Discontinuity of the product in multiplier algebras
Abstract
Entire functions operate in complete locally A-convex algebras but not continuously. Actually squaring is not always continuous. The counterexample, we give, is a multiplier algebra.
Full text
Publicacions
Ma emá iques,
Vol
34
(1990),
397-401
.
Abs ac
DISCONTINUITY
OF
TI-IE
PRODUCT
IN
MULTIPLIER
ALGEBRAS
M
.
OUDADESS
En i e
unc ions
ope a e
in
comple e
locally
A-con ex
algeb as
bu
no
con inuously
.
Ac ually squa ing
is
no
always con inuous
.
The
coun e -
example,
we
gi e,
is
a
mul iplie
algeb a
.
1
.
In oduc ion
W
.
Zelazko
cons uc s
([13])
an
example
o a
non m-con ex
algeb a
on
which
all
en i e
unc ions
ope a e
.
Doing
so
he
sol es
a
p oblem
s a ed
in
[12]
.
The
example
u ns
ou
o
be
a
uni o mly
A-con ex
algeb a
.
The
p oblem
in
ques ion
had
also
been
sol ed
in
[10]
.
We
ob ain
ha en i e
unc ions
do
no
ope a e
con inuously
.
Ac ually
we
show by a
coun e -example,
which
is
a
mul iplie
algeb a,
ha
he
p oduc
is
no
(globally)
con inuous
in
gene al
.
On
he
o he
hand
we
ob ain he e
ha
i
is
always
sequen ially
con inuous
in
any
uni al
and
comple e
locally
A-con ex
algeb a
.
In
he
Uni o mly
A-con ex
case
i is
hypocon inuous
.
2
.
Sequen ial
con inui y
and
hypocon inui y
o
he
p oduc
Le
E
be
a
locally
con ex
algeb a
wi h
a
opology
de ined
by
he amily
o
semi-no ms
(ha)aEA
.
Then
E
is
said
o
be
locally
A-con ex
([4])
i
o
e e y
xE
E
and
e e y
AE
A
he e
exis
M(A,
x)
>
0,
N(A,
x)
>
0
such
ha
Pa(xy)
< M(A,x)px(y)
(y E
E)
.
pa(yx)
G
N(A,
x)Pa(y)
(y
E E)
.
A
lócally
A-con ex
algeb a
is
said
o
be
Uni o mly
A-con ex
algeb a
i
M(A,
x)
and
N(A,x)
can
be chosen independen ly
o
A
([5])
.
Obse e
ha
he
so-called locally
m-con ex
algeb as
([9])
a e
pa icula
cases
o
he
abo e
de ini ion
.
Some
examples
o
all
hese
classes
o
algeb as
and
ela ionships
among
hem
can
be
seen
in
([4])
and
([5])
.
39
8
M
.
OUDADESS
Le
E
be a
commu a i e
Banach
algeb a
wi hou
o de
i
.e i
xy
=
0
(y
E
E)
hen
x
=
0
.
The
mul iplie
algeb a
M(E)
o
E
is
he
space
o
linea
ope a o s
T
e i ying
T(x
.y)
=
xT(y)(x, y E
E)
.
Endowed
wi h
he
s ong
opology
gi en
by
he amily
o
semi-no ms
(Px)xEE,
whe e
p,,(T)
=
JITxIj(x
E
E),
M(E)
is
a
uni al,
comple e, uni o mly
locally
A-con ex
algeb a
which
is
no
always
m-
con ex
since
i
is
a
gene aliza ion
(see
[1,
p
.
139]) o
he
algeb a
Cb(R),
o
[4],
ha
is
no
m-con ex
.
We
can
endow
any
uni al
locally
A-con ex
algeb a
wi h
a
locally
m-con ex
opology
M(T)
ine
han
by
pu ing
q, (x)
=
sup{pa(x
.y)
:
pa(y)
<
1}
.
This
opology
is
comple e
when
T
is
.
Mo eo e
and
M( )
ha e
he
same
bounded
se s
([2])
;
indeed
i
su ices
o
show
ha
bounded
se s
o
a e
bounded
o
M(T),
bu
his
ollows
om
he
ac
ha
any
ba el in a
comple e
locally
con ex
space
is
bo ni o ous
.
P oposi ion
2
.1
.
En i e
unc ions
ope a e
on
any
uni al
and
compe e
locally
A-con ex
algeb a
.
P oo -
(E,
M( ))
is
a
uni al
comple e
locally
m-con ex
algeb a
and
en i e
unc ions
ope a e
on such
algeb as
([9])
;
he
esul
ollows
since
is
coa se
han
M( )
.
P oposi ion
2
.2
.
In
any
uni al
and
comple e
locally
A-con ex
algeb a
(E,
T),
he
p oduc
is
always
sequen ially
con inuous
.
P oo -
Le
(xn)n
and
(yn)n
be
wo
sequences
con e ging
o
ze o
in
(E,' )
.
Since
T
and
M(T)
ha e
he
same
bounded
se s,
(ga(x
n
))
n
is
bounded
o
e e y
A
.
