scieee AI-readable full text Open interactive document viewer

Pathways to a fully sustainable electricity supply for Nigeria in the mid-term future

Oyewo, Ayobami Solomon,Aghahosseini, Arman,Bogdanov, Dmitrii,Breyer, Christian

Abstract

Post-print / Final draft

Full text

This is a version of a publication in Please cite the publication as follows: DOI: Copyright of the original publication: This is a parallel published version of an original publication. This version can differ from the original published article. published by Pathways to a fully sustainable electricity supply for Nigeria in the mid-term future Oyewo Ayobami Solomon, Aghahosseini Arman, Bogdanov Dmitrii, Breyer Christian Oyewo A.S., Aghahosseini, A., Bogdanov, D., Breyer, C. (2018). Pathways to a fully sustainable electricity supply for Nigeria in the mid-term future. Energy Conversion and Management, vol. 178, pp. 44-64. DOI: 10.1016/j.enconman.2018.10.036 Author's accepted manuscript (AAM) Elsevier Energy Conversion and Management 10.1016/j.enconman.2018.10.036 © 2018 Elsevier Ltd. UNCORRECTED PROOF Energy Conversion and Management xxx (2018) xxx-xxx Contents lists available at ScienceDirect Energy Conversion and Management journal homepage: www.elsevier.com Pathways to a fully sustainable electricity supply for Nigeria in the mid-term future Ayobami Solomon Oyewo, Arman Aghahosseini, Dmitrii Bogdanov, Christian Breyer Lappeenranta University of Technology, Skinnarilankatu 34, 53850 Lappeenranta, Finland ARTICLE INFO Keywords: Nigeria Energy transition Desalination Photovoltaic Energy system Storage Decarbonisation ABSTRACT Ambitious actions focused on rapid defossilisation of today’s energy systems require greater urgency, in order to avert unmanageable impacts of climate change. Transitioning to a cost-effective and carbon-neutral energy system in Nigeria and across the globe by the second half of this century is vital. This study explores a paradigmatic pathway to a fully sustainable energy system for Nigeria, by 2050. The research approach is to simulate a cost-optimised transition pathway towards 100% renewable energy based power system for Nigeria, using a linear optimisation model. The model is based on hourly resolution for an entire year. The country researched is structured into 6 sub-regions. The optimisation for each of the 5-year time periods is carried out based on assumed costs and technological status until 2050 for all energy technologies involved. The levelised cost of electricity declines from 54 €/MWh in 2015 to 46 €/MWh in 2050 for the power sector in the Best Policy Scenario and further declines to 35 €/MWh with sector coupling. Whereas, the cost of electricity increased to 75 €/MWh in the Current Policy Scenario without greenhouse gas emission cost. The results clearly reveal that integrating a renewable energy technology mix with a wide variety of storage technologies is the most competitive and least cost electricity option for Nigeria in the mid-term future, as indicated by the Best Policy Scenario. In particular, the compatibility and predominant role of solar photovoltaics and batteries is paramount towards a rapid transition of Nigeria’s power sector, due to highly favourable economics. This study concludes with the implications of a stable and supportive policy environment, transitioning to a defossiliated energy system in Nigeria could be achieved in the mid-term future. This study is the first of its kind in full hourly resolution for Nigeria, and demonstrates the need for carrying out detailed analyses in examining gaps in energy transition understanding based on various policy constraints for developing countries in comparable climates. Nomenclature A-CAES adiabatic compressed air storage BPS best policy scenario CAPEX capital expenditure CCGT combined cycle gas turbine CHP combined heat and power CPS current policy scenario CSP concentrating solar thermal power DISCOs Electricity Distribution Companies in Nigeria ECN Electricity Corporation of Nigeria ESPR electric power sector reform FMWR Federal Ministry of Water Resources GENCOs power generation companies in Nigeria GT gas turbine HVDC high voltage direct current LCOC levelised cost of curtailment LCOE levelised cost of electricity LCOS levelised cost of storage LCOT levelised cost of transmission NDA Niger Dams Authority NEEAP National Energy Efficiency Action Plan NEPA National Electric Power Authority NESI Nigerian Electricity Supply Industry NREEP National Renewable Energy and Efficiency Policy OCGT open cycle gas turbine OPEX operational expenditure PHCN Power Holding Company of Nigeria PHS pumped hydro storage PV photovoltaic RE renewable energy RoR run-of-river SHS solar home system SNG synthetic natural gas SSA Sub-Saharan Africa Email addresses: [email protected] (A.S. Oyewo); christian.[email protected] (C. Breyer) https://doi.org/10.1016/j.enconman.2018.10.036 Received 10 August 2018; Received in revised form 11 October 2018; Accepted 13 October 2018 Available online xxx 0196-8904/ © 2018. UNCORRECTED PROOF A.S. Oyewo et al. Energy Conversion and Management xxx (2018) xxx-xxx ST steam turbine SWA State Water Agency TRANSCO Transmission Company of Nigeria TES thermal energy storage UN United Nations VRE variable renewable energy WACC weighted average cost of capital 1. Introduction Transitioning away from the contemporary to a net zero emission energy system around the middle of the 21st century is of paramount importance [1], in order to keep global temperature rise well below 2°C above pre-industrial levels and pursuing efforts to limit this to 1.5°C [2]. Staying under 2°C requires an urgent shift towards defossiliated energy systems [3]. Renewable energy (RE) sources are vital to avoid the unmanageable impacts of climate change [4]. In addition, RE sources could address the current electricity supply gaps and future demands in many countries in Sub-Saharan Africa (SSA), as well as in Nigeria [5]. Electricity demand in West Africa grew from 29 TWh in 2000 to 61 TWh in 2012; the highest demand in the region is in Nigeria, which accounts for about 50% of the total demand [6]. By 2040, total electricity demand in Nigeria is expected to reach 291 TWh according to the International Energy Agency (IEA) [6]. Nigeria faces an enormous challenge with access to electricity [7]. In spite of the country’s abundant oil and gas resources, it still suffers from huge under-capacity in electricity generation, with frequent power outages driving consumers towards wide-spread use of costly backup generators [6]. The Nigerian power sector is not yet able to meet the entire power needs of the country [8]. As Akuru et al. [7] question, whether there could ever be stable and cost-effective electricity in Nigeria. Nigeria’s on-grid electricity consumption is low, at 126 kWh per capita compared to other developing countries [9]. The per capita electricity consumption of Ghana and South Africa are 2.9 times (361 kWh) and 31 times (3926 kWh) higher than that of Nigeria, respectively [9]. More than 90 million people in Nigeria still lack access to grid electricity, which represents 55% of the country’s population [6]. Unmet power demand results in load shedding, blackouts, and reliance on expensive diesel backup generators [10]. In 2012, an estimated amount of 16 TWh electricity demand was served by backup generators in SSA, and Nigeria accounts for about three-quarters of the electricity supplied by backup generators in the region [11]. The cost of electricity from generators (0.14–0.22 €/kWh) are more than twice as expensive as grid-based power (0.06–0.09 €/kWh) in Nigeria [9]. Furthermore, the country’s economic growth is hampered by the prevalent energy crisis [11]. The Nigerian government aims at a holistic economy transformation and have identified various barriers to the country’s economic development, which includes the erratic power supply, poor and crumbling infrastructure and over-reliance on the oil sector [11]. To address the erratic power supply, the Nigerian electricity vision 30:30:30 recognises the significance of RE sources to complement the current fossil fuel consumption and guarantee energy security. By 2030, on-grid capacity is expected to reach 30 GW, of which RE will contribute a 30% share of the total electricity mix [12]. There are plans underway to build nuclear and coal power plants in Nigeria [12]. Beyond environmental and public health risk of building fossil-fu- elled power plants [13], most nuclear power plants incurred construction period overruns [14] and substantial cost escalation [15]. According to [16], 180 nuclear reactors representing 178 GW and 459 bUSD worth of investment, incurred almost 231 bUSD in cost overruns. In addition, the cost of providing electricity from RE technologies in particular solar photovoltaic (PV) and wind are increasingly competitive with fossil-based power plants. The global weighted average levelised cost of electricity (LCOE) of utility-scale solar PV fell by 68% between 2010 and 2017 [17]. For instance, the current tariffs for new solar PV and wind (0.041 €/kWh) are now 40% cheaper than new baseload coal (0.069 €/kWh) in South Africa [18]. A recent study on cost comparison of various power technologies for Nigeria reveals that RE technologies are one of the strongest options to meet the power need of Nigeria in the most cost competitive way [19]. Recent studies have demonstrated the possibility of achieving a 100% renewables based power systems for cases such as Nigeria [5], SSA [10], Northeast Asia [20], Europe [21] and global [22]. These studies have shown that deep decarbonisation of the future power system is possible taking into account technical, economic and societal constraints, but it is also the least cost electricity option with utmost societal welfare. In addition, the Paris Agreement and the Sustainable Development Goal 7 (SDG 7) can be well supported by the deployment of small and large scale RE technologies, in view of tackling the two main challenges faced globally; climate change and widespread