Tapinoma pymaeum (Dufour, 1857) (Hymenoptera, Formicidae), not a rare species
Abstract
Tapinoma pygmaeum is an ant known from seven localities. Five of them are in the province of Girona (Spain). The apparent rarity and skewed distribution of this species is probably an artifact due to the confussion, in field samplings, with a similar species, Plagiolepis pygmaea.
Full text
Orsis 12. 1997 89-92 Tapinoma pygmaeum (Du four, 1 857) (Hymenoptera, Formicidae), not a rare species X. Espadalerl E. Garcia-Berthou2 1. Universitat Autbnoma de Barcelona. Departament de Biologia Animal, de Biologia Vegetal i d'Ecologia. 08193 Bellaterra (Barcelona). Spain 2. Universitat de Girona. Departament de Cibncies Ambientals i Institut d'Ecologia AquAtica. Pla~a Hospital, 6. 17071 Girona. Spain Manuscript received on May 1996 Abstract Tapinoma pygmaeum is an province of Girona (Spain). probably an artifact due to Plagiolepis pygmaea. ant known from seven localities. Five of them are in the The apparent rarity and skewed distribution of this species is the confussion, in field samplings, with a similar species, Key words: ant, distribution, pseudo-rarity. Resumen. Tapinoma pygmaeum (Dufour, 1857) (Hymenoptera, Formicidae), especie no rara Tapinoma pygmaeum es una hormiga conocida en siete localidades. Cinco de ellas se encuentran en la provincia de Girona (España). La aparente rareza y esta distribución sesgada de las localidades puede ser un artefacte debido a que haya sido confundida, en el campo, con Plagiolepis pygmaea, similar, a primera vista, en aspecto. Palabras clave: distribución, honniga, pseudo-rareza. This species has suffered a rather confusing taxonomical and nomenclatura1 history (Shattuck, 1994): considered as a distinct genus (Micromyrma pygmaeum Dufour, 1857), as a synonym of Plagiolepis pygmaea (Latreille, 1798), or with other different specific names (Tapinoma dufouri Donisthorpe, 1943, Tapinoma confusum M.R. Smith, 1951). We believe that it still has strong recognition problems. The present status of poor knowledge may be mediated by the abscence of expectations in finding it, probably because of ignoring the possibility to find it. Cabinet identification should not be a question; discrimination from Plagiolepis species in the field is facilitated by the abundant pubescence of T. pygmaeum, which gives a dull aspect instead of a shining appearance; behaviour is also diffe-
90 Orsis 12, 1997 X. Espadaler; E. Garcia-Berthou rent, this species being more rapid and aggressive. Presently known records of Tapinoma pygmaeum are the following: 1. Saint Sever (Landes, F) (Dufour, 1857). 2. Cuceglio Canavese (Piemonte, I) Menozzi, 1925). 3. Setcases (Girona, E), 3.07.1976 and 2.07.1977, (Espadaler, 1977) 4. L'Estartit (Girona, E), Abbot & Elmes leg. (Espadaler, 1979). 5. Queralbs (Girona, E), 15.1 1.1975, Escola leg. (Espadaler, 1979). 6. Can Roca Roja, La Salut, Sant Feliu de Pallarols (Girona, E), 8.1 1.1981, Escol2 leg. 7. Banyoles (Girona, E), 27.07.1990, Garcia-Berthou leg. The last sample (no. 7) is of unusual origin. A single worker was identified in the gut contents of mosquitofish, Gambusia holbrooki (Pisces, Poeciliidae). The fish was captured with dip nets in the littoral zone of Lake Banyoles, namely in the channel connecting the main lake with the adjacent Lake Vilar. This fish individual was part of an intensive dietary study of Lake Banyoles fish (Garcia- Berthou, 1994). As observed in many lakes, the habitat of mosquitofish is strictly limited to vegetated littoral zone (les than 1 m deep) because of predation risk by other fish especies. Mosquitofish diet is also, as usual, typified by water surface prey, namely of terrestrial origin (e.g., ants) or aquatic neustonic (cladocera and adults of Diptera Nematocera). Similar feeding habits of mosquitofish have been reported in the Camargue wetlands (France), where ants were also detected (Crivelli & Boy, 1987), and Australiann rivers, where ants were dominant (Arthington, 1989). Other ants -mainly sexualspresentin gut contents of several fish species were Aphaenogaster subterranea (Latreille). Crematogaster scutellaris (Olivier), Hypoponera eduardi (Forel), Lasius niger (Linné), Leptothorax sp., and Tetramorium semilaeve André. According to the geographical distribution pattern (figure 1) and circumstances of collection we can point out the following comments: 1. The distribution of T. pygmaeum does not seem to be limited by its dispersa1 ability. Sexuals are winged and wing length is similar, in proportion to body size, to that of other congeneric European species (T. nigerrimum (Nylander), T. erraticum (Latreille), T. ambiguum Emery, T. simrothi Krausse). 