Then
he conclusion
ollows
om
he ela ion
pa(x
.y)
<
ga(x)
.pa(y),
o
e e y
x and y
.
E
We
can
endow
any
uni al
and
comple e
uni o mly
A-con ex
algeb a
(E,
T)
wi h
a
Banach
algeb a
no m
11
-
11
ine
han
T,
by
pu ing
lixil
=
sup{q (x)
A E
A}
;
i is
Coch an's
no m
([5])
.
And,
as be o e,
we
can
show
ha
and
11 -
11
ha e
he
same
bounded
se s
.
This
has, as
a
consequence,
he
p oposi ion
2 o
[13]
.
Now
ecall
ha , in a locally
con ex
algeb a
(E,
T)
.
The
mul iplica ion
is
said
o
be
le
( igh )
hypocon inuous
i
o
each
neighbo hood
U
o
O
and
any
bounded
se
B
he e
exis s
a
neighbo hood
V
o o
such
ha
B
.V
C
U(VB
C
U)
.
The
mul iplica ion, in
E,
is
called
hypocon inuous
i i is le
as well as
igh
hypocon inuous
.
P oposi ion
2
.3
.
In
a uni al
and
comple e
uni o mly
A-con ex
algeb a
(E,
T)
he
p oduc
is
always hypocon inuous
.
P oo
.
By
([6,
p oposi ion
9,
p
.
155])
i
is
su icien
o
p ó e
ha
i
we
conside
he
map
u
:
x
--->
L
x
,
whe eLx(y)
=
xy
(x,
y
E
E)
hen
;
' o
e e y
DISCONTINUITY
OF
THE
PRODUCT
IN
MULTIPLIER
ALGEBRAS
399
bounded
se
B
in
E,
he
se
u(B)
is
equicon inuous
.
Bu
his
ollows
om
he
ela ion
pa(xy)
<
lix¡l
.
pa(y)(x,
yE
E,
A
EA)
and
he
ac
ha
T
and
ha e
he
same
bounded
se s
.
3
.
Discon inui y
o
he
p oduc
Ou
coun e -example
is
he
mul iplie
algeb a
o
an
H*-algeb a
.
I
goes
along
he
lines
o ([7,
p oblem
111])
.
An
H*-algeb a
is
a
Banach
algeb a
E,
wi h
in olu ion
*,
which
is
a
Hilbe
space
unde
a
scala
p oduc
( .,
.)
such
ha
.
a)
lixl¡2
=
(x,
x), o
e e y
x in
E
b)
IIx*11
=
lixil,
o
e e y
x
in
E
c)
x*
.x
:~
0,
o
e e y
x
in
E {0}
.
d)
(x
.
y, z)
=
(y,
x*
.z)
=
(x,
z
.y*),
o
e e y
x,
y,
z in
E
.
In
such
commu a i e
algeb as
he e
always
exis s
a
comple e
o hogonal
sys-
em
o
idempo en
and
sel -adjoin
elemen s
(we
can
e en
suppose
mo e
bu
his
is
su icien
o
ou
needs
;
c
[3])
.
Coun e -example
5
.1
.
Le
(E,
be
a
commu a i e
in ini e
dimen-
sional
H*-algeb a
.
Wi hou
loss
o
gene ali y
suppose
E
sepa able
.
Le
hen
(e
l ,
e
2
,... ,
ek
. . .
)
be
a
comple e o hogonal
sys em
o
sel -adjoin
and
indem
po en elemen s
.
The
se
{
.ek
:
k
=
1,2
. .
.
.
}
is
unbounded
since
llek
l1
>_
(k
=
1, 2,
.
.
)
and
i
con ains
he
null
ec o
in
i s
weak
closu e
(c
.,
[7,
p ob-
lem
28])
.
Hence
he e
exis s
a
ne
(k¡)¡
o
posi i e in ege s
such
ha
k
;
.ek
j
con e ges
weakly
o
ze o
(i
canno
be
a
sequence)
.
Fo
each
k,
conside
he
mul iplie
Ak
de ined
by
Ak(x)
=
k'
.ek
.x
whe e
k' is
he ou h
oo
o
k
.
We
ha e
11Ak
;(x)J12
=
(
k
;
.ek
i
,
x
.x*),
hence
11Ak
;(x)jj
0
.
Bu
Ak
;
(x)
=
k
;
.ek
;
.x,
and
.
i
he e o e
we
ake
in
pa icula
x
=
(1,
. .
.,n~
1 ,
...
),
hen
A4,
(x)
=
ek
i.
So
JIA4
¡
(x)jj
>
1
.
Whence
squa ing
is
no
con inuous
.
Rema ks
.
1
.
In
many
in e es ing si ua ions
he
p oduc
is
con inuous
.
This
is
he
case
o
he
example
Cb(R)
o
[4]
.
I
is
also so o
any
mul iplie
algeb a
M(E)
whe e
E
admi s
ac o iza ion,
Le
o
e e y
z
E
E,
he e
exis
x
and
y
in
E
such
ha z
=
x
.y
.
2
.