energy poverty [3]. The current electricity deficit and rising demand in Nigeria necessitates rapid response in bridging the gap between demand and supply [12], due to its growing population and unprecedented economic progress [10]. Therefore, tackling the plague of recurrent power outages and rising electricity demand in a way that is economically sustainable and safeguards livelihoods in Nigeria [7], which requires the deployment of RE infrastructure as a key solution with benefits that are multifaceted [10]. Nigeria has vast untapped RE resources [8], integrating RE technology mix with a wide variety of storage technologies could be competitive and the least cost electricity option for Nigeria [19]. This research presents the importance of carrying out an analytical and comprehensive investigation, when assessing least cost electrification options and transition pathways for developing countries, like Nigeria, under various policy constraints. The analysis for Nigeria is exemplary for developing countries of comparable climates. To better understand the transition pathways, eight scenarios have been defined based on governmental intended transition plans (Current Policy Scenarios) and zero emission scenarios (Best Policy Scenarios), which full match the targets of the Paris Agreement. Further, the impact of various factors such as greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions cost and sector coupling are assessed as well. The chosen optimisation modelling approach synthesises and reflects in-depth insights on how demand of different energy sectors such as power, non-energetic industrial gas and desalination can be met. The optimisation for each period, modelled in 5-year intervals, is carried out based on assumed costs and technological status until 2050. The paper is structured as follows: Section 2 presents an overview of the Nigerian power sector. The research methodology is described in Section 3. Results are presented and analysed in Section 4. In Section 5, the results are discussed and compared with related studies. Conclusion and policy implications are presented in Section 6. 2. The Nigerian power sector The history of electricity generation in Nigeria dates back to 1886, when two generating plants were installed to serve the Lagos Colony. In 1929, Nigeria’s first utility company, the Nigerian Electricity Supply Company was established [23]. Further development in the sector, led to the establishment of the Electricity Corporation of Nigeria (ECN) in 1951 to oversee electricity distribution in the country [23]. In 1962, the Niger Dams Authority (NDA) was established to oversee hydropower development [24]. The NDA oversaw power generation, while distribution and sales were undertaken by ECN. However, the ECN and NDA were merged in 1972 and resulted in the formation of the National Electric Power Authority (NEPA), which was responsible for generation, transmission, and distribution of electricity for the entire country. Reforms in the power sector in 2005 resulted in un 2 UNCORRECTED PROOF A.S. Oyewo et al. Energy Conversion and Management xxx (2018) xxx-xxx bundling of the NEPA and a renaming to Power Holding Company of Nigeria (PHCN) [25]. In spite of the long existence of electricity in the country and reforms, the power sector development has been at a slow rate. Today, gas and hydropower plants dominate the on-grid power generation capacity in Nigeria, which represent 86% and 14% of the total installed capacity, respectively [19]. The country’s power sector consists of three main sub-sectors [8], namely; generation companies (GENCOs), transmission company (TRANSCO) and distribution companies (DIS- COs) as shown in Fig. 1 [26]. Currently, there are 22 gas and 3 hydro on-grid generating plants operating in the Nigerian electricity supply industry (NESI) as shown in Fig. 2, concentrated in Southern Nigeria, with a total installed capacity of 12,522MW, and available capacity of 7141MW [9]. The management of Transmission Company of Nigeria is contracted to Manitoba Hydro International (Canada). The national grid consists of about 5524km of 330kV and 6802km of 132kV transmission lines [12]. The electricity distribution company of Nigeria consists of 11 companies across the country, as shown in Fig. 1 [8]. The distribution grid is operated mainly on 33kV (medium voltage) and 11kV (low voltage), comprising a network of over 24,000km [23]. The available capacity could be used for electricity generation, but is constrained by internal plant issues, majorly maintenance and repair issues. In addition, Nigeria’s power grid faces daily challenges [27], due to water shortage, high frequency due to demand imbalances, in Fig. 1. Overview of Nigeria’s generation, transmission and distribution sector [26]. Fig. 2. Nigeria’s 25 on-grid power plants locations [9]. 3 UNCORRECTED PROOF A.S. Oyewo et al. Energy Conversion and Management xxx (2018) xxx-xxx sufficient gas supply, and line constraints due to inadequate grid infrastructure as shown in Fig. 3 [9]. These constraints have led to a mismatch in demand and supply, and over-reliance on backup generators, among other issues. In addition, the power industry loses an average of 6m€(1.4 billion Naira) in revenue daily, due to these constraints. Fig. 4 shows the revenue lost to various constraints in the Nigerian power industry. For many years, the power sector was owned, managed and controlled by the government. The state-owned monopoly utility NEPA, throughout its existence, failed to meet the country’s electricity need [25]. Upon the advent of the democratic government in 1999, the Federal Government of Nigeria has committed huge financial investments of about 14 b€to refurbish the power sector, but without proportionate outcomes [25]. One of the key measures taken by the government to revamp the power sector was privatisation of power assets [8]. To this end, various policy measures were established in view of the privatisation [23]. In 2005, the Electric Power Sector Reform (ESPR) Act was enacted to allow private investors involvement in the previous governments’monopolised sector. Fig. 5 shows the structure of the post-re- form power sector [29]. Besides hydropower, Nigeria does not yet have any large RE-based generating plants, contributing to its on-grid electricity, in spite of the country having huge RE potential and energy market prospects. Fig. 6 shows the solar and wind resources maps for Nigeria. The data are provided by NASA [30,31], reprocessed by the German Aerospace Center [32] and converted to full load hours according to Bogdanov and Breyer [20] and Afanasyeva et al. [33]. However, a fundamental action towards RE development in Nigeria lies in a strategic and supportive policy direction by the Nigerian government towards a progressive RE master plan [7]. Such policy, legal and institutional framework are at their nascent stage in Nigeria [8] and are foreseen to foster RE development [12]. In 2015, the Federal Government of Nigeria approved the National Renewable Energy and Efficiency Policy (NREEEP), which is the country’s first ever RE-specific policy, which provides the descriptive framework for energy efficiency and RE development in Nigeria. The country targets to increase its total on-grid capacity from 4 GW in 2015 to 30 GW by 2030 [12]. This target was determined through the process of developing the National Renewable Energy Action Plan (NREAP) and National Energy Efficiency Action Plan (NEEAP), as stated in the NREEEP 2015. The share of on-grid RE Fig. 3. Electricity generation and constraints (Ct) in Nigeria [28]. Fig. 4. Revenue lost to constraints in the Nigeria power sector [28] (1 billion Naira is equivalent to 2m€). 4 UNCORRECTED PROOF A.S. Oyewo et al. Energy Conversion and Management xxx (2018) xxx-xxx Fig. 5. Post-reform power sector structure [29]. Fig. 6. Maps of Nigeria showing annual full load hours for solar PV single–axis tracking (left) and onshore wind (right) for the year 2005. supply is expected to increase from its present 1.3% in 2015 to 16% by 2030 in the NREEEP 2015. However, upon the completion and endorsement of NREAP 2016, the target was revised to a 30% share of RE supply by 2030. 3. Research methods The research approach applies linear optimisation modelling in determining the optimal investment and electricity generation technology mix, needed to satisfy electricity demand in Nigeria by 2050 [22]. A linear optimisation energy system tool, the LUT Energy System Transition model [20], is used to simulate the Nigerian power system. The model was designed and developed to analyse an energy transition from the current (as of the beginning of 2015) fossil based-system to a 100% RE-based power system by 2050, covering the demand of power, non-energetic industrial gas and desalination sectors. The transition is modelled in 5-year steps from 2015 to 2050, and is carried out based on assumed costs and technological status for all energy technologies involved. The electricity generating plants required for the energy transition from 2015 to 2050 is considered according to Caldera et al. [34] and based on Farfan and Breyer [35]. Two essential constraints are taken into consideration as the basis for the energy system transition modelling. Firstly, after 2015, no new fossil-based power plants are installed. The existing fossil-based power plants are gradually phased out based on their technical lifetimes. However, the installation of gas turbines is permitted after 2015 due to lower carbon emission, high efficiency of the technology, and in particularly due to the possibility to accommodate bio-methane and synthetic natural gas in the system, so that a fuel shift towards sustainable fuels can be realised. Secondly, RE capacity growth cannot exceed 4% per year, in order to prevent system disruptions. 