyanagi MD);
Resea ch Cen e o Neu ology, Moscow, Russia (M K a chenko PhD,
P o M A Pi ado DSc); Ins i u e o Risk Assessmen Sciences, U ech
Uni e si y, U ech , Ne he lands (P o H K omhou PhD); Depa men o
Social and P e en i e Medicine, School o Public Heal h and Depa men
o Demog aphy and Public Heal h Resea ch Ins i u e, Uni e si y o
Mon eal, Mon eal, QC, Canada (P o B Kua e De o PhD); Ins i u e o
Public Heal h, Hace epe Uni e si y, Anka a, Tu key (B Kucuk Bice PhD);
Na ional Cance Ins i u e, Rock ille, MD, USA (Q Lan PhD); Help Me See,
Inc, New Yo k, NY, USA (V C Lansingh PhD); Ins i uo Mexicano de
O almologia, Que e a o, Mexico (V C Lansingh PhD); Depa men o
Medical Sciences, Uppsala Uni e si y, Uppsala, Sweden
(P o A La sson PhD); Hong Kong Poly echnic Uni e si y, Hong Kong,
China (P H Lee PhD); Tuscany Regional Cen e o Occupa ional Inju ies
and Diseases, Flo ence, I aly (M Le i PhD); Depa men o Da a
Managemen , Peking Uni e si y Clinical Resea ch Ins i u e, Beijing, China
(Y Li PhD); Na ional Cen e o Ch onic and Noncommunicable Disease
Con ol and P e en ion (Y Li PhD), Chinese Cen e o Disease Con ol and
P e en ion, Beijing, China (P o X Liang MD); San F ancisco VA Medical
Cen e , San F ancisco, CA, USA (Y Li PhD); Sama a Uni e si y, Sama a,
E hiopia (M L Liben MPH); Uni e si y o Hai a, Hai a, Is ael
(P o S Linn MD); All India Ins i u e o Medical Sciences, New Delhi, India
(R Lodha MD, P o R Malho a MS, P o N Tandon PhD); Uni e si y o
Ba i, Ba i, I aly (P o G Log oscino PhD); Uni e si y o B is ol, B is ol, UK
(K J Looke PhD); Ins i u e o Nu i ion, F ied ich Schille Uni e si y Jena,
Jena, Ge many (P o S Lo kowski PhD); Ain ee Uni e si y Hospi al
Na ional Heal h Se ice Founda ion T us , Li e pool, UK
(P o RLune icius PhD); School o Medicine, Uni e si y o Li e pool,
Li e pool, UK (P o R Lune icius PhD); Compe ence Clus e o Nu i ion
and Ca dio ascula Heal h (nu iCARD) Halle-Jena-Leipzig, Jena, Ge many
(P o S Lo kowski PhD); A eneo de Manila Uni e si y, Manila, Philippines
(E R K Maca ayan PhD); Mansou a Facul y o Medicine, Mansou a, Egyp
(H Magdy Abd El Razek MBBCH); Aswan Facul y o Medicine, Aswan
Uni e si y Hospi al, Aswan, Egyp (M Magdy Abd El Razek MBBCH);
Facul y o Heal h Sciences and Social Wo k, Depa men o Public Heal h,
T na a Uni e si y, T na a, Slo akia (M Majdan PhD); Na ional Ins i u e o
Heal h Resea ch, Teh an, I an (P o R Majdzadeh PhD); Uni e sidade
Fede al de Minas Ge ais, Belo Ho izon e, B azil (P o D C Mal a PhD);
The Uni e si y o Queensland, B isbane, QLD, Aus alia
(P o A A Mamun PhD); Uni e si y o Milano Bicocca, Monza, I aly
(P o L G Man o ani DSc); Depa men o Physics and A mosphe ic
Science (A an Donkelaa PhD), Dalhousie Uni e si y, Hali ax, NS, Canada
(P o R V Ma in PhD); Hospi al Uni e si a io Doc o Pese , Valencia,
Spain (J Ma inez-Raga PhD, M To ajada PhD); CEU Ca dinal He e a
Uni e si y, Moncada, Spain (J Ma inez-Raga PhD); Fede al Ins i u e o
Educa ion, Science and Technology o Cea á, Caucaia, B azil
(F R Ma ins-Melo PhD); Key S a e Labo a o y o Molecula De elopmen al
Biology, Ins i u e o Gene ics and De elopmen al Biology, Chinese
Academy o Sciences, Beijing, China (M Mazidi PhD); Uni e si y Hospi als
B is ol NHS Founda ion T us , B is ol, UK (C McAlinden PhD); Public
Heal h Wales, Swansea, UK (C McAlinden PhD); Queensland Cen e o
Men al Heal h Resea ch, The Pa k Cen e o Men al Heal h, Wacol, QLD,
Aus alia (P o J J McG a h PhD); Queensland B ain Ins i u e
(P o J J McG a h PhD), Uni e si y o Queensland, B isbane, QLD,
Aus alia (S R Mish a MPH); Ipas Nepal, Ka hmandu, Nepal
(S Meha a PhD); Janakpu i Supe special y Hospi al, New Delhi, India