In
connec ion
wi h
he
p e ious
ema k,
we
can
no ice
ha
he e
canno
exis
a Banach
algeb a
E
admi ing
a
bounded
app oxima e
iden i y
and
such
ha
he
se
N
=
{x
:
x
2
=
0}
is
O-dense
in
E
.
Indeed
he
p oduc ,
and
in
pa icula squa ing,
is
con inuous,
hence
{TeM(E)
:
T
2
=
0}
in
,0-closed
.
I
is
also
P-dense
since
i
con ains
N
and
E
is
/i-dense in
M(E)
o
i
admi s
a
bounded
app oxima e
iden i y
.
The e o e
any
elemen
o
M(E)
should
be
nilpo en
.
Bu
his
con adic s
he
ac
ha
M(E)
is
always
uni al
.
3
.
Inciden ally
we
ge
ha
an
absolu ely
con e gen
se ies
in a
comple e
locally
con ex
space
does
no
necessa ily de ine a
con inuous
mapping
.
Indeed
i
(E,
T)
is
a
locally
uni o mly
A-con ex
algeb a
whose
opology
T
is
gi en
by
a
40
0
M
.
OUDADESS
amily
o
semino ms
(Paja,
he e
exis s
a
Banach
algeb a
no m
and
a
>
0
such
ha
Pa(x)
<
a
.11xII,
o
e e y
Aand
e e y
x
.
Now
i
(z)
=
a
n
.zn
is
an
en i e
unc ion,
hen,
o
e e y
A,
Pa(E
an
.2
n
)
<
a
.
1
:
janl
.11Xlln
.
Hence
he
se ies
is
absolu ely
con e gen
;
bu he
p e ious
coun e -example
shows
ha
he
map
x
-->
(x)
is
no
always
con inuous
.
Acknowledg uen s
.
1'm
indeb ed
o
he
e e ee
o
ha ing
de ec ed
an
e o
in
he
i s
e sion
and
ha ing
sugges ed
many
imp o emen s
o
he
w i ing
o
he
second one
.
Re e ences
[1[
M
.
AKKAR,
"E ude
Spec ale
e
s uc u es
d'algéb es
opologiques
e
bo -
nologiques complé es,"
Thése
d'é a ,
Uni
.
d
e
Bo deaux
1,
1976
.
[2]
M
.
AKKAR,
L
.
OUBBI
AND
M
.
OUDADESS,
ALgéb es
A-con exes
e
p obléme
de
Michaél,
P oc
.
A
.M
.S
.
(á
pa ai e)
.
[3]
F
.F
.
BONSALL
AND
J
.
DUNCAN,
"Comple e
no med
algeb as,"
E gebnisse
de
Ma hema ik,
Band
80,
Sp inge -Ve lag,
1973
.
[4]
A
.C
.
COCHRAN
.
R
.
KEOW
N
AND
C
.R
.
WILLIAMS,
On
a
class
o
opo-
logical
algeb as,
Paci ic
J
.
Ma h
.
34
(1970),
17-25
.
[5]
A
.
C
.
COCHRAN,
Rep esen a ion o
A-con ex
algeb as,
P oc
.
Ame
.
Ma h
.
Soc
.
4
1
(1973),
473-479
.
[6J
A
.
GROTHENDIECK,
Espaces
ec o iels
opologiques,
Pub
.
Soc
.
Ma h
.,
S
.
Paulo
(1964)
.
[7]
P
.R
.
HALMOS,
"A
Hilbe
space
p oblem
book,"
Second
Ed
.,
Sp inge -Ve -
lag,
1974
.
[8]
R
.
LARSEN,
"The
mul iplie
p oblem,"
Lec
.
No es
Ma h
.
105,
Sp inge -
Ve lag,
1969
.
[9]
E
.A
.
MICHABL,
Locally
mul iplica i ely
con ex
opological
algeb as,
Memoi s
Ame
.
Ma h
.
Soc
.
11,
P o iden e
(1952)
.
[10]
M
.
OUDADESS,
Théo émes
de
s uc u es
e
p op ié és
ondamen ales
des
algéb es
uni o mémen
A-con exes,
C
.
R
.
A ad
.
Sci
.
Pa i
s
296,
Sé ie
1(1983),851-853
.
[11]
J.K
.
WANG,
Mul iplie s
o
commu a i e
Banach
algeb as,
Paci ic
J
.
Ma h
.
(1961),
1131-1149
.
DISCONTINUITY
OF
THE
PRODUCT
IN
MULTIPLIER
ALGEBRAS
401
[12]
W
.
ZELAZKO,
Selec ed
opics in
opological
algeb as,
Lec
.
No es
sé ies
31
(1971),
Ma ema isk
Ins i u ,
Aa hus
Uni e si e
.
[13]
W
.
ZELAZKO,
A
non m-con ex
algeb a
on
which
ope a e
all
en i e
unc-
ions,
Ann
.
Polinici
Ma h
.
46
(1985),
389-394
.
Ecole
No male
Supé ieu e
Takaddoum
B
.P
.
5118 Raba
MAROC
Rebu
el
26
d'Ab il
de
1990