3.1. Model structure The LUT Energy System Transition model is developed for comprehensive analyses of energy transition from current energy systems to 100% RE-based systems. The model is based on linear optimisation with an hourly resolution of the energy system parameters for an entire year, under a set of applied constraints, assumptions for the future RE powered system and demand. Detailed model description, equations and applied constraints can be found in [20]. The model is compiled using MATLAB [36], while the optimisation is carried out in MOSEK [37]. Fig. 7 shows the flow diagram of the main input parameters and outputs of the model. A full set of technical and financial assumptions used in this study are presented in the Supplementary Material (Table S1). The target function of the model optimisation is to minimise the total annual energy system cost, which is calculated as the sum of annual costs of the installed capacities of each technology, costs of energy 5 UNCORRECTED PROOF A.S. Oyewo et al. Energy Conversion and Management xxx (2018) xxx-xxx Fig. 7. Main inputs and outputs of the LUT Energy System Transition model [22]. generation, and costs of generation ramping. In addition, the energy system consists of distributed generation and self-consumption of residential, commercial and industrial consumers. The transition analysis considers the potential of the prosumer market segment as an essential aspect of system planning. Thus, another mini-transition hourly model describes the prosumers PV systems and battery development capacity. Prosumers can install rooftop PV and lithium-ion batteries, depending on the cost, or buy electricity from the grid. The target function of the prosumers is the minimisation of cost of electricity consumed. This cost is calculated as the sum of self-generation cost, annual cost, and cost of electricity consumed from the grid. Excess electricity generated by prosumers can be sold to the overall energy system for 0.02 €/kWh. 3.2. Applied technologies The main technologies applied for the Nigerian energy system modelling can be divided into four main categories: •Electricity generation technologies •Electrical energy storage technologies •Electricity transmission technologies •Energy sector bridging technologies to provide more flexibility to the energy system Fig. 8 shows the block diagram of the energy model and all applied technologies for the transition. The RE generation technologies intro Fig. 8. Block diagram of the LUT Energy System Transition model used for Nigeria [22]. 6 UNCORRECTED PROOF A.S. Oyewo et al. Energy Conversion and Management xxx (2018) xxx-xxx duced in the model include various PV technologies (ground-mounted and rooftop solar PV systems), hydropower (run-of-river and reservoir based), biomass plants (solid biomass and biogas), wind onshore turbines, geothermal power plants, concentrating solar thermal power (CSP) and waste-to-energy power plants. While the fossil generation technologies are coal, oil, open cycle gas turbines (OCGT) and combined cycle gas turbines (CCGT), as well as nuclear power. Due to the variability of RE and to ensure a steady supply of electricity, the RE technologies are complemented by various storage technologies. These technologies include pumped hydro storage (PHS), Li-ion batteries assumed to serve residential and system storage, thermal energy storage (TES), adiabatic compressed air energy storage (A-CAES) [38] and power-to-gas (PtG) [39]. Energy sector bridging technologies such as gas from PtG process and seawater reverse osmosis (SWRO) desalination [34] provide more flexibility to the energy system. PtG includes synthetic natural gas (SNG): methanation, water electrolysis, gas storage, carbon dioxide (CO⁠2) direct air capture, and gas turbines (OCGT and CCGT). Due to the absence of hydrogen and CO⁠2 storage, PtG technologies operate in synchronisation. In addition, the model uses a 48-hour biogas buffer storage, and part of the biogas can be upgraded to biomethane and is introduced into the gas storage. 3.3. Country division The multi-node approach used in the model enables description of any desired configuration. Based on this approach, Nigeria is divided into six sub-regions, according to political zoning of the country, namely, North-East (NIG-NE), North-West (NIG-NW), North-Central (NIG-NC), South-East (NIG-SE), South-South (NIG-SS) and South-West (NIG-SW). Each of the sub-regions represents a node. The nodes are interconnected via transmission lines, within the country borders, as shown in Fig. 9. 3.4. Financial and technical assumptions The financial and technical assumptions for all the energy system components are made in 5-year time steps, which include capital expenditures (CAPEX), operational expenditures (OPEX) and lifetimes, from 2015 to 2050, and are provided in the Supplementary Material (Table S1). Weighted average cost of capital (WACC) is set to 7% in this study, but for residential PV prosumers, WACC is set at 4% due to lower financial return requirements. The technical assumptions concerning storage technologies, efficiency numbers for generation, and power losses in HDVC power lines and converters, can be found in the Supplementary Material (Tables S2–S4). The electricity prices for residential, commercial and industrial consumers for the year 2015 were retrieved from electricity DISCOs tariff document available online at the Nigerian Electricity Regulatory Commission (NERC) website [40]. The electricity price was calculated until 2050 according to Gerlach et al. [41] and Breyer and Gerlach [42]. The electricity price for all sub-regions are available in the Supplementary Material (Table S5). The upper limits for all RE technologies were estimated according to Bogdanov and Breyer [20] and lower limits are obtained from Farfan and Breyer [35]. Upper and lower limits of RE and fossil fuels are provided in the Supplementary Material (Tables S6 and S7). For all other technologies, upper limits are not specified. However, for solid biomass residues, biogas and waste-to-energy plants it is assumed, due to energy efficiency reasons, that the available and specified amount of fuel is used during the year. Key power capacities required for the energy transition for Nigeria are provided in the Supplementary Material (Tables S8–S13). The current transmission line capacities connecting the sub-re- gions within the country were taken from [43]. The existing power grid, its development, and overall impact on electricity transmission and distribution losses were taken into account in the study. Fig. 9. Nigeria sub-regions and transmission lines configuration. 7 UNCORRECTED PROOF A.S. Oyewo et al. Energy Conversion and Management xxx (2018) xxx-xxx 3.5. Renewable resource potential The feed-in profiles for PV optimally tilted, PV single-axis tracking, wind energy and CSP are calculated according to Bogdanov and Breyer [20] and Afanasyeva et al. [33], based on resource data provided by NASA [30,31], reprocessed by the German Aerospace Center [32]. The feed-in values for hydropower are computed based on monthly resolved precipitation data for the year 2005 as a normalized sum of precipitation in the sub-regions. Such an estimate leads to a good approximation for the annual generation of hydro power plants [44]. Full load hourly data of various resources are presented in the Supplementary Material (Tables S14–S19). The resource profiles visualised in an hourly resolution can be found in the Supplementary Material (Figs. S1 and S2). In addition, the storage throughput is available in the Supplementary Material (Tables S20–S25). The potentials for waste and biomass resources for Nigeria are taken from German Biomass Research Centre [45] and classified according to Bogdanov and Breyer [20]. The costs for biomass are calculated using data from the IEA [46] and Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) [47]. For solid waste, a 50 €/ton gate fee was assumed for 2015, which increased up to 100 €/ton in 2050. The geothermal potentials are calculated for the sub-regions based on the available information related to heat flow rate [48] and ambient temperature of the surface for the year 2005 [49]. For the sub-re- gions where the heat flow data were not available, extrapolation was performed to get the required data. The potential is estimated based on the available data [50], different temperature levels [51] and available heat at the mid-point of a 1km thick deep layer and between the depths of 1–10km globally with 0.45°×0.45° spatial resolution [52]. 3.6. Demand Electricity demand data are taken from [11], and are verified with data provided in [12]. The electricity demand until 2050 is provided in the Supplementary Material (Table S5). The hourly load profiles for electricity are calculated as a fraction of the total demand in each sub-region based on synthetic load data weighted by the sub-regions population [53]. For seawater desalination, SWRO is mainly used in this study due to its low-cost and energy efficiency advantages from 2020 onwards [54]. Nonetheless, multiple effect distillation (MED) dominates in the start of the transition and complements from 2020 onwards. The required desalination capacity, technical constraints and financial assumptions from 2015 to 2050 are calculated by using the methodology described in [54]. The non-energetic industrial gas demand data are taken from IEA statistics website [55] and extrapolated until the year 2050 based on IEA’s assumption for non-energy gas demand growth rate for Nigeria [6]. 3.7. Scenarios In this study six scenarios have been developed, which are briefly described in Table 1. The scenarios explore pathways to a 100% RE system in the mid-term future, covering the demands of the power, non-en- ergetic industrial gas and desalination sectors. 