scieee AI-readable full text Open interactive document viewer

Reviews

Monnickendam, Andrew

Abstract

Cairns CRAIG, Out of history.

Full text

128 Links & Letters 4, 1997 Reviews In this way, her own critica1 perspective can certainly be a conflictive arena for remains undiscriminating of the social women and a place for negotiating iden- and cultural forces at work in women's tities. texts. Her eagerness to revalue women's Neus Carbonell i Camós literature obscures the fact that gender Estudis Universitaris Vic Cairns CRAIG. Out ofHistoy. Edinburgh: Polygon, 1996. 296 pages. Cairns Craig, lecturer in English literature at the University of Edinburgh, has been general editor of the Aberdeen University Press The Histoy of Scottish Literature (1987-8) and editor of its fourth volume on twentieth-centurv literature. He is also well-known as one of the leading contributors to the journal Cencrastw his contributions to its earlv issues were largely responsible for its success. Both publications shared the common aim of relocating Scottish literature into a contemporary context, a position which discards the restrictions im~osed by purely historical scholarship and the limiting paradigm of national or cultural identity. Out ofHisto y is a collection of seven closely connected essays, «Prologue», «The Body in the Kit Bag», «Out of History)). «Absences», ((George Orwell and the English Ideology», «Being Bemeen)), and ((Epilogue: Posting Towards the Future», which analyse the way in which Scotland has been out of history -out- side the maior develo~ment of UK affairs and outside contemporary theoretical modelsin order to propose how it should engage in these issues. Little opposition has been made to the argument that Scottisln culture stagnated in a time warp for most of the nineteenth century, however ironical it might be that Walter Scott is widely regarded as the father figure of the historical novel. Scottish culture became ~arochid because it saw itself as such: provincial to the metropolitan centre, making the high road to London the solution adopted by many gifted writers from Carlyle to Barrie down to the present day. Cairns Craig argues that this situation arises because Scots continually looked to English models, to the kind associated with Arnold. T.S. Eliot and Leavis. onlv to feel inferior: «At no time in its hist4 could Scotland have been described as an 'organic' or a 'unified' culture: it could nev- O er have been envisaged as one 'comprehensive' mind transcending the 'prejudices of politics and fashions of taste' of a particular period therefore it could not qualify as a tradition or as a literature.)) (p. 15) T.S. Eliot's blueprint for literary history and tradition exile Scotland to the periphery, which is not, it has to be pointed out, a natural process for a marginalised culture, as the case of Ireland proves without a doubt; a literary tradition based on the creation of a powerful national mythology has led to the boast that Irish authors have written the best modern literature in Enelish. There- " fore, if we want to find an analogous situation to Scotland's. we have to look to the experience ofwriters of the other cultures which made up the British Empire. History «in a terrifying and alienating form» (p. 48) thrust Scottish culture back into a historical continuum in 1914. This is clear from the vast number of Scottish novels and poems which deal with the First World War and its devastating effects. Perhaps the most important of these is L.G. Gibbon's Sunset Song (1932) However, the novel ends when its major character turns her back on the historical world and the devastation it has caused to her life and that of the community's, retreating to a location Reviews Links & Letters 4, 1997 129 clearly out of history. This conclusion is explicable in part as a rejection of history being equated with war, and partly because the models of historical metanarrative at her disposition do not suffice. In the essay from which the book takes its title, Cairns Craig tackles the enigma 1 referred to some lines back: that of Scott. The Waverley Novels do not leave a school behind them in Great Britain, as they do in continental Europe. The enigma can be resolved by separating Scott from his legacy. Scott bequeathed a model of history or historical fiction based on the twin conceots of realism and progressive history. Yet if we attempt to judge Scott by these criteria, the result is dissatisfaction or comolete rejection. Cairns Craig's hypothesis is that the Waverley Novels are based more on a geographical than a historical axis. Thus, when Waverley crosses the highland barrier, he journeys back into past history. As it stands, that is not in itself a novel idea, but, Cairns Craig proceeds: «The novel Vaverlev.. . can exemolifv -I I I the inevitable victory of civility over barbarism only by revealing with equal power the possible reversal of civility into barbarism.)) (p. 70) This is a crucial distinction, if we look at