2. Habitat degradation through human activities does not seem to be a main distribution factor; in fact, four localities belong to rather strongly human modified habitats. 3. It is unlikely that the province of Girona presents particular climatic, geographical, or biological features limiting there the presence of T. pygmaeum. 4. Given the similitude in size and colour with P. pygmaea and P. schmitzii, this species has been probably obviated in field collections in Europe. 5. Environmental attributes of the Iberian localities of this species show a certain degree of humidity: a river wood at 1500 m altitude (locality 3), a mixed wood at > 1200 m (locality 5), a mountain meadow at 11 10 m (locality 6) and at the
Tapinoma pygmaeum, not a rare ant Orsis 12, 1997 91 border of a lake (locality 7). No data are available for locality 4. The Italian sample was obtained from inside an empty shoot of Rubus and the type material was collected in an orchard. 6. We do not believe in any bias in Spanish collectors. A useful indication may be the capture frequency by a non-myrmecologist: 21 samples corresponded to Plagiolepis and 2 to T. pygmaeum, out of 527 ant samples (i.e., identified species) collected by O. Escoli (Museum of Zoology, Barcelona) from northwest Spain. I I 5" Figure 1. Geographical distribution of Tapinoma pygmaeum (Dufour). Solid circles: previous records; open circles: new records. Number refers to locality (see text).
92 Orsis 12, 1997 X. Espadaler; E. Garcia-Berthou We suggest that the actual abundance and range of this species are broader than presently known. It will be necessary, therefore, to carefully check for its presence in field collections, specially in hurnid biotopes, avoiding the confusion with the much abundant P. pygmaea, one of the most common ant species in the westem Mediterranean. This is a good example of pseudo-rarity (Gaston, 1994), generated as an artifact -in the present case, by the failure to discriminate the specific identityin which a species may be regarded as rare (geographically restricted, locally sparse, low abundance) when it is not. Aknowledgements Oleguer Escola (Museum of Zoology, Barcelona) has provided many opportunities to study ants and discuss on entomological subjects. His help with ant collection is greatly appreciated. Francesc Córdoba assisted in sample processing. The second author (EGB) was supported by the Autonomous Government of Catalonia (FI fellowship, CIRIT grant AR89) and the Council of Banyoles. References Arthington, A.H. 1989. Diet of Gambusia afinis holbrooki, Xiphophorus helleri, X. nzaculatus and Poecilia reticulata (Pisces: Poeciliidae) in streams of southeastern Queensland, Australia. Asian Fisheries Science 2: 193-212. Crivelli, A.J.; Boy, V. 1987. The diet of mosquitofish Gambusia aflnis (Baird & Girard) (Poeciliidae) in Mediterranean France. Rev. Ecol. 42: 421 -435. Dufour, L. 1857. Mélanges entomologiques. Ann. Soc. ent. Fr. 5: 39-70. Espadaler, X. 1977. Descripción de 10s sexuados de Tapinorna pygmaeum (Dufour, 1857) (Hymenoptera, Formicidae). Vie Milieu 27: 119-128. - 1979. Citas nuevas o interesantes de hormigas (Hym. Formicidae) para España. Bol. Asoc. esp. Entom. 3: 95-101. Garcia-Berthou, E. 1994. Ecologia alimentaria de la comunitat de peixos de 1'Estany de Banyoles. Ph.D. dissertation. University of Girona. Gaston, K.J. 1994. Rarity. Chapman & Hall. London. Menozzi, C. 1925. Note staccate di mirmecologia. Boll. Soc. ent. Ital. 57: 17-22. Shattuck, S. 1994. Taxonomic catalog of the ant subfamilies Aneuretinae and Dolichoderinae (Hymenoptera: Formicidae). University of California. Publications in Entomology 112: 1-241 + xix.