4. Results This section presents the findings of the modelling outcomes for the Nigerian energy transition pathways in the mid-term future. Financial implication of the energy transition, installed capacities, electricity generation mix, transmission and storage are analysed in this section. Order of the figures in the entire paper are as follows: Figure (a) is assigned to BPS-1, Figure (b) to BPS-2, Figure (c) to BPS-3, Figure (d) to CPS-1, Figure (e) to CPS-2, and Figure (f) to CPS-3. Table 1 Overview of the studied scenarios. Scenario name Description Best Policy Scenario (BPS-1) – Power only scenario The target of the LUT model is to reach 100% RE by 2050. In addition, GHG emission cost is applied in the model to restrict fossil power plants. In this scenario, only electricity demand is covered Best Policy Scenario (BPS-2) – Power only scenario (planned hydropower capacity considered) This scenario is the same as the above scenario. In addition, the planned hydropower capacity is also considered. For instance, Zungeru hydropower project of 0.7 GW and Mambilla project of 3.0 GW are to be installed in 2020 and 2025 [56], respectively, during the transition and according to the respective planning [12] Best Policy Scenario (BPS-3) – Integrated scenario In this scenario, power, SWRO desalination and non-energetic industrial gas sectors demand is covered Best Policy scenarios without GHG emission cost (BPSnoCC) In these scenarios, GHG emission cost is not considered for the Best Policy Scenario 1 and 2. The financial implication, installed capacities and generation for Best Policy Scenario 1 no GHG emission cost (BPS-1noCC) and Best Policy Scenario 2 no GHG emission cost (BPS-2noCC) are only discussed in Section 4.9 Current Policy Scenario (CPS-1) In this scenario, the country’s target relating to electricity capacity mix up to 2030 is considered according to [12]. However, the post-2030 capacity mix is extrapolated up to 2050. Current Policy Scenario (CPS-2) –no GHG emission cost This scenario is the same as the previous described scenario, except that in this scenario GHG emission cost is not considered in the modelling Current Policy Scenario (CPS-3) After 2030, no new fossil power plants are allowed except nuclear power plants, because the country aims at reaching 4.8 GW installed capacity of nuclear by 2035 4.1. Levelised cost of electricity The LCOE obtained for all the scenarios are shown in Fig. 10. The average financial results for the scenarios are expressed as LCOE, which includes all generation, storage, curtailment, transmission, fuel and GHG emission costs. The LCOE trend from now until 2050 varies for the different scenarios. Firstly, the system LCOE trend during the transition for the Best Policy Scenarios is observed as shown in Fig. 10(a)–(c). In the BPS-1 and BPS-2, the LCOE increased slightly around 2025, beyond 2025 the system LCOE further declines to 48 €/MWh and 46 €/MWh by 2050, respectively. However, the LCOE remains stable until 2030 and further declines to 34 €/MWh by 2050 in the BPS-3. The increase observed in the LCOE trend in the Best Policy Scenarios, particularly in BPS-1 and BPS-2, around 2025 are due to investment requirements. From 2030 onwards, the system LCOE steadily declines, signifying the impact of low-cost RE technologies, in particular solar PV and battery technologies in the Best Policy Scenarios. By 2050, the system LCOE is mainly dominated by cost of generation and storage, as solar PV contributes to the largest share of electricity generation and its complementarity by battery storage. Fig. 10(d)–(f) presents the corresponding LCOE for the Current Policy Scenarios. Fuel and GHG emission costs contribute to more than half of the total LCOE by 2050 in the Current Policy Scenarios, except in CPS-2 because GHG emission cost was not taken into account. This also led to LCOE deviation in 2015 for the CPS-2 in comparison to other scenarios. By 2050, the LCOE is 120 €/MWh, 75 €/MWh and 100 €/MWh in CPS-1, CPS-2 and CPS-3, respectively, as shown in Fig. 10(d)–(f). Additional financial results for all the scenarios are available in the Supplementary Material (Figs. S3–S5). 8 UNCORRECTED PROOF A.S. Oyewo et al. Energy Conversion and Management xxx (2018) xxx-xxx Fig. 20. Total gas demand (left) and gas input by source (right) from 2015 until 2050. Fig. 21. Hourly resolution of state of charge of gas storage and production of methanation units in 2050. Fig. 22. Electricity generation and demand profile in full hourly resolution for the Best Policy Scenario 1 for the NIG-NE in 2050. are discharged during the night hours as shown in Fig. 22. Fig. 23 presents the hourly generation profile in NIG-SW during a week in the rainy season. During this week the role of gas turbines is observed in providing flexibility to the power system due to low generation from RE. However, PV prosumers, electricity imports and battery discharge during night hours have a substantial influence in this sub-region. Fig. 24 shows the energy flow in the Best Policy Scenario 3 (Integrated scenario). It shows the RE generators, storage technologies, transmission grids, total electricity demand for each sector and system losses. The potential usable heat and system losses include the difference between the electricity generation and final electricity demand. Both includes curtailed electricity, the heat released from biomass, biogas and waste-to-energy power plants, charge and discharge from storage technologies, electrolysers and methanation processes. Solar PV meets additional demand due to sector coupling in the Integrated scenario. 4.9. Comparison of key differences in all scenarios by 2050 This section presents key differences in all scenarios examined by 2050 as presented in Table 2. The total annualised cost of system trajectory from 2015 to 2050 is shown in Fig. 25. The modelled financial outcomes reveal that a fully decarbonised energy system is the least cost option for Nigeria. The total annualised cost of system for all Current Policy Scenarios are higher than in the Best Policy Scenarios, except in the BPS-3 due to sector coupling. The average total annualised cost of system in all Current Policy Scenarios are 42% higher than in Best Policy Scenarios. The total annualised cost of system ranges from 15 UNCORRECTED PROOF A.S. Oyewo et al. Energy Conversion and Management xxx (2018) xxx-xxx Fig. 23. Electricity generation and demand profile in full hourly resolution for the Best Policy scenario 1 for the NIG-SW in 2050. Fig. 24. Energy flow of the system for the Integrated scenario in 2050. Table 2 Difference in key parameters and financial outcomes in 2050 for all scenarios. BPS-1 BPS-2 BPS-3 BPS-1noCC BPS-2noCC CPS-1 CPS-2 CPS-3 Financial outcome Total annualised cost of system [b€] 16.6 15.8 27.2 16.2 15.5 42.2 26.4 35.0 LCOE [€/MWh⁠el] 48 46 35 47 45 120 76 100 Electricity parameter Demand [TWh⁠el] 347 347 637 347 347 347 347 347 Generation [TWh⁠el] 398 396 697 395 383 353 353 353 Installed capacity [GW] 198 194 351 192 190 68 64 95 15 to 42 b€in all the scenarios. The LCOE obtained in the Current Policy Scenarios are higher than in the Best Policy Scenarios. The LCOE is found to be in the range of 34.5–120.4 €/MWh. The capacity requirements are higher in the Best Policy Scenarios than in the Current Policy Scenarios. This is due to lower FLH of solar PV that dominates the overall capacities in Best Policy Scenarios, while the Current Policy Scenarios are dominated by thermal generators that run on higher FLH. On average, capacity requirements in all Best Policy Scenarios are about 70% higher than in the Current Policy Scenarios. Higher genera tion is observed in the Best Policy Scenarios than in the Current Policy Scenarios. Furthermore, the Best Policy Scenario 1 no GHG emission cost (BPS-1noCC) and the Best Policy Scenario 2 no GHG emission cost (BPS-2noCC) are examined in this research. The Best Policy Scenario no GHG emission cost modelling outcome reveals that a RE-based energy system would yet be more competitive in the mid-term future in Nigeria. By 2050, RE electricity generation reaches 97.8% of total electricity generation in BPS-1noCC and BPS-2noCC. In both scenarios as 16 UNCORRECTED PROOF A.S. Oyewo et al. Energy Conversion and Management xxx (2018) xxx-xxx Fig. 25. Comparison of total annualised cost of system for all scenarios in 2050. GHG emission cost is not applied, natural gas is allowed to be used in gas turbines. However, the RE installed capacities slightly drop in both scenarios, due to increased FLH of gas turbines. The total annualised cost of system and LCOE decrease slightly in BPS-1noCC and BPS-2noCC as GHG emission cost is assumed to be zero throughout the transition for both scenarios as shown in Table 2. Additional information on these scenarios are available in the Supplementary Material (Tables S11–S12, S22–S23, S30–S32 and Figs. S16–S19). 5. Discussion This study presents pathways of transitioning to a zero GHG emission energy system for Nigeria under the defined scenarios. The key objectives of this research is to show that a fully sustainable energy system is technically and economically feasible and the respective financial consequences in comparison to a fossil-based power system. Such an energy system can be achieved with abundant RE resource availability in the country, enabled by strong political support for renewable energy development. A 100% RE-based energy system is achievable in Nigeria. This study is the first of its kind to be conducted for Nigeria. The LCOE values obtained in this study indicate that cost of electricity could decrease from 54 €/MWh in 2015 to 46 €/MWh in BPS-1, 48 €/MWh in BPS-2 and 35 €/MWh in BPS-3 by 2050. Whereas in the Current Policy Scenarios, the LCOE increased from 54 €/MWh in 2015 to 120 €/MWh in CPS-1, and 100 €/MWh in CPS-3 by 2050. However, the LCOE obtained by the no GHG emission cost scenarios declined from 51 €/MWh in 2015 to 47 €/MWh in BPS-1noCC, 45 €/MWh in BPS-2noCC and 76 €/MWh in CPS-2 by 2050. Results obtained in the fully renewable end-point scenarios for Nigeria in terms of LCOE are comparable to the global average LCOE obtained using the LUT model, which shows a range of about 50–70 €/MWh [22]. The decreasing costs of RE technologies expected during the transition, particularly solar PV, contributes to the decreasing cost of electricity over the transition in the Best Policy Scenarios. In addition, sector coupling of seawater desalination, non-energetic