European historical novels which use a historical narrative to pave the way for a projected national unity, or if we study the novels of the 'American Scott' J. Fenimore Cooper, in which the path to the modern USA is charted; in both cases, no possibility of reversal is conceivable. Moreover, Cairns Craig, in an extremely perceptive analogy, proposes that Scott's reversal links him to Stevenson, arguing that the terrible conclusion of The Strange Case ofDr. Jekyll and Mr Hyde gives out an identical warning: that the horror mav lie in the " future and is not necessarily confined to the past. 1 deliberately use the word 'horror' as an allusion to Conrad and Heart of Darkness in order to cement the colonial paradigm, as the novella graphically illustrates 'the possible reversal of civility into barbarism' actually taking place. The principal merit of Cairns Craig's study lies, for me at least, in his critique of Marxist readings of culture and history. These have their roots in Scottish Enlightenment thought and its belief in progressive history. Lukacs' reinstatement of Scott as an important novelist is based on the former's belief that the latter demonstrates how the historical path towards a world-wide proletarian revolution has begun, illustrated by the way in which Scott debunks the ruling elites he portrays, the kings, princes, dukes and aristocracy in general, turning the bourgeois characters into heroes and predicting that they will in turn give way to the proletarian characters, the servants, 'lowlife' characters in general, who are more vital than the middling. heroes. This his- U torical pattern allows modern scholars to deconstruct national myths, tartanry and the Highlands in the case of Scott " and Scotland, as being purely nostalgic and irrelevant to history. In a highly controversial statement, Cairns Craig argues that the hostility towards national myths theoretically justifies a belief in progressive history but covers up a far deeper reaction, namely 'the profound hatred of the intellectuals for the culture they inhabited. the ~rofound embarrassment they suffered by being unable, any more, to identifv themselves with some universalist truth that would redeem theni from Scottishness.' (p. 107) While adhering to historical ideological models, their rejection of their national culture tended to be simply geographical. A complete contrast is provided by their counterparts in England, and especially in the case of that most fabricated of literary identities, George Orwell. His distance from his predecessors is explained by his inability 'to take over the mythos of England as defined by Edwardian writers -a mixture of Fabian socialism and ramblers' club naturism.' (p. 132) 130 Links & Letters 4, 1997 Reviews His distrust of totalitarianism, whether of 1948 or 1984, is accordingly not an expression of fear about totalitarianism in general, nor a parody of Stalin, but a deep rooted hostility to modernity and the desuuction of an essentially ruralist view of England. This would explain the deeply patriotic strain throughout both his domestic U and imperial writing. Similar conceptual paradoxes niark the thinking of E.P. Thompson, author of the monumental Making of the English Working Classes. Thompson's work is both a historical account and 'celebration of England's radical history'. (p.155) What this entails is that for Thompson the heroic nature of the class strugile might form part of a universal history but its Englishness, its national character is far more striking. Similarly, Raymond Williams' work -despite the author's Welsh nationality and due to his belief that Welsh culture is subordinateshares with Thompson's the belief that the gradual nature of change in England, bereft of revolutions, is the civilised model to follow. What Cairns Craig says of Williams could equally well apply to Thompson or Orwell, riamely that: 'Class provides the instrument for attacking the patterns of domination he perceives with English culture. but the instrument which conveys the attack is itself an integral part of a definition of English culture which has suppressed any co~sciousness of its relations of cultural domination with the other 'cultures' of its boundaries.' (p. 146) What strove to pass for universal, actually turns out be local, or national. Clearly, Cairns Craig's critique of these three thinkers is one of the most coherent and radical to have appeared, questioning the basis of much of the work of post-Marxist critical theory, now so influential in universities and intellectual circles. For what he is proposing is that when, for example, cultural materialists or new historicists launch their assault on Shakes~earean studies under a banner of anti-establishment views, they are simply maintaining, if not strengthening, the foundations of that very same belief in the validity of the national English culture that they are supposedly waging war against; or, take another instance, when feminists take up the challenge of