industrial gas and electricity demand results in a further reduction in LCOE by 22% in 2050 as observed in BPS-3. Sector coupling provides additional flexibility to the power system. In addition, a higher share of low-cost generation leads to the LCOE reduction. The additional demand required due to sector coupling is mainly satisfied by installation of low-cost solar PV. PtG technology enables the coverage of gas demand for the integrated scenario (BPS-3) creating additional electricity demand of 290 TWh⁠el in the year 2050, which results in increased generation capacity. The outstanding role of PV technologies and batteries needs to be highlighted in the fully renewable end-point scenarios in Nigeria. By 2050, PV single-axis tracking dominates the system in the Best Policy Scenarios. While the rest of the PV capacity is met by PV prosumers. Prosumers contribute 22% of total generated PV electricity in 2050. PV-battery prosumers will reduce dependency on the centralised system in the nearest future in Nigeria according to the results of this research. In comparison to the Current Policy Scenarios, PV capacity range from 11 GW to 52 GW in 2050, the highest share of PV installed capacity is observed in the CPS-3. By 2050, PV technologies generate 364 TWh (93% of total generation), 350 TWh (89%) and 667 TWh (96%) in BPS-1, BPS-2 and BPS-3, respectively. The increased generation in BPS-3 is due to demand of three energy sectors. Whereas in the Current Policy Scenarios, PV generation ranged from 22 TWh to 112 TWh, accounting for 6–32% of the total electricity generation in 2050. The highest installed PV capacities were found in the northern sub-regions in particular the NIG-NW and NIG-NE, due to excellent solar resource conditions in the north of Nigeria and respective low cost of PV technology. In addition to the foregoing analysis, solar PV technology will play a major role in the Nigeria future power system, based on the results of this research and from resource point of view as discussed in [58]. Most studies on future energy systems in Nigeria have attempted to analyse renewables potential in meeting the growing electricity demand of the country [8], but did not investigate what this may mean in concrete power generation mix options. Brimmo et al. [59] provided an in-depth review on wind, hydropower, geothermal and nuclear energy options in Nigeria. Solar energy resource current application and the extent of utilisation is presented in [58], while Akuru et al. [7] based on literature, modeled scenarios and field experience conclude that 100% RE in Nigeria could be driven by individuals rather than sole dependence on government actions. The rest of the generation is supplied by wind energy, hydropower, geothermal and biomass in the 100% RE-based scenarios considered in this research. In the BPS-2, hydropower projects under construction such as Mambilla hydropower project in Taraba State and Zungeru hydropower project in Niger State were considered. Hydropower has been a major part of the Nigerian power fleet. The Government of Nigeria also plans to build more hydropower capacity in the nearest future. Increased hydropower capacity is one marked feature of the BPS-2. However, dispatchable hydropower contributes to lower storage needed in BPS-2. By 2050, hydropower capacity is 1.7 GW in BPS-1 and BPS-3, while it reaches 5.3 GW in BPS-2. The hydropower installed capacity is 12.1 GW each in CPS-1 and CPS-2, while installed capacity reaches 5.9 GW in CPS-3 in 2050. According to IEA New Policy Scenario, hydropower capacity is expected to increase from 2 GW (11%) in 2012 to 15 GW (19%) in 2040 [6]. The high share of hydropower in BPS-2 results in lower LCOE and storage requirement, as hydro reservoirs serves as virtual storage [60]. One of the main constraints of hydropower development is cost overruns and schedule spills [14], especially large hydropower projects [15]. According to [16], 61 hydropower dams were analysed representing 114 GW and 271.5 bUSD worth of investment experienced a mean cost overrun of 231 bUSD [16]. These projects exhibited a mean cost overrun of 70% [16]. Another study reports an average 96% cost overrun on hydropower development, where the authors report that the cost overruns figures exclude inflation, debt, environmental cost and social cost [61]. The specific capacity density derived in the LUT Energy System model is 75MW/km⁠2 for optimally tilted PV and 8.4MW/km⁠2 for onshore wind in [20]. Hence, the total area of land required in Nigeria for solar PV and wind capacities in 2050 is 2409km⁠2 (0.3% of total land area) and 361km⁠2 (0.04%) for BPS-1, 2317km⁠2 (0.3%) and 53km⁠2 (0.01%) for BPS-2, and 4369km⁠2 (0.5%) and 209km⁠2 (0.02%) for BPS-3. The land area requirement for achieving a 100% RE system should be no limiting factor, according to the results of this research. Furthermore, there are plans underway in Nigeria to build new thermal power plants [19], mainly nuclear and coal power plants [12]. The Current Policy Scenarios are mainly dominated by thermal plants, which include gas turbines, nuclear and coal power plants. In 2017, the Nigerian government signed a multi-billion dollar contract with 17 UNCORRECTED PROOF A.S. Oyewo et al. Energy Conversion and Management xxx (2018) xxx-xxx Rosatom, a Russian nuclear company to build four nuclear plants in Akwa Ibom and Kogi State to contribute 4.8 GW to Nigerian electricity by the year 2035 [62]. In 2000, Rosatom estimated cost to build two new pressurised water reactors of the VVER series at the Leningrad nuclear power plant 2 at 1.74 b€for 2.17 GW. By 2011, Rosatom set price for this type of project was estimated at 3.73 b€, more than twice the original price [63]. The cost of Olkiluoto 3, Finland, which was planned to begin operation in 2009, have increased from 3.2 b€to 8.5 b€for 1.6 GW, and stand the risk of further cost increase [64]. Countries like Nigeria should be aware of binding nuclear contracts, similar to the contract signed in 2014 by the Hungarian government with Rosatom, incurred financial burden is always borne by the foreign government. Rosatom nuclear construction projects within Russia and other countries have not been characterised by delays and cost overruns, but also by lack of proper quality control and safety concerns [63]. Sovacool et al. [16] analysed 401 power plant projects in 57 countries, thereof 180 nuclear reactors representing 177 GW. These reactors had a mean cost overrun of 117%, and more than 9 in 10 projects suffered from cost escalation [16]. In addition, nuclear energy violates all sustainability criteria that should form a framework for a resilient energy system design discussed in [13]. Various risks are associated with nuclear energy [65], which includes environmental and health risks as witnessed in Fukushima and Chernobyl, irreparable impact on ecosystem resulting from genetic mutation plants and animals, and risk of nuclear weapons proliferation and potential terrorist attacks on nuclear facilities [13]. The Current Policy Scenarios are observed to be expensive due to high capital costs of thermal plants in particular nuclear. According to [66], the LCOE median values ranged from 79 to 112 €MWh, and LCOE including external and GHG emission cost ranged from 87 to 120 €/MWh [67]. Rather than building new nuclear and coal power plants in Nigeria, gas turbines (OCGT and CCGT) could be an option alongside with new investments in RE technologies in particular solar PV. In all the scenarios, gas power plants emerge as the dominant thermal power plant, particularly in the Current Policy Scenarios. The result obtained in the Current Policy Scenarios, is comparable to the findings of the IEA New Policy Scenario, which reports gas-fired generation will form the core of the Nigerian future power sector [6]. According to IEA [6], gas power plant capacity may be 37 GW (48%) and coal may be 8 GW (10%) by 2040. Similarly, according to the IRENA Renewable Promotion scenario about 55% electricity generation is supplied by gas power plant, hydropower supply is about 35% and remaining share is supplied by imports for the year 2030 [68]. In the Best Policy Scenarios, gas power plants are used as a very valuable and flexible balancing technology on different time scales, from days to weeks. Gas turbines can be installed after 2015, because of lower GHG emissions and the possibility to substitute the fossil natural gas with SNG or biomethane. Storage technologies play a vital role in this study, particularly in the Best Policy Scenarios due to high shares of RE resources. Solar PV dominated power grids are usually characterised by high storage requirements [69]. In this research, high penetration RE source, in particular solar PV, is complemented by battery storage due to daily requirement. The PV-battery hybrid system emerges to become the least cost solution in a 100% RE-based powers system by 2050. In addition, the cost of batteries declined by 80% in the past 6years [70], further cost reduction is expected [71], policies designed to strengthen market growth and innovation in battery storage can drive the future cost reduction [72]. The continued cost decline of PV-battery systems [22] combined with excellent solar resources in Nigeria are the key drivers for a high share of PV in all the Best Policy Scenarios. By 2050, battery storage output in the Best Policy Scenarios ranged from 157 TWh to 166 TWh and from 13 TWh to 42 TWh in the Current Policy Scenarios. The plausible reason for low storage output and requirement in the Current Policy Scenarios is due to higher share of dispatchable hydropower and thermal power plants. Additional battery storage de mand of 106 GWh is projected in 2050 because of higher PV prosumers installed capacity. The battery prosumers output increased from 0.2 TWh in 2025 to 32.1 TWh in 2050. In terms of storage capacity, gas storage dominates in the Best Policy Scenarios, while battery storage dominates in the Current Policy Scenarios, followed by TES. The technology requirement in the Best Policy Scenarios are higher than in the Current Policy Scenarios, due to lower FLH of RE in particular solar PV and strict constraints on fossil fuel. The high gas storage capacity is required for PtG and gas turbines, as fossil natural gas is replaced by SNG. According to Fasihi et al. [73], RE-based synthetic fuels are a real option for decarbonising the power system for the year 2030 and beyond. The role of power grids becomes prominent from 2020 onwards, and utilisation increases with penetration of RE shares in the power system, particularly in the Best Policy Scenarios. The grid interconnection enhances the shifting of energy from exporting sub-regions with high renewable resource potentials to the importing sub-regions. According to the results of this study, transmission grids are vital in reaching a fully sustainable power system in Nigeria by 2050. Brown et al. [21] show that sector coupling, together with electricity transmission networks, can reduce the total system costs by up to 37% compared to a system with none of these flexibility options. However, a mix of several flexibility options such as long- and short-term energy storage, district heating and synthetic fuels are found to be more beneficial than power transmission alone. Investments in grid expansion are vital to the development of the Nigerian power system. According to the IEA New Policy Scenario, the rate of electricity access is expected to increase from 45% in 2012 to around 85% in 2040 through grid extension due to high population density and widespread network coverage in the country [6]. However, grid extension is often a time-consuming process, which might leave many people without electricity for a long period [74]. The grid extension approach has not contributed significantly to an eradication of energy poverty in many SSA countries, including Nigeria [75]. Thus, off-grid solutions based on RE technology, particularly solar PV based technologies (solar home systems (SHS) and mini-grids), provide solutions in areas where grid extension is not cost-effective [76]. According to Bertheau et al. [77], two scenarios were modelled to understand the effects on future grid extension plans in SSA. Results of the modelling reveals that about 96 million Nigerians are un-electrified. In the first scenario based on the existing grid, 22.1 million people (23%), 38.5 million people (40%) and 35.6 million people (37%) can be electrified by mini-grids, grid extension and solar home systems, respectively. The second scenario, in which modelling was based on the planned grid, 17.3 million people (18%), 51 million people (53%) and 27.9 million people (29%) can be electrified by mini-grids, grid extension and SHSs, respectively [77]. Furthermore, SHS can serve as short-term solution until grid connection can be achieved or economic power makes the establishment of mini-grid feasible [78]. Accelerating electrification access requires in depth spatial and techno-economic analysis in identifying least cost and optimal electrification mix options in rural areas [79]. Ouedraogo [80] highlights that the electrification rate in SSA has to be increased 40-fold from today’s electrification level to decrease the electricity poverty in the continent. This can be achieved by an increase of new RE-based power generation capacity and off-grid systems. Furthermore, the water sector is fundamental to the country’s development, and the government of Nigeria has made provision for water and basic sanitation the responsibility of the Federal Ministry of Water Resources (FMWR) [81]. Water availability varies across the country. According to [81], Nigeria North-West and North-East are the main regions with water scarcity. In the aforementioned regions, political and economic problems hinder water services. The Nigerian government is committed to providing water coverage to 9 million people yearly beginning from 2016 until 2030. The estimated investment requirement is 378m€/year, based on United Nation (UN) connection 18 UNCORRECTED PROOF A.S. Oyewo et al. Energy Conversion and Management xxx (2018) xxx-xxx price of 42 €/person to the water network. The nominal tariff charged by the State Water Agency (SWA) ranged from 1.26 to 1.68 €per family per month. Water supply from alternative providers ranges from 5.0 to 6.7 €/m⁠3 in the North, while prices range from 1.7 to 3.4 €/m⁠3 in the South [81]. According to the results of this research, LCOW declines from 0.66 €/m⁠3 in 2015 to 0.56 €/m⁠3 in 2050. The capex required in 2050 to meet the Nigerian water demand is 14.7m€, whereas the annual opex fixed and variable is 1.1m€and 1.8m€, respectively. The results obtained are comparable to the findings of Barasa et al. [5] for the SSA region based on overnight approach for the year 2030, which conclude that SSA countries will be powered mainly by solar PV and complemented by wind energy. In addition, the LCOE obtained in the Best Policy Scenarios are comparable to the LCOE obtained in [5]. Examining the application of a carbon price during the transition, particularly in the Best Policy Scenarios, led to a rapid transition and fast GHG emissions reduction in comparison to no GHG emission cost scenarios. However, the no GHG emission cost scenarios achieved comparable results in terms of capacity, generation, costs of electricity and GHG emission trajectory to the Best Policy Scenarios. By 2050, the RE electricity generation reaches 97.8% in the no GHG emission cost scenarios, with about 2% energy supplied by fossil gas. This indicates that Nigeria’s energy transition is achievable without GHG emission cost implementation. The results of this research is fully in line with the recent agreement of several African cities, such as Lagos in Nigeria, Cape Town and Johannesburg in South Africa and Accra in Ghana, to cut carbon emissions to zero until 2050 [82]. An energy system optimisation analysis for the University of Ilorin in Nigeria under several configurations show that a hybrid PV-Diesel-Battery system is the best solution to reduce the GHG emissions cost significantly, while the system costs are also the lowest compared to other configurations [83]. However, the capital cost of solar PV assumed is much higher than the current cost in Nigeria [84]. If the actual cost of solar PV was considered, it is likely that hybrid PV-Battery systems will offer the least cost, while wind energy can also complement. Akuru et al. [7] conclude that 100% RE is possible in Nigeria with the country’s abundant RE resources, but that the right government backing is lacking. Though the role of the government cannot be compromised, individuals could drive the transition to 100% RE in Nigeria by installing RE systems in mega cities like Lagos, Abuja or Port Harcourt [7]. 6. Conclusion and policy implications Transition to a carbon-neutral energy system in Nigeria will require a strong political commitment at all levels of governance. Beyond technical feasibility and economic viability of an energy transition towards a zero GHG emission system, it encompasses long-term and well-de- signed policy interventions. A concerted and consistent policy action that would restrict new investments in fossil power plants, and facilitate RE development in a long-term perspective is exigent for the transition in Nigeria. This research offers key insights to energy system planners and policymakers in Nigeria, and demonstrates the need for a detailed analysis in determining knowledge gaps in transition pathway options under various policy constraints for developing countries of comparable climates. The results of this research demonstrate that a decarbonised energy system is quite competitive in all Best Policy Scenarios in comparison to the Current Policy Scenarios. The high competitiveness is based on an increasing share of RE technologies, particularly the high cost competitiveness of solar PV and supporting batteries. Solar PV dominates all the Best Policy Scenarios by 2050, where PV single-axis tracking contributes the most (63–83%) to the total PV installed capacities followed by PV prosumers. The high shares of PV in the Best Policy Scenarios are reflected in an increase in battery storage utilisation. The combination of solar PV and battery storage was found to be very beneficial for the power system. The need for electricity storage in the energy system is a key characteristic for high penetration levels of VRE. Short-term (Li-ion), medium-term (TES), and long-term (gas storage) storage are required to balance daily, weekly and seasonal variability of RE. Furthermore, energy storage provides flexibility to the energy system by enabling demand balancing. Grid interconnection within the country allows shifting of electricity from one point in time to another, enabling large-scale generation and demand balancing between the different sub-regions. Moreover, gas turbines provide additional flexibility to the power system, where fossil gas is substituted with SNG or biomethane from 2015 onwards in the Best Policy Scenarios. The produced gas can be either used in the power sector to balance the system when it is needed, or stored in gas storage to meet the demand of non-energetic industrial gas sector. Energy policy in Nigeria should place solar PV at its core. The current perspective of RE utilisation, possible motivation for RE development, barriers and challenges in Nigeria require deliberate actions and strong political will. From a policy perspective, this research identifies investment requirements, timing and operations across Nigeria. Such information are relevant for policy makers and energy planners in Nigeria for setting energy investment targets. During the transition, solar PV and batteries emerge as the most important technologies, complemented by wind energy and existing hydropower. In addition, gas turbines provide flexibility to the power system. A 100% RE-based system is reachable and is the real policy option for Nigeria. RE resources can meet the electricity demand of the power, seawater desalination and