occupying their own litérary geography, as Virginia Woolf dernands, that space will remain essentially anglocentric however radical it claims to be, for even when it leaves England behind geographically, it is English culture, or to be more precise, a certain view of English culture, that retains its place as thevmodel to follow. Hopefully, 1 have given sufficient reasons for readers to want to go out and buy this erudite, thought-provoking volume. Reading through this review, 1 have become aware that it is dense and not necessarily easy to grasp at first reading. This is the reviewer's fault entirely, and the consequence of trying to summarise what 1 ho~e will become a verv im~or- ,L tant book. In the past few years, manyarticles and books have attacked contemporary critical theory for its avoidance of the question of artistic value and accused it of being hostile to its own disci~line and resp&sible for falling standards. However valid such analvsis mav or mav not be, it replies to one way of thinking, which is aptly labelled progressive, the post-Marxist, the new-left, feminism and so on, by presenting alternative parameters. 1 would suggest that this is the case of Harold Bloom's intriguing study The Western Canon: The Books annd Scholars of the Ages : an emphasis on non- or anticanonical literature and criticism is countered by Bloom setting forth the validity of that canon. Unfort~natel~, until the publication of Out of History, very few critics have attempted to analyse contemporary critical theory on its own terms and point to its inherent inconsistencies. Several explanations are posible: Reviews Links & Letters 4, 1997 131 if it has been able to absorb its peripheries, as the incor~oration of Williarns and 0kell suggestl, it is extrernely dificult to find a way to begin to disrnantle an ideology which is universalist in theory but nationalist in practice; second, Williarns is such an irn~ortant figure within " conternporary critical circles that capable but voluntary iconoclasts are few and far between. Cairns Craig cails for a radical re-orientation of literary studies based on a far more coherent use of historiography and the inclusion of geographical paradigrns in critical rnodels. This is clearly an enorrnous chailenee, and one looks " - fonvard to the continuation of the exciting debate that Out ofHistory has started. Andrew Monnickendam Universitat Autbnorna de Barcelona Declan KIBERD, Inventing Irekznd: The Literature of the Modern Nation London: Jonathan Cape, 1995. 719 pages. whatever U given Can always be reimagined, howeverfour-square, Plank-thick, hull-stupid and out of its time It happens to be. (Seamus Heaney, 'The Settle Bed', Seeing Things) «If God invented whiskey to prevent the Irish from ruling the world, then who invented Ireland ?» Kiberd's answer to that initiai question is to be found in his new book, which rnay be labelled as the first critical history of rnodern Irish literature written within a postcolonid framework. As such, it fills a large gap in literary studies and will soon becorne an absolute mustfor those interested in rnodern Irish writing. Apart from a few helpful 'interchapters' that give an ovewiew of the sociopolitical context, the bulk of the book consists of thirty-five chapters in which Kiberd aiternates literary-historical analysis centred on a topic (childhood and Ireland, rnothers and daughters, deanglicisation, nationali~ and cosrnopolitanism, the Great War and Irish rnemory, Ireland and the end of the British ernpire, etc.) with an analysis of the literature and politicai ideas of the main Irish writers of the 20th century (Wilde, Shaw, Sorne~ille and Ross, Lady Gregory, O'Casey, Synge, Yeats, Joyce, Bowen, Beckett, Flann O'Brien, Seamus Heaney, Brian Friel, etc.). Throughout the book Kiberd rnakes intelligent connections between past and present and benveen Ireland and other postcoloniai literatures and countries; the breadth of his schoiarshi~ is extraordinarv, and his , . readings of particular texts and periods are often brilliant and innovative. In Edward W. Said's terms (reproduced on the back jacket of the book), Kiberd's is a «dazzling, bravura performance)). According to Kiberd, the postcolonial history of Ireland is a succession of plays in which writers perforrn different versions of Englishness and Irishness to one another. Frorn the time of the conquest of Ireland by England in the 16th and early 17th centuries, English and Irish authors sought national identity by rneans of differentiation: while contesting each other's invented images, they created their own national irnage. The Drocess was reci~rocal and went on and on in a vicious circle: in the period of national building each of thern (like Caliban and ~rosp'&o) badly needed the other in order to assert their own identitv. But in fact, at the beginning both ~ng lish and Irish were more or less alike. For Kiberd, then, Ireland (and it could be argued that any modern nation) is a forged, 'imagined comrnunity'