non-energetic industrial gas sectors. Furthermore, based on all scenarios examined in this study, the Best Policy Scenarios present the least cost electricity pathways for Nigeria in comparison with the Current Policy Scenarios. The LCOE ranges from 34 to 48 €/MWh for the Best Policy Scenarios, whereas the LCOE for the Current Policy Scenarios lie between 75 and 120 €/MWh. The Current Policy Scenarios clearly demonstrate the need for a cleaner energy system, as a fossil dominated system violates all sustainability criteria. New investments in nuclear power plants in Nigeria are not competitive and show a high risk profile, leading to low social acceptance. Finally, a well designed RE roadmap, an attractive environment for local and foreign investors, electricity market reforms, research and development and other emissions abatement policies would be required to drive RE development in Nigeria. Innovative financing mechanisms advancing RE development elsewhere in the world can be adopted in Nigeria as well. Further research will be conducted, incorporating other energy sectors (e.g. transport and heat sector) for a wider analysis of the energy transition in Nigeria in the future. Acknowledgements The authors gratefully recognize the governmental financing of Tekes (Finnish Funding Agency for Innovation) for the ‘Neo-Carbon Energy’projects under the number 40101/14. Ayobami Solomon Oyewo would like to thank LUT Foundation for the valuable scholarship. Appendix A. Supplementary material Supplementary data to this article can be found online at https:// doi.org/10.1016/j.enconman.2018.10.036. References [1] [UNFCCC] –United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change. Adoption of the Paris Agreement –proposal by the president, UNFCCC, Paris; 2015. Available online: <http://unfccc.int/resource/docs/2015/cop21/eng/l09.pdf>. [2] G. Yun, G. Xiang, Z. Xiaohua, The 2 °C global temperature target and the evolution of the long-term goal of addressing climate change—from the united nations framework convention on climate change to the Paris agreement, Engineering 3 (2) (2017) 272–278. [3] Ramanathan V, Molina MJ, Zaelke D, Borgford-Parnell N, Alex K, Auffhammer M, et al. Under 2 degrees celsius: fast action policies to protect people and the planet 19 UNCORRECTED PROOF A.S. Oyewo et al. Energy Conversion and Management xxx (2018) xxx-xxx from extreme climate changes, presented at COP22 Summit, Marrakech. First report of the committee to prevent extreme climate change (CPECC), Washington, DC; 2016. Available online: <https://bit.ly/2ws6iC8> [accessed on 27 December 2017]. [4] C. Arndt, D. Arent, Special section of applied energy: energy and climate change in sub-Saharan Africa, Appl Energy 161 (2016) 553–555. [5] M. Barasa, D. Bogdanov, A.S. Oyewo, Ch. Breyer, A cost optimal resolution for Sub-Saharan Africa powered by 100% renewables in 2030, Renew Sustain Energy Rev 92 (2018) 440–457. [6] [IEA] –International Energy Agency. Africa energy outlook. A focus on the energy prospects in sub-Saharan Africa, Paris; 2014. Available online: <www.iea.org/ publications/freepublications/publication/WEO2014_AfricaEnergyOutlook.pdf> [accessed on 20 January 2016]. [7] U.B. Akuru, I.E. Onukwube, O.I. Okoro, E.S. Obe, Towards 100% renewable energy in Nigeria, Renew Sustain Energy Rev 71 (2017) 943–953. [8] S.O. Oyedepo, Towards achieving energy for sustainable development in Nigeria, Renew Sustain Energy Rev 34 (2014) 255–272. [9] [NESI] –Nigerian Electricity Supply Industry. Nigeria power baseline report, Abuja; 2015. Available online: <http://mypower.ng/wp-content/uploads/2018/ 01/Baseline-Report.pdf> [accessed on 5 May 2018]. [10] Oyewo AS, Aghahosseini A, Breyer Ch. Assessment of energy storage technologies in transition to a 100% renewable energy system for Nigeria. 11th International renewable energy storage conference (IRES 2017), Düsseldorf, March 14–16; 2017. Available online: <https://goo.gl/i92QRL>. [11] [GIZ] –Deutsche Gesellschaft für Internationale Zusammenarbeit. The Nigerian Energy Sector: an overview with a special emphasis on renewable energy, energy efficiency and rural electrification, Frankfurt; 2015. Available online: <www.giz. de/en/downloads/giz2015-en-nigerian-energy-sector.pdf>. [12] [SE4ALL] –Sustainable Energy for All. Action Agenda for Nigeria. SE4ALL, Abuja; 2016. Available online: <http://www.se4all.org/sites/default/files/NIGERIA_ SE4ALL_ACTION_AGENDA_FINAL.pdf> [accessed on 18 December 2017]. [13] M. Child, O. Koskinen, L. Linnanen, Ch. Breyer, Sustainability guardrails for energy scenarios of the global energy transition, Renew Sustain Energy Rev 91 (2018) 321–334. [14] B.K. Sovacool, A. Gilberta, D. Nugent, An international comparative assessment of construction cost overruns for electricity infrastructure, Energy Res Social Sci 3 (2014) 152–160. [15] B.K. Sovacool, A. Gilberta, D. Nugent, Risk, innovation, electricity infrastructure and construction cost overruns: testing six hypotheses, Energy 74 (2014) 906–917. [16] B.K. Sovacool, D. Nugent, A. Gilberta, Construction Cost overruns and electricity infrastructure: an unavoidable risk?, Electr J 27 (4) (2014) 112–120. [17] [IRENA] –International Renewable Energy Agency. Renewable power generation costs in 2017. Abu Dhabi; 2018. Available online: <http://www.irena.org// media/Files/IRENA/Agency/Publication/2018/Jan/IRENA_2017_Power_Costs_ 2018.pdf> [accessed on 24 March 2018]. [18] Department of Energy. Stakeholder consultation workshop: preparation of the second edition of the state of renewable energy in South Africa report market overview and current levels of renewable energy deployment, Pretoria; 2016. Available online: <http://www.energy.gov.za/files/ renewable-energy-status-report/ Market-Overview-and-Current-Levels-of-Renewable-Energy-Deployment-NERSA. pdf> [accessed on 1 January 2017]. [19] Heinrich Böll Stiftung. Comparison of costs of electricity generation in Nigeria. Abuja; 2017. <https://ng.boell.org/sites/default/files/true_cost_of_power_ technical_report_final.pdf> [accessed on 19 December 2017]. [20] D. Bogdanov, Ch. Breyer, North-East Asian Super Grid for 100% renewable energy supply: optimal mix of energy technologies for electricity, gas and heat supply options, Energy Convers Manage 112 (2016) 176–190. [21] Brown T, Schlachtberger D, Kies A, Schramm S, Greiner M. Synergies of sector coupling and transmission extension in a cost-optimised, highly renewable European energy system; 2018. Available online: <https://arxiv.org/abs/1801.05290>. [22] Ch. Breyer, D. Bogdanov, A. Aghahosseini, A. Gulagi, M. Child, A.S. Oyewo, et al., Solar photovoltaics demand for the global energy transition in the power sector, Prog Photovoltaics Res Appl (2017) https://doi.org/10.1002/pip.2950. [23] M.O. Oseni, An analysis of the power sector performance in Nigeria, Renew Sustain Energy Rev 15 (9) (2011) 4765–4774. [24] Y.S. Mohammed, M.W. Mustafa, N. Bashir, A.S. Mokhtar, Renewable energy resources for distributed power generation in Nigeria: a review of the potential, Renew Sustain Energy Rev 22 (2013) 257–268. [25] [UNCTAD] –United Nations conference on trade and development. Unlocking the potential of the power sector for industrialization and poverty alleviation in Nigeria. Washington DC; 2017 Available online: <http://unctad.org/en/ PublicationsLibrary/ser-rp-2017d6_en.pdf> [accessed 5 May 2018]. [26] KPMG. A guide to the Nigerian power sector. Nigeria; 2016. Available online: <https://assets.kpmg.com/content/dam/kpmg/ng/pdf/tax/ a-guide-to-nigerian-power-sector.pdf> [accessed on 20/12/2017]. [27] Cervigni R, Rogers JA, Dvorak I. Assessing low-carbon development in Nigeria: an analysis of four sectors. World Bank Study. Washington, DC: World Bank; 2013. Available online: <http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/ 333931468332952975/ Assessing-low-carbon-development-in-Nigeria-an-analysis-of-four-sectors> [accessed 17 September 2017]. [28] [NESISTATS] –Nigerian Electricity Supply Industry Statistics. Abuja; 2018. Available online: <http://mypower.ng/> [accessed 1 April 2018]. [29] Zarma IH, Ahmed AS, Ahmed T, Sambo AS, Yusuf G. Embracing new frontiers –investment opportunities in Nigerian power sector. 35th National Solar Energy Forum (NASEF), Abuja, November 13–16; 2017. Available online: <https://goo.gl/ fBNZJj>. [30] Stackhouse PW, Whitlock CH, editors. Surface meteorology and solar energy (SSE) release 6.0, NASA SSE 6.0, earth science enterprise program. National Aeronautic and Space Administration (NASA), Langley; 2008. <http://eosweb.larc.nasa.gov/ sse/> [accessed 18 June 2018]. [31] Stackhouse PW, Whitlock CH, editors. Surface meteorology and solar energy (SSE) release 6.0 Methodology, NASA SSE 6.0, earth science enterprise program. National Aeronautic and Space Administration (NASA), Langley; 2009. <http:// eosweb.larc.nasa.gov/sse/documents/SSE6Methodology.pdf> [accessed 18 June 2018]. [32] D. Stetter, Enhancement of the REMix energy system model: global renewable energy potentials optimized power plant siting and scenario validation, Dissertation, faculty of energy-, process and bio-engineering, University of Stuttgart, 2012. [33] S. Afanasyeva, D. Bogdanov, Ch. Breyer, Relevance of PV with single-axis tracking for energy scenarios, Sol Energy 173 (2018) 173–191. [34] U. Caldera, D. Bogdanov, S. Afanasyeva, Ch. Breyer, Integration of reverse osmosis seawater desalination in the power sector based on PV and wind energy, for the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, Water 10 (1) (2018) 3. [35] J. Farfan, Ch. Breyer, Structural changes of global power generation capacity towards sustainability and the risk of stranded investments supported by a sustainability indicator, J Cleaner Prod 141 (2017) 370–384. [36] The MathWorks, Inc. MATLAB R2016a, Massachusetts, United States; 2016. Available online: <http://allpcworld.com/matlab-free-download/> [accessed on 2 July 2017]. [37] Mosek ApS. MOSEK version 8, Copenhagen, Denmark; 2017. Available online: <https://www.mosek.com/downloads/> [accessed on 2 July 2017]. [38] A. Aghahosseini, Ch. Breyer, Assessment of geological resource potential for compressed air energy storage in global electricity supply, Energy Convers Manage 169 (2018) 161–173. [39] M. Götz, J. Lefebvre, F. Mörs, A.M. Koch, F. Graf, S. Bajohr, et al., Renewable Power-to-Gas: a technological and economic review, Renew Energy 85 (2016) 1371–1390. [40] [NERC] –Nigeria Electricity Regulatory Commission, Abuja. <http://www. nercng.org/index.php/media-library/public-notices/ 326-notice-of-commencement-of-myto-2015>. [41] Gerlach A, Breyer Ch, Werner C. Impact of financing cost on global grid-parity dynamics till 2030. 29th European photovoltaic solar energy conference, Amsterdam; September 22–26 2014. Available online: <https://goo.gl/dv75Py>. [42] Ch. Breyer, A. Gerlach, Global overview on grid-parity, Prog Photovoltaics Res Appl 21 (2013) 121–136. [43] [WAPP] –West African Power Pool. Update of the ECOWAS Revised Master Plan for the Generation and Transmission of Electrical Energy. WAPP. Cotonou; 2011. Available online: <http://www.ecowapp.org/sites/default/files/mp_wapp_ volume_1.pdf> [accessed on 05/01/2018]. [44] Verzano K. Climate change impacts on flood related hydrological processes: further development and application of a global scale hydrological model. Reports on Earth System Science, 71,Max‐Planck‐Institut für Meteorologie, Hamburg, Dissertation, Faculty of Electrical Engineering and Computer Science, University of Kassel; 2009. [45] [DBFZ] –Deutsches Biomasse Forschungs Zentrum. In: Thrän D, Bunzel K, Seyfert U, Zeller V, Müller K, Matzdorf B, Weimar H, editors. Endbericht Globale und regionale räumliche Verteilung von Biomassepotenzialen. 04347 Leipzig; 2010 [in German]. <http://literatur.ti.bund.de/digbib_extern/dn047244.pdf>. [46] [IEA] –International Energy Agency. Technology roadmap –bioenergy for heat and power. IEA Publications: Paris; 2012. [47] [IPCC] –Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Special report on RE sources and CC mitigation. Intergovernmental panel on climate change. Geneva; 2011. Available online: <www.ipcc.ch/pdf/specialreports/srren/SRREN_FD_SPM_final. pdf>. [48] [IASPEI] –International Association of Seismology and Physics of the Earth's Interior. The international heat flow commission, Colorado, USA. IHFC database; 2015. Available online: <www.heatflow.und.edu/index2.html>. [49] AAPG. Global Heat Flow Database. American Association of Petroleum Geologists. Tulsa, USA; 2015. Available online: <www.datapages.com/ gis-map-publishing-program/gis-open-files/global-framework/ global-heat-flow-database>. [50] C.R. Chamorro, J.L. García-Cuesta, M.E. Mondéjar, A. Pérez-Madrazo, An estimation of the enhanced geothermal systems potential for the Iberian Peninsula, Renew Energy 66 (2014) 1–14. [51] C.R. Chamorro, J.L. García-Cuesta, M.E. Mondéjar, A. Pérez-Madrazo, Enhanced geothermal systems in Europe: an estimation and comparison of the technical and sustainable potentials, Energy 65 (2014) 250–263. [52] Huenges E. Geothermal energy systems, exploration, development and utilization. 2nd ed. Weinheim, Germany; 2012. [53] Toktarova A, Gruber L, Hlusiak M, Bogdanov D, Breyer Ch. Long-term load forecasting in high resolution for all countries globally; 2018 [submitted for publication]. [54] U. Caldera, D. Bogdanov, Ch. Breyer, Local cost of seawater RO desalination based on solar PV and wind energy: a global estimate, Desalination 385 (2016) 207–216. [55] [IEA] –International Energy Agency. IEA Statistics, Paris. <http://www.iea.org/ statistics/statisticssearch/report/?country=NIGERIA&product=naturalgas& year=2015>. [56] Africa Energy. Power market intelligence for a challenging environment, Hastings. Available online: <https://www.africa-energy.com/live-data/about-live-data>. [57] A. Gulagi, D. Bogdanov, Ch. Breyer, The role of storage technologies in energy transition pathways towards achieving a fully sustainable energy system for India, J Energy Storage 17 (2018) 525–539. [58] O.S. Ohunakin, M.S. Adaramola, O.M. Oyewola, R.O. Fagbenle, Solar energy applications and development in Nigeria: drivers and barriers, Renew Sustain Energy Rev 32 (2014) 294–301. 20 UNCORRECTED PROOF A.S. Oyewo et al. Energy Conversion and Management xxx (2018) xxx-xxx [59] A.T. Brimmo, A. Sodiq, A. Sofela, I. Kolo, Sustainable energy development in Nigeria: wind, hydropower, geothermal and nuclear (Vol. 1), Renew Sustain Energy Rev 74 (2017) 474–490. [60] Farfan J, Breyer Ch. Combining floating solar photovoltaic power plants and hydropower reservoirs: a virtual battery of great global potential. 12th International renewable energy storage conference (IRES 2017); 13–15, 2018, Düsseldorf. Available online: <https://bit.ly/2t98idr>. [61] A. Ansar, B. Flyvbjerg, A. Budzier, D. Lunn, Should we build more large dams? The actual costs of hydropower megaproject development, Energy Pol 69 (2014) 43–56. [62] Premium Times. Special report: amidst safety concerns, Nigeria signs nuclear power project with Russia’s Rosatom. Abuja; 2018. Available online: <https:// www.premiumtimesng.com/news/headlines/ 254629-special-report-amidst-safety-concerns-nigeria-signs-nuclear-power-project-russias-rosatom. html> [accessed on 7 May 2018]. [63] Greenpeace. Rosatom risks: exposing the troubled history of Russia’s state nuclear corporation. Amsterdam; 2014. Available online at <https://www.greenpeace. org/hungary/PageFiles/636986/rosatom_risks.pdf> [accessed on 23 July 2018]. [64] Rosendahl J, Forsell T. Areva's Finland reactor to start in 2019 after another delay in Reuters; Helsinki; 2017. Available online at <https://www.reuters.com/article/ us-finland-nuclear-olkiluoto/ arevas-finland-reactor-to-start-in-2019-after-another-delay-idUSKBN1CE1ND> [accessed on 23 July 2018]. [65] T.W. Brown, T. Bischof-Niemz, K. Blok, Ch. Breyer, H. Lund, B.V. Mathiesen, Response to 'Burden of proof: a comprehensive review of the feasibility of 100% renewable-electricity systems, Renew Sustain Energy Rev 92 (2018) 834–847. [66] M. Ram, M. Child, A. Aghahosseini, D. Bogdanov, A. Poleva, Ch. Breyer, Comparing electricity production costs of renewables to fossil and nuclear power plants in G20 countries, Study by Lappeenranta University of Technology and Greenpeace, Amsterdam, 2017. [67] M. Ram, M. Child, A. Aghahosseini, D. Bogdanov, A. Lohrmann, Ch. Breyer, A comparative analysis of electricity generation costs from renewable, fossil fuel and nuclear sources in G20 countries for the period 2015–2030, J Clean Prod (2018) https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2018.07.159, [in press]. [68] [IRENA] –International Renewable Energy Agency. West African power pool: planning and prospects for renewable energy. Abu Dhabi; 2013. Available online: <http://www.irena.org/-/media/Files/IRENA/Agency/Publication/2013/WAPP. pdf> [accessed on 24 March 2018]. [69] F. Cebulla, J. Haas, J. Eichman, W. Nowak, P. Mancarella, How much electrical energy storage do we need? A synthesis for the U.S., Europe, and Germany, J Clean Prod 181 (2018) 449–459. [70] Lambert F. Electric vehicle battery cost dropped 80% in 6 years down to $227/ kWh e tesla claims to be below $190/kWh, in Electrek; 2017. Available online: <https://electrek.co/2017/01/30/ electric-vehicle-battery-cost-dropped-80-6-years-227kwh-tesla-190kwh/>. [71] O. Schmidt, A. Hawkes, A. Gambhir, I. Staffell, The future cost of electrical energy storage based on experience rates, Nat Energy 2 (2017) 17110. [72] N. Kittner, F. Lill, D.M. Kammen, Energy storage deployment and innovation for the clean energy transition, Nat Energy 2 (2017) 17125. [73] M. Fasihi, D. Bogdanov, Ch. Breyer, Long-term hydrocarbon trade options for the Maghreb region and Europe—renewable energy based synthetic fuels for a net zero emissions world, Sustainability 9 (2017) 306. [74] D. Mentis, M. Welsch, F.F. Nerini, O. Broad, M. Howells, M. Bazilian, et al., A GIS-based approach for electrification planning—a case study on Nigeria, Energy Sustain Dev 29 (2015) 142–150. [75] S. Szabo, K. Bodis, T. Huld, M. Moner-Girona, Sustainable energy planning: leapfrogging the energy poverty gap in Africa, Renew Sustain Energy Rev 28 (2013) 500–509. [76] Breyer Ch, Werner C, Rolland S, Adelmann P. Off-grid photovoltaic applications in regions of low electrification: high demand, fast financial amortization and large market potential. In: 26th European photovoltaic solar energy conference, Hamburg; September 5–9 2011. Available online: <https://goo.gl/NL2dDM>. [77] P. Bertheau, A.S. Oyewo, C. Cader, Ch. Breyer, P. Blechinger, Visualizing national electrification scenarios for Sub Saharan Africa, Energies 10 (11) (2017) 1899. [78] S. Szabo, K. Bodis, T. Huld, M. Moner-Girona, Energy solutions in rural Africa and mapping electrification costs of distributed solar and diesel, Environ Res Lett 6 (2011). [79] P. Bertheau, C. Cader, P. Blechinger, Electrification modelling for Nigeria, Energy Proc 93 (2016) 108–112. [80] N.S. Ouedraogo, Modeling sustainable long-term electricity supply-demand in Africa, Appl Energy 190 (2017) 1047–1067. [81] Macheve B, Danilenko A, Abdullah R, Bove A, Joe Moffitt L. State water agencies in Nigeria: a performance assessment. Directions in development. Washington, DC: World Bank. License: Creative Commons Attribution CC BY 3.0 IGO40; 2015. 10.1596/978-1-4648-0657-5. [82] Climate Action, African cities commit to reaching zero carbon by 2050. London; 2018. Available online: <http://www.climateactionprogramme.org/news/ african-cities-commit-to-reaching-zero-carbon-by-2050> [accessed on 21 June 2018]. [83] B.O. Ariyo, M.F. Akorede, I.O.A. Omeiza, S.A.Y. Amuda, S.A. Oladeji, Optimisation analysis of a stand-alone hybrid energy system for the senate building, university of Ilorin, Nigeria, J Build Eng 19 (2018) 285–294. [84] PV magazine. GreenWish Partners taps into Nigeria’s solar potential with $280m investment –pv magazine International. Berlin; 2017. Available online: <https:// www.pv-magazine.com/2017/03/21/ greenwish-partners-taps-into-nigerias-solar-potential-with-280m-investment/> [accessed on 21